Auto Gratuity

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 [2] 3

nferrandi
too excited for words

Member since 10/05

18538 total posts

Name:
Nicole

Re: Auto Gratuity

I get what you're saying about the mass produced food on a prixe fix, but again I wold bet the tip was just added because it was V Day. I know that DH and I went out for dinner during restaurant week and they added the tip for just the two of us. They would not have done it on a regular night. I think the theory was that people were getting a discounted meal but they wanted to protect their servers from having a "bad" night. I don't know if I agree with it, but I think that's the theory.

Posted 2/15/11 2:07 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

neener1211
:-)

Member since 4/07

22952 total posts

Name:
J

Re: Auto Gratuity

I think the Auto Gratuity thing is a little ridiculous, although I can understand wanting to protect employees.

I've seen the gratuities for 15%, 18% and 20% listed on the bill with the amounts so that you don't have to figure it out (not that it's hard to figure out). I think that is a little nicer than just assuming that service was good enough for 20%.

Posted 2/15/11 2:11 PM
 

AngnShaun
Sisters

Member since 1/10

21015 total posts

Name:
Ang

Re: Auto Gratuity

the hibachi place we go to does it...

Posted 2/15/11 2:16 PM
 

klingklang77
kraftwerk!

Member since 7/06

11489 total posts

Name:
Völlig losgelöst

Re: Auto Gratuity

Posted by Christine

Posted by nrthshgrl

Posted by klingklang77

Yes, they do the same job at a chain and a fancy restaurant, but a server pays taxes based on their sales. So if you leave $10 on a $50 check and $10 on a $100 check, the server in the last check kind of gets screwed.



I'm confused. Are you saying the waitress pays taxes based on their sales?? That's not my understanding.

I thought the waitress pays taxes based solely on her hourly wage & tipsChat Icon

Of course the restaurant does have to pay taxes but that's not the server's responsibility.

I do chalk it up to eating at a more expensive restaurant means I pay a larger tip. Cost of my eating there.

As for the auto gratuity, I'm just curious was it stated on the menu? It's a good heads up because I haven't noticed a lot of places adding it in but that may have changed.




The server pays income tax on their tips & wages. I believe the IRS estimates their tip income based on their reported sales. This way tax is paid on all (or just about all) of their tips whether the customer pays the tip by credit card or cash.

As far as the $$$ of the tip increasing with the prices of the restaurant, I am fine with that since he level of service increases as well. At more expensive restaurants, there are usually more people waiting on you and there is a much greater attention to detail that is may be over looked in less expensive places.



Yes, sorry I wasn't clear. At the end of the night, or whatever time frame, the server should declare all of their tips, but most declare about 10% (that's what is suggested) of their sales. If you get less than 10% every time you work, you should probably quit Chat Icon b/c you aren't that good. But you'll have to declare about 10% so there is no suspicion, even if you get less than that.

Then on top of that, depending on the restaurant, the server will have to "tip out" the other people. Chain places often work on this concept. Well at least they did when I worked there. So for example, bus boys, service bartenders, sometimes hostesses, and food runners don't have sales but they still get the low salary. The server will have to give them some money at the end of the night. That comes out of their tips as well. This doesn't happen in every restaurant.

My point being that if you give a flat tip, no matter what the bill at every place you go to, you could possibly hurt the server.

Posted 2/15/11 2:20 PM
 

sfp0701
Liam's Mommy!

Member since 1/07

9764 total posts

Name:
Tricia

Re: Auto Gratuity

I don't mind auto tip but, 20% seems a bit much. We usually tip that much but, it should be up to us. NOW.. I could see not putting 18% because, when a place does that we tend to just tip that. If they did 15% we would tip extra.

However, like I said. 20% is for good service. Don't assume I want/need to give that to you. I had a friend who was a waitress and she used to complain about the 20% percent rule and hated that people used that as the guidline. She thought 20% was cheap and people should tip moreChat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon ummm... no..

Posted 2/15/11 2:33 PM
 

MrsKS
Thank You St. Gerard.....

