AAP announcement tomorrow

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 2 3 [4]

Deedlebugs
Blessed

Member since 12/05

10281 total posts

Name:
Kiki

Re: AAP announcement tomorrow

Hey the AAP also recommends that you EBF! Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

ETA: I am just being a clown! I think it is great if you can keep your child RF till 2 but everyone needs to realize that there will always be exceptions.

Message edited 2011-03-21 14:14:36.030000.

Posted 3/21/11 2:07 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: AAP announcement tomorrow

Posted by LoveyQ

And quite frankly, I know *I* don't give a hoot if a cop won't give me a ticket if DS is FF before 2 years old. That, to me, has no bearing on keeping my son as safe as possible.



I think though that there are degrees to this.

rear facing is "safest" in the event of an accident...but NOT being in an accident is safest of all.

if you child is a true distraction to your driving while rear facing, that is the imminent danger I would imagine. your distraction.

this whole motherhood thing is a game of balance. finding the place were the least danger lies.

for some, it's a rear facing child who is content and doesn't go too crazy about it.

for another, it's turning your child b/c they were so unhappy/uncomfortable or any other condition (if my son made himself puke there would be no question in my mind about turning him) that makes him/her a distraction to your own driving or their behavior becomes a hazard in its own right.

I think we should just take the information, do what we can with it, and Chat Icon that we never have to test any of these theories.

Posted 3/21/11 2:07 PM
 

tara73
carseat nerd

Member since 11/09

3669 total posts

Name:
Buttercup

Re: AAP announcement tomorrow

Posted by MAC222

Posted by tarabelle99

Posted by MAC222

DS is 15 months, I would love to keep him RF until 2. I have no desire to put him FF. He doesnt seem to mind the fact that his feet have been hitting the back seat since I put him in ths seat...

here is my question though....

DS was 36" tall at 1 year. Is there a better seat than the Marathon, that may stop his feet from hitting?

Thank you, and thank you for sharing this post



Classic Marathon of Marathon 70?

MyRide has a bit more leg room due to it's deep recline. Off the top of my head...



Reg. Marathon. I think the My Ride is a lot bigger...this was the other one I was going to get, and wound up with the Britax



I have the Classic Boulevard and the MyRide.

DD1 Def has more legroom in her MR than she does the Blvd. And the MR actually gives more room for the person in the front seat than the BLVD does.

That said, DD1 doesnt complain much in either seat, though when asked she says she likes the MR better. But, it has cupholders. Cupholders are everything to a 3 yo Chat Icon

Honestly, if he seems comfy, I'd leave him be.

Posted 3/21/11 2:14 PM
 

yankinmanc
Happy Days!

Member since 8/05

18208 total posts

Name:

Re: AAP announcement tomorrow

I am not going to get involved in any debates, but to give you some perspective on this, here in the UK we go FF at 9 months. Just something to think about.

Here are our recommendations:
Forward-facing car seats - from 9kg/20lbs to 18kg/40lbs (approx. 9 mths to 4 yrs)

•forward-facing car seat
•baby/toddler is secured by the seat’s integral 5-point safety harness
•adjustable seating positions for greater comfort
•seat is secured in the car by the adult seat belt, or the Isofix™ clip system (Isofix™ models only)
Highback booster seats with integral harnesses - from 9kg/20lbs to 36kg/79lbs (approx. 9 mths to 11 yrs)

•forward-facing seat
•baby/toddler/child is secured by the seat’s integral 5-point safety harness
•seat is secured in the car by the adult seat belt
Highback boosters (without harnesses) and booster seats - from 15kg/33lbs to 36kg/70lbs (approx. 4 yrs to 11 yrs)

•forward-facing seat
•toddler/child and seat are secured in the car by the adult seat belt
•seat raises child to enable adult seat belt to fit more securely, safely and comfortably
•extra height also gives a better view, helping to relieve boredom/travel sickness

Posted 3/21/11 2:16 PM
 

LIMOMx2
...

Member since 5/05

24989 total posts

Name:

Re: AAP announcement tomorrow

Posted by headoverheels

Posted by 5ofClubs

Posted by Deedlebugs

Posted by justpeachy

Moms of children under 2 that are now forward facing will you now be flipping them back to rearfacing.

DD is almost 18 months and we recently just turned her forward facing.


Please no drama



No! I knew the risks before I switched him.


Just curious why you switched him then?



She already posted why, Allison.



Just saw it. I was on my phone and it is hard to read threads sometimes.

