Being a Conservative
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: 1 [2] | |
|
Re: Being a Conservative I, for one, found this to be a very informative thread, and I'm glad you started it! Just had to add that! |
|
Posted 2/7/08 10:11 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: Being a Conservative Posted by wannabemom Posted by leese I agree. I am a fiscal conservative and believe in State's rights. Though socially, I am liberal. As with everything that is discussed in the mainstream media, things get distorted into 20 second media bites. I swear, it's not due to media sloppiness.... Both political parties have ample opportunity to define themselves in the media, and the new GOP leaders have chosen this direction. it really is due to the NeoCon's remodelling the GOP to suit the fundamentalist christian ideal.... the fiscal conservatives have been marginalized in the party. My dad was a minor politician in the conservative party in the 70's, and his positions were mainly fiscal conservative.... he would cringe if he saw what happened to the GOP...... I disagree since I work in the media world and follow it daily. Sure, they have the chance to redefine themselves in other mediums but I was discussing the way the media world works. It is hard for average Americans who watch the nightly news to understand any of the parties out there in 20 second sound bites. And, it isn't just politics, it's a wide variety of things like policies and programs. |
|
Posted 2/7/08 10:24 PM
|
|
|
Re: Being a Conservative Posted by hope2bamom Conservatives want a smaller federal government. That the power should be resolved into the states, as I said before refer to the 10th amendment, the 9th amendment or the Constitution as a whole, as it is a truism. They are for lower taxes, not just the wealthy like people would like you to believe, but lower taxes for everyone. But not just lower taxes, cut cost on federal spending. They want to promote business in America, by again, giving tax breaks. And when I say they mostly follow the Constitution, I am talking about the Federal government out of public schools, which is SPECIFICALLY says they have no claim to in the Constitution. The federal government should not be involved in agriculture, again stated in the Constitution. I could go on, but unless people are really interested in it, I feel like I would be wasting my time. it is about individual freedom, not shared wealth. A true Conservative, would send most of the matters that you brought up back to the states where they belong, according to the Constitution. It is like if I called all Liberals Godless, that is a blanket statement that is simply not true. Not all Conservatives are religious or Christian. The Constitution is a system of restraints against the natural tendency of government to expand in the direction of absolutism. Now I am babbling, and probably cleared up nothing, but what you said makes me really sad and scared for the Republican party. ***This is my view, I already know not every one thinks like me. Thank you for explaining this so well. This described my feelings better than i could have. So many people on this board would certainly agree (given responses to other threads) that the needs of the people in new york are drastically different than, say, those in Alabama and that the local governments should have more power to respond accordingly to those needs. But, they'd rather stab their eyes out with a dull #2 pencil than admit to agreeing with an, essentially, conservative ideal
|
|
Posted 2/7/08 10:25 PM
|
|
|
Re: Being a Conservative Politics confuse me. |
|
Posted 2/7/08 10:28 PM
|
|
|
Re: Being a Conservative I will be honest in saying this--I am a registered Democrat, and probably one of those people guilty of lumping Conservatives, Religious Rights and Republicans into the same category... |
|
Posted 2/7/08 10:28 PM
|
|
|
Re: Being a Conservative But, they'd rather stab their eyes out with a dull #2 pencil than admit to agreeing with an, essentially, conservative idea |
|
Posted 2/8/08 8:47 AM
|
|
|
Re: Being a Conservative I'm responding to this post not to rip the poster apart, but b/c I think it was a very honest, open post. I think a LOT of people tend to feel this way, and I'm hoping that at least a few people will start to acknowledge that GOP does NOT equal Religious Right. Posted by MrsRivera I will be honest in saying this--I am a registered Democrat, and probably one of those people guilty of lumping Conservatives, Religious Rights and Republicans into the same category... ...why? Mostly because there are many overlapping tenets, and one seems to run right into the other. Honestly, if you really feel this way, then you haven't really done much research on the subject. I'm not trying to be flip, but just the idea that you think that the tenants of the Religious Right and what the GOP stands for "run right into each other" and overlap so much as to to be almost the same thing shows me that you don't necessarily have a clear understanding of the history and defining characteristics of the Republican party. I don't think churches teach much about federalism either, but I could be wrong. I'm not exactly evangelical here, though have nothing agianst anyone who is. That, and the fact that I've never actually come across anything the GOP stands for that I support. Really? Nothing? Like the 10th Amendment? Federalism? Have you looked much beyond abortion, gay marriage, and the war? I'm a card carrying