Member since 12/09

8306 total posts

Name:
Kerri

Re: Auto Gratuity

Posted by klingklang77

On holidays some restaurants do it. Where I worked they did it. 20% is a bit high IMO; 18% would be better. I don't doubt that you are a good tipper, but you'd be surprised at the people that go out only on holidays.

It's done to protect the waitstaff. I don't disagree with it as long as the service was good.

When I worked in the restaurant industry, we used to call Valentine's/NYE etc. "amateur night" Chat Icon .



I agree.

However, I usually see it happen with large parties.

I do understand the reasoning behind it. Again, so long as there is good service. I wonder though... if the service was very poor could you fight the auto gratuity amount?

the part of me that likes this idea comes from knowing and understanding how waitstaff works in most places. They really make VERY little an hour; in some cases less than $2 an hour. they literally live off of tips... and all too often they give great service only to be handed a piss poor tip. I've seen it happen so many times when I worked in this industry (I wasn't a waitress but worked in a diner). It always disturbed me to see a $2 tip on a $100 dollar bill with a party of 4. I've seen a few really amazing waitresses receive CHANGE... less than a dollar just thrown across the table. Chat Icon

Posted 2/15/11 2:41 PM
 

MrsKS
Thank You St. Gerard.....

Member since 12/09

8306 total posts

Name:
Kerri

Re: Auto Gratuity

Posted by sfp0701

I don't mind auto tip but, 20% seems a bit much. We usually tip that much but, it should be up to us. NOW.. I could see not putting 18% because, when a place does that we tend to just tip that. If they did 15% we would tip extra.

However, like I said. 20% is for good service. Don't assume I want/need to give that to you. I had a friend who was a waitress and she used to complain about the 20% percent rule and hated that people used that as the guidline. She thought 20% was cheap and people should tip moreChat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon ummm... no..



I think 20% is a good tip!!

where she was working...was it like a really inexpensive menu?? because 20% of like $10 might not be a lot... but most places it costs more than that to eat.

Posted 2/15/11 2:43 PM
 

apples99
love my sunshine..

Member since 11/08

1535 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Auto Gratuity

i just called them and i spoke to the "asst. manager" and she just brushed me off by saying, well it is how they do it on special occassions to keep the guests moving faster.. I asked, well why wasn't it made clear on anywhere and ask for more tip.. if you want people to get out then you just get a flat 20% and kick them out, rather than leave a line for additional tip Chat Icon she was, its for exceptional service.. Chat Icon

anyway, she told me to speak to general manager tomorrow.. how stupid..

Posted 2/15/11 2:49 PM
 

apples99
love my sunshine..

Member since 11/08

1535 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Auto Gratuity

Posted by MrsKS

Posted by sfp0701

I don't mind auto tip but, 20% seems a bit much. We usually tip that much but, it should be up to us. NOW.. I could see not putting 18% because, when a place does that we tend to just tip that. If they did 15% we would tip extra.

However, like I said. 20% is for good service. Don't assume I want/need to give that to you. I had a friend who was a waitress and she used to complain about the 20% percent rule and hated that people used that as the guidline. She thought 20% was cheap and people should tip moreChat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon ummm... no..



I think 20% is a good tip!!

where she was working...was it like a really inexpensive menu?? because 20% of like $10 might not be a lot... but most places it costs more than that to eat.



absolutely not.. it was just 20 or 25 bucks as tip, I would just chalked it up and been like whatever.. but this was not nice, especially since we had two drinks each at the bar (tipped the bartender) and it was added on to our dinner bill to be calculated into final tip again.. not nice!

Posted 2/15/11 2:51 PM
 

MrsKS
Thank You St. Gerard.....

Member since 12/09

8306 total posts

Name:
Kerri

Re: Auto Gratuity

Posted by klingklang77

Posted by Christine

Posted by nrthshgrl

Posted by klingklang77

Yes, they do the same job at a chain and a fancy restaurant, but a server pays taxes based on their sales. So if you leave $10 on a $50 check and $10 on a $100 check, the server in the last check kind of gets screwed.



I'm confused. Are you saying the waitress pays taxes based on their sales?? That's not my understanding.

I thought the waitress pays taxes based solely on her hourly wage & tipsChat Icon

Of course the restaurant does have to pay taxes but that's not the server's responsibility.

