AAP announcement tomorrow

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 [2] 3 4

TripletMom
My crazy Trio

Member since 3/09

2246 total posts

Name:
Paula

Re: AAP announcement tomorrow

They can recommend all they want but its the PARENTS choice on what to do with their kids. I turned my kids around at 1 yrs old bc that is what worked best for me. Back in my day I didnt even have a carseat and I was fine. I am not starting an argument with anyone on here and not judging what you do for your kids. I just dont like the fact that the RF carseat Moms like to jump all over the FF carseat Moms.....

Posted 3/21/11 11:04 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

BellaRock
I am all the Me I will ever Be

Member since 5/06

9746 total posts

Name:
She who shall remain nameless

Re: AAP announcement tomorrow

I turned my oldest at 12 months but I plan on keeping my youngest RF for as long as I can. He is pretty tall so I hope to last the 2 years.

Posted 3/21/11 11:11 AM
 

tara73
carseat nerd

Member since 11/09

3669 total posts

Name:
Buttercup

Re: AAP announcement tomorrow

Posted by TripletMom

They can recommend all they want but its the PARENTS choice on what to do with their kids. I turned my kids around at 1 yrs old bc that is what worked best for me. Back in my day I didnt even have a carseat and I was fine. I am not starting an argument with anyone on here and not judging what you do for your kids. I just dont like the fact that the RF carseat Moms like to jump all over the FF carseat Moms.....



As much as you hate the "RF MOM" attitude, as a tech, I hate the "but I didn't have a carseat and I was fine" mentality. I don't judge those who make different decisions than me, but I don't always understand it when the evidence contradicts the decision. Some things are gray areas, yes, but this isn't one of them.

Change isn't always a bad thing, ya know.

I'm not going to retype a longwinded response so here's my post from another thread. So here's what I posted in the other thread.

The recommendations that are made are evidence based. They are rooted in reality, a reality that sadly is based on children's lost lives and catastrophic injuries.

Here's one way to look at changes:

At one point in time, cars didn't have seat belts. Lots of people were injured or killed in accidents.

Now we have lap belts in cars. Lives are saved, injuries are reduced. There is much rejoicing.

Car seats were introduced in the 60's/70's and some parents thought enough to use them, but many still didn't.

But wait, we're finding out that maybe just lap belts aren't the best option. We should add a shoulder portion because people keep getting head injuries.

So, front seat passengers got 3 point lap/shoulder belts. And again, there was much rejoicing.

Research of car accident injuries and fatalities has found that those newfangled car seats? They're a pretty good idea and actually save lives, so laws were changed to say you had to use one. There was more rejoicing.

But wait. We have a problem. Most of these kids under age 1 who are in an accident are still getting hurt or killed in spite of their carseats. Maybe we should keep them riding backwards until they're 1 so they're more protected.

Airbags and crumple zones are added to cars because research from accidents are still showing more injuries and deaths that could probably be prevented.

And you know those lap belts in the back seat? Maybe those should be lap/shoulder belts too. Those lap belts really weren't the best idea in retrospect.

And maybe we should have kids in booster seats, we are seeing a lot of kids with abdominal injuries that could be prevented if only the belt fit them right.

HEY! I got it! We have the airbags in the front and know they work, why not on the sides too? Side impacts are so much worse than frontal collisions or rear enders.

And there was more rejoicing.

And you remember that 1 & 20 thing? Maybe we should look at what happens between 1 and 2. And while we're at it, look at how long we keep these kids in harnesses before we booster them. And let's look at how long we booster them........

and eventually you end up where we are today......

and there was much rejoicing when the AAP and NHTSA FINALLY updated their antiquated policies/recommendations.

Message edited 2011-03-21 11:15:29.843000.

Posted 3/21/11 11:14 AM
 

lucyloo
nope

Member since 1/06

9758 total posts

Name:

Re: AAP announcement tomorrow

Am I the only one who felt they had to turn around DC because they were uncomfortable and wouldn't stop crying?

