Auto Gratuity

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2 3

apples99
love my sunshine..

Member since 11/08

1535 total posts

Name:
me

Auto Gratuity

Anyone hear of such a thing? DH and I went out for dinner last night and there was a 20% auto gratuity added to our bill.. it was just part of the bill.. no suggested tip, or anything like that. Then there was another line for additional tip?!?

I have seen tips added on for a party of 5 or more.. which at best is 15% and then some indicate what the tip would be at 10% 15% 17% and 20%.. and you can pick whatever you'd like.

I never saw an auto gratuity added on.. and I have had my fair share of fine meals and not so fine meals, we are huge tippers regardless.. but in this situation, the food was slightly better than avg, and it was from a prix fixe menu, so it wasn't anything out of the ordinary.. is this the norm?

Posted 2/15/11 8:33 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

MrsMerlot
Unconditional Love

Member since 4/06

6005 total posts

Name:
Chrissy

Re: Auto Gratuity

About 15% of the restaurants I've been to in the city include gratuity and clearly stated on the bill.

Just came back from Miami - and gratuity is ALWAYS included - so it's now the "norm" for me to look at the bill and see if it's there.

Posted 2/15/11 8:36 AM
 

apples99
love my sunshine..

Member since 11/08

1535 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Auto Gratuity

Posted by MrsMerlot

About 15% of the restaurants I've been to in the city include gratuity and clearly stated on the bill.

Just came back from Miami - and gratuity is ALWAYS included - so it's now the "norm" for me to look at the bill and see if it's there.



I know that about Miami but this just says Auto Gratuity and amount..

Posted 2/15/11 8:38 AM
 

klingklang77
kraftwerk!

Member since 7/06

11489 total posts

Name:
Völlig losgelöst

Re: Auto Gratuity

On holidays some restaurants do it. Where I worked they did it. 20% is a bit high IMO; 18% would be better. I don't doubt that you are a good tipper, but you'd be surprised at the people that go out only on holidays.

It's done to protect the waitstaff. I don't disagree with it as long as the service was good.

When I worked in the restaurant industry, we used to call Valentine's/NYE etc. "amateur night" Chat Icon .

Posted 2/15/11 8:40 AM
 

apples99
love my sunshine..

Member since 11/08

1535 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Auto Gratuity

Posted by klingklang77

On holidays some restaurants do it. Where I worked they did it. 20% is a bit high IMO; 18% would be better. I don't doubt that you are a good tipper, but you'd be surprised at the people that go out only on holidays.

It's done to protect the waitstaff. I don't disagree with it as long as the service was good.

When I worked in the restaurant industry, we used to call Valentine's/NYE etc. "amateur night" Chat Icon .




Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Amateur night.. lol

I can see their point then.. but it wasn't indicated anywhere that they would do this.. so I was taken aback that semi nice restaurant would actually do this.. the service was decent, it was kind of like an assembly line.. plop the plate, remove it, next item.

But its cute that there's a term coined for this.. Chat Icon

Posted 2/15/11 8:47 AM
 

LeShellem
A new beginning

Member since 2/07

3600 total posts

Name:
LeShelle

Re: Auto Gratuity

The majority of the restaurants I have gone to in NYC do this. Most of the times it isn't all that obvious.

Posted 2/15/11 9:21 AM
 

leighdvm
My golden boys!

Member since 3/06

4419 total posts

Name:
Michele

Re: Auto Gratuity

I've seen it down here in NC for parties of 8 or more (or 10, depending on restaurant). I've noticed there's an additional tip line, but if 18% is already added, I usually don't add extra.

Posted 2/15/11 9:22 AM
 

StaceyWill
It's a girl!!!

Member since 6/10

21539 total posts

Name:
Stacey

Re: Auto Gratuity

They started doing this at one of our fave restaurants. We questioned it and the waiter said that they don't see any of that $$, that it's for renovations or something. Needless to say, we don't go there anymore.

Posted 2/15/11 9:40 AM
 

jilliibabii
Mrs. O'Connor

Member since 6/10

12821 total posts

Name:
Jillian

Re: Auto Gratuity

I've only ever seen this for large groups or on the cruise we go on.

Posted 2/15/11 9:42 AM
 

apples99
love my sunshine..

Member since 11/08

1535 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Auto Gratuity

We didn't question it either.. I would have, but DH just wanted to let it go, so I figured I'd ask here. Had it been 15% or 18%, I think I would have been much more ok with it because it is standard.. but 20% for medicore service and then asking for additional tip just rubbed me the wrong way. Maybe I'm just looking way too much into it.. I do find it a bit tacky but I can see their side as well.. they don't want to get jipped but it was a semi fine restaurant, and I feel their patrons would have tipped generously without them having to do this..

Posted 2/15/11 9:47 AM
 

jasmine
little boy blue <3

Member since 10/10

1475 total posts

Name:
x

Re: Auto Gratuity

Seems to be common for larger groups, I guess because it's tough on the waitstaff and the restaurant wants to protect them from being screwed over. A lot of the time I have found automatic gratuity = half-asssed service.