I do chalk it up to eating at a more expensive restaurant means I pay a larger tip. Cost of my eating there.

As for the auto gratuity, I'm just curious was it stated on the menu? It's a good heads up because I haven't noticed a lot of places adding it in but that may have changed.




The server pays income tax on their tips & wages. I believe the IRS estimates their tip income based on their reported sales. This way tax is paid on all (or just about all) of their tips whether the customer pays the tip by credit card or cash.

As far as the $$$ of the tip increasing with the prices of the restaurant, I am fine with that since he level of service increases as well. At more expensive restaurants, there are usually more people waiting on you and there is a much greater attention to detail that is may be over looked in less expensive places.



Yes, sorry I wasn't clear. At the end of the night, or whatever time frame, the server should declare all of their tips, but most declare about 10% (that's what is suggested) of their sales. If you get less than 10% every time you work, you should probably quit Chat Icon b/c you aren't that good. But you'll have to declare about 10% so there is no suspicion, even if you get less than that.

Then on top of that, depending on the restaurant, the server will have to "tip out" the other people. Chain places often work on this concept. Well at least they did when I worked there. So for example, bus boys, service bartenders, sometimes hostesses, and food runners don't have sales but they still get the low salary. The server will have to give them some money at the end of the night. That comes out of their tips as well. This doesn't happen in every restaurant.

My point being that if you give a flat tip, no matter what the bill at every place you go to, you could possibly hurt the server.



kingklang you are absolutely correct. My mother was a waitress for over 20 years and this is exactly how it worked. they have to claim a certain percentage of their tips on their taxes and their petty hourly salary is also taxes. and 10% is the norm of what they claim.

Also, in some cases.. the waitresses have to pay the BREAD people from their tips. You know the bread on the table at restaurants? Some places make the waitresses pay for that bread. The one place i worked at was like this and a place my mother worked at was also like this.

and a lot of diner's work on that concept as well... the "tip out" concept you posted about. And a lot of places work this way, not all but a lot.

Posted 2/15/11 2:54 PM
 

Pomegranate5
LIF Adult

Member since 2/11

4798 total posts

Name:
Pomegranate5

Re: Auto Gratuity

I used to work at a restaurant and on holidays where there was a special menu (V-Day, New Years Eve, etc) they usually added the gratuity to each bill no matter how big the party was. I think the norm was 18%, so I guess 20% doesn't seem unreasonable.

Posted 2/15/11 2:58 PM
 

MrsKS
Thank You St. Gerard.....

Member since 12/09

8306 total posts

Name:
Kerri

Re: Auto Gratuity

Posted by apples99

Posted by MrsKS

Posted by sfp0701

I don't mind auto tip but, 20% seems a bit much. We usually tip that much but, it should be up to us. NOW.. I could see not putting 18% because, when a place does that we tend to just tip that. If they did 15% we would tip extra.

However, like I said. 20% is for good service. Don't assume I want/need to give that to you. I had a friend who was a waitress and she used to complain about the 20% percent rule and hated that people used that as the guidline. She thought 20% was cheap and people should tip moreChat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon ummm... no..



I think 20% is a good tip!!

where she was working...was it like a really inexpensive menu?? because 20% of like $10 might not be a lot... but most places it costs more than that to eat.



absolutely not.. it was just 20 or 25 bucks as tip, I would just chalked it up and been like whatever.. but this was not nice, especially since we had two drinks each at the bar (tipped the bartender) and it was added on to our dinner bill to be calculated into final tip again.. not nice!



I'm confused. what part are you posting about?
I was specifically talking about the friend of sfp's who thinks 20% was a cheap tip and would complain about it.

Posted 2/15/11 2:58 PM
 

apples99
love my sunshine..

Member since 11/08

1535 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Auto Gratuity

Posted by MrsKS

Posted by apples99

Posted by MrsKS

Posted by sfp0701

I don't mind auto tip but, 20% seems a bit much. We usually tip that much but, it should be up to us. NOW.. I could see not putting 18% because, when a place does that we tend to just tip that. If they did 15% we would tip extra.