Really, DS became more of a distraction to me while driving which I felt was riskier than keeping him RF. He's happier now and I'm less distracted.

Posted 3/21/11 11:23 AM
 

TripletMom
My crazy Trio

Member since 3/09

2246 total posts

Name:
Paula

Re: AAP announcement tomorrow

Posted by tarabelle99

Posted by TripletMom

They can recommend all they want but its the PARENTS choice on what to do with their kids. I turned my kids around at 1 yrs old bc that is what worked best for me. Back in my day I didnt even have a carseat and I was fine. I am not starting an argument with anyone on here and not judging what you do for your kids. I just dont like the fact that the RF carseat Moms like to jump all over the FF carseat Moms.....



As much as you hate the "RF MOM" attitude, as a tech, I hate the "but I didn't have a carseat and I was fine" mentality. I don't judge those who make different decisions than me, but I don't always understand it when the evidence contradicts the decision. Some things are gray areas, yes, but this isn't one of them.

Change isn't always a bad thing, ya know.

I'm not going to retype a longwinded response so here's my post from another thread. So here's what I posted in the other thread.

The recommendations that are made are evidence based. They are rooted in reality, a reality that sadly is based on children's lost lives and catastrophic injuries.

Here's one way to look at changes:

At one point in time, cars didn't have seat belts. Lots of people were injured or killed in accidents.

Now we have lap belts in cars. Lives are saved, injuries are reduced. There is much rejoicing.

Car seats were introduced in the 60's/70's and some parents thought enough to use them, but many still didn't.

But wait, we're finding out that maybe just lap belts aren't the best option. We should add a shoulder portion because people keep getting head injuries.

So, front seat passengers got 3 point lap/shoulder belts. And again, there was much rejoicing.

Research of car accident injuries and fatalities has found that those newfangled car seats? They're a pretty good idea and actually save lives, so laws were changed to say you had to use one. There was more rejoicing.

But wait. We have a problem. Most of these kids under age 1 who are in an accident are still getting hurt or killed in spite of their carseats. Maybe we should keep them riding backwards until they're 1 so they're more protected.

Airbags and crumple zones are added to cars because research from accidents are still showing more injuries and deaths that could probably be prevented.

And you know those lap belts in the back seat? Maybe those should be lap/shoulder belts too. Those lap belts really weren't the best idea in retrospect.

And maybe we should have kids in booster seats, we are seeing a lot of kids with abdominal injuries that could be prevented if only the belt fit them right.

HEY! I got it! We have the airbags in the front and know they work, why not on the sides too? Side impacts are so much worse than frontal collisions or rear enders.

And there was more rejoicing.

And you remember that 1 & 20 thing? Maybe we should look at what happens between 1 and 2. And while we're at it, look at how long we keep these kids in harnesses before we booster them. And let's look at how long we booster them........

and eventually you end up where we are today......

and there was much rejoicing when the AAP and NHTSA FINALLY updated their antiquated policies/recommendations.



And like I said I am not here to start an agrument and I am HAPPY you are a carseat installer and do a great job at what you do.....I stated my opinion and didnt see the need for you to go off on this tangent.My kids will stay FF facing and nothing will change that......I dont go around thinking what may happen....I could get hit by a truck crossing the street with them in the stroller which they arent protected in so PLEASE do not start with me!!!!

Posted 3/21/11 11:31 AM
 

LoveyQ
Stalkers, get a life.

Member since 11/07

12820 total posts

Name:

Re: AAP announcement tomorrow

Posted by TripletMom

They can recommend all they want but its the PARENTS choice on what to do with their kids. I turned my kids around at 1 yrs old bc that is what worked best for me. Back in my day I didnt even have a carseat and I was fine. I am not starting an argument with anyone on here and not judging what you do for your kids. I just dont like the fact that the RF carseat Moms like to jump all over the FF carseat Moms.....



I'm not jumping all over anyone, and I sure don't have triplets and all the work that comes with them, so I give you a lot of credit.