Posted 3/21/11 2:18 PM
 

tara73
carseat nerd

Member since 11/09

3669 total posts

Name:
Buttercup

Re: AAP announcement tomorrow

Posted by Ophelia

Posted by LoveyQ

And quite frankly, I know *I* don't give a hoot if a cop won't give me a ticket if DS is FF before 2 years old. That, to me, has no bearing on keeping my son as safe as possible.



I think though that there are degrees to this.

rear facing is "safest" in the event of an accident...but NOT being in an accident is safest of all.

if you child is a true distraction to your driving while rear facing, that is the imminent danger I would imagine. your distraction.

this whole motherhood thing is a game of balance. finding the place were the least danger lies.

for some, it's a rear facing child who is content and doesn't go too crazy about it.

for another, it's turning your child b/c they were so unhappy/uncomfortable or any other condition (if my son made himself puke there would be no question in my mind about turning him) that makes him/her a distraction to your own driving or their behavior becomes a hazard in its own right.

I think we should just take the information, do what we can with it, and Chat Icon that we never have to test any of these theories.



I think there is a big difference between the parent who HAS to turn their child because of car sickness or crying to the point of distracting the driver/vomiting or medical issues and someone who views the 1 & 20 as a milestone and turns them "just because" in spite of knowing that they should be RF still.

I don't understand it. To me, we do everything we can to keep our kids safe and to ignore the recommendations with no rhyme or reason puzzles me.

BUT, I don't judge. I don't have to understand what people do, but I will always preach the benefits of RF because I've probably done a little too much research into it and it scares the crap out of me. But I don't look down on those who have chosen to FF early. I don't know their reasons or their knowledge on the subject.

I've said it before and I'll say again: Just because it's legal doesnt mean it's safe.

Posted 3/21/11 2:27 PM
 

TripletMom
My crazy Trio

Member since 3/09

2246 total posts

Name:
Paula

Re: AAP announcement tomorrow

Posted by DRMom

Posted by tarabelle99

Posted by TripletMom
You know I tried to hold my tongue on this, I really did. But, Paula did you actually change your avatar to address this post and possibly this poster?



NO matter how I answer this is will come out be a bitchy response even though it is NOT meant to be....I have had this pic as my avatar for a few weeks now. I took all the pics of the kids downs weeks ago as well.My questions is WHY does is matter to you or anyone else if I did change my avatar??? I am NOT starting anything here but COME on now already......



Posted 3/21/11 2:40 PM
 

LoveyQ
Stalkers, get a life.

Member since 11/07

12820 total posts

Name:

Re: AAP announcement tomorrow

Posted by Ophelia

Posted by LoveyQ

And quite frankly, I know *I* don't give a hoot if a cop won't give me a ticket if DS is FF before 2 years old. That, to me, has no bearing on keeping my son as safe as possible.



I think though that there are degrees to this.

rear facing is "safest" in the event of an accident...but NOT being in an accident is safest of all.

if you child is a true distraction to your driving while rear facing, that is the imminent danger I would imagine. your distraction.

this whole motherhood thing is a game of balance. finding the place were the least danger lies.

for some, it's a rear facing child who is content and doesn't go too crazy about it.

for another, it's turning your child b/c they were so unhappy/uncomfortable or any other condition (if my son made himself puke there would be no question in my mind about turning him) that makes him/her a distraction to your own driving or their behavior becomes a hazard in its own right.

I think we should just take the information, do what we can with it, and Chat Icon that we never have to test any of these theories.



Yes, VERY true. I mean, if DS were under 2 and literally making himself sick and making it a beyond nightmare to put him in the car and I was so distracted by it (amazing how those little voices can be so distracting!), then yes, I would consider the overall safety when thinking about the recommendations.

But to just turn because they LOOK uncomfortable to me, or because it was fine for all these years to people I personally know, or because he's bothered/annoyed etc., well then no, that's where I think it's my place as his mother to keep him as safe as possible, KWIM?

Posted 3/21/11 2:45 PM
 

DRMom
Two in Blue

Member since 5/05

20223 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: AAP announcement tomorrow

Posted by TripletMom

Posted by DRMom

Posted by tarabelle99

Posted by TripletMom
You know I tried to hold my tongue on this, I really did. But, Paula did you actually change your avatar to address this post and possibly this poster?



NO matter how I answer this is will come out be a bitchy response even though it is NOT meant to be....I have had this pic as my avatar for a few weeks now. I took all the pics of the kids downs weeks ago as well.My questions is WHY does is matter to you or anyone else if I did change my avatar??? I am NOT starting anything here but COME on now already......




