American Idol- Top 10
Posted 3/22/2012 9:43:00 AM by BaysideForever

Here were my thoughts on last night. Please share yours!!

I think Phil and Colton did the best, hands down.

I would put in the bottom 3 (solely based on this week): Hollie, Jessica and Skylar.


Deandre: OK

Erika: (omg! her hair!) OK.

Joshua: Good, but not as amazing as last week's performance

Skylar: Didn't like her this week

Elise: She does have a great voice, but I enjoy it so much more without looking at her. I really think the reason that she always ends up in the bottom 3 each week is not because of her voice but because she just comes off SO UNLIKEABLE!!! but they were really pushing this episode to keep her out of the bottom 3 and that kind of annoyed me.

Phil: love, love, love, love, LOVE!!!!!!

Hollie: I liked her so much in auditions, but she is the biggest disappointment this season. I have not liked any of her live performances. She is the most unpolished and inconsistent. I did not like her outfit this week or the performance.

HeeJun: He is such an oddball and makes me laugh, but I oddly loved his performance. His accent was pretty severe in this song though, and that does hinder his performances I believe.

Jessica: I know all the judges liked her, but this week, I did not like it. I found it boring and like the mentors said, she was oversinging and it seemed like she was putting on an act. If she screamed a little less and did a little less runs, it would have sounded better. She needs to get more natural.

Colton: loved, loved, loved
Print Post      Close Window