However, like I said. 20% is for good service. Don't assume I want/need to give that to you. I had a friend who was a waitress and she used to complain about the 20% percent rule and hated that people used that as the guidline. She thought 20% was cheap and people should tip moreChat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon ummm... no..



I think 20% is a good tip!!

where she was working...was it like a really inexpensive menu?? because 20% of like $10 might not be a lot... but most places it costs more than that to eat.



absolutely not.. it was just 20 or 25 bucks as tip, I would just chalked it up and been like whatever.. but this was not nice, especially since we had two drinks each at the bar (tipped the bartender) and it was added on to our dinner bill to be calculated into final tip again.. not nice!



I'm confused. what part are you posting about?
I was specifically talking about the friend of sfp's who thinks 20% was a cheap tip and would complain about it.



my fingers went quicker than my brain.. i realized that after i hit "post" Chat Icon

Posted 2/15/11 3:00 PM
 

MrsKS
Thank You St. Gerard.....

Member since 12/09

8306 total posts

Name:
Kerri

Re: Auto Gratuity

Posted by apples99

i just called them and i spoke to the "asst. manager" and she just brushed me off by saying, well it is how they do it on special occassions to keep the guests moving faster.. I asked, well why wasn't it made clear on anywhere and ask for more tip.. if you want people to get out then you just get a flat 20% and kick them out, rather than leave a line for additional tip Chat Icon she was, its for exceptional service.. Chat Icon

anyway, she told me to speak to general manager tomorrow.. how stupid..



food aside (because that's not the waitress's fault usually)... was it bad service??

ETA: usually when the gratuity is added automatically it says so on the menu... so if it's a holiday menu it states such right under where it says the holiday. Was that not there at all??

Message edited 2011-02-15 15:02:35.917000.

Posted 2/15/11 3:01 PM
 

heidla
Me and the guys

Member since 5/05

4024 total posts

Name:
Heidi

Re: Auto Gratuity

I work in a pretty popular and very touristy bar in the theatre district. In our case, we do auto grat at the tables because not only are we serving your drinks, we are also singing and providing your entertainment throughout the evening. This didn't used to be the norm, but after too many people came in had a great time and praised us and then left $2.00 on $150.00 check we decided that we needed to protect ourselves.

If you are auto grated and you don't feel that the service (not the crappy food or the tacky decor or the overpriced items or anything else that the staff has no control over) merited it you should ask for it to be removed.

Also, when you use a credit card it automatically prints the additional tip line. It's not our choice for it to be there.

Posted 2/15/11 3:04 PM
 

apples99
love my sunshine..

Member since 11/08

1535 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Auto Gratuity

Posted by MrsKS

Posted by apples99

i just called them and i spoke to the "asst. manager" and she just brushed me off by saying, well it is how they do it on special occassions to keep the guests moving faster.. I asked, well why wasn't it made clear on anywhere and ask for more tip.. if you want people to get out then you just get a flat 20% and kick them out, rather than leave a line for additional tip Chat Icon she was, its for exceptional service.. Chat Icon

anyway, she told me to speak to general manager tomorrow.. how stupid..



food aside (because that's not the waitress's fault usually)... was it bad service??

ETA: usually when the gratuity is added automatically it says so on the menu... so if it's a holiday menu it states such right under where it says the holiday. Was that not there at all??



it was ok, i did feel rushed, but i'm a slow eater.. and we would have possibly left 20% anyway

it wasn't mentioned anywhere, had it been mentioned on their website or on the special menus they created for yesterday, it would have been fine as it was advertised as such.. but they didnt.. o well.. its like Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 2/15/11 3:06 PM
 

MrsKS
Thank You St. Gerard.....

Member since 12/09

8306 total posts

Name:
Kerri

Re: Auto Gratuity

Posted by apples99

Posted by MrsKS

Posted by apples99

i just called them and i spoke to the "asst. manager" and she just brushed me off by saying, well it is how they do it on special occassions to keep the guests moving faster.. I asked, well why wasn't it made clear on anywhere and ask for more tip.. if you want people to get out then you just get a flat 20% and kick them out, rather than leave a line for additional tip Chat Icon she was, its for exceptional service.. Chat Icon

anyway, she told me to speak to general manager tomorrow.. how stupid..



food aside (because that's not the waitress's fault usually)... was it bad service??

