|
Re: American Idol- Top 10
Posted 3/23/2012 11:29:50 AM by Jax430 I'm a huge Billy Joel fan, and know every song out there. Because of that, I'm super-critical of Billy Joel covers. I actually thought that Wednesday's show was better than some other Billy Joel nights. Deandre was okay. Entertaining, but not great. Could have been better, could have been worse. I thought Erika was fantastic. It was her best night yet, and she should NOT have gone home. Joshua: Has a great voice, but you could tell he didn't really know or feel the song. Also, my DH sang "She's Got A Way" to me at our wedding, so that's my favorite cover of it. Skyler: I said from the beginning that she was going to do "Shameless", and I didn't like it. Elise: Fabulous song choice. I loved that she ignored Jimmy and did a lesser-known songs. It's one of my favorites, and I thought she did a great job. She really understood the song. I understand what some of you are saying about her being unlikable, but I do enjoy her performances. Phil: Fabulous! He really was the only one to modernize a Billy Joel song. My sister and I were so impressed. (She's responsible for my love of Billy, as she is 10.5 years older and had me growing up listening to him). Hollie: "Honesty" was too old and cynical a song for her. She's a sweet girl with a nice voice, but I didn't love it. HeeJun: DH and I love his personality, but he should have gone home this week. He had us laughing, but there's no way he should have stayed over Erika. He even said last night that he's not out to be a star...then why the heck are you on IDOL?! Jessica: Amazing voice, always. However, I was actually kind of bored by her performance, and I like that song. Colton: Initially, I was disappointed that he chose the most standard of Billy Joel songs, but he really did a fabulous job. Loved him. |