conservative and there are plenty of things I agree with Democrats about and disagree with many Republicans about. People hear that I don't believe the federal government should have the power to ban abortion, that I'm staunchly against the death penalty, and that I support gay marriage and then ask me, "How can you possibly be a Republican then??" Um, easy. There's a LOT more to it than just those issues. I honestly think that the vast majority of people who feel THIS strongly against the GOP are basing 99% of their opinion on a very small population of Republican politicians (mainly, unfortunately George W. Bush) and a very small group of issues. I think I'd get slammed for grouping all liberals into such a narrow category (and I don't, by the way... I actually acknowledge that people can align themselves with a political party and still remain free thinkers), so I'm always surprised as how often this happens to conservatives. This is not direct at the post I quoted AT ALL, but I feel the need to say it because it's something that irks me: I, personally, as a conservative, am tired of hearing non-conservatives tell me what I believe. I can think for myself, thank you. I will say that I feel many liberals such as myself (younger ones in particular) tend to interchange the three because many things DO seem that black and white. Well, if you don't want to dig deeper, of COURSE things will seem that black and white. The GOP isn't defined only by the last 8 years no more than the Democrats are characterized solely by Bill Clinton. What so many people fail to realize is that the Republican party isn't as flat as people seem to think it is. There are easily two groups falling under the GOP - yes, the Religious Right "Pat Robertson Republicans" as John McCain has called them is one sect. However, the vast majority of us don't fall under that sect. I thought John McCain did an excellent job in 2000 trying to distance himself from that sect when challenging George Bush. A lot of his words and speeches at that time have turned eerily prophetic... *shudder* (I'm a big separation of church and state person...) I think the GOP was somewhat reactionary in 2000 trying to be the family values party - and I admit I disagreed with that vehemently at the time. Unfortunately, that then became the defining characteristic (at leat to most non-conservatives) of the party for the past 8 years. Hopefully that will start to change. The fact that the Religious Right has shoved themselves into the lime light and rallied behind the Republicans doesn't change the fact that GOP appeals to people outside that narrowly defined group -- and has a history FAR broader than just the Religious Right. I find it incredibly closed minded (not to mention ironic) to hear liberals call the GOP closed minded, when they won't even entertain any explanation or argument on anything a conservative might actually say or think. They jsut think we're all a bunch of Religious Right Pat Robertson drones screaming "Jesus wants the government run this way!" when in fact, that's simply not true. They don't acknowledge that we can be just as intelligent and well-informed as they are and still disagree. I don't doubt there are conservatives who give the same closed-minded attitude toward more liberal stances. I just think that so many people like to think "conservative = closed-minded" and "liberal = open-minded" when, in fact, they're just misuing the words... I think I've come to the conclusion that many Democrats, in particular the younger ones whose political exposure to Republicans has mainly been Dubyah, just don't want to believe that the GOP isn't the same thing as the Religious Right and that there are Republicans out there who are NOT members of the Religious Right. They just turn a blind eye and don't even want to listen when any conservative speaks. That's their right, but it doesn't mean their interpretation of the GOP is accurate. |
|
Posted 2/8/08 9:13 AM
|
|
|
Re: Being a Conservative Posted by hope2bamom It is not only the media but it is also our educational system that creates false ideas about Conservatives. Not to mention they filter history, and don't truly teach the Constitution. It really frustrates me. Why do you think this. I was a HS SS teacher for a long time and would love to hear your theory as for NY and CA - just b/c it's a blue state - doesn't mean everywhere is blue. Long Island and San Diego tend to vote Republican. ------------------------------------------------------- My father is registered with the Conservative Party and *gasp* an atheist!! LOL that breaks the sterotype Posted by leese I agree. I am a fiscal conservative and believe in State's rights. Though socially, I am liberal. this is how I usually tend to be - Libertarian |
|
Posted 2/8/08 9:24 AM
|
|
|
Re: Being a Conservative ~Kara |
|
Posted 2/8/08 9:24 AM
|
|
|
Re: Being a Conservative Posted by hope2bamom Oh and as for when people tell me Conservatives don't like change, this is how I define it for some people that seems to make sense. - Radical change and unproven beliefs should not be quickly implemented before tested I agree with you there - I always say that democracy is a slow (sometimes painfully slow) process. But radical change can come on both ends of the political spectrum, ala WWII. |
|
Posted 2/8/08 9:33 AM
|
|
|
Re: Being a Conservative Posted by prncss I, for one, found this to be a very informative thread, and I'm glad you started it! Just had to add that! Me too!
