Article: Down and Out on $250,000

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

MrsSchwags
Soccer Baseball Lax Mom

Member since 10/05

11240 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Article: Down and Out on $250,000

Has anyone read this article?

I thought it was quite interesting and it sparked a lot of conversation between my hubby and I.

http://money.msn.com/tax-planning/down-and-out-on-250000-dollars-a-year-fiscal-times.aspx?gt1=33005

Posted 3/25/11 3:04 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Nifheim
allo

Member since 1/09

5476 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Article: Down and Out on $250,000

You can make 75K and have the same debt/income ratio as someone making 250K its the way you spend/invest your money. That being said someone making 250K has the ability to really live comfortably even if in NY more so then the average salary of 85K and that is where the difference is.

Posted 3/25/11 3:12 PM
 

MorningCuppaCoffee
Tired!

Member since 12/07

16353 total posts

Name:
Allison

Re: Article: Down and Out on $250,000

Thanks for sharing. DH and I don't make nearly that much combined here on LI. I am glad they used LI though as an area. I post on another national message board and I've basically been accused of lying when I talk about how much things cost here. When I mention property taxes, and of course good old family health care which costs us close to $20K a year, I'm always met with the "why don't you just move somewhere cheaper like the Midwest".


Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 3/25/11 3:15 PM
 

lululu
LIF Adult

Member since 7/05

9511 total posts

Name:

Re: Article: Down and Out on $250,000

That's a very informative article, but I don't think it will help to change a lot of people's minds on $250k not being a huge amount of income from certain places.

Also, as a side note - I am glad to see that a town on Long Island was picked as representative of an area with top notch public schools!

Posted 3/25/11 3:19 PM
 

Otherme
Square head cutie pants

Member since 3/06

6899 total posts

Name:

Re: Article: Down and Out on $250,000

DH and I talk about this all the time. $250,000 is relative - all depends where you live

$250K HHI in NYC is NOT the same as $250K HHI in Iowa. Just isn't

so using that as a standard of wealth, without taking into account the area of the country a person lives is completely unfair

Posted 3/25/11 3:24 PM
 

lululu
LIF Adult

Member since 7/05

9511 total posts

Name:

Re: Article: Down and Out on $250,000

Posted by Nifheim

You can make 75K and have the same debt/income ratio as someone making 250K its the way you spend/invest your money. That being said someone making 250K has the ability to really live comfortably even if in NY more so then the average salary of 85K and that is where the difference is.



I think that the article points that you can't live REALLY comfortably on Long Island, while still saving for your child's education, taking ONE nice family vacation, still contributing to your 401k etc, etc, etc.

I think that you will find your perspective to be very different once you are supporting a couple of kids and paying for childcare - which is what the article is referring to. On Long Island I feel like if you are not fortunate enough to be really wealthy, or have family that can help you out with your childcare costs, you aren't just going to be living as comfortably as you would like to believe at $250k a year. Sad but true!

Message edited 2011-03-25 15:27:24.083000.

Posted 3/25/11 3:26 PM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: Article: Down and Out on $250,000

I think they should raise it to $500,00k.

what I really think is that the corporate tax loopholes are what need to be addressed. the top 1% needs to start PAYING their fair share. enough of this ******** already. Chat Icon

Posted 3/25/11 3:31 PM
 

Nifheim
allo

Member since 1/09

5476 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Article: Down and Out on $250,000

Oh i agree with the fact that 250K here on LI is very different then 250K in Iowa. Taxation is not completely fair across the country. But I also think people who make 250K must realize the average is like 85K on LI. We make less then that and have a house, struggle but we don't have kids because of it.

Most of my friends who have kids don't make more then 90K with a house, so it really depends on your lifestyle.

Posted 3/25/11 3:31 PM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: Article: Down and Out on $250,000

Posted by Otherme

so using that as a standard of wealth, without taking into account the area of the country a person lives is completely unfair




I agree with this. locality needs to be taken into consideration.

but we really need to take a look at local taxes...b/c I think that is where the real benefit of this article lies.

we pay far more in LOCAL taxes than we do to the federal govt.

