Would you consider preselecting your baby's traits?
| Forum Opinion Poll | ||||||||||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
Designer Babies Anyone? POLL
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: [1] 2 | |
|
Designer Babies Anyone? POLL Didn't realize there is already a thread about this... feel free to take the poll though, and the article is below: Message edited 2009-03-04 00:05:03.967000. |
|
Posted 3/3/09 10:16 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: Designer Babies Anyone? POLL H to the L no!!! We need to stop playing god! Message edited 2009-03-04 17:17:58.590000. |
|
Posted 3/4/09 6:44 AM
|
|
|
Re: Designer Babies Anyone? POLL As a diabetic with high blood pressure and high cholesterol, you bet I would do whatever I can to prevent my DC from inheriting diabetes.... I wouldn't wish this disease, or any other disease on anyone.... |
|
Posted 3/4/09 8:01 AM
|
|
|
Re: Designer Babies Anyone? POLL As someone who just had PGD done, I selected yes to fatal defects. While it was not an issue in our case since all our chromosomally normal embies were the same sex, we would never have made our decision on which ones to put back based upon gender. Just looking for a healthy child...I dont care what gender or color they are |
|
Posted 3/4/09 8:18 AM
|
|
|
Re: Designer Babies Anyone? POLL I checked off yes for defects and illnesses. If I could protect my future child from some of the inherited diseases and illnesses that are in my family and that some family members suffer from, I certainly would! |
|
Posted 3/4/09 8:26 AM
|
|
|
Re: Designer Babies Anyone? POLL I said only to reduce fatal defects. If my parents tried to avoid any defect I would not be here nor would my siblings. Two of us have genetic clotting factors and the other 2 have asthma. My son may have inherited my clotting factors but will live a full healthy life and I wouldn't trade him for anything. |
|
Posted 3/4/09 8:37 AM
|
|
|
Re: Designer Babies Anyone? POLL Posted by mrswask I checked off yes for defects and illnesses. If I could protect my future child from some of the inherited diseases and illnesses that are in my family and that some family members suffer from, I certainly would! ITA |
|
Posted 3/4/09 9:11 AM
|
|
|
Re: Designer Babies Anyone? POLL Posted by mrswask I checked off yes for defects and illnesses. If I could protect my future child from some of the inherited diseases and illnesses that are in my family and that some family members suffer from, I certainly would! ITA too, plus to reduce fatal defects |
|
Posted 3/4/09 9:44 AM
|
|
|
Re: Designer Babies Anyone? POLL I voted "to reduce fatal defects." Both DH and I are Ashkenazi (E. European) Jews, and b/c of our heritage may potentially be carriers for Tay Sachs. The thought of bringing a baby into the world that will live a maximum of five years and be in pain and suffer for that entire time is abhorrent to me. But IMO, life-threatening disease is the only kind of testing I'd agree to. There are things that I'd like to see in my child (DH's musical talent, my hazel eyes) but I'd never pursue medical intervention to make them appear, KWIM? |
|
Posted 3/4/09 10:20 AM
|
|
|
Re: Designer Babies Anyone? POLL Posted by MissJones H to the L no!!! We need to stop playing god! I 100% agree. I know how horrible it is when a child dies so young. And I know it would be great if we could rid our children of certain diseases. But I truly believe things happen for a reason and we shouldn't mess with that. It just seems so unnatural. |
|
Posted 3/4/09 11:07 AM
|
|
|
Re: Designer Babies Anyone? POLL Okay I may get some flames for this but I honestly don't see the harm in it. |
|
Posted 3/4/09 11:12 AM
|
|
|
Re: Designer Babies Anyone? POLL Posted by azoodie Okay I may get some flames for this but I honestly don't see the harm in it. Isn't it already "playing God" to some extent to be doing IVF or those sorts of procedures to begin with? What makes preventing genetic defects any different either - if God wills it who are we to try and prevent it? To me it's all or nothing. You can't say it's playing God in one case but not in the other. If these embryos are already being tested why not allow them to pick blue eyes or brown hair? ITA I wanted to write what you wrote but was afraid of being flamed personally i do not care what anyone does but what you said is exactly how i feel, playing god is playing god regardless of what you choose |
|
Posted 3/4/09 11:28 AM
|
|
|
Re: Designer Babies Anyone? POLL This really disturbs me. I mean, I can understand the desire to want to avoid diseases but even so, the idea of specifically choosing one embryo over another because of it's supposed superior genes just feels so entirely and completely WRONG to me. |
|
Posted 3/4/09 11:40 AM
|
|
|
Re: Designer Babies Anyone? POLL Posted by MissJones H to the L no!!! We need to stop playing god! ITA. It's survival of the fittest - and a natural order of things. IMO this is not a good idea... though unfortunately I'm sure it'll be awhile before anyone truly realizes the effects this will have on things... As someone who has been thru IVF twice and is still trying to get (and stay) pregnant, I CAN NOT imagine doing it for superficial reasons such as picking my kids hair and eye color--- it's morally wrong and disgusting IMO. Part of IVF is allowing the embryos to grow and keeping it as natural as possible, putting back those that are growing properly and are "on target" for where they should be---- and while I see why some people have PGD done, it's done for medically necessary reasons- not to choose the gender of your child or any other superficial reasons...
