Re: What do you think?
Posted 8/5/2008 10:15:43 PM by shellybean


Posted by headoverheels


Posted by shellybean


Posted by headoverheels

not a mom yet... but i think that some of the posters on here are missing the point.

you specifically told your MIL and SIL no bath, and you had a good reason - it is part of your evening routine.

i suspect that you are not as "uptight' with everything as with this one particular wish... and you, being the mom, have every right to set the rules for your child. doesn't matter if that means you are uptight or not. if my mom or MIL went against my wishes AFTER ASKING ME i would be livid.

i took your post as asking whether we thought it was uptight of you to be mad at your MIL and DH when you specifically said "no bath" - i didn't take it as you asking whether we thought you were being uptight by having him on a particular schedule.

in this case, i think you are right.



I agree but I see no reason in not allowing her to bathe him in the first place...what is the reasoning on why you dont want her to bathe him...its not like an everyday thing that he would be getting 2 bathes