Article: Down and Out on $250,000
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: 1 [2] | |
|
Re: Article: Down and Out on $250,000 Posted by ap123 This article does a really good job of explaining that $250k does not make you rich, it barely makes you comfortable if you are living in an expensive town, close to the city with good schools. Nothing says congrats for your hard work and success like getting the privilege of footing over 50% of the nations tax bill. I think this sums it up perfectly!!!! |
|
Posted 3/26/11 9:26 AM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: Article: Down and Out on $250,000 Posted by Ophelia Posted by neener1211 I just wish someone would pay me a $250k salary so I could prove this article wrong. talk to your neighborhood plumber. he's got none of those pesky student loan payments. and some of his income is in cash and not reported. The average income in LI doesn't take into account that many people under report their earnings. |
|
Posted 3/26/11 10:32 AM
|
|
|
Re: Article: Down and Out on $250,000 Posted by lululu Definitely think that a big part of it is commuting costs to NYC. we live only 28 minutes from the city and my husbands LIRR ticket and metrocard costs $270 a month PLUS $3 a day to park at the train station - so $330 a month. If we were both working in the city that's an additional $660 a month!!! It's crazy!!! Are you in Nassau or Queens? I'm 30 minutes from the city in Queens, my DH pays the same for commuting & on top of that we have city tax to pay. My house is overpriced & has about 0 feet of land! For some reason we still stay
|
|
Posted 3/26/11 10:51 AM
|
|
|
Re: Article: Down and Out on $250,000 Posted by JenniferEver I think though that saying "$250K does not make you rich in LI" really depends on what your definition of rich is. Because I grew up in a working class neighborhood in a single income working class family with uneducated parents, to me people who live in houses, not apartments are rich. A backyard and a pool = rich! Taking one or more vacations every year = rich. I have friends who grew up in other parts of Queens for whom the above was the norm and they'd call themselves middle class. In NYC/LI I think a lot of us are just accustomed to a higher standard of living, and other people might call "rich" what we call "comfortable" Think about how people live upstate or in other parts of the country...I think it's also a matter of perspective. ETA: According to the article, it's the 97th percentile for household income in the US. How could that possibly NOT be considered rich? ITA, I grew up middle class, but never considered ourselves rich, but what I considered comfortable, and was achieved on less than 250,000, would be considered wealthy in other parts of the country. I went to private school, we owned a beach house, went skiing every winter. These were normal to me, but might seem excessive in other parts of the country. Also, people in this area, myself included, live beyond their means, which is not comfortable. Message edited 2011-03-26 10:54:25.180000. |
|
Posted 3/26/11 10:53 AM
|
|
|
Re: Article: Down and Out on $250,000 Posted by ChrisDee We live in Port Jeff, DH takes the LIRR to work and works long hours. Just his train ticket is over $400 per month and another $300 plus in gas to get to Ronkonkoma Train Station. He commutes about 4 hrs per day. If he has a fair amount of Overtime, he sleeps at work because it is not worth coming home. We pay a fair amount in taxes, plus all the commuting costs it is not as cheap as you might think. We all make our choices and do what we have to do. I will tell you this. We could live like rich people(my perspective) on $250,000. We have a pretty good life on a lot less. I know everyone has a different opinion of what is important/not important but for us (especially having lived out of state and seeing a different way of life) but having to commute 4 hours a day in order to live well in this area is not my idea of living the good life. (I am not attacking you -- I am attacking the situation in NY) This is also why we pay through the nose to rent a 1br apartment in the city. In many respects I do consider us well off (and we make under $250k), but between the staggering amount of taxes we pay especially after the city taxes are added on, I think that you still have to make a lot of sacrifices to live on or near $250k in many areas around here whether it is commute, living accommodations, etc because the salary you bring in limits you. My definition of the word "rich" would mean not having to do that. Just a different perspective... |
|
Posted 3/26/11 11:11 AM
|
|
|
Re: Article: Down and Out on $250,000 Posted by lululu Posted by ap123 This article does a really good job of explaining that $250k does not make you rich, it barely makes you comfortable if you are living in an expensive town, close to the city with good schools. Nothing says congrats for your hard work and success like getting the privilege of footing over 50% of the nations tax bill. I think this sums it up perfectly!!!! Definately! Here on LI it takes $250k to be able to make tax & mortgage payments on a nice home, pay for healthcare, food, transportation, and a few basic extras like cable, childcare, etc. and still have anything left over for "luxuries" like saving enough for retirement and your children's education. The high cost of local & state taxes was a real eye-opener. |
|
Posted 3/26/11 11:36 AM
|