The only time it annoys me is if they are not upfront about the fact that it is included. Ex: a sportsbar we used to frequent has an automatic 20% grat. We didn't realize at first because they bring the bill and once you give your card thely bring you back just the CC slip so you only see the total and the add'l tip line. I'm sure its done purposefully. We definitely double-tipped at least once before we caught on. I can only imagine how many people are drinking and fail to realize the bill is higher than it should be. I think it should be printed in bold on the bill and the CC slip. Now we write "gratuity included" on the tip line.

Posted 2/15/11 10:03 AM
 

Thats-what-she-said
LIF Infant

Member since 2/11

285 total posts

Name:
Just Me

Re: Auto Gratuity

Since I waitressed my way through college I totally think this is a great idea. Although I think you should be able to choose the percentage you want to leave.

Unfortunately most people are not good tippers. Maybe it is that people don't realize waiters and waitresses are making so little per hour, or they are just cheap, but some people would not hesitate to just leave $5 on the table no matter how much the bill is.

Posted 2/15/11 10:17 AM
 

apples99
love my sunshine..

Member since 11/08

1535 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Auto Gratuity

Posted by Thats-what-she-said

Since I waitressed my way through college I totally think this is a great idea. Although I think you should be able to choose the percentage you want to leave.



ITA and or if they will blindly add gratutity, it should be mentioned somewhere on the menu so guests can see it when they are sober Chat Icon

Posted 2/15/11 10:20 AM
 

nferrandi
too excited for words

Member since 10/05

18538 total posts

Name:
Nicole

Re: Auto Gratuity

I wouldn't be surprised if it was just because it was a holiday. And since it was a prixe fixe, chances are you got your coursed dinner at a discount compared to ordering the same items off the meni, which is probably why they bumped the tip to 20%

Posted 2/15/11 10:53 AM
 

JennP
LIF Adult

Member since 10/06

3986 total posts

Name:
Jenn

Re: Auto Gratuity

I haven't seen this but we don't go out to eat much.

This would annoy me, though. It's a pet peeve of mine; I don't like being told how much of a tip to leave.

This from a great tipper and former waitress.

Posted 2/15/11 11:02 AM
 

SlurpeeDad
LIF Adolescent

Member since 1/11

713 total posts

Name:
SlurpeeDad

Re: Auto Gratuity

I work in an industry that involves tipping and I think this is a little ridiculous. I have no problem with it for parties of 6 or more, but for a couple to go out and have a tip already included in the bill is not cool with me. I want the ability to tip what I think is appropriate. Where is the incentive for the waiter/waitress to do a good job if they already know their tip?

On a separate note, I don't necessarily understand the 20% rule anyway. If I got to a fancier restaurant, the waiter/waitress doesn't really do anything different then the one's at a chain restaurant but because the food and booze are more money, they make more money? I don't think I'm cheap and will always tip the appropriate amount, I just don't know if I agree with it.

Posted 2/15/11 11:03 AM
 

apples99
love my sunshine..

Member since 11/08

1535 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Auto Gratuity

Posted by nferrandi

I wouldn't be surprised if it was just because it was a holiday. And since it was a prixe fixe, chances are you got your coursed dinner at a discount compared to ordering the same items off the meni, which is probably why they bumped the tip to 20%



ITA.. prixe fixe menus are discounted, but the quality is also not par to their regular menu. It's massed produced and to honest, they items they had on their menu yesterday is not a part of their regular menu.. close variations.

Posted 2/15/11 11:14 AM
 

Blu-ize
Plan B is Now Plan A

Member since 7/05

32475 total posts

Name:
Susan

Re: Auto Gratuity

I think that's nuts for a small party.

what if the service sucked?

I've waitressed and what incentive does that give a server to do a good job?

Posted 2/15/11 11:18 AM
 

PumpkinGirl
:o)

Member since 10/08

1838 total posts

Name:

Re: Auto Gratuity

Posted by Blu-ize

I think that's nuts for a small party.

what if the service sucked?

I've waitressed and what incentive does that give a server to do a good job?



I agree. I wouldn't ever do less than 15% even if they were horrible, but I agree the amount should be up to the patron.. not an automatic 20%

Posted 2/15/11 11:23 AM
 

klingklang77
kraftwerk!

Member since 7/06

11489 total posts

Name:
Völlig losgelöst

Re: Auto Gratuity

Posted by SlurpeeDad

On a separate note, I don't necessarily understand the 20% rule anyway. If I got to a fancier restaurant, the waiter/waitress doesn't really do anything different then the one's at a chain restaurant but because the food and booze are more money, they make more money? I don't think I'm cheap and will always tip the appropriate amount, I just don't know if I agree with it.



I'm a little confused. Would you tip, for example, 15% at a chain restaurant and 15% at a nice restaurant? Do you mean the same percentage for both types of restaurants?

Yes, they do the same job at a chain and a fancy restaurant, but a server pays taxes based on their sales. So if you leave $10 on a $50 check and $10 on a $100 check, the server in the last check kind of gets screwed.