ETA: usually when the gratuity is added automatically it says so on the menu... so if it's a holiday menu it states such right under where it says the holiday. Was that not there at all??



it was ok, i did feel rushed, but i'm a slow eater.. and we would have possibly left 20% anyway

it wasn't mentioned anywhere, had it been mentioned on their website or on the special menus they created for yesterday, it would have been fine as it was advertised as such.. but they didnt.. o well.. its like Chat Icon Chat Icon



all in all it should be listed somewhere if it's not the norm.

valentines day is a HUGE day to go out, so you might have actually been rushed because of how busy the waitress might have been.

I think if you were going to leave 20% regardless than there's no use getting too upset over it. I know you said you called the restaurant, were you going to take the tip back at all? Or was that just to say Hey next time can you give your customers a heads up??

I have a story that would really leave you livid!! I had a really really really awful server. I mean literally the worst I've ever had in my life! And I have a soft spot for servers. When I paid the bill with my debit card, I left NO TIP and wrote such on the receipt. The ring up was the amount of the bill without tip. When I went to check my bank acct a few days later, this guy had added his own tip on!!! It wasn't an auto grat thing either.. he literally just wrote his tip in!! I called and demanded my tip money back and told the manager the whole story. then i went on yelp.com and did a review using his name and all!! I couldn't believe it!! And there were other reviews of guys from the same place doing the same thing to them!! changing their tip amounts and all.

Posted 2/15/11 3:11 PM
 

MrsKS
Thank You St. Gerard.....

Member since 12/09

8306 total posts

Name:
Kerri

Re: Auto Gratuity

Posted by heidla

I work in a pretty popular and very touristy bar in the theatre district. In our case, we do auto grat at the tables because not only are we serving your drinks, we are also singing and providing your entertainment throughout the evening. This didn't used to be the norm, but after too many people came in had a great time and praised us and then left $2.00 on $150.00 check we decided that we needed to protect ourselves.

If you are auto grated and you don't feel that the service (not the crappy food or the tacky decor or the overpriced items or anything else that the staff has no control over) merited it you should ask for it to be removed.

Also, when you use a credit card it automatically prints the additional tip line. It's not our choice for it to be there.



ITA with all you wrote!
the 2 on a 150 bill used to really annoy me. it's so rude. I'm for auto gratuity in some cases. this is the main reason.

Also, a lot of times the waitress or waiter is punished with a bad tip due to situations which are not their fault at all. I've def seen that happen a lot.

And even your 3rd point.... that even happens at pizzeria restaurants. When I leave the tip on my card, it adds it to the total and still adds a tip line anyway.

Posted 2/15/11 3:14 PM
 

apples99
love my sunshine..

Member since 11/08

1535 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Auto Gratuity

Posted by MrsKS

all in all it should be listed somewhere if it's not the norm.

valentines day is a HUGE day to go out, so you might have actually been rushed because of how busy the waitress might have been.

I think if you were going to leave 20% regardless than there's no use getting too upset over it. I know you said you called the restaurant, were you going to take the tip back at all? Or was that just to say Hey next time can you give your customers a heads up??

I have a story that would really leave you livid!! I had a really really really awful server. I mean literally the worst I've ever had in my life! And I have a soft spot for servers. When I paid the bill with my debit card, I left NO TIP and wrote such on the receipt. The ring up was the amount of the bill without tip. When I went to check my bank acct a few days later, this guy had added his own tip on!!! It wasn't an auto grat thing either.. he literally just wrote his tip in!! I called and demanded my tip money back and told the manager the whole story. then i went on yelp.com and did a review using his name and all!! I couldn't believe it!! And there were other reviews of guys from the same place doing the same thing to them!! changing their tip amounts and all.




I would never take the tip back.. it just to find out whether this was the norm or not.. I "yelped" them as well and nothing about the auto grat was mentioned so it was kinda like, ok well next time inform your patrons please.

What happend to you.. is theft! He robbed you and the waiter should have been fired! I can't believe that.. Chat Icon

Posted 2/15/11 3:15 PM
 

MrsKS
Thank You St. Gerard.....

