Re: Auto Gratuity
Posted 2/15/2011 2:54:02 PM by MrsKS


Posted by klingklang77


Posted by Christine


Posted by nrthshgrl


Posted by klingklang77

Yes, they do the same job at a chain and a fancy restaurant, but a server pays taxes based on their sales. So if you leave $10 on a $50 check and $10 on a $100 check, the server in the last check kind of gets screwed.



I'm confused. Are you saying the waitress pays taxes based on their sales?? That's not my understanding.

I thought the waitress pays taxes based solely on her hourly wage & tipsChat Icon

Of course the restaurant does have to pay taxes but that's not the server's responsibility.

I do chalk it up to eating at a more expensive restaurant means I pay a larger tip. Cost of my eating there.

As for the auto gratuity, I'm just curious was it stated on the menu? It's a good heads up because I haven't noticed a lot of places adding it in but that may have changed.




The server pays income tax on their tips & wages. I believe the IRS estimates their tip income based on their reported sales. This way tax is paid on all (or just about all) of their tips whether the customer pays the tip by credit card or cash.

As far as the $$$ of the tip increasing with the prices of the restaurant, I am fine with that since he level of service increases as well. At more expensive restaurants, there are usually more people waiting on you and there is a much greater attention to detail that is may be over looked in less expensive places.



Yes, sorry I wasn't clear. At the end of the night, or whatever time frame, the server should declare all of their tips, but most declare about 10% (that's what is suggested) of their sales. If you get less than 10% every time you work, you should probably quit Chat Icon b/c you aren't that good. But you'll have to declare about 10% so there is no suspicion, even if you get less than that.

Then on top of that, depending on the restaurant, the server will have to "tip out" the other people. Chain places often work on this concept. Well at least they did when I worked there. So for example, bus boys, service bartenders, sometimes hostesses, and food runners don't have sales but they still get the low salary. The server will have to give them some money at the end of the night. That comes out of their tips as well. This doesn't happen in every restaurant.

My point being that if you give a flat tip, no matter what the bill at every place you go to, you could possibly hurt the server.



kingklang you are absolutely correct. My mother was a waitress for over 20 years and this is exactly how it worked. they have to claim a certain percentage of their tips on their taxes and their petty hourly salary is also taxes. and 10% is the norm of what they claim.

Also, in some cases.. the waitresses have to pay the BREAD people from their tips. You know the bread on the table at restaurants? Some places make the waitresses pay for that bread. The one place i worked at was like this and a place my mother worked at was also like this.

and a lot of diner's work on that concept as well... the "tip out" concept you posted about. And a lot of places work this way, not all but a lot.
Print Post      Close Window