| Posted By |
Message |
|
|
American Idol- Top 10
Here were my thoughts on last night. Please share yours!!
I think Phil and Colton did the best, hands down.
I would put in the bottom 3 (solely based on this week): Hollie, Jessica and Skylar.
Deandre: OK
Erika: (omg! her hair!) OK.
Joshua: Good, but not as amazing as last week's performance
Skylar: Didn't like her this week
Elise: She does have a great voice, but I enjoy it so much more without looking at her. I really think the reason that she always ends up in the bottom 3 each week is not because of her voice but because she just comes off SO UNLIKEABLE!!! but they were really pushing this episode to keep her out of the bottom 3 and that kind of annoyed me.
Phil: love, love, love, love, LOVE!!!!!!
Hollie: I liked her so much in auditions, but she is the biggest disappointment this season. I have not liked any of her live performances. She is the most unpolished and inconsistent. I did not like her outfit this week or the performance.
HeeJun: He is such an oddball and makes me laugh, but I oddly loved his performance. His accent was pretty severe in this song though, and that does hinder his performances I believe.
Jessica: I know all the judges liked her, but this week, I did not like it. I found it boring and like the mentors said, she was oversinging and it seemed like she was putting on an act. If she screamed a little less and did a little less runs, it would have sounded better. She needs to get more natural.
Colton: loved, loved, loved
|
Posted 3/22/12 9:43 AM
|
| |
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
|
|
|
Re: American Idol- Top 10
My favorites this week...Colton and Phillip.
I think the bottom three will bee HeeJun, Skylar and Hollie. I'm hoping that HeeJun goes home. He's funny, but I'm tired of the antics...his voice has a nice quality to it but I don't think it compares to some of the other contestants...
As for Joshua, Ericka, Elise and Jessica....I liked them, I didn't love them this week.
|
Posted 3/22/12 11:17 AM
|
| |
|
APT910
Let It Be
 Member since 2/11 5021 total posts
Name: Ashley
|
Re: American Idol- Top 10
I totally agree with you about Elise! If I close my eyes and listen to her I think she's amazing, but I just don't like her!
Heejun is the exact opposite! I don't think his singing is great but I love his personality!!
Colton was definitely my favorite this week!
|
Posted 3/22/12 11:24 AM
|
| |
|
mnm918
LIF Adult
 Member since 10/10 1209 total posts
Name: Michele
|
Re: American Idol- Top 10
OK so I agree with the OP that there is something about Elise that I just don't connect with. I really actually loooooove her voice but she really is soo unlikeable she really doesnt have that bubbly personality .. she's just blah.. I prefer Erica over her by far!!!!
last night I loooved Colton, Jessica, Mantasia, and Erica!
Heejun needs to go! I am over his rediculousness.. he's putting on a show and making a mockery out of the music.. I cant stand it and I think the people voting are putting him through for his personality not voice because he is just average!.. Like Jimmy iovine said its not comedy Idol? He's playing the stupid all to much! He needs to go ASAP!! but unfortunately like Sanjaya, and others that have been awful they will stick around until 6 or 7!
I loooove Deandre but hes been really boring me!!! his song choices are awful and hes not doing anything to really stand out :( its disappointing because he really is super talented and has amazing vocalS!
I looove Erica.. She really is unique and original and hervoice is just so polished and controlled! I think she is so professional and I don't understand why people do not vote for her :(
I loove Hollie but enough with those power ballads.. we get it she has this big old voice and shes super cute but change it up a little.. show a little diversity.. I still think she's talented
Usually I do not loove the country singers but Skylar is cute and bubbly and has a nice voice.. I think she didn't do well last night and I wouldn't mind seeing her go although she will def make something of herself
Phil Phillips is sooo adorable!! Hes talented , different, refreshing.. he makes every song his own and I just love that!! He def is going to go far.. he;s on top of my list!!
Jessica Sanchez.. I am calling it now this girl is going to win this whole thing! She is only what 16 years old and that voice is incredible!! I don't mind her oversinging because she has those pipes! She can literally do anything she's that good! Its been awhile since there was a girl winner and I just have a feeling she will take it!
Colton - he is def EMO/rock and I loooved it:) hes talented and has his own style and uniqueness.. Im also a sucker for the piano so if he does that every week Im sold!! lol Hes def goin to go to TOP 3 for sure:)
Joshua Ledet.. OMG what a voice on him!!! He reminds me of Jacob from last year but prob a little better.. I really feel every song he sings .. I think he can go far but He prob will go 5th or 6th .. not sure how many people may get tired of his voice.. we'll see
Message edited 2012-03-22 11:35:28.130000. |
Posted 3/22/12 11:33 AM
|
| |
|
Mere09
So Dam* Lucky
 Member since 10/08 6368 total posts
Name:
|
Re: American Idol- Top 10
Last night I voted for: Colton - It was just beautiful what he did. Best of the night fo sho! Phil - He'll get my vote every week because I love DMB (and he's adorable). Erika - I like her. And she did a good job last night.