But I still honestly do not understand why, if it's proven and now being officially recommended, parents don't follow the recommendations that would help keep your precious cargo as safe as possible. Especially, as Ophelia said, this is one thing we can control and there are so many others that we are so beyond our control - such as other people's driving.

"Back in the day" TONS of stuff were done that were fine for a lot of people. They may have also been deadly to a lot of people. Just because you were safe, doesn't mean that someone else fared the same way.

I honestly just don't get it. Not judging, not arguing, I really just don't understand the reasoning.

Posted 3/21/11 11:31 AM
 

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: AAP announcement tomorrow

Wow. Glad I kept DD rear facing until 2 even more now.

Posted 3/21/11 11:33 AM
 

tara73
carseat nerd

Member since 11/09

3669 total posts

Name:
Buttercup

Re: AAP announcement tomorrow

Posted by TripletMom
And like I said I am not here to start an agrument and I am HAPPY you are a carseat installer and do a great job at what you do.....I stated my opinion and didnt see the need for you to go off on this tangent.My kids will stay FF facing and nothing will change that......I dont go around thinking what may happen....I could get hit by a truck crossing the street with them in the stroller which they arent protected in so PLEASE do not start with me!!!!



Not starting anything. I didn't go off on a tangent. I responded to a very specific part of your statement. A statement which, honestly, needs to be addressed even if YOU don't care to hear it, others may be interested.

Like I said, I don't judge your decision, I just don't understand it.

Back to why I clicked back into the thread:

CNN Posted a great story with an awesome FAQ for anyone who wants to read another one

http://www.cnn.com/2011/HEALTH/03/21/car.seat.guidelines.parenting/index.html?hpt=P1&iref=NS1

Posted 3/21/11 11:39 AM
 

Deedlebugs
Blessed

Member since 12/05

10281 total posts

Name:
Kiki

Re: AAP announcement tomorrow

I just switched DS to FF at 13 months. I had planned on keeping him RF till 2 but he started making himself throw up and choke every time we put him in his seat. I would have loved to have kept him RF but it is what it is. Chat Icon

Posted 3/21/11 11:41 AM
 

pickles16
Real Estate Professional

Member since 11/07

17227 total posts

Name:
Jen

Re: AAP announcement tomorrow

Posted by dita

Am I the only one who felt they had to turn around DC because they were uncomfortable and wouldn't stop crying?

Really, DS became more of a distraction to me while driving which I felt was riskier than keeping him RF. He's happier now and I'm less distracted.



I did this, plus DD is off the charts for height and this is I think partially the reason why she was so unhappy, he legs were crushed!!! We turned her around at 16 mos

Posted 3/21/11 11:48 AM
 

headoverheels
s'il vous plaît

Member since 6/07

42079 total posts

Name:
LB

Re: AAP announcement tomorrow

Posted by Deedlebugs

I just switched DS to FF at 13 months. I had planned on keeping him RF till 2 but he started making himself throw up and choke every time we put him in his seat. I would have loved to have kept him RF but it is what it is. Chat Icon



You have to make the best choice for your family, obviously you don't want him choking in the car! Chat Icon

I don't understand why this has to be a debate. We all know what the recommendations are, and if you choose to go against them, do it, but I wouldn't view the "RF mom mindset" as a personal attack on those decisions, because I don't think they are.

Posted 3/21/11 11:49 AM
 

CookieMomster
Golden

Member since 5/09

6414 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: AAP announcement tomorrow

Posted by headoverheels

Posted by Deedlebugs

I just switched DS to FF at 13 months. I had planned on keeping him RF till 2 but he started making himself throw up and choke every time we put him in his seat. I would have loved to have kept him RF but it is what it is. Chat Icon



You have to make the best choice for your family, obviously you don't want him choking in the car! Chat Icon

I don't understand why this has to be a debate. We all know what the recommendations are, and if you choose to go against them, do it, but I wouldn't view the "RF mom mindset" as a personal attack on those decisions, because I don't think they are.

AGREE!!!!

