....
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: 1 [2] | |
|
Re: .... Posted by alli3131 Posted by BigB Posted by blu6385 Posted by nraboni Posted by BigB As a mom of twins, this is always an interesting topic for me. So many times, my kids are short changed because it is two at the same time. However, when you have 2 kids that make communion a year apart or even 2 years apart, I don't short change your kids. This is a really sore point for me. So, thank you for being equally generous to both children. How do you know you are getting short changed or its all a family can afford? I am wondering this too ... for me for twins I would give the same amount I would give one amount but I personally don't give that much money to one child. I feel 50-75 is more than enough and I would probably give a little more for family but I am not sure. I also don't base my gift on where the party is being held. I would never give less jut because its in a backyard and I wouldn't give more because someone else chose to have it in a catering hall that might cost more money they chose to have it there and I don't feel any obligation to have to give more just because it maybe in a nicer place! Because I know what they give for 1 kid and I see what they give my kids and it isn't the same. So for example, if the normal gift is 100 for holy communion, my kids get 150 to split. It isn't that I am not grateful, but it isn't their fault that they are twins, and had they been born 2 years apart, they would have gotten 100.00 like the other kids. And, I may not know all the details of what all of my people can afford, but I have a pretty good idea of it. But a gift is a gift. Absolutely. But if you would normally give one child $100 then why isn't it doubled when it happens to be two children? As another twin mom I totally get it. |
|
Posted 4/21/14 10:37 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: .... Posted by cds58019 Posted by alli3131 Posted by BigB Posted by blu6385 Posted by nraboni Posted by BigB As a mom of twins, this is always an interesting topic for me. So many times, my kids are short changed because it is two at the same time. However, when you have 2 kids that make communion a year apart or even 2 years apart, I don't short change your kids. This is a really sore point for me. So, thank you for being equally generous to both children. How do you know you are getting short changed or its all a family can afford? I am wondering this too ... for me for twins I would give the same amount I would give one amount but I personally don't give that much money to one child. I feel 50-75 is more than enough and I would probably give a little more for family but I am not sure. I also don't base my gift on where the party is being held. I would never give less jut because its in a backyard and I wouldn't give more because someone else chose to have it in a catering hall that might cost more money they chose to have it there and I don't feel any obligation to have to give more just because it maybe in a nicer place! Because I know what they give for 1 kid and I see what they give my kids and it isn't the same. So for example, if the normal gift is 100 for holy communion, my kids get 150 to split. It isn't that I am not grateful, but it isn't their fault that they are twins, and had they been born 2 years apart, they would have gotten 100.00 like the other kids. And, I may not know all the details of what all of my people can afford, but I have a pretty good idea of it. But a gift is a gift. Absolutely. But if you would normally give one child $100 then why isn't it doubled when it happens to be two children? As another twin mom I totally get it. For me personally - I gave my twin second cousins $150 for their bar mitzvah. We couldn't go (it was in CA) and we aren't close. At the time, I couldn't swing more. So maybe if I typically gave $100, they could feel slighted - but when parties are spaced out, it's more time to save. Jmo. |
|
Posted 4/21/14 10:49 PM
|
|
|
Re: .... Posted by alli3131 Posted by BigB Posted by blu6385 Posted by nraboni Posted by BigB As a mom of twins, this is always an interesting topic for me. So many times, my kids are short changed because it is two at the same time. However, when you have 2 kids that make communion a year apart or even 2 years apart, I don't short change your kids. This is a really sore point for me. So, thank you for being equally generous to both children. How do you know you are getting short changed or its all a family can afford? I am wondering this too ... for me for twins I would give the same amount I would give one amount but I personally don't give that much money to one child. I feel 50-75 is more than enough and I would probably give a little more for family but I am not sure. I also don't base my gift on where the party is being held. I would never give less jut because its in a backyard and I wouldn't give more because someone else chose to have it in a catering hall that might cost more money they chose to have it there