|
|
Posted 3/4/09 11:44 AM
|
|
|
Re: Designer Babies Anyone? POLL While I agree that it shouldn't be done solely for looks or sex (mainly because it caused a huge imbalance in China of males), I don't agree with the you're playing god, the natural order of things or survival of the fittest arguement. |
|
Posted 3/4/09 12:41 PM
|
|
|
Re: Designer Babies Anyone? POLL Posted by azoodie Okay I may get some flames for this but I honestly don't see the harm in it. Isn't it already "playing God" to some extent to be doing IVF or those sorts of procedures to begin with? What makes preventing genetic defects any different either - if God wills it who are we to try and prevent it? To me it's all or nothing. You can't say it's playing God in one case but not in the other. If these embryos are already being tested why not allow them to pick blue eyes or brown hair? I wrote something similar in the other related thread. Every one of us who has had surgery (including C-sections), antibiotics, vaccinations, etc, have all "played God" in one form or another..... While I don't necessarily believe in "God", I believe that if there is one, he is allowing us to do this things. An omnipotent being could easily not let us come up with thoughts and techniques to "play God" if he didn't want us to. "The Lord works in mysterious ways." Sometimes the "mysterious ways" may be medicine and genetic manipulation..... |
|
Posted 3/4/09 12:57 PM
|
|
|
Re: Designer Babies Anyone? POLL To those who said it isn't playing god...while I understand what you mean (being that IVF and other procedures do indeed create a child that would not be there otherwise) doesn't it seem like a huge difference? |
|
Posted 3/4/09 1:02 PM
|
|
|
Re: Designer Babies Anyone? POLL Posted by GoldenRod Posted by azoodie Okay I may get some flames for this but I honestly don't see the harm in it. Isn't it already "playing God" to some extent to be doing IVF or those sorts of procedures to begin with? What makes preventing genetic defects any different either - if God wills it who are we to try and prevent it? To me it's all or nothing. You can't say it's playing God in one case but not in the other. If these embryos are already being tested why not allow them to pick blue eyes or brown hair? I wrote something similar in the other related thread. Every one of us who has had surgery (including C-sections), antibiotics, vaccinations, etc, have all "played God" in one form or another..... While I don't necessarily believe in "God", I believe that if there is one, he is allowing us to do this things. An omnipotent being could easily not let us come up with thoughts and techniques to "play God" if he didn't want us to. "The Lord works in mysterious ways." Sometimes the "mysterious ways" may be medicine and genetic manipulation..... I guess as someone who does strongly believe in God, I tend to think that the plan wasn't to give us science for purposes such as picking superficial traits for our childen. Genetic defects/illnesses are one thing....but hair color, height etc...I just don't understand it I guess. It seems very unethical in my eyes. But that is only my opinion! |
|
Posted 3/4/09 1:06 PM
|
|
|
LaurenExp
Member since 8/06 11613 total posts Name: |
Re: Designer Babies Anyone? POLL I completely believe in PGD to check for genetic anamolies present in an embryo, but to discard perfectly good embryos based on hair color or eye color, I just feel is morally wrong. |
Posted 3/4/09 1:06 PM
|
|
|
Re: Designer Babies Anyone? POLL Yet another case where the science has outpaced the ethics... as to playing god, so is birth control right?When the pill came out there was the same argument in many circles... 3+ decades later it's totally accepted. So the ethics will evolve as the science is applied I suppose. Using the technology strictly for physical traits is disgusting to me; and foolish really, do you think I could've "designed" this |
|
Posted 3/4/09 1:17 PM
|
|
|
Re: Designer Babies Anyone? POLL Only to eliminated defects especially fatal ones. Other then that, no way!!! |
|
Posted 3/4/09 1:19 PM
|
|
|
Re: Designer Babies Anyone? POLL Posted by maybebaby To those who said it isn't playing god...while I understand what you mean (being that IVF and other procedures do indeed create a child that would not be there otherwise) doesn't it seem like a huge difference? But it does not sit well with me AT ALL that it may someday come down to people hand picking traits they want their children to have. I think the two are very very different. Nope, I personally don't see a difference. I 100% support IVF - but IMO (and of course this is my opinion I see no difference in the lab technician picking "quality" eggs or in the case of IUI "quality" sperm and PGD. EVERY case of PGD is technically the selection of desirable traits. If it's their money and that's what they choose to do it with it so be it, not my place to judge. I honestly don't think many people would opt to do this for that sole purpose. PGD is not a procedure to be taken lightly and costs a lot of $$$$. |
|
Posted 3/4/09 1:35 PM
|
|
|
Re: Designer Babies Anyone? POLL If I knew that we were at a high risk for one reason or another of creating a child with a fatal defect, then I could see checking for that. As for choosing gender or eye color or some other trait... NO! |
|
Posted 3/4/09 1:38 PM
|
|
|
Re: Designer Babies Anyone? POLL Posted by LaurenExp I completely believe in PGD to check for genetic anamolies present in an embryo, but to discard perfectly good embryos based on hair color or eye color, I just feel is morally wrong. But isn't that what happens to every embryo that is not implanted anyway? They may be perfectly good as well but are just discarded. |
|
Posted 3/4/09 1:38 PM
|
|
|
Re: Designer Babies Anyone? POLL Posted by colette Yet another case where the science has outpaced the ethics... as to playing god, so is birth control right?When the pill came out there was the same argument in many circles... 3+ decades later it's totally accepted. It is not totally accepted. Maybe by a majority, but some still see it as immoral |
|
Posted 3/4/09 1:42 PM
|
|
| Pages: [1] 2 | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| The slippery slope... (re: Designer Babies) | Celt | 3/2/09 | 31 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| ‘Designer’ babies with made-to-order defects? | bridget-n-jimmy | 12/22/06 | 11 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Our babies | Diana1215 | 3/22/06 | 6 | Pets |
| I read that at this stage of pregnancy, babies sleep 90-95% of the time | MrsJ | 3/20/06 | 10 | Pregnancy |
| Babies and cats | Disneygirl | 3/15/06 | 7 | Parenting |
| Just wanted to share- for babies with sleep issues | sunny | 3/13/06 | 2 | Parenting |





