OK-I think Jerseypanda already wrote that and I stated that was why I posed this as a question. It doesn't matter, but if you did I would think it was passive-aggressive/lame/silly. But you didn't so that doesn't apply to you. Tarabelle comes on and posts very valid and truthful information. I just don't understand the venom I guess.

As far as the original post, obviously if your child is so miserable rear facing that he/she is a distraction to driving safely, then yes, it is probably optimal to turn them at 1.


Posted 3/21/11 2:47 PM
 

Xelindrya
Mommy's little YouTube Star!

Member since 8/05

14470 total posts

Name:
Veronica

Re: AAP announcement tomorrow

Posted by DancinBarefoot

Posted by AimeeE2006

How can most kids comfortably sit rear-facing until 2 years old? DD was 1 1/2 when I finally put in her a front facing carseat and I only changed her because her legs were squished.



My DD was over 2 before I turned her. Now that she is foward facing she sits the same way she did rear facing - indian style.

It is merely our perception that their legs are squished (and better that, then a broken neck and complete paralysis).



Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon
exactly.

The kids could care less.. they are more flexible than us and literally smaller and less to worry about, heck they can't even touch both elbows over their heads yet at 2 why would criss cross applesauce bother them?

I'm totally bias since AJ was RF as long as possible over 2yrs of age.

Posted 3/21/11 3:56 PM
 

dm24angel
Happiness

Member since 5/05

34581 total posts

Name:
Donna

Re: AAP announcement tomorrow

Ahhh been a while since we had some nice Carseat drama.

My girls are in a smallish seat, they are squished...their legs are all bent up and they cry. I turn the radio louder , for ME, this is one thing I can control and will control and will follow the guidelines no matter how cramped my kids are.

But thats just it, they are guidelines. i will never understand a mom who switches a child early FF because the kid appeared uncomfortable or for their own ease, that to me is just odd, but if its affecting the safety of the mom driving, like others said, well then the guidelines are not LAWS for the pure reason of instances like that IMO.
Too much defensiveness on both sides. Its sad.

Posted 3/21/11 4:19 PM
 

MrsRbk
<3 <3 <3 <3

Member since 1/06

19197 total posts

Name:
Michelle

Re: AAP announcement tomorrow

My intention was to keep DD RF until she was 2.

With that said, she was RF until 17 months when I had to install the base for DC#2. Her seat was then moved from middle seat to behind the drivers side, there was NO way to put her seat RF at that point as I would not fit into the drivers seat.

DS is still in his infant carrier, but not for much longer. My intention is to keep him RF until he is 2 (he is now 7 months.)

Posted 3/21/11 4:31 PM
 

beachgirl
LIF Adult

Member since 7/05

7967 total posts

Name:
sara

Re: AAP announcement tomorrow

I just wanted to add that when my DD was a baby - 5 years ago they recommended you could turn them around at 1 year - 2o lbs. I kept her RF until she was 16 months as I did feel it was safer despite the recommendations at the time. She was always SO miserable in the car and DH has enough so he turned her around at 16 months and guess what? she was still miserable in the car so RF or FF it did not matter for her.

Just a word of caution to you moms that think turning them around will turn them into happy little creatures in the car - it may not happen.Chat Icon

Posted 3/21/11 5:07 PM
 

missrock
Beautiful!!!!

Member since 5/06

3808 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: AAP announcement tomorrow

I dont understand why this topic will always spark a debate. Everyone is different and has different parenting styles. If someone feels comfortable in having their DC FF before two years then let them without offering your opinions.

They are clearly aware of the new recommendation from the AAP and they are all adults and do what they feel is right. Im just upset because some girls on this board make others feel bad for their actions....even if someone is confident in THEIR actions. Kinda like the girls that turn their kids around at 1 are not keeping their kids safe.

I can definitly tell you that my DS was and nightmare. He would cry the whole way to our destination and I made the decision to turn him around at a year because i was so stressed out when driving that I would speed and try to beat lights. When I turned him around he was so much better. I have another child and driving crazy like that put her life at risk also. People have their reasons and others should respect that without making them feel like horrible mothers.

Luckily my DS turns a 2 next month and I dont have to worry about it.

Message edited 2011-03-21 18:54:37.280000.

Posted 3/21/11 6:53 PM
 

tara73
carseat nerd

Member since 11/09

3669 total posts

Name:
Buttercup

Re: AAP announcement tomorrow

Posted by missrock

I dont understand why this topic will always spark a debate. Everyone is different and has different parenting styles. If someone feels comfortable in having their DC FF before two years then let them without offering your opinions.

