.

Posted By Message
Pages: << 2 3 4 [5]

maybebaby
LIF Adult

Member since 11/05

6870 total posts

Name:
Maureen

Re: What do you think?

Posted by shellybean

Posted by headoverheels

not a mom yet... but i think that some of the posters on here are missing the point.

you specifically told your MIL and SIL no bath, and you had a good reason - it is part of your evening routine.

i suspect that you are not as "uptight' with everything as with this one particular wish... and you, being the mom, have every right to set the rules for your child. doesn't matter if that means you are uptight or not. if my mom or MIL went against my wishes AFTER ASKING ME i would be livid.

i took your post as asking whether we thought it was uptight of you to be mad at your MIL and DH when you specifically said "no bath" - i didn't take it as you asking whether we thought you were being uptight by having him on a particular schedule.

in this case, i think you are right.



I agree but I see no reason in not allowing her to bathe him in the first place...what is the reasoning on why you dont want her to bathe him...its not like an everyday thing that he would be getting 2 bathes, its just once in a while...my feeling is that if someone is watching your baby for free cut them a little slack as long as they are trying to do a nice thing...



You summed up exactly how I feel...

I don't know....I don't have family near me..I travel 5 hours each time I see them, or they travel here. I cherish the time so much that they spend (not saying you don't!)...and if they wanted to give my kid a bath, I have no prob. with it.

If my mom or MIL asked me if they could bathe Johnny....and I said "no"..their feelings would be pretty hurt. YES you are the mom and I understand that but I feel people need to pick and choose battles. There is zero harm in a bath and if it makes them happy why not?

If my kid hated the bath....or had really dry skin and it would cause more harm than good, then I could understand saying not to do it. Otherwise I just don't see the big deal. JMHO!

Posted 8/5/08 10:07 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

headoverheels
s'il vous plaƮt

Member since 6/07

42079 total posts

Name:
LB

Re: What do you think?

Posted by shellybean

Posted by headoverheels

not a mom yet... but i think that some of the posters on here are missing the point.

you specifically told your MIL and SIL no bath, and you had a good reason - it is part of your evening routine.

i suspect that you are not as "uptight' with everything as with this one particular wish... and you, being the mom, have every right to set the rules for your child. doesn't matter if that means you are uptight or not. if my mom or MIL went against my wishes AFTER ASKING ME i would be livid.

i took your post as asking whether we thought it was uptight of you to be mad at your MIL and DH when you specifically said "no bath" - i didn't take it as you asking whether we thought you were being uptight by having him on a particular schedule.

in this case, i think you are right.



I agree but I see no reason in not allowing her to bathe him in the first place...what is the reasoning on why you dont want her to bathe him...its not like an everyday thing that he would be getting 2 bathes, its just once in a while...my feeling is that if someone is watching your baby for free cut them a little slack as long as they are trying to do a nice thing...



i wasn't judging her on whether i thought she should allow them to bathe her DS... and i wasn't going to say what i would do in her situation. i only commented on what she asked - if she was out of line for being mad that they went against her wishes.

if she HAD asked, i might have said that in this case, since they don't watch him all the time, that i personally would have said sure, go ahead and give him a bath, because i didn't think that this one time would make a difference, and it would be special for her MIL and SIL. but since that's not what she asked Chat Icon that's not what i answered. Chat Icon

Posted 8/5/08 10:10 PM
 

EmmaNick
*

Member since 12/06

16001 total posts

Name:
*

Re: What do you think?

I would be annoyed to a point, but I think you have to pick your battles. If this is one you really are dead set on, then let her know once again no baths, and blame it on your ped. or something.

I'll tell you my little story on this. Emma goes with her dad on Sunday's and they spend the day at his mom's (her grandmother) house typically. He brought her home one evening and said his mom had given her a bath and put her PJ's on. I was really annoyed because a. why is someone else bathing my child and b. she was a sweat bucket from sitting in the carseat in the hot car so I had to bathe her again. So I did say something in a nice way. The response I got back was that the bath his mother gave her brought a little bit of joy to her in the rough year she had with her husband (Emma's grandpa) dying and he wasn't about to tell her no she can't bathe her grandchild Chat Icon I let it go after that.