Member since 12/09

8306 total posts

Name:
Kerri

Re: Auto Gratuity

Posted by apples99

Posted by MrsKS

all in all it should be listed somewhere if it's not the norm.

valentines day is a HUGE day to go out, so you might have actually been rushed because of how busy the waitress might have been.

I think if you were going to leave 20% regardless than there's no use getting too upset over it. I know you said you called the restaurant, were you going to take the tip back at all? Or was that just to say Hey next time can you give your customers a heads up??

I have a story that would really leave you livid!! I had a really really really awful server. I mean literally the worst I've ever had in my life! And I have a soft spot for servers. When I paid the bill with my debit card, I left NO TIP and wrote such on the receipt. The ring up was the amount of the bill without tip. When I went to check my bank acct a few days later, this guy had added his own tip on!!! It wasn't an auto grat thing either.. he literally just wrote his tip in!! I called and demanded my tip money back and told the manager the whole story. then i went on yelp.com and did a review using his name and all!! I couldn't believe it!! And there were other reviews of guys from the same place doing the same thing to them!! changing their tip amounts and all.




I would never take the tip back.. it just to find out whether this was the norm or not.. I "yelped" them as well and nothing about the auto grat was mentioned so it was kinda like, ok well next time inform your patrons please.

What happend to you.. is theft! He robbed you and the waiter should have been fired! I can't believe that.. Chat Icon



isn't that crazy!! and part (only part because there's more) of why he was a bad waiter was because he HAND SIFTED through my sandwich to remove bacon and threw the cheese that had been all through his hands back on my sandwich... it had fingerprints and all in it!!!! times that that I wish i was from the board of health!!!

I agree the auto grat should def be listed someplace.

Posted 2/15/11 3:21 PM
 

apples99
love my sunshine..

Member since 11/08

1535 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Auto Gratuity

Posted by heidla

I work in a pretty popular and very touristy bar in the theatre district. In our case, we do auto grat at the tables because not only are we serving your drinks, we are also singing and providing your entertainment throughout the evening. This didn't used to be the norm, but after too many people came in had a great time and praised us and then left $2.00 on $150.00 check we decided that we needed to protect ourselves.

If you are auto grated and you don't feel that the service (not the crappy food or the tacky decor or the overpriced items or anything else that the staff has no control over) merited it you should ask for it to be removed.

Also, when you use a credit card it automatically prints the additional tip line. It's not our choice for it to be there.



I would be pizzed off too about 2 bucks on 150 check.. but just playing devil's advocate, some of them may have been toursits and not sure how do this.. in many places, you pay the bill and leave the "change" as tip.. and a while back we had guests from overseas and one of men told my dad that he was showing off for tipping so high Chat Icon Chat Icon and of course it went through the grapevine back home and we heard it from some our relatives as well.. so I can understand with some folks..

And honestly, I don't many people going out to have a good time would have pulled a manager aside and been like take off the tip.. maybe some, but a lot people will not for the fear of being labelled cheap. I totally get why it was done.. I was just questioning about this being the norm.. and we did not go anywhere in the City, and stayed local.

Message edited 2011-02-15 15:26:17.640000.

Posted 2/15/11 3:25 PM
 

GinaR
LIF Adult

Member since 9/08

1976 total posts

Name:
Gina

Re: Auto Gratuity

It is not usually done for groups smaller than like 6 people. And it is usually like 18% not 20% that is added. And if it will beadded, I think it needs to be stated on the menu somewhere. Honestly, if you had only wanted to tip say 17% I think you can just do the math yourself and leave that amount. i don't think they can stop you for it, kwim? Unless it was mentioned somewhere.

Posted 2/15/11 3:50 PM
 

JessInCA
live laugh love

Member since 8/06

5082 total posts

Name:
Jess

Re: Auto Gratuity

I've also seen it in resturants on holidays with the prix fixe menu. No biggie, but it would've been a good idea to let people know about it ahead of time.