They are clearly aware of the new recommendation from the AAP and they are all adults and do what they feel is right. Im just upset because some girls on this board make others feel bad for their actions....even if someone is confident in THEIR actions. Kinda like the girls that turn their kids around at 1 are not keeping their kids safe.

I can definitly tell you that my DS was and nightmare. He would cry the whole way to our destination and I made the decision to turn him around at a year because i was so stressed out when driving that I would speed and try to beat lights. When I turned him around he was so much better. I have another child and driving crazy like that put her life at risk also. People have their reasons and others should respect that without making them feel like horrible mothers.

Luckily my DS turns a 2 next month and I dont have to worry about it.




So if someone is comfortable with their decision, why do they feel the need to boast about it on a thread discussing the opposite opinion? IMO that is asking for trouble. And, really, if you don't want to hear others' opinions, then maybe posting on a public forum probably isn't the best idea. Even worse is posting in a thread on a subject and disagreeing vehemently and then complaining when people question your viewpoint or comment on it.

If I go to an EBF thread and proudly proclaim that I formula fed my baby from day one and boo to you then I am more than likely doing nothing more than looking to cause problems. If I come in and post that I had to FF because of XYZ in an intelligent manner, I'll probably not incite a riot.

I have no problem with people having a differing opinion, I do have a problem with people looking to start drama by posting things meant to promote hostility.

No one attacked anyone on this thread. Some people asked questions in response to differing opinions and some stated they didn't understand why (myself included) but the hostility is coming from the very people stating they feel attacked.

I don't get it. If discussing RF isn't your thing, then why would you post in a thread just to say "HEY I FF MY KID AT 1!!! NAH NAH NAH NAH NAH!" this is why this topic "always sparks debate".. There's no question, no intelligent point in this type of posting. Only taunting. Intelligently state your case, without hostility. Provide a decent argument (like Missrock did with her kid being a nightmare and a few others did explaining their situation with vomiting kids etc). Don't just sit there sticking your tongue out at those who may feel that this is a GOOD thing that the AAP/NHTSA did.

jmvho




Posted 3/21/11 7:52 PM
 

azoodie

Member since 8/05

8377 total posts

Name:
Team SEXY BACK

Re: AAP announcement tomorrow

Thank you for posting this. I was going to keep him RF for as long as possible, but will now try and go to 2 years (hope we make it - he is tall)!

Posted 3/21/11 7:54 PM
 

chelle
It's a Good Life

Member since 8/06

15404 total posts

Name:
Isn't it obvious?

Re: AAP announcement tomorrow

Posted by Deedlebugs

Posted by justpeachy

Moms of children under 2 that are now forward facing will you now be flipping them back to rearfacing.

DD is almost 18 months and we recently just turned her forward facing.


Please no drama



No! I knew the risks before I switched him.



Ditto.

Perfectly happy and comfortable with my decision to turn her FF at around 16 mths.

Posted 3/21/11 9:12 PM
 

JennB
My princess <3

Member since 5/09

2473 total posts

Name:
Jenn

Re: AAP announcement tomorrow

Wow. My DH took DD to our ped. for her 1 year visit and the ped said to turn her seat to forward facing. I told DH it was too early and he thinks bc the dr said it was ok that we have to. I kind of agreed with him. Now I am scared and I think we will turn it back tomorrow

Posted 3/21/11 10:22 PM
 

NoStressMom
My Heart and Soul

Member since 5/05

11122 total posts

Name:
D

Re: AAP announcement tomorrow

Posted by Diana1215

Lay off the moms who switched them early. Everyone does what they need to do at the time. No one is a perfect parent out there. Maybe you kept your child rear facing until they were four but yet do something else that other people may not agree with.


I kept my kid rear facing until his screaming drove me to turn him around. I felt we were in danger every time I got into the car with him. I was constantly turning around, trying to console him through the mirror.

You do what you need to do at the end of the day and it's no one's place to judge. This information is amazing, and so helpful, and I will tell anyone I can that Rear Facing is the safest - but if they choose to turn their kid at a year, that is their choice.


I agree 100%Chat Icon

Posted 3/22/11 8:05 AM
 
Pages: 1 2 3 [4]
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
An announcement that should have been tomorrow dooodles 4/28/08 214 Parenting
Announcement- With Picture!! stepherg 9/20/05 14 Parenting
I found the announcement I wanna use! HereWeGoAgain 9/20/05 11 Pregnancy
Logan's Birth Announcement betty 9/20/05 18 Parenting
Public Service Announcement Redhead 7/31/05 107 Families Helping Families ™
I have an announcement!!! june262004 7/28/05 63 Families Helping Families ™