|
|
Posted 2/8/08 9:39 AM
|
|
|
Re: Being a Conservative Why do you think this. I was a HS SS teacher for a long time and would love to hear your theory |
|
Posted 2/8/08 10:07 AM
|
|
|
Re: Being a Conservative I hear what you are saying about the levels of different states. My niece came here to go to school from Arizona and was floored by how little she was taught in AZ. |
|
Posted 2/8/08 10:53 AM
|
|
|
Re: Being a Conservative U.S History was taught in my school, or at least when I went which was a while ago |
|
Posted 2/8/08 11:13 AM
|
|
|
Re: Being a Conservative Posted by hope2bamom [ Conservatives want a smaller federal government. That the power should be resolved into the states, as I said before refer to the 10th amendment, the 9th amendment or the Constitution as a whole, as it is a truism. They are for lower taxes, not just the wealthy like people would like you to believe, but lower taxes for everyone. But not just lower taxes, cut cost on federal spending. They want to promote business in America, by again, giving tax breaks. And when I say they mostly follow the Constitution, I am talking about the Federal government out of public schools, which is SPECIFICALLY says they have no claim to in the Constitution. The federal government should not be involved in agriculture, again stated in the Constitution. I could go on, but unless people are really interested in it, I feel like I would be wasting my time. it is about individual freedom, not shared wealth. A true Conservative, would send most of the matters that you brought up back to the states where they belong, according to the Constitution. It is like if I called all Liberals Godless, that is a blanket statement that is simply not true. Not all Conservatives are religious or Christian. The Constitution is a system of restraints against the natural tendency of government to expand in the direction of absolutism. Now I am babbling, and probably cleared up nothing, but what you said makes me really sad and scared for the Republican party. ***This is my view, I already know not every one thinks like me. EXCELLENT POINTS!!! You summed it up very well!! I'm a Constitutional junkie myself...big fan of the process of Federalism and the limitations on the Federal Gov't set forth in the 10th Amendment. |
|
Posted 2/8/08 11:24 AM
|
|
|
Re: Being a Conservative Posted by Erica As for your NY experience, it seems you left NY before 11-12th grade - which is where US history is taught. I went to excellent schools. The US History I learned (and I was in the AP class) wasn't very in-depth regarding the constitution and the concept of federalism. Neither was my government class in 12th grade. I remember being shocked at some of the stuff I learned in my constitutional law class in law school. |
|
Posted 2/8/08 11:34 AM
|
|
|
Re: Being a Conservative Posted by Kara I'm responding to this post not to rip the poster apart, but b/c I think it was a very honest, open post. I think a LOT of people tend to feel this way, and I'm hoping that at least a few people will start to acknowledge that GOP does NOT equal Religious Right. MrsRivera -- this really isn't against you or directed at your personally. It's just that you said some things that I think a LOT of other liberals also think, and I'm responding to that sentiment. Posted by MrsRivera I will be honest in saying this--I am a registered Democrat, and probably one of those people guilty of lumping Conservatives, Religious Rights and Republicans into the same category... ...why? Mostly because there are many overlapping tenets, and one seems to run right into the other. Honestly, if you really feel this way, then you haven't really done much research on the subject. I'm not trying to be flip, but just the idea that you think that the tenants of the Religious Right and what the GOP stands for "run right into each other" and overlap so much as to to be almost the same thing shows me that you don't necessarily have a clear understanding of the history and defining characteristics of the Republican party. I don't think churches teach much about federalism either, but I could be wrong. I'm not exactly evangelical here, though have nothing agianst anyone who is. That, and the fact that I've never actually come across anything the GOP stands for that I support. Really? Nothing? Like the 10th Amendment? Federalism? Have you looked much beyond abortion, gay marriage, and the war? I'm a card carrying conservative and there are plenty of things I agree with Democrats about and disagree with many Republicans about. People hear that I don't believe the federal government should have the power to ban abortion, that I'm staunchly against the death penalty, and that I support gay marriage and then ask me, "How can