Posted 2/15/11 4:08 PM
 

heidla
Me and the guys

Member since 5/05

4024 total posts

Name:
Heidi

Re: Auto Gratuity

Posted by apples99

Posted by heidla

I work in a pretty popular and very touristy bar in the theatre district. In our case, we do auto grat at the tables because not only are we serving your drinks, we are also singing and providing your entertainment throughout the evening. This didn't used to be the norm, but after too many people came in had a great time and praised us and then left $2.00 on $150.00 check we decided that we needed to protect ourselves.

If you are auto grated and you don't feel that the service (not the crappy food or the tacky decor or the overpriced items or anything else that the staff has no control over) merited it you should ask for it to be removed.

Also, when you use a credit card it automatically prints the additional tip line. It's not our choice for it to be there.



I would be pizzed off too about 2 bucks on 150 check.. but just playing devil's advocate, some of them may have been toursits and not sure how do this.. in many places, you pay the bill and leave the "change" as tip.. and a while back we had guests from overseas and one of men told my dad that he was showing off for tipping so high Chat Icon Chat Icon and of course it went through the grapevine back home and we heard it from some our relatives as well.. so I can understand with some folks..

And honestly, I don't many people going out to have a good time would have pulled a manager aside and been like take off the tip.. maybe some, but a lot people will not for the fear of being labelled cheap. I totally get why it was done.. I was just questioning about this being the norm.. and we did not go anywhere in the City, and stayed local.



I understand that tipping customs in other countries differ that is part of the reason we decided to start auto grating. I also know that some people are just a-holes. A couple of weeks ago we had a party of 12. One of them came to the bar and asked for their check while their server was singing. I gave them their check. They left the money on the table and left. When their server brought the check to me to ring it into the register they had left $159.00 to cover a $432.00 check. They had just left so I followed them into another bar down the street. They explained that some people left the party early and didn't leave money for their portion of the bill. I explained that I was sorry they had crappy friends, but that they chose them and they were still responsible for the bill (mind you I was screamng this all over crappy techno music surrounded by gay men and drag queensChat Icon ) Finally, after I mentioned calling the cops, one of them gave me a credit card. You would think that stuff like this is a rarity, but sadly it's not. I've gotten very good at running through the crowds on 46th street over the past 11 yrs.

I have had people ask for hte grat to be taken off and I have no problem with doing so if the service was bad. I work with a couple of people that feel they deserve that tip no matter what, but I don't think we are just entitled to a tip. I work for it.

Posted 2/15/11 5:35 PM
 

apples99
love my sunshine..

Member since 11/08

1535 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Auto Gratuity

Posted by heidla


I understand that tipping customs in other countries differ that is part of the reason we decided to start auto grating. I also know that some people are just a-holes. A couple of weeks ago we had a party of 12. One of them came to the bar and asked for their check while their server was singing. I gave them their check. They left the money on the table and left. When their server brought the check to me to ring it into the register they had left $159.00 to cover a $432.00 check. They had just left so I followed them into another bar down the street. They explained that some people left the party early and didn't leave money for their portion of the bill. I explained that I was sorry they had crappy friends, but that they chose them and they were still responsible for the bill (mind you I was screamng this all over crappy techno music surrounded by gay men and drag queensChat Icon ) Finally, after I mentioned calling the cops, one of them gave me a credit card. You would think that stuff like this is a rarity, but sadly it's not. I've gotten very good at running through the crowds on 46th street over the past 11 yrs.





omg.. that is horrible!! i would have been so embarrsed if my friends pulled something like that.. geeze.. and u running after them, omg, I'd be scared Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon I'm scared to even ask how what convo went down.. wow

Posted 2/15/11 5:45 PM
 
Pages: 1 [2] 3
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Should the Auto Industry Be Bailed Out? .. Dulcinea 11/12/08 56 Families Helping Families ™
At what age is your auto insurance supposed to go down? Mommy2Boys 10/13/08 9 Families Helping Families ™
is there an auto insurance company that doesnt check your credit? Jessica 7/22/08 6 Families Helping Families ™
What are interest rates on auto loans right now? Mommy2Boys 3/3/08 2 Families Helping Families ™
does any one know of any auto body shops... antoinette 2/23/08 7 Families Helping Families ™
Has anyone ever used Big Bucks Auto to sell their car??? beautyq115 6/30/07 3 Families Helping Families ™