anyone potty train before 12m or relatively early?

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

mommyIam

Member since 7/09

9209 total posts

Name:
Shana

anyone potty train before 12m or relatively early?

So before ds goes for bath, I sit him on the potty. The first times he cried and peed, secnod time just cried, third time peed! Its been about a week, now he expects it, and doesn't cry, just pees every time, we cheer and life goes on.

I know old school, old country gals on here can attest to being potty trained by 1 year, but how do they communicate that they need it, and how do you teach them to communicate it?

I was potty trianed at 10m, but my mom doesn't really explain how, or anything, just that I grunted when I needed to go. DS cues aren't that clear lol

Message edited 2011-02-21 23:16:48.397000.

Posted 2/21/11 11:12 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

karjules
Love my Jules :)

Member since 1/07

2056 total posts

Name:
Karen

Re: anyone potty train before 1?

Not sure..DD potty trained at 2 1/2..I heard a saying that even if you try before 3 they arent' trained untiil 3 lol.

Some people do potty training and don't use diapers from very early on. I don't know thats not me I just followed DD's cues..she def was no where ready by 1, but if your DC does, maybe keep up with it. If anything it will mean less diapers! Chat Icon

Posted 2/21/11 11:18 PM
 

MamaB17
Back for baby #3

Member since 5/09

4065 total posts

Name:
N

Re: anyone potty train before 12m or relatively early?

I was wondeting this too. My mom doesnt remember. Lol.

Posted 2/21/11 11:20 PM
 

labonnevie
sometimes 1+1= 4 <3

Member since 8/09

3869 total posts

Name:
the lucky one

Re: anyone potty train before 12m or relatively early?

i'm interested to see what people have to say about this... i don't think i could potty train DD this early since there is no way to tell when she has to go. its why i'm afraid to let her roam without a diaper on!

Posted 2/21/11 11:22 PM
 

GioiaMia
Let's Go Rangers!

Member since 1/07

14818 total posts

Name:

Re: anyone potty train before 12m or relatively early?

When my mom was growing up, everyone was trained at around one. She had us all trained very early except my brother had some poop issues until kindergarten that we all love to talk about at family functions! Chat Icon

We plan on TRYING to start AM early, but I can't see my mom being as strict with her as she was with us.

My coworker is Chinese and her ILs trained her son VERY early (a little over a year). He was taught that whenever they whistled he would have to try to pee. . . and it worked!!!!

ETA: My totally uninformed and uneducated opinion is that our generation and our culture makes potty training this huge psychological issue. It is like there is so much pressure to not mess up your kid for life by pressuring him or her to use the potty. I think that if this pressure wasn't there, potty training would be easier for the parent AND the child.

Message edited 2011-02-22 06:24:24.530000.

Posted 2/22/11 6:21 AM
 

Janice
Sweet Jessie Quinn

Member since 5/05

27567 total posts

Name:
Janice

Re: anyone potty train before 12m or relatively early?

8 out of 10 poops are on the toilet since 6 mos old.

peeing is random...sometimes it happens, sometimes it doesn't.

Posted 2/22/11 6:53 AM
 

bethsiar
LIF Adult

Member since 9/05

1390 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: anyone potty train before 12m or relatively early?

I potty trained both my older girls when they were 15 months.

I just kept putting them on the potty, I even did the kitchen timer to remind me and did a dance when they did it and if they pooped they got to put a sticker on their potty book (by Katy Katz). Basically the same way you would train a 3 year old I think.

I think it's actually easier to train earlier. They dont refuse it and say NO like a 2 or 3 yr old would. At that age, they just accept that its time to sit on the potty again and read a book.

I dont know why ppl wait so long these days, maybe its ingrained in us so that Huggies can sell more diapers and then potty training takes longer for toddlers so they can sell pull ups and nighttime diapers and all the other cr@p. I wouldnt be surprised if they're the ones releasing stories that its not good to potty train babies Chat Icon

Posted 2/22/11 7:01 AM
 

mommyIam

Member since 7/09

9209 total posts

Name:
Shana

Re: anyone potty train before 12m or relatively early?

I appreciate the responses I don't mean he'll be 100% potty trained by 12m, I mean I want to introduce it, in a non stressful fun way. I don't care if it takes him till he's in kindergarten to be out of diapers.