and I don't feel any obligation to have to give more just because it maybe in a nicer place! Because I know what they give for 1 kid and I see what they give my kids and it isn't the same. So for example, if the normal gift is 100 for holy communion, my kids get 150 to split. It isn't that I am not grateful, but it isn't their fault that they are twins, and had they been born 2 years apart, they would have gotten 100.00 like the other kids. And, I may not know all the details of what all of my people can afford, but I have a pretty good idea of it. But a gift is a gift. In a perfect world where people shit rainbows and ride unicorns this would be true but this is the real world and people, parents in this case, think with their hearts and feel slighted because their kids, being twins, are getting less than others. I get it. We're humans. We have feelings, we sometimes think with our hearts. No one wants their kid to get less and anyone who says otherwise is full of shit. Well, except on LIF where everyone is politically correct all the time ![]() To the op, give what you can afford. Message edited 2014-04-22 05:58:48.953000. |
|
Posted 4/22/14 5:58 AM
|
|
|
Re: .... Posted by BigB As a mom of twins, this is always an interesting topic for me. So many times, my kids are short changed because it is two at the same time. However, when you have 2 kids that make communion a year apart or even 2 years apart, I don't short change your kids. This is a really sore point for me. So, thank you for being equally generous to both children. I am Late to the game on this one but I have twins and feel the opposite as you. I feel bad that people feel that they have to bring double the gifts...that can get to be a lot! My kids are only 3 but I am grateful for whatever gifts they get and will teach them the same. |
|
Posted 4/22/14 7:17 AM
|
|
|
Re: .... Posted by cds58019 Posted by alli3131 Posted by BigB Posted by blu6385 Posted by nraboni Posted by BigB As a mom of twins, this is always an interesting topic for me. So many times, my kids are short changed because it is two at the same time. However, when you have 2 kids that make communion a year apart or even 2 years apart, I don't short change your kids. This is a really sore point for me. So, thank you for being equally generous to both children. How do you know you are getting short changed or its all a family can afford? I am wondering this too ... for me for twins I would give the same amount I would give one amount but I personally don't give that much money to one child. I feel 50-75 is more than enough and I would probably give a little more for family but I am not sure. I also don't base my gift on where the party is being held. I would never give less jut because its in a backyard and I wouldn't give more because someone else chose to have it in a catering hall that might cost more money they chose to have it there and I don't feel any obligation to have to give more just because it maybe in a nicer place! Because I know what they give for 1 kid and I see what they give my kids and it isn't the same. So for example, if the normal gift is 100 for holy communion, my kids get 150 to split. It isn't that I am not grateful, but it isn't their fault that they are twins, and had they been born 2 years apart, they would have gotten 100.00 like the other kids. And, I may not know all the details of what all of my people can afford, but I have a pretty good idea of it. But a gift is a gift. Absolutely. But if you would normally give one child $100 then why isn't it doubled when it happens to be two children? As another twin mom I totally get it. I'm not a mother at all but hope to be one soon. However, I totally understand where both the twin moms are coming from... |
|
Posted 4/22/14 9:01 AM
|
|
|
Re: .... Posted by HoneyBadger Posted by alli3131 Posted by BigB Posted by blu6385 Posted by nraboni Posted by BigB As a mom of twins, this is always an interesting topic for me. So many times, my kids are short changed because it is two at the same time. However, when you have 2 kids that make communion a year apart or even 2 years apart, I don't short change your kids. This is a really sore point for me. So, thank you for being equally generous to both children. How do you know you are getting short changed or its all a family can afford? I am wondering this too ... for me for twins I would give the same amount I would give one amount but I personally don't give that much money to one child. I feel 50-75 is more than enough and I would probably give a little more for family but I am not sure. I also don't base my gift on where the party is being held. I would never give less jut because its in a backyard and I wouldn't give more because someone else chose to have it in a catering hall that might cost more money they chose to have it there and I don't feel any obligation to have to give more just because it maybe in a nicer place! Because I know what they give for 1 kid and I see what they give my kids and it isn't the same. So for example, if