Posted 3/21/11 11:50 AM
 

jerseypanda
Life is good.

Member since 1/07

9164 total posts

Name:
Amanda

Re: AAP announcement tomorrow

Posted by TripletMom

They can recommend all they want but its the PARENTS choice on what to do with their kids. I turned my kids around at 1 yrs old bc that is what worked best for me. Back in my day I didnt even have a carseat and I was fine. I am not starting an argument with anyone on here and not judging what you do for your kids. I just dont like the fact that the RF carseat Moms like to jump all over the FF carseat Moms.....



I actually didn't see any "RF carseat moms" jumping all over any "FF carseat moms". Chat Icon

Pretty much every RF mom response I've seen will say that they understand that it's a personal decision. Not sure how saying you just don't understand it is jumping all over people who choose to do it.

Posted 3/21/11 11:53 AM
 

DomesticDeeva
Tiebreaker on deck!!!

Member since 11/08

2088 total posts

Name:
Dee

Re: AAP announcement tomorrow

Posted by TripletMom

They can recommend all they want but its the PARENTS choice on what to do with their kids. I turned my kids around at 1 yrs old bc that is what worked best for me. Back in my day I didnt even have a carseat and I was fine. I am not starting an argument with anyone on here and not judging what you do for your kids. I just dont like the fact that the RF carseat Moms like to jump all over the FF carseat Moms.....





Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 3/21/11 11:53 AM
 

LeShellem
A new beginning

Member since 2/07

3600 total posts

Name:
LeShelle

Re: AAP announcement tomorrow

I turned DS around one week before his 2nd birthday. So glad with my choice. For my DS all he knew was rear facing. He didn't know he had a choice. His legs were so long that he had them up the back seat and you know what he didn't mind, he made due.
And when I did turn him around a week before his 2nd birthday he actually wanted the front passenger seat pushed all the way back so that his legs would rest on the back of the seat like they did when he was rear facing.
I know kids can be cranky, not want to do certain things and we as parents will try to accomodate them, but when it comes to their saftety it is the responsibiliity of parents like us to say no, this is for your safety.

Posted 3/21/11 11:55 AM
 

TripletMom
My crazy Trio

Member since 3/09

2246 total posts

Name:
Paula

Re: AAP announcement tomorrow

Posted by jerseypanda

Posted by TripletMom

They can recommend all they want but its the PARENTS choice on what to do with their kids. I turned my kids around at 1 yrs old bc that is what worked best for me. Back in my day I didnt even have a carseat and I was fine. I am not starting an argument with anyone on here and not judging what you do for your kids. I just dont like the fact that the RF carseat Moms like to jump all over the FF carseat Moms.....



I actually didn't see any "RF carseat moms" jumping all over any "FF carseat moms". Chat Icon

Pretty much every RF mom response I've seen will say that they understand that it's a personal decision. Not sure how saying you just don't understand it is jumping all over people who choose to do it.



They werent in this thread I was just making an statement I am SORRY I didnt say that it wasnt is THIS thread that RF were jumping all over RF Moms...

Posted 3/21/11 12:00 PM
 

Sassyz75
Turning a new page

Member since 5/05

9731 total posts

Name:
Dina

Re: AAP announcement tomorrow

I totally get that it's "safer" to have them rear facing.

My DS is 15 months and forward facing.. we turned him last month.. it is what it is- he was just unhappy and crying and I can't drive like that.

I take everything the AAP says as a guideline.. my kids have also eaten Peanut Butter early and shell fish...

Posted 3/21/11 12:10 PM
 

LIMOMx2
...

Member since 5/05

24989 total posts

Name:

Re: AAP announcement tomorrow

This is one recommendation that I would not ignore. It is for the safety of your child.

Posted 3/21/11 12:12 PM
 

brownie
Baby #1 is here!

Member since 11/08

13903 total posts

Name:

Re: AAP announcement tomorrow

I turned DD at 16 months...but now at 20 months and hearing more/reading more about all of this, I feel like I shouldn't have...