you possibly be a Republican then??" Um, easy. There's a LOT more to it than just those issues. I honestly think that the vast majority of people who feel THIS strongly against the GOP are basing 99% of their opinion on a very small population of Republican politicians (mainly, unfortunately George W. Bush) and a very small group of issues. I think I'd get slammed for grouping all liberals into such a narrow category (and I don't, by the way... I actually acknowledge that people can align themselves with a political party and still remain free thinkers), so I'm always surprised as how often this happens to conservatives. This is not direct at the post I quoted AT ALL, but I feel the need to say it because it's something that irks me: I, personally, as a conservative, am tired of hearing non-conservatives tell me what I believe. I can think for myself, thank you. I will say that I feel many liberals such as myself (younger ones in particular) tend to interchange the three because many things DO seem that black and white. Well, if you don't want to dig deeper, of COURSE things will seem that black and white. The GOP isn't defined only by the last 8 years no more than the Democrats are characterized solely by Bill Clinton. What so many people fail to realize is that the Republican party isn't as flat as people seem to think it is. There are easily two groups falling under the GOP - yes, the Religious Right "Pat Robertson Republicans" as John McCain has called them is one sect. However, the vast majority of us don't fall under that sect. I thought John McCain did an excellent job in 2000 trying to distance himself from that sect when challenging George Bush. A lot of his words and speeches at that time have turned eerily prophetic... *shudder* (I'm a big separation of church and state person...) I think the GOP was somewhat reactionary in 2000 trying to be the family values party - and I admit I disagreed with that vehemently at the time. Unfortunately, that then became the defining characteristic (at leat to most non-conservatives) of the party for the past 8 years. Hopefully that will start to change. The fact that the Religious Right has shoved themselves into the lime light and rallied behind the Republicans doesn't change the fact that GOP appeals to people outside that narrowly defined group -- and has a history FAR broader than just the Religious Right. I find it incredibly closed minded (not to mention ironic) to hear liberals call the GOP closed minded, when they won't even entertain any explanation or argument on anything a conservative might actually say or think. They jsut think we're all a bunch of Religious Right Pat Robertson drones screaming "Jesus wants the government run this way!" when in fact, that's simply not true. They don't acknowledge that we can be just as intelligent and well-informed as they are and still disagree. I don't doubt there are conservatives who give the same closed-minded attitude toward more liberal stances. I just think that so many people like to think "conservative = closed-minded" and "liberal = open-minded" when, in fact, they're just misuing the words... I think I've come to the conclusion that many Democrats, in particular the younger ones whose political exposure to Republicans has mainly been Dubyah, just don't want to believe that the GOP isn't the same thing as the Religious Right and that there are Republicans out there who are NOT members of the Religious Right. They just turn a blind eye and don't even want to listen when any conservative speaks. That's their right, but it doesn't mean their interpretation of the GOP is accurate. Excellent post!!!
|
|
Posted 2/8/08 11:44 AM
|
|
|
Re: Being a Conservative Posted by hope2bamom ~Kara I got the BIGGEST smile on my face when I read this! I am so happy I started this thread I can't even tell you. I too, am very happy that you started this thread!
|
|
Posted 2/8/08 12:32 PM
|
|
| Pages: 1 [2] | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sorry- Do you thing my dr. is being too conservative | Dutchess | 1/3/08 | 13 | Multiple Births |
| do you think my ob/gyn is being too conservative?? | Dutchess | 1/2/08 | 2 | Multiple Births |








None of them were taught anything about the Constitution. My younger sister, who goes to a completely different school then I did in Washington (suppose to be one of the best
, throughout middle school and both 9th and 10th grade. We went over quite a bit. And even when I talk to all my friends about the Constitution (obviously something I am passionate about) they have NO idea what they are talking about. And when we discuss the New Deal, the repeat the same thing I was taught before I left. I pick on the New Deal, only because i feel it is very misrepresented.