Posted 3/25/11 3:33 PM
 

neener1211
:-)

Member since 4/07

22952 total posts

Name:
J

Re: Article: Down and Out on $250,000

I just wish someone would pay me a $250k salary so I could prove this article wrong.Chat Icon

Posted 3/25/11 3:34 PM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: Article: Down and Out on $250,000

Posted by neener1211

I just wish someone would pay me a $250k salary so I could prove this article wrong.Chat Icon



talk to your neighborhood plumber. he's got none of those pesky student loan payments. Chat Icon

Posted 3/25/11 3:35 PM
 

memi7206
LIF Adult

Member since 3/11

2355 total posts

Name:
Due Dec 29th!!!!!

Re: Article: Down and Out on $250,000

Posted by lululu

Posted by Nifheim

You can make 75K and have the same debt/income ratio as someone making 250K its the way you spend/invest your money. That being said someone making 250K has the ability to really live comfortably even if in NY more so then the average salary of 85K and that is where the difference is.



I think that the article points that you can't live REALLY comfortably on Long Island, while still saving for your child's education, taking ONE nice family vacation, still contributing to your 401k etc, etc, etc.

I think that you will find your perspective to be very different once you are supporting a couple of kids and paying for childcare - which is what the article is referring to. On Long Island I feel like if you are not fortunate enough to be really wealthy, or have family that can help you out with your childcare costs, you aren't just going to be living as comfortably as you would like to believe at $250k a year. Sad but true!



I dont know, my DH and I live in Smithtown with crazy high taxes, we dont make anywhere near 250K, we own a home, have a child in daycare, just bought a new car, take a nice vacation (sometimes 2) a year, DS wants for nothing, we both have 401Ks and we contribute to DS 529 every month. We do that with money left over every month. I think a lot is how you manage your money, and of course your consumer debt. We would be SUPER comfortable on 250K here on LI.

Posted 3/25/11 3:35 PM
 

neener1211
:-)

Member since 4/07

22952 total posts

Name:
J

Re: Article: Down and Out on $250,000

Posted by Ophelia

Posted by neener1211

I just wish someone would pay me a $250k salary so I could prove this article wrong.Chat Icon



talk to your neighborhood plumber. he's got none of those pesky student loan payments. Chat Icon



Chat Icon Should have married a plumber! Chat Icon

Posted 3/25/11 3:38 PM
 

Otherme
Square head cutie pants

Member since 3/06

6899 total posts

Name:

Re: Article: Down and Out on $250,000

I have to stop reading comments on articles..

the comments the majority of people are making on the article are clearly made by people who missed the point of the article and just want to rip on people who make $250K.
As i said before.. it's all relative to where in the country you live

yes, you can certainly live comfortably on LI with $250K, but you are not rich

Posted 3/25/11 3:41 PM
 

jasmine
little boy blue <3

Member since 10/10

1475 total posts

Name:
x

Re: Article: Down and Out on $250,000

It is frustrating that a lot of the high-paying jobs in the NY area are in the city, and you either need a long commute (especially compared with other areas of the country) and still pay a relatively high amount or to pay $$$$$$ to have a shorter commute.

It really does make this area unappealing... because we can either pay out the nose for a tiny tiny place or spend 3+ hours a day each commuting. Chat Icon

Edit: I think there is a big difference between making $250k combined in LI jobs and living comfortably on long island v. making $250k combined in NYC and living comfortably on long island. To me, living comfortably doesnt involve that kind of commute...

then again, we don't make $250k...

Message edited 2011-03-25 15:44:53.857000.

Posted 3/25/11 3:43 PM
 

lululu
LIF Adult

Member since 7/05

9511 total posts

Name:

Re: Article: Down and Out on $250,000

Definitely think that a big part of it is commuting costs to NYC. we live only 28 minutes from the city and my husbands LIRR ticket and metrocard costs $270 a month PLUS $3 a day to park at the train station - so $330 a month. If we were both working in the city that's an additional $660 a month!!! It's crazy!!!

Posted 3/25/11 3:55 PM
 

JRG71
*****************

Member since 5/05

5025 total posts

Name:

Re: Article: Down and Out on $250,000

We get killed with the alternative minimum tax every year. For a tax that was not meant to hurt the 'middle class' - It surely does.
I think the definitions of who has to pay AMT needs to be changed.

As for being down and out on 250k - I agree with other posters, It should be 500K or 1m for high taxed area's. It's insane to think that 250K is rich on LI - It's comfortable, but not rich.

Posted 3/25/11 6:01 PM
 

JenniferEver
The Disney Lady

Member since 5/05

18163 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Article: Down and Out on $250,000

I think though that saying "$250K does not make you rich in LI" really depends on what your definition of rich is.