Should I try turning her RF now after she's been FF?

Posted 3/21/11 12:14 PM
 

LoveyQ
Stalkers, get a life.

Member since 11/07

12820 total posts

Name:

Re: AAP announcement tomorrow

Posted by brownie

I turned DD at 16 months...but now at 20 months and hearing more/reading more about all of this, I feel like I shouldn't have...

Should I try turning her RF now after she's been FF?




You can try turning her back - I know it's probably harder since she now knows there's another option, but I would try and give it a little while to see if she adjusts.

As a side point, this is exactly why it's good to have these threads - maybe there's another parent out there that thought they could/would/should turn their child at 1 year old, but now knows that's not safest and not what's recommended by the experts.

Posted 3/21/11 12:17 PM
 

katiebug
I'll love you for always

Member since 2/08

4624 total posts

Name:
Katie

Re: AAP announcement tomorrow

Posted by Sassyz75

I totally get that it's "safer" to have them rear facing.

My DS is 15 months and forward facing.. we turned him last month.. it is what it is- he was just unhappy and crying and I can't drive like that.

I take everything the AAP says as a guideline.. my kids have also eaten Peanut Butter early and shell fish...




Actually the AAP is all for early introduction of peanut butter and shell fish Chat Icon

Posted 3/21/11 12:20 PM
 

alisha
LIF Adult

Member since 3/07

1199 total posts

Name:

Re: AAP announcement tomorrow

I just want to say - THANK YOU - for all your advice. If not for this site, I would have turned my daughter months ago.

My parents and in-laws think I am nuts insisting that DD stay rear-facing as long as posssible.

Now I can print the AAP recommendation as proof.

I don't post often enough, but LIF is an amazing resource!

Posted 3/21/11 12:37 PM
 

juanvi
Get Out!

Member since 10/06

4463 total posts

Name:
Christina

Re: AAP announcement tomorrow

my ped just told me this

Posted 3/21/11 12:44 PM
 

Diana1215
Living on a prayer!!!

Member since 10/05

29450 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: AAP announcement tomorrow

I am all for rear facing as long as possible. I am a lunatic about having carseats installed and whatnot.

But, with Jack I turned him at 15 months (the rec. was 1 at that point)

With Tyler, he was screaming every time I put him into the car that he was becoming more of a hazard to my driving. He has been much happier since I turned him (16 mnths)

That being said, with every month that passes (he will be 18 months) I thank god that he is closer to the recommendation. It's just something that lingers in the back of my mind at all times. I can never get those videos and visuals out of my head. Chat Icon

Posted 3/21/11 1:01 PM
 

tara73
carseat nerd

Member since 11/09

3669 total posts

Name:
Buttercup

Re: AAP announcement tomorrow

Posted by Diana1215

I am all for rear facing as long as possible. I am a lunatic about having carseats installed and whatnot.

But, with Jack I turned him at 15 months (the rec. was 1 at that point)

With Tyler, he was screaming every time I put him into the car that he was becoming more of a hazard to my driving. He has been much happier since I turned him (16 mnths)

That being said, with every month that passes (he will be 18 months) I thank god that he is closer to the recommendation. It's just something that lingers in the back of my mind at all times. I can never get those videos and visuals out of my head. Chat Icon



Have you ever tried turning him back? I've heard of parents having success turning them back a couple months later (DD1 had a brief phase of fighting/crying in the car but got over it quickly so I have no personal experience)

Posted 3/21/11 1:07 PM
 
Pages: 1 [2] 3 4
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
An announcement that should have been tomorrow dooodles 4/28/08 214 Parenting
Announcement- With Picture!! stepherg 9/20/05 14 Parenting
I found the announcement I wanna use! HereWeGoAgain 9/20/05 11 Pregnancy
Logan's Birth Announcement betty 9/20/05 18 Parenting
Public Service Announcement Redhead 7/31/05 107 Families Helping Families ™
I have an announcement!!! june262004 7/28/05 63 Families Helping Families ™