Posted 2/15/11 12:36 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Auto Gratuity

Posted by klingklang77

Yes, they do the same job at a chain and a fancy restaurant, but a server pays taxes based on their sales. So if you leave $10 on a $50 check and $10 on a $100 check, the server in the last check kind of gets screwed.



I'm confused. Are you saying the waitress pays taxes based on their sales?? That's not my understanding.

I thought the waitress pays taxes based solely on her hourly wage & tipsChat Icon

Of course the restaurant does have to pay taxes but that's not the server's responsibility.

I do chalk it up to eating at a more expensive restaurant means I pay a larger tip. Cost of my eating there.

As for the auto gratuity, I'm just curious was it stated on the menu? It's a good heads up because I haven't noticed a lot of places adding it in but that may have changed.

Posted 2/15/11 12:44 PM
 

SlurpeeDad
LIF Adolescent

Member since 1/11

713 total posts

Name:
SlurpeeDad

Re: Auto Gratuity

Posted by klingklang77

Posted by SlurpeeDad

On a separate note, I don't necessarily understand the 20% rule anyway. If I got to a fancier restaurant, the waiter/waitress doesn't really do anything different then the one's at a chain restaurant but because the food and booze are more money, they make more money? I don't think I'm cheap and will always tip the appropriate amount, I just don't know if I agree with it.



I'm a little confused. Would you tip, for example, 15% at a chain restaurant and 15% at a nice restaurant? Do you mean the same percentage for both types of restaurants?

Yes, they do the same job at a chain and a fancy restaurant, but a server pays taxes based on their sales. So if you leave $10 on a $50 check and $10 on a $100 check, the server in the last check kind of gets screwed.



I always tip 15%-20% no matter what restaurant I go to. I understand that the tip will be more at more expensive restaurants, I just don't really agree with it.

I don't understand why any server would be screwed when it comes to taxes though. I would imagine they get taxed on their base pay and whatever tips they report. I don't see why they would get taxed on the amount of sales, when they aren't guaranteed an exact tip. I could be wrong, but that just doesn't make sense to me.

Posted 2/15/11 12:51 PM
 

apples99
love my sunshine..

Member since 11/08

1535 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Auto Gratuity

Posted by nrthshgrl
As for the auto gratuity, I'm just curious was it stated on the menu? It's a good heads up because I haven't noticed a lot of places adding it in but that may have changed.




Nope.. not listed. Had it been listed, then fine. It was our call whether we wanted to eat there or not.. but it was not listed anywhere.. just came with the bill and it was cost of food and drinks, tax and then auto gratuity.

When we got the sign the receipt, it had the amount, "additional tip" and total..

tacky, tacky, tacky.. I think I'm going to call them to let them know..

Posted 2/15/11 12:51 PM
 

Sweetheart409
LIF Adult

Member since 11/10

2219 total posts

Name:

Re: Auto Gratuity

i've only seen this in restaurants in the city before and it was 20%...

Posted 2/15/11 1:00 PM
 

Christine
2nd verse same as the 1st

Member since 5/05

15287 total posts

Name:

Re: Auto Gratuity

Posted by nrthshgrl

Posted by klingklang77

Yes, they do the same job at a chain and a fancy restaurant, but a server pays taxes based on their sales. So if you leave $10 on a $50 check and $10 on a $100 check, the server in the last check kind of gets screwed.



I'm confused. Are you saying the waitress pays taxes based on their sales?? That's not my understanding.

I thought the waitress pays taxes based solely on her hourly wage & tipsChat Icon

Of course the restaurant does have to pay taxes but that's not the server's responsibility.

I do chalk it up to eating at a more expensive restaurant means I pay a larger tip. Cost of my eating there.

As for the auto gratuity, I'm just curious was it stated on the menu? It's a good heads up because I haven't noticed a lot of places adding it in but that may have changed.




The server pays income tax on their tips & wages. I believe the IRS estimates their tip income based on their reported sales. This way tax is paid on all (or just about all) of their tips whether the customer pays the tip by credit card or cash.

As far as the $$$ of the tip increasing with the prices of the restaurant, I am fine with that since he level of service increases as well. At more expensive restaurants, there are usually more people waiting on you and there is a much greater attention to detail that is may be over looked in less expensive places.

Posted 2/15/11 1:08 PM
 
Pages: [1] 2 3
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Should the Auto Industry Be Bailed Out? .. Dulcinea 11/12/08 56 Families Helping Families ™
At what age is your auto insurance supposed to go down? Mommy2Boys 10/13/08 9 Families Helping Families ™
is there an auto insurance company that doesnt check your credit? Jessica 7/22/08 6 Families Helping Families ™
What are interest rates on auto loans right now? Mommy2Boys 3/3/08 2 Families Helping Families ™
does any one know of any auto body shops... antoinette 2/23/08 7 Families Helping Families ™
Has anyone ever used Big Bucks Auto to sell their car??? beautyq115 6/30/07 3 Families Helping Families ™