Because I grew up in a working class neighborhood in a single income working class family with uneducated parents, to me people who live in houses, not apartments are rich. A backyard and a pool = rich! Taking one or more vacations every year = rich.

I have friends who grew up in other parts of Queens for whom the above was the norm and they'd call themselves middle class. In NYC/LI I think a lot of us are just accustomed to a higher standard of living, and other people might call "rich" what we call "comfortable"

Think about how people live upstate or in other parts of the country...I think it's also a matter of perspective.

ETA: According to the article, it's the 97th percentile for household income in the US. How could that possibly NOT be considered rich?

Message edited 2011-03-25 18:20:17.170000.

Posted 3/25/11 6:18 PM
 

itsbabytime
LIF Adult

Member since 11/05

9644 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Article: Down and Out on $250,000

Posted by memi7206

Posted by lululu

Posted by Nifheim

You can make 75K and have the same debt/income ratio as someone making 250K its the way you spend/invest your money. That being said someone making 250K has the ability to really live comfortably even if in NY more so then the average salary of 85K and that is where the difference is.



I think that the article points that you can't live REALLY comfortably on Long Island, while still saving for your child's education, taking ONE nice family vacation, still contributing to your 401k etc, etc, etc.

I think that you will find your perspective to be very different once you are supporting a couple of kids and paying for childcare - which is what the article is referring to. On Long Island I feel like if you are not fortunate enough to be really wealthy, or have family that can help you out with your childcare costs, you aren't just going to be living as comfortably as you would like to believe at $250k a year. Sad but true!



I dont know, my DH and I live in Smithtown with crazy high taxes, we dont make anywhere near 250K, we own a home, have a child in daycare, just bought a new car, take a nice vacation (sometimes 2) a year, DS wants for nothing, we both have 401Ks and we contribute to DS 529 every month. We do that with money left over every month. I think a lot is how you manage your money, and of course your consumer debt. We would be SUPER comfortable on 250K here on LI.



Yeah, but, Smithtown is pretty far out in LI and the cost of living there is cheaper. The houses cost alot less than the homes that are reasonable commuting distance to NYC. If you are someone that works really long hours in NYC you just cannot commute to a town like Smithtown and, I guarantee you, your mortgage payment is ALOT higher.

Posted 3/25/11 8:45 PM
 

Katareen
5,000 Posts!

Member since 4/10

7180 total posts

Name:
Katherine

Re: Article: Down and Out on $250,000

Posted by itsbabytime
Yeah, but, Smithtown is pretty far out in LI and the cost of living there is cheaper. The houses cost alot less than the homes that are reasonable commuting distance to NYC. If you are someone that works really long hours in NYC you just cannot commute to a town like Smithtown and, I guarantee you, your mortgage payment is ALOT higher.



I have to disagree with this. Smithtown is not an inexpensive place to live--and there are a ton of towns in Nassau that are probably a lot cheaper to live.

DH and I have a very nice standard of living on less than half that--so for $250K we could do quite well. You just need a very good vision of wants vs needs.

Posted 3/25/11 9:23 PM
 

itsbabytime
LIF Adult

Member since 11/05

9644 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Article: Down and Out on $250,000

Posted by Katareen

Posted by itsbabytime
Yeah, but, Smithtown is pretty far out in LI and the cost of living there is cheaper. The houses cost alot less than the homes that are reasonable commuting distance to NYC. If you are someone that works really long hours in NYC you just cannot commute to a town like Smithtown and, I guarantee you, your mortgage payment is ALOT higher.



I have to disagree with this. Smithtown is not an inexpensive place to live--and there are a ton of towns in Nassau that are probably a lot cheaper to live.

DH and I have a very nice standard of living on less than half that--so for $250K we could do quite well. You just need a very good vision of wants vs needs.



I didn't say it was inexpensive - I said the homes were cheaper than those closer/easier commute to the city. I don't think there really is any debate about that. If you are looking at the nice areas, with a good school district that are 30 min from NYC vs. 1 hr you are easily paying hundreds of thousands more. Just look at what you get for $800,000 in Smithtown vs. what you get in manhasset, port washington, great neck etc. And, its not just smithtown, look at Dix Hills etc., I don't think it is debatable that the further east you go you generally get more for your money all other things considered equal.

Posted 3/25/11 9:33 PM
 

memi7206
LIF Adult

Member since 3/11

2355 total posts

Name:
Due Dec 29th!!!!!