Posted 8/5/08 10:11 PM
 

shellybean
Love my Baby Boy!

Member since 4/07

5191 total posts

Name:
mich

Re: What do you think?

Posted by headoverheels

Posted by shellybean

Posted by headoverheels

not a mom yet... but i think that some of the posters on here are missing the point.

you specifically told your MIL and SIL no bath, and you had a good reason - it is part of your evening routine.

i suspect that you are not as "uptight' with everything as with this one particular wish... and you, being the mom, have every right to set the rules for your child. doesn't matter if that means you are uptight or not. if my mom or MIL went against my wishes AFTER ASKING ME i would be livid.

i took your post as asking whether we thought it was uptight of you to be mad at your MIL and DH when you specifically said "no bath" - i didn't take it as you asking whether we thought you were being uptight by having him on a particular schedule.

in this case, i think you are right.



I agree but I see no reason in not allowing her to bathe him in the first place...what is the reasoning on why you dont want her to bathe him...its not like an everyday thing that he would be getting 2 bathes, its just once in a while...my feeling is that if someone is watching your baby for free cut them a little slack as long as they are trying to do a nice thing...



i wasn't judging her on whether i thought she should allow them to bathe her DS... and i wasn't going to say what i would do in her situation. i only commented on what she asked - if she was out of line for being mad that they went against her wishes.

if she HAD asked, i might have said that in this case, since they don't watch him all the time, that i personally would have said sure, go ahead and give him a bath, because i didn't think that this one time would make a difference, and it would be special for her MIL and SIL. but since that's not what she asked Chat Icon that's not what i answered. Chat Icon



oh ok...i just really see no harm in it...honestly i dont think my mom or MIL would even ask me if they could bathe him...But yes, they should respect her wishes but I think that her saying no is really just not nice...Im sorry im not trying to make you feel bad...do you have a good relationship with MIL. If your mom wanted ot bathe him woulod you feel the same or would you let her? It just kinda seems like a power struggle with MIL...Dont get me wrong, maybe shes done you wrong and you just want to return the favor, I dont know the situation...Chat Icon

Posted 8/5/08 10:15 PM
 

Rycois
Blessed with 2blue/2pink

Member since 12/05

13341 total posts

Name:
J

Re: What do you think?

.

Message edited 2011-06-24 14:55:42.070000.

Posted 8/5/08 10:16 PM
 

jaclyn78
LIF Adolescent

Member since 11/06

635 total posts

Name:
Jaclyn

Re: What do you think?

Honestly, I think you have every right to feel the way you do. Every mother has her own parenting style. If this is something you're uncomfortable with, they need to respect your wishes. I definitely don't think you're uptight, you just like to do things in a certain way. I'm the same way with my DD. Maybe b/c she's my first child, maybe b/c I feel guilty working and I'd like to do certain things with her by myself. Oh, and that kiddie pool comment...Chat Icon

Posted 8/5/08 10:20 PM
 

Rycois
Blessed with 2blue/2pink

Member since 12/05

13341 total posts

Name:
J

Re: What do you think?

Posted by jaclyn78

Oh, and that kiddie pool comment...Chat Icon


I know - I should have said, "well you only have a crappy kiddie pool and my mom has a big inground pool so of course he goes in that one Chat Icon "

Posted 8/5/08 10:25 PM
 

shellybean
Love my Baby Boy!

Member since 4/07

5191 total posts

Name:
mich

Re: What do you think?

Posted by SweetCaroline

Posted by jaclyn78

Oh, and that kiddie pool comment...Chat Icon


I know - I should have said, "well you only have a crappy kiddie pool and my mom has a big inground pool so of course he goes in that one Chat Icon "

Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Were you the poster whose MIL put him in the pool for the 1st time, that was just wrong!!

Posted 8/5/08 10:27 PM
 

jaclyn78
LIF Adolescent

Member since 11/06

635 total posts

Name:
Jaclyn

Re: What do you think?

Posted by SweetCaroline

Posted by jaclyn78

Oh, and that kiddie pool comment...Chat Icon


I know - I should have said, "well you only have a crappy kiddie pool and my mom has a big inground pool so of course he goes in that one Chat Icon "



Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 8/5/08 10:39 PM
 

AimeeE2006
Time flies!