Last night he was tugging on me in a very weird way, I didn't get it, and then 20 minutes he had an explosive poop. I wonder if he was telling trying to tell me.

Posted 2/22/11 7:13 AM
 

MamaB17
Back for baby #3

Member since 5/09

4065 total posts

Name:
N

Re: anyone potty train before 12m or relatively early?

So b/c of this post I sat dd 10months on the potty before her bath. My mom is visiting so she turned water on and put her finger under the cold water. Then put her finger on dd's leg. A few secs later she peed on the potty. Lol. I know it was random but I am going to keep doing it before her bath to get her use to the potty.

Posted 2/22/11 7:51 PM
 

LML
Twins!

Member since 10/09

1320 total posts

Name:
Laura

Re: anyone potty train before 12m or relatively early?

Stupid question...what kind of potty are you using? Do you buy one of those little plastic ones or the seat that goes over the regular toilet? I just can't picture DD fitting on one of those.

Posted 2/22/11 8:04 PM
 

BaroqueMama
Chase is one!

Member since 5/05

27530 total posts

Name:
me

Re: anyone potty train before 12m or relatively early?

I wholeheartedly believe that disposable diapers are the reason we don't potty train earlier in this country anymore.
I'm sure many people will disagree with me, but because they're so absorbent, a baby can't really feel when they're wet, which I think inhibits the process of training.
Everyone in my family was trained by 18 months. I started DD on the potty at 12m, not to train her, but to get her used to it. Then I got lazy and didn't care for a while, but she ended up being trained before she even turned 2 by me putting regular underwear on her.

Posted 2/22/11 8:16 PM
 

itsbabytime
LIF Adult

Member since 11/05

9644 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: anyone potty train before 12m or relatively early?

I guess I'm in the minority here but, I would never try to force potty training on a child that young because I would be worried about the associations they would have now and later in life. If my child were crying as they peed when I tried to get them to pee on the potty I would remove them immediately. i would not repeatedly do it as they cried. I don't really see the big deal about waiting until they are 2. At that age it is clear to them what the deal is - they understand it and the concept without being scared or upset by it. IMO, that is why people wait. A 12 mo old might catch on to it but they are not "getting" it and, who knows what is going through their mind and what their memory of it will be if they are actually crying while being forced to do it.

Posted 2/22/11 9:51 PM
 

MamaB17
Back for baby #3

Member since 5/09

4065 total posts

Name:
N

Re: anyone potty train before 12m or relatively early?

Posted by LML

Stupid question...what kind of potty are you using? Do you buy one of those little plastic ones or the seat that goes over the regular toilet? I just can't picture DD fitting on one of those.



We have a little plastic potty. I like the potty seats for the reg toilet but they are too big for her tiny hiney. Once we actually start potting training, I want to get her to use the potty seat to avoid having to always clean the potty. Chat Icon

Posted 2/22/11 10:11 PM
 

Linda1003
love my 2 boys

Member since 8/08

10923 total posts

Name:
Linda

Re: anyone potty train before 12m or relatively early?

But are they getting it at that age.. you may time yourself to put them on the potty but they aren't communicating to you that they need to go right?????

Also.. this would only "work" for a SAHM....

Posted 2/23/11 8:03 AM
 

Janice
Sweet Jessie Quinn

Member since 5/05

27567 total posts

Name:
Janice

Re: anyone potty train before 12m or relatively early?

my baby never cries...
i sit her on toilet...we sing...she yells when she is done.
never on there for more then 3 minutes.

I don't care at all if people have kids in diapers till 5-but really, you should be using cloth.

It is a shared planet and it does become the concern of other people if you chose not to try and still use disposables.
If everyone waited till their kid was 5 to take the disposables away the current 3 largest contributor to landfills i am sure would skyrocket to possibly #1.

keep them in diapers...but please think twice about how many diapers your toddler is adding to a pile that is always going to be on this earth.

Chat Icon Chat Icon thanks.

Posted 2/23/11 8:25 AM
 

Dani77
It's FUN to be ONE

Member since 7/09

4363 total posts

Name:
Danicia

Re: anyone potty train before 12m or relatively early?