the normal gift is 100 for holy communion, my kids get 150 to split. It isn't that I am not grateful, but it isn't their fault that they are twins, and had they been born 2 years apart, they would have gotten 100.00 like the other kids. And, I may not know all the details of what all of my people can afford, but I have a pretty good idea of it. But a gift is a gift. In a perfect world where people shit rainbows and ride unicorns this would be true but this is the real world and people, parents in this case, think with their hearts and feel slighted because their kids, being twins, are getting less than others. I get it. We're humans. We have feelings, we sometimes think with our hearts. No one wants their kid to get less and anyone who says otherwise is full of shit. Well, except on LIF where everyone is politically correct all the time ![]() To the op, give what you can afford. ![]()
|
|
Posted 4/22/14 9:03 AM
|
|
|
.... You know what? Times are tough for a lot of people financially. If you have the money to give both a nice chunk, good for you. Do it. Be generous. If you have only enough for them to split a nice chunk, so be it. If people are not happy with your gift, they can shove it. Will twins get shafted? Maybe. But so do Christmas babies and other holiday babies. And guess what? Life goes on. Some people can afford to be super generous. Others are scraping by. A gift should be appreciated no matter the amount. Personally, I'd love to be super generous with gifts. But the reality is that I have to really think about every dollar. I am not rich by LI means. Someone isn't happy with my gift...then next time, don't invite me. |
|
Posted 4/22/14 9:15 AM
|
|
|
Re: .... Posted by MissJones You know what? Times are tough for a lot of people financially. If you have the money to give both a nice chunk, good for you. Do it. Be generous. If you have only enough for them to split a nice chunk, so be it. If people are not happy with your gift, they can shove it. Will twins get shafted? Maybe. But so do Christmas babies and other holiday babies. And guess what? Life goes on. Some people can afford to be super generous. Others are scraping by. A gift should be appreciated no matter the amount. Personally, I'd love to be super generous with gifts. But the reality is that I have to really think about every dollar. I am not rich by LI means. Someone isn't happy with my gift...then next time, don't invite me.
|
|
Posted 4/22/14 9:21 AM
|
|
|
Re: .... Posted by MissJones You know what? Times are tough for a lot of people financially. If you have the money to give both a nice chunk, good for you. Do it. Be generous. If you have only enough for them to split a nice chunk, so be it. If people are not happy with your gift, they can shove it. Will twins get shafted? Maybe. But so do Christmas babies and other holiday babies. And guess what? Life goes on. Some people can afford to be super generous. Others are scraping by. A gift should be appreciated no matter the amount. Personally, I'd love to be super generous with gifts. But the reality is that I have to really think about every dollar. I am not rich by LI means. Someone isn't happy with my gift...then next time, don't invite me. Love this!!! I wish everyone had this great attitude about things. |
|
Posted 4/22/14 9:31 AM
|
|
|
Re: .... Posted by MissJones You know what? Times are tough for a lot of people financially. If you have the money to give both a nice chunk, good for you. Do it. Be generous. If you have only enough for them to split a nice chunk, so be it. If people are not happy with your gift, they can shove it. Will twins get shafted? Maybe. But so do Christmas babies and other holiday babies. And guess what? Life goes on. Some people can afford to be super generous. Others are scraping by. A gift should be appreciated no matter the amount. Personally, I'd love to be super generous with gifts. But the reality is that I have to really think about every dollar. I am not rich by LI means. Someone isn't happy with my gift...then next time, don't invite me. This opinion IS great but it's also not REALISTIC. Fact remains, people are human and as such can and WILL react emotionally and sometime IRRATIONALLY. I'm not saying it's right but it happens. To think otherwise and act like you never would react that way is laughable and frankly, unrealistic. |
|
Posted 4/22/14 11:09 AM
|
|
|
Re: .... Posted by BigB As a mom of twins, this is always an interesting topic for me. So many times, my kids are short changed because it is two at the same time. However, when you have 2 kids that make communion a year apart or even 2 years apart, I don't short change your kids. This is a really sore point for me. So, thank you for being equally generous to both children. I have a solution for this - since you have one joint party and don't have to shell out for another party in 2 years for the second communion and invite all the same people - why don't you take some of the money that would have been spent on the party and supplement the gifts.