Member since 1/06

5698 total posts

Name:
Aimee

Re: What do you think?

Posted by Luv2bAmom

To be honest with you what they asking to do does not sound like a big deal to me. The fact that they want to give him a bath would not bother me, I think they just want to bond with him.

That being said I firmly beleive that the parents make the final decision for the child period, so your child your rules.

ETA: I do not think you are being uptight for expecting them to respect your wishes, but I think that what you are asking them not to do (bathe your DC) sounds uptight to me.



ITA.

Posted 8/5/08 11:13 PM
 

SweetT
LIF Adult

Member since 4/06

1305 total posts

Name:
Ali

Re: What do you think?

PPl, no matter who, should respect your wishes as a Mom. Stick up for youself!

Posted 8/5/08 11:15 PM
 

IheartF&M
Finally made it to 1,000!!!!

Member since 6/08

1059 total posts

Name:
stacy

Re: What do you think?

Posted by lululu

Posted by imthekevinofcindyandkevin

Okay I'm going to go out on a limb here a take a guess that your DH is a nice guy, good husband and father. I'm guessing he has lots of good qualities and you married him and decided to have a family together, yes?

Well your MIL had a lot to do with the man he became and I think she just wants to have a good time with your baby. She knows you're his mother and that your wishes should be followed. I don't think she's trying to impose on your time with him. I think she just wants to relax and have fun and not worry that you're going to go crazy over every little thing she does and if that's the case then don't let her watch him.

You're in a power struggle with her whether you want to admit it or not. Subconsciously you saying "You had your shot at raising babies and now I'm the mommy so what I say goes". Whether it's rational or not you feel the need to assert your power over them.

Relax and let the grandparents have fun. Believe me they are not going to do anything to hurt him. They love him too.
And in the grand scheme of things does it really matter that he gets a bath from grandma and mommy in one day?

Trust me there will be bigger fish to fry as you go through this journey called parenthood. Do yourself a favor and don't alienate those people who love your child also.



Thanks for posting this. I think that it is really well put and I think it helped me get a little perspective with my own issues with my MIL.

I have found from talking to so many other moms that a lot of us seem to have this power struggle with our MILs. I think that a big part of it is the need for us to assert ourselves as the mommy, and the MIL wanting to get some control over the baby.

That being said, the best way for the MIL to gain trust would be to empathize with the position of a new mom and respect even the things that they might perceive to be uptight. I know that when my MIL actually respects my wishes it makes me want to give her more control to do whatever she wants with my son.



Lululu....I ditto everything you said. I am in the same situation with my MIL. We are in constant battle for control. To the point where everyone in the family sees it (so immature). But when she asks my opinion or asks if she can do something, it makes me want to let her have more freedom.
Its a terrible feeling this constant struggle.

With all that being said I would NOt want my MIL to bathe my child but I am not proud that I feel this way. I wish I could be one of the moms who say "who cares".

Posted 8/6/08 12:11 AM
 

CrankyPants
I'm cranky

Member since 7/06

18178 total posts

Name:
Mama Cranky

Re: What do you think?

You're the mom, so whether your requests are uptight or not, they should be respected. To blatantly defy your wishes and possibly lie about it makes your in laws nutty, not you.

I agree with the sentiment of previous posters in that I let my in laws bathe DD, but that is MY choice. This is YOUR choice. The fact that you have a very good reason for saying "no" is secondary to me-even if you had no reason at all, it's still your choice.

I think Kevin makes a valid point in saying that we all could be a little more understanding of our in laws because they raised sons good enough for us to fall in love with, raise families with, etc. However, I don't think it has anything to do with whether you were right or wrong in this scenario. YOUR kid, YOUR choices.

Posted 8/6/08 9:13 AM
 

Stefanie
&hearts;

Member since 5/05

23599 total posts

Name:
Stefanie

Re: What do you think?

When you think about it, it kinda sounds as if you're being uptight but then again...if I make personal and think about MY mil doing this, it gets me mad to think that someone would disrespect my wishes.