|
|
Re: Article: Down and Out on $250,000 Posted by jasmine Posted by ChrisDee We live in Port Jeff, DH takes the LIRR to work and works long hours. Just his train ticket is over $400 per month and another $300 plus in gas to get to Ronkonkoma Train Station. He commutes about 4 hrs per day. If he has a fair amount of Overtime, he sleeps at work because it is not worth coming home. We pay a fair amount in taxes, plus all the commuting costs it is not as cheap as you might think. We all make our choices and do what we have to do. I will tell you this. We could live like rich people(my perspective) on $250,000. We have a pretty good life on a lot less. I know everyone has a different opinion of what is important/not important but for us (especially having lived out of state and seeing a different way of life) but having to commute 4 hours a day in order to live well in this area is not my idea of living the good life. (I am not attacking you -- I am attacking the situation in NY) This is also why we pay through the nose to rent a 1br apartment in the city. In many respects I do consider us well off (and we make under $250k), but between the staggering amount of taxes we pay especially after the city taxes are added on, I think that you still have to make a lot of sacrifices to live on or near $250k in many areas around here whether it is commute, living accommodations, etc because the salary you bring in limits you. My definition of the word "rich" would mean not having to do that. Just a different perspective... This was exactly my point but, you said it better from a different angle. I was just trying to say that if you end up with more disposable income b/c you are further from the city you are sacrificing a lot to get that extra $$$. |
|
Posted 3/26/11 12:37 PM
|
|
|
Re: Article: Down and Out on $250,000 Excellent article! Thanks for sharing, I agree that 250k is not rich either once you factor in childcare, taxes and expenses...in most major cities, 250k is really barely upper middle class.. |
|
Posted 3/26/11 2:26 PM
|
|
|
Re: Article: Down and Out on $250,000 Posted by JRG71 We get killed with the alternative minimum tax every year. For a tax that was not meant to hurt the 'middle class' - It surely does. I think the definitions of who has to pay AMT needs to be changed. As for being down and out on 250k - I agree with other posters, It should be 500K or 1m for high taxed area's. It's insane to think that 250K is rich on LI - It's comfortable, but not rich. My thoughts exactly! DH is a cop, I'm a teacher and according to the rest of the country, we're RICH because we make over $200k combined. We're as middle class as they come and suffer with the alternative miminum tax every year! It $UCKS!!! They should allow for cost of living expenses around the country and adjust accordingly....
|
|
Posted 3/26/11 5:15 PM
|
|
|
Re: Article: Down and Out on $250,000 Posted by KennysMommy Posted by JRG71 We get killed with the alternative minimum tax every year. For a tax that was not meant to hurt the 'middle class' - It surely does. I think the definitions of who has to pay AMT needs to be changed. As for being down and out on 250k - I agree with other posters, It should be 500K or 1m for high taxed area's. It's insane to think that 250K is rich on LI - It's comfortable, but not rich. My thoughts exactly! DH is a cop, I'm a teacher and according to the rest of the country, we're RICH because we make over $200k combined. We're as middle class as they come and suffer with the alternative miminum tax every year! It $UCKS!!! They should allow for cost of living expenses around the country and adjust accordingly....Better watch out, you might be close to the Millionaire Tax threshold. hehe. Message edited 2011-03-26 17:41:15.400000. |
|
Posted 3/26/11 5:40 PM
|
|
|
Re: Article: Down and Out on $250,000 I see both sides of it but I certainly wouldn't be crying if I made that in a year. It would change my life dramatically for the better. We make less than half that and do just fine but if we had children we would likely be struggling. I fear that in a few years we will have to move if we start a family. We live 5 min from our jobs, but out east there really aren't any jobs. I couldn't imagine doing a commute to the city. I have a friend who's husband does and believe me they do well but the poor husband gets home at 9 at night and leaves before 5. That's not something I would cal "comfortable" idk I really can see both sides of the argument. While 250k is nothing to sneeze at in my world my circumstance are drastically different than someone who might make that and be struggling a little. LI is very expensive I dont think anyone here would dispute that. I think the rest of the country has an impression that we are all rich and make a ton of money when the truth is we are all just working to put food on the table and a roof over our heads |
|
Posted 3/26/11 9:34 PM
|
|
|
Re: Article: Down and Out on $250,000 Also I think it should. 500k |
|
Posted 3/26/11 9:34 PM
|
|
| Pages: 1 [2] | |








with this article is the author labeling Huntington as a "suburb" of NYC..to me, anything in Queens or Brooklyn is a suburb but a town in Suffolk that is easily a 2 hours drive on the LIE any weekday isn't really a "suburb".

We're as middle class as they come and suffer with the alternative miminum tax every year! It $UCKS!!! They should allow for cost of living expenses around the country and adjust accordingly....