|
|
Posted 4/22/14 11:22 AM
|
|
|
Re: .... Posted by MK2010 Posted by BigB As a mom of twins, this is always an interesting topic for me. So many times, my kids are short changed because it is two at the same time. However, when you have 2 kids that make communion a year apart or even 2 years apart, I don't short change your kids. This is a really sore point for me. So, thank you for being equally generous to both children. I have a solution for this - since you have one joint party and don't have to shell out for another party in 2 years for the second communion and invite all the same people - why don't you take some of the money that would have been spent on the party and supplement the gifts. What does this even mean?? You quoted a poster who HAS twins and was thanking the op for giving equally and generously. She wasn't saying it was a hardship for her to give. |
|
Posted 4/22/14 11:36 AM
|
|
|
Re: .... Posted by HoneyBadger Posted by MK2010 Posted by BigB As a mom of twins, this is always an interesting topic for me. So many times, my kids are short changed because it is two at the same time. However, when you have 2 kids that make communion a year apart or even 2 years apart, I don't short change your kids. This is a really sore point for me. So, thank you for being equally generous to both children. I have a solution for this - since you have one joint party and don't have to shell out for another party in 2 years for the second communion and invite all the same people - why don't you take some of the money that would have been spent on the party and supplement the gifts. What does this even mean?? You quoted a poster who HAS twins and was thanking the op for giving equally and generously. She wasn't saying it was a hardship for her to give. I wasn't trying to be mean or negative. The poster mentioned it was a sore point with twins that sometimes they get lumped together - twins are short changed. I was just saying - let's say you are going to spend $800 on a party for your child. Then the next child has the same life event and you spend $800. If you have twins - most likely you are going to have 1 party instead of two and then with the $800 you have saved from having to have the second party - you take some of that and say put it toward a college fund for your kid - money that might have been coming from guests if the parties were 2 years apart. Just another way to look at things. Really not trying to .
|
|
Posted 4/22/14 11:45 AM
|
|
|
Re: .... Posted by MK2010 Posted by HoneyBadger Posted by MK2010 Posted by BigB As a mom of twins, this is always an interesting topic for me. So many times, my kids are short changed because it is two at the same time. However, when you have 2 kids that make communion a year apart or even 2 years apart, I don't short change your kids. This is a really sore point for me. So, thank you for being equally generous to both children. I have a solution for this - since you have one joint party and don't have to shell out for another party in 2 years for the second communion and invite all the same people - why don't you take some of the money that would have been spent on the party and supplement the gifts. What does this even mean?? You quoted a poster who HAS twins and was thanking the op for giving equally and generously. She wasn't saying it was a hardship for her to give. I wasn't trying to be mean or negative. The poster mentioned it was a sore point with twins that sometimes they get lumped together - twins are short changed. I was just saying - let's say you are going to spend $800 on a party for your child. Then the next child has the same life event and you spend $800. If you have twins - most likely you are going to have 1 party instead of two and then with the $800 you have saved from having to have the second party - you take some of that and say put it toward a college fund for your kid - money that might have been coming from guests if the parties were 2 years apart. Just another way to look at things. Really not trying to .Ok, so you're saying at least the perk in them being lumped together is at least they only have to spend money on one party vs two. That is a fair assessment though I totally took your post for being snarky. |
|
Posted 4/22/14 11:49 AM
|
|
|
Re: .... Posted by HoneyBadger Posted by MK2010 Posted by BigB As a mom of twins, this is always an interesting topic for me. So many times, my kids are short changed because it is two at the same time. However, when you have 2 kids that make communion a year apart or even 2 years apart, I don't short change your kids. This is a really sore point for me. So, thank you for being equally generous to both children. I have a solution for this - since you have one joint party and don't have to shell out for another party in 2 years for the second communion and invite all the same people - why don't you take some of the money that would have been spent on the party and supplement the gifts. What does this even mean?? You quoted a poster who HAS twins and was thanking the op for giving equally and generously. She wasn't saying it was a hardship for her to give. I think the point being made was that the mom of twins was complaining about her twins not getting the same gift as a single child yet the family is only paying to have one party. Not that I think a gift amount should be based on the cost of a party - but I do get the point |