Heejun was hilarious but he needs to go. I'm sick of Hollie doing ballads. I don't know...she just bores me. Jessica can SING! I can't believe she's only 16! Skylar I can take or leave. Joshua has a pretty amazing voice, but not the kind of voice I would be able to listen to a whole album of. I can't even think of who Deandre is right now, so that can't be a good sign. lol Elise...I LOVE her voice but she is so incredibly unlikeable!!! I can't even put my finger on what it is. Unfortunate for her.
Message edited 2012-03-22 15:35:25.240000. |
Posted 3/22/12 3:34 PM
|
| |
|
KwaaksNest
Love my boys!
 Member since 6/10 2825 total posts
Name: Samantha
|
Re: American Idol- Top 10
I can't stand Deandre and Elsie, idk i dont think that they are that good
I Love philip and Colton, and i have a soft spot of Heejun. I think he is good in his own kind of way but i dont think he will win
|
Posted 3/22/12 3:52 PM
|
| |
|
Goobster
:)
Member since 5/07 27557 total posts
Name: :)
|
Re: American Idol- Top 10
Posted by BaysideForever
Elise: She does have a great voice, but I enjoy it so much more without looking at her. I really think the reason that she always ends up in the bottom 3 each week is not because of her voice but because she just comes off SO UNLIKEABLE!!! but they were really pushing this episode to keep her out of the bottom 3 and that kind of annoyed me.
Colton: loved, loved, loved
Erika's hair looks RIDICULOUS. I am sorry but I hate when their style drastically changes. Seems too contrived to me and this haircut makes her look older and heavier IMO.
Elise...yes...that's what I said. She comes off as gruff and unlikeable. I think that's why the judges kept advocating for her and then they tried to play on her personal side with having her "students" come up to be with her, crying, etc. Tried to portray her as more personable...didnt work for me. Something just rubs me the wrong way about her (sorta like Haylee, former contestant who will sing tonight).
Loved Colton.
Phill Phillips sux IMO. I just cant stand him, his guitar, his shoulders shrugged up when he sings, the way his face looks when he sings or simply the way he sings. I think he is just run of the mill Dave Matthew wanna be.
Deandre...all I see is Naima (sp) from last year when I watch him. LOL
Heejun needs to go. And I thought it was SOOO rude and unprofessional to joke with Tommy H. about looking up to Madonna or Jessica Sanchez or Michael Bolton. He is trying to be funny but I found it rather rude and unappreciative and Tommmy H didnt have a clue he was trying to be funny. To me, he made of mockery of Tommy H, who clearly was clueless this guy has no desire to sing and be an American Idol. He has other interests that are more important apparently. Shame on the judges for putting him through and taking up a spot someone else would have appreciated more and been more WORTHY of.
Message edited 2012-03-22 16:23:20.913000. |
Posted 3/22/12 4:22 PM
|
| |
|
wanttobeamom
LIF Adult
Member since 5/09 2448 total posts
Name:
|
Re: American Idol- Top 10
Does Holly have a lisp? I keep hearing words sung "off"!
|
Posted 3/22/12 9:18 PM
|
| |
|
cheryl28
LIF Adult
Member since 2/10 4657 total posts
Name:
|
Re: American Idol- Top 10
Posted by wanttobeamom
Does Holly have a lisp? I keep hearing words sung "off"!
She has an accent. She sounds a bit weird sometimes. I don't think she was born here. We looked it up the other night but I can't remember and can't find it at the moment.
I was a little sad erika went home. She wasn't the best but there are certainly worse performers on there.
|
Posted 3/23/12 9:12 AM
|
| |
|
Jax430
Hi!
Member since 5/05 18919 total posts
Name: Jackie
|
Re: American Idol- Top 10
I'm a huge Billy Joel fan, and know every song out there. Because of that, I'm super-critical of Billy Joel covers. I actually thought that Wednesday's show was better than some other Billy Joel nights.
Deandre was okay. Entertaining, but not great. Could have been better, could have been worse.
I thought Erika was fantastic. It was her best night yet, and she should NOT have gone home.
Joshua: Has a great voice, but you could tell he didn't really know or feel the song. Also, my DH sang "She's Got A Way" to me at our wedding, so that's my favorite cover of it.
Skyler: I said from the beginning that she was going to do "Shameless", and I didn't like it.
Elise: Fabulous song choice. I loved that she ignored Jimmy and did a lesser-known songs. It's one of my favorites, and I thought she did a great job. She really understood the song. I understand what some of you are saying about her being unlikable, but I do enjoy her performances.
Phil: Fabulous! He really was the only one to modernize a Billy Joel song. My sister and I were so impressed. (She's responsible for my love of Billy, as she is 10.5 years older and had me growing up listening to him).
Hollie: "Honesty" was too old and cynical a song for her. She's a sweet girl with a nice voice, but I didn't love it.
HeeJun: DH and I love his personality, but he should have gone home this week. He had us laughing, but there's no way he should have stayed over Erika. He even said last night that he's not out to be a star...then why the heck are you on IDOL?!
Jessica: Amazing voice, always. However, I was actually kind of bored by her performance, and I like that song.
Colton: Initially, I was disappointed that he chose the most standard of Billy Joel songs, but he really did a fabulous job. Loved him.
|
Posted 3/23/12 11:29 AM
|
| |
|