Re: Article: Down and Out on $250,000

Posted by Katareen

Posted by itsbabytime
Yeah, but, Smithtown is pretty far out in LI and the cost of living there is cheaper. The houses cost alot less than the homes that are reasonable commuting distance to NYC. If you are someone that works really long hours in NYC you just cannot commute to a town like Smithtown and, I guarantee you, your mortgage payment is ALOT higher.



I have to disagree with this. Smithtown is not an inexpensive place to live--and there are a ton of towns in Nassau that are probably a lot cheaper to live.

DH and I have a very nice standard of living on less than half that--so for $250K we could do quite well. You just need a very good vision of wants vs needs.

'

correct, its not inexpensive AT ALL. Its also not that far east, its still 45 minutes from riverhead and about 25 mins from Huntington. I can be in plainview much quicker than riverhead. Youre comparing wealthy areas to upper middle class/middle class in the two counties. There are towns like Amagansett whos costs are on par with the likes of Manhassett. Smithtown is no different really from Massapequa, Plainview, Seaford, Syosset. Either way, its not a p!ssing contest of what area is more expensive. Its can you live comfortably on 250K on LI. IMO, the answer is absolutely. Its all about what you are willing to give and take on to live comfortably on 250K. Its doable in suffolk and its doable in Nassau. Can you have the best of everything in either county and live well off.....no, comfortably, yes.

Message edited 2011-03-25 22:27:32.497000.

Posted 3/25/11 9:40 PM
 

ap123
LIF Infant

Member since 10/10

268 total posts

Name:

Re: Article: Down and Out on $250,000

This article does a really good job of explaining that $250k does not make you rich, it barely makes you comfortable if you are living in an expensive town, close to the city with good schools. Nothing says congrats for your hard work and success like getting the privilege of footing over 50% of the nations tax bill.

Posted 3/25/11 9:48 PM
 

ChrisDee
My Girls

Member since 11/06

9543 total posts

Name:
Christine

Re: Article: Down and Out on $250,000

Posted by itsbabytime

Posted by memi7206

Posted by lululu

Posted by Nifheim

You can make 75K and have the same debt/income ratio as someone making 250K its the way you spend/invest your money. That being said someone making 250K has the ability to really live comfortably even if in NY more so then the average salary of 85K and that is where the difference is.



I think that the article points that you can't live REALLY comfortably on Long Island, while still saving for your child's education, taking ONE nice family vacation, still contributing to your 401k etc, etc, etc.

I think that you will find your perspective to be very different once you are supporting a couple of kids and paying for childcare - which is what the article is referring to. On Long Island I feel like if you are not fortunate enough to be really wealthy, or have family that can help you out with your childcare costs, you aren't just going to be living as comfortably as you would like to believe at $250k a year. Sad but true!



I dont know, my DH and I live in Smithtown with crazy high taxes, we dont make anywhere near 250K, we own a home, have a child in daycare, just bought a new car, take a nice vacation (sometimes 2) a year, DS wants for nothing, we both have 401Ks and we contribute to DS 529 every month. We do that with money left over every month. I think a lot is how you manage your money, and of course your consumer debt. We would be SUPER comfortable on 250K here on LI.



Yeah, but, Smithtown is pretty far out in LI and the cost of living there is cheaper. The houses cost alot less than the homes that are reasonable commuting distance to NYC. If you are someone that works really long hours in NYC you just cannot commute to a town like Smithtown and, I guarantee you, your mortgage payment is ALOT higher.



We live in Port Jeff, DH takes the LIRR to work and works long hours. Just his train ticket is over $400 per month and another $300 plus in gas to get to Ronkonkoma Train Station. He commutes about 4 hrs per day. If he has a fair amount of Overtime, he sleeps at work because it is not worth coming home. We pay a fair amount in taxes, plus all the commuting costs it is not as cheap as you might think. We all make our choices and do what we have to do. I will tell you this. We could live like rich people(my perspective) on $250,000. We have a pretty good life on a lot less.

Message edited 2011-03-25 22:57:19.070000.

Posted 3/25/11 10:56 PM
 

Salason
&hearts;

Member since 6/05

9878 total posts

Name:

Re: Article: Down and Out on $250,000

Message edited 2011-03-26 10:12:08.270000.

Posted 3/25/11 11:01 PM
 
Pages: [1] 2