I don't know...I'm on the fence about this ... I can lean anyway...
I have in fact seen a few family and friends have their children potty trained by 18 months... it was amazing. I know one of them was delayed with speach, but knew sign language...and would sign he needed to go...yet he was sooo tiny.
Then I've also heard about how they don't fully get it, or they may not be 'ready' yet. I dont' think if the child is crying each time that they are on the potty, it should be kept up. ... no matter WHAT the age. Give it a week or so, and then maybe try again. If the screaming continues, then maybe I would give it up for a month or so.
I don't think 12 months is too young to try... anything for that matter. Their minds are like sponges...it's crazy how much DS learns just from observing us. I havent yet tried to potty train with him or anything, but he does know how to drink out of a normal cup all on his own, which many people say isn't possible. But, he still refuses to walk. LOL. Each child is different.

Posted 2/23/11 8:29 AM
 

snowprincess
My happy babies

Member since 3/06

3428 total posts

Name:

Re: anyone potty train before 12m or relatively early?

i have been putting my son on the potty since 10 months- he will poop almost every mornign -we just read books and sing songs

when we are home i get more and daycare is willing to put him on when ever - i feel this way he won't be scared when he can tell me he has to go

Posted 2/23/11 8:32 AM
 

mommyIam

Member since 7/09

9209 total posts

Name:
Shana

Re: anyone potty train before 12m or relatively early?

I wasn't asking for opinions on whether to wait or not. I don't force anything.

In the past day, ds (11m) learned the sign for potty and bangs on the bathroom door and signs it, I put him on it, he sits sometimes goes sometimes not, but as soon as he gets up to play or whatever I diaper him up and all done.

Imo, he's asking to try something, I know he understands, I'm not sure he is physically ready, but I know for a fact some babies successfully potty train by 12m with no drama. So why not give the chance to a baby that's curious?

Posted 2/23/11 8:33 AM
 

maybebaby
LIF Adult

Member since 11/05

6870 total posts

Name:
Maureen

Re: anyone potty train before 12m or relatively early?

I have heard that in a lot of cases its not truly being "potty trained" at that early of an age, its more "parent trained". Meaning that yes, putting your child on the potty repeatedly throughout the day will result in going successfully on the potty at one time or another..

But TRUE potty training is when a child is in underwear and can verbalize or somehow communicate every time that they need the potty...you can take them outside in underwear and not worry that there will be accidents all day.

12 months sounds so young to me. I know its possible, i know in many other countries its done earlier. My mom said that I was potty trained at 18 months and even that sounds crazy early to me....

I want to stat with Ryan at 2, he is showing CRAZY signs now that he is ready..he tells us everytime he needs to poop and he hates being in poop diapers. But i realistically expect him to be trained more towards 2.5-3.

Posted 2/23/11 8:33 AM
 

maybebaby
LIF Adult

Member since 11/05

6870 total posts

Name:
Maureen

Re: anyone potty train before 12m or relatively early?

Posted by mommyIam

I wasn't asking for opinions on whether to wait or not. I don't force anything.

In the past day, ds (11m) learned the sign for potty and bangs on the bathroom door and signs it, I put him on it, he sits sometimes goes sometimes not, but as soon as he gets up to play or whatever I diaper him up and all done.

Imo, he's asking to try something, I know he understands, I'm not sure he is physically ready, but I know for a fact some babies successfully potty train by 12m with no drama. So why not give the chance to a baby that's curious?



You actually know kids who were fully potty trained at 1 year old?? I only ask b/c there is a big difference between a kid being fully potty trained and another mother saying "oh yes, he is going on the potty now.." and in reality it's once in a while but not potty trained. Just curious! I don't know anyone who trained their kids that early!

Posted 2/23/11 8:36 AM
 

Kelly9904
Mommy to 2 amazing little boys

Member since 5/05

9306 total posts

Name:
Kelly

Re: anyone potty train before 12m or relatively early?

My opinion is that at 12 months are they really potty trained the way we think of potty training.

I mean I didnt potty train DS until he was nearly 3 but by the time he was PT, I didnt have to stay on top of him, or time him, he would tell me I have to go potty and run to the bathroom to go.

At 12 months are the capable of truly potty training or are we as parents just responsible for watching their every cue to anticipation when they have to go? Or are they just holding it until we put them on the potty signaling its time to "release"?

Posted 2/23/11 8:36 AM
 

jmf423
:)

Member since 5/05

6372 total posts

Name:

Re: anyone potty train before 12m or relatively early?

Posted by Kelly9904

My opinion is that at 12 months are they really potty trained the way we think of potty training.