I mean, if you're telling her no and she's not listening to this...what else is she doing/will she be doing?

In the end, you may sound uptight to his mother and sister, but you know what, you're the mom and what you say should go.

Do you have a good relationship with your MIL or has there been power struggles in the past with her?

Posted 8/6/08 9:46 AM
 

PrincessP
Big sister!!!!!!!!!!

Member since 12/05

17450 total posts

Name:

Re: What do you think?

Posted by Stefanie

When you think about it, it kinda sounds as if you're being uptight but then again...if I make personal and think about MY mil doing this, it gets me mad to think that someone would disrespect my wishes.

I mean, if you're telling her no and she's not listening to this...what else is she doing/will she be doing?

In the end, you may sound uptight to his mother and sister, but you know what, you're the mom and what you say should go.

Do you have a good relationship with your MIL or has there been power struggles in the past with her?



Exactly what she said!
The more I thought about your situation the more I realized if I was in your situation I would be ******! So if I were the receiver listening to all the above responses about giving her a chance etc... it might infuriate me. BUT since I am on the other side being the giver of alternatives I am more likely to rationalize what you should do.
Ultimately, you have to do what is best for your family. If you dont want her to give dc a bath...dont. BUT like I said a few pages back...be prepared to have to cut alot of ties. In the end you and MIL are going to have a miserable relationship if it continues as is. You have that option...you can cut off or drastically cut off or you can pick and choose battles as they come. That is all in your hands. You are in control of what kind of relationship you want for your family.

Posted 8/6/08 9:52 AM
 

Ang-Rich
Beyond Compare

Member since 5/05

17988 total posts

Name:

Re: What do you think?

I was talking to DH about this last night (fortunately he has gotten used to hearing about LIF in response to "how was your day?" Chat Icon ) and he told me something I thought was worth sharing:

When we brought Lucas home we put him on his back to sleep - like every medical professional had told us to do. My MIL told me to put him on his belly - that what she did with her kids (that's what my mom did too) but I was too afraid to go against the advice of my doctor. My MIL was offended. DH pulled her aside and told her that we would never doubt her and he knew that once we were comfortable we would take her advice but for now we need to do what we think is best...just like she did. He reminded her that she learned and we would learn and that we appreciate her advice and experience...he told her he knew it would be needed time and time again.

He also told her to trust HIM - he knew I'd be a good mom just like her -that's one of the reasons he wanted a family with me.

It took a while for her to get over it and for a while she wouldn't give me any advice. But soon I started sleeping Lucas on his belly and I told her that she was right and thanked her for letting me figure it out. All was good again. I am fortunate to have a good relationship with my MIL but we still butt heads once in a while. But on the fip side I can't tell you how many times I have overheard her talking about what a good job I do - how good of a mom I am. That means a lot.

Now I don't think that you are looking to fight with your MIL. I think that you are hurt that she is saying that you are uptight (that used to hurt me too) and more importantly I think that you are upset because you want to trust her and it's hard when she goes over you like that. If my MIL has slept my son on his belly before I was ready to have that happen I would have been beyond upset. But at the end of the day it doesn't matter what it is - bath or sleep - EVERYONE that is with your child needs to respect your wishes.

I feel like the uptight/relaxed parent conversation turns almost into a debate - like who is a better parent...like the SAHM vs. Working Moms. The reality is no one way is better. Both have their pros and cons. It's what you make of it. I see nothing wrong with being either way...but it bothers me to see it constantly up for discussion.

Posted 8/6/08 10:05 AM
 

Rycois
Blessed with 2blue/2pink

Member since 12/05

13341 total posts

Name:
J

Re: What do you think?


Thanks again Chat Icon

Message edited 2011-06-24 14:56:05.777000.

Posted 8/6/08 10:36 AM
 

KartveliT
...

Member since 1/08

8363 total posts

Name:

Re: What do you think?

Last night, in an argument DH tells me I'm an uptight mom, I need to relax more and that "people" have commented that I'm uptight. I get very upset and demand to know who but I assume it's him mom & sister. He later backtracks that he made that up - but I have a feeling he did not.
I don't think you are being "uptight" AT ALL you are being a mom , it's your child and as many already said above, your wishes should be respected.
If I tell my MIL or my mother(or whoever is watching the baby) that I don't want them to give the baby a bath bc I like to do it, that means that they should NOT bathe the baby.
If I tell them that I don't want the baby to watch TV that means that they should NOT let her( even if it's an educational show)
If I tell them that the baby can't have a binky other than when she sleeps , that means that they should NOT give it to her. (my sister has these problems with her MIL and sometimes she is told that she is an uptight mom)
I don't understand why is it being uptight if a mother wants things done the certain way when it comes to her own child.
Chat Icon Chat Icon


Message edited 2008-08-06 10:48:19.207000.

Posted 8/6/08 10:41 AM
 

LIMOMx2
...

Member since 5/05

24989 total posts

Name:

Re: What do you think?

Ok my being very laid back I can see how you may be seen as being uptight.

But it also seems that by other posts that you do not like your MIL. Is there anyone else that can watch your child? Maybe daycare?

It seems like you both have problems with each other and maybe another babysitting, daycare situation would be better.

Posted 8/6/08 10:48 AM
 

Rycois
Blessed with 2blue/2pink

Member since 12/05

13341 total posts

Name:
J

Re: What do you think?

Posted by 5ofClubs

Ok my being very laid back I can see how you may be seen as being uptight.

But it also seems that by other posts that you do not like your MIL. Is there anyone else that can watch your child? Maybe daycare?

It seems like you both have problems with each other and maybe another babysitting, daycare situation would be better.



She does not watch Ryan for us on a regular basis - my DH, my mom and I split the week up right now. DS will start daycare in the fall. She is only with him for a few hrs here and there when DH needs her to help out so he can work on our house.

Posted 8/6/08 10:52 AM
 

LIMOMx2
...

Member since 5/05

24989 total posts

Name:

Re: What do you think?

Posted by SweetCaroline

Posted by 5ofClubs

Ok my being very laid back I can see how you may be seen as being uptight.

But it also seems that by other posts that you do not like your MIL. Is there anyone else that can watch your child? Maybe daycare?

It seems like you both have problems with each other and maybe another babysitting, daycare situation would be better.



She does not watch Ryan for us on a regular basis - my DH, my mom and I split the week up right now. DS will start daycare in the fall. She is only with him for a few hrs here and there when DH needs her to help out so he can work on our house.


That's good. It seems like daycare will work out great for everyone. And they don't have a bath there or a poolChat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 8/6/08 10:54 AM
 

annie
This is how I play basketball!

Member since 6/05

1980 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: What do you think?

Posted by Luv2bAmom

To be honest with you what they asking to do does not sound like a big deal to me. The fact that they want to give him a bath would not bother me, I think they just want to bond with him.

That being said I firmly beleive that the parents make the final decision for the child period, so your child your rules.

ETA: I do not think you are being uptight for expecting them to respect your wishes, but I think that what you are asking them not to do (bathe your DC) sounds uptight to me.



ITA. I think we need to pick our battles with ILs.

Posted 8/6/08 12:29 PM
 

ARIELSMOM
Love my Babes

Member since 8/05

5889 total posts

Name:
MEREDITH

Re: What do you think?

With my kids, especially my first, i was very much like that. As my daughter got older (tolder age) i didnt mind if people who were around her all the time, my mom,sister and very close friend, gave her a bath. As long as i knew about it, and it was in the "bedtime routine"
newborns and infants- me and DH only, but now that ds is older, i dont mind as long as its someone he is comfortable with, and im comfortable with.
What would bother me most is that they arent respecting your wishes. Maybe you can explain to them how you feel, and when he gets a little older and you feel more comforatble, they can be a part of bath time.

Posted 8/6/08 12:54 PM
 

QuoteTheRaven424
22 Months?!!!!

Member since 5/05

13659 total posts

Name:
And If That Isn't A True Blue Miracle

Re: What do you think?

i don't even have to read the whole thread Chat Icon

bottom line? it's your child - you set the rules as to who does what - no questions asked

Message edited 2008-08-06 13:30:05.837000.

Posted 8/6/08 1:22 PM
 
Pages: << 2 3 4 [5]