|
Posted 4/22/14 11:50 AM
|
|
|
Re: .... Posted by HoneyBadger Posted by MK2010 Posted by HoneyBadger Posted by MK2010 Posted by BigB As a mom of twins, this is always an interesting topic for me. So many times, my kids are short changed because it is two at the same time. However, when you have 2 kids that make communion a year apart or even 2 years apart, I don't short change your kids. This is a really sore point for me. So, thank you for being equally generous to both children. I have a solution for this - since you have one joint party and don't have to shell out for another party in 2 years for the second communion and invite all the same people - why don't you take some of the money that would have been spent on the party and supplement the gifts. What does this even mean?? You quoted a poster who HAS twins and was thanking the op for giving equally and generously. She wasn't saying it was a hardship for her to give. I wasn't trying to be mean or negative. The poster mentioned it was a sore point with twins that sometimes they get lumped together - twins are short changed. I was just saying - let's say you are going to spend $800 on a party for your child. Then the next child has the same life event and you spend $800. If you have twins - most likely you are going to have 1 party instead of two and then with the $800 you have saved from having to have the second party - you take some of that and say put it toward a college fund for your kid - money that might have been coming from guests if the parties were 2 years apart. Just another way to look at things. Really not trying to .Ok, so you're saying at least the perk in them being lumped together is at least they only have to spend money on one party vs two. That is a fair assessment though I totally took your post for being snarky. That's why I used the winking emoticon. I have less than 200 posts - still new at this.
|
|
Posted 4/22/14 11:52 AM
|
|
|
Re: .... Posted by MK2010 Posted by HoneyBadger Posted by MK2010 Posted by HoneyBadger Posted by MK2010 Posted by BigB As a mom of twins, this is always an interesting topic for me. So many times, my kids are short changed because it is two at the same time. However, when you have 2 kids that make communion a year apart or even 2 years apart, I don't short change your kids. This is a really sore point for me. So, thank you for being equally generous to both children. I have a solution for this - since you have one joint party and don't have to shell out for another party in 2 years for the second communion and invite all the same people - why don't you take some of the money that would have been spent on the party and supplement the gifts. What does this even mean?? You quoted a poster who HAS twins and was thanking the op for giving equally and generously. She wasn't saying it was a hardship for her to give. I wasn't trying to be mean or negative. The poster mentioned it was a sore point with twins that sometimes they get lumped together - twins are short changed. I was just saying - let's say you are going to spend $800 on a party for your child. Then the next child has the same life event and you spend $800. If you have twins - most likely you are going to have 1 party instead of two and then with the $800 you have saved from having to have the second party - you take some of that and say put it toward a college fund for your kid - money that might have been coming from guests if the parties were 2 years apart. Just another way to look at things. Really not trying to .Ok, so you're saying at least the perk in them being lumped together is at least they only have to spend money on one party vs two. That is a fair assessment though I totally took your post for being snarky. That's why I used the winking emoticon. I have less than 200 posts - still new at this. Be warned, the winkie emoticon is more often used for purposes of snark here than not lol
|
|
Posted 4/22/14 11:57 AM
|
|
| Pages: 1 [2] | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| another wedding related post | Beth | 8/18/06 | 4 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Please post DH attending a wedding suit looks... | itsbabytime | 7/8/06 | 4 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| This is a wedding post | Jessica | 6/28/06 | 59 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Post a wedding pic | IGLover | 5/17/06 | 183 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| another post re: wedding gift advice | Bxgell2 | 2/20/06 | 22 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| NPR: Post your favorite Wedding Pic! | mommy2bella | 12/12/05 | 27 | Parenting |









.