I mean I didnt potty train DS until he was nearly 3 but by the time he was PT, I didnt have to stay on top of him, or time him, he would tell me I have to go potty and run to the bathroom to go.

At 12 months are the capable of truly potty training or are we as parents just responsible for watching their every cue to anticipation when they have to go? Or are they just holding it until we put them on the potty signaling its time to "release"?



That is what i always wonder. Anyone I know who had a child trained early(before 16mths) seemed like this. The parent was trained to take them on to the potty at timed intervals....not so much the child would say that had to go.
I wish I could potty train my almost 16mth olds!! But I can't imagine them being able to tell me they had to use the potty when we are out or I can't bring the there on time, kwim.
NOT flaming or judging those who train early....just trying to understand it more.

Posted 2/23/11 8:59 AM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: anyone potty train before 12m or relatively early?

Posted by mommyIam

I wasn't asking for opinions on whether to wait or not. I don't force anything.

In the past day, ds (11m) learned the sign for potty and bangs on the bathroom door and signs it, I put him on it, he sits sometimes goes sometimes not, but as soon as he gets up to play or whatever I diaper him up and all done.

Imo, he's asking to try something, I know he understands, I'm not sure he is physically ready, but I know for a fact some babies successfully potty train by 12m with no drama. So why not give the chance to a baby that's curious?



dude, don't ask this here. I was involved in the most RIDICULOUS thread ever about this. look it up if you want to laugh. b/c whether you asked for opinions about it or not, you will get them.

my son goes on the potty maybe once or twice a day, he's 16 months. I would like to have him "day" trained by 18 months. he still takes milk during the night so I am not holding my breath for night time training.

do whatever you want. he will get it soon enough.

we have this and he digs it pretty well. he sits on there with a book. Chat Icon

External Image

Posted 2/23/11 9:25 AM
 

mommyIam

Member since 7/09

9209 total posts

Name:
Shana

Re: anyone potty train before 12m or relatively early?

Posted by Ophelia

dude, don't ask this here. I was involved in the most RIDICULOUS thread ever about this. look it up if you want to laugh. b/c whether you asked for opinions about it or not, you will get them.





I'm stubborn, I think I was on that thread too, I just don't see potty training as the evil as some do.

Ill keep asking and questioning, cause I know it can be done, it has been done, and by the most caring and wonderful parents... I just want to know and share how with those that will consider starting early.

Enough with the vacuum of info, let's learn from eachother

And yes, I watch ds really close for cues, I always have. I'm not on top of him, he plays independently 90% of the time, but I'm in observation mode 80% of that time. I learn a lot about him.

Posted 2/23/11 11:06 AM
 

mommyIam

Member since 7/09

9209 total posts

Name:
Shana

Re: anyone potty train before 12m or relatively early?

Posted by maybebaby


You actually know kids who were fully potty trained at 1 year old?? I only ask b/c there is a big difference between a kid being fully potty trained and another mother saying "oh yes, he is going on the potty now.." and in reality it's once in a while but not potty trained. Just curious! I don't know anyone who trained their kids that early!



Yes, all my cousins where at least by the time they where walking. My sister and I where as well.

I was by 10m, and completly by 1 year, my sister did early too, but we both walked by 9m, and its the norn internationally to train as soon as baby starts walking.

My cousins kids are all varried, some where easily trained by 1y, some not fully till 4.

Its nice to live in a society where children can be who they are and do what they are ready to do.

Like I said I can care less when he 100% potty trains. I just want to introduce him to it, the same way I would introduce using a straw or a spoon. I can care less when he can spoonfeed himself without making a mess. I trust hell learn when he's ready.

Message edited 2011-02-23 11:21:11.637000.

Posted 2/23/11 11:20 AM
 
Pages: [1] 2
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
What age did you/will you start to potty train? Tine73 12/3/08 18 Parenting
How do I potty train DD in 3 days? annie 11/6/08 4 Parenting
Moms of boys at what age did they potty train? jessbaby 9/19/08 13 Parenting
Was your DC scared of the toliet when you tried to potty train? JerseyMamaOf3 7/9/08 1 Parenting
What Age Did You Start To Potty Train DC? ArmyOfBabies 3/13/08 11 Parenting
So, we are embarking on a mission to potty train today... BaroqueMama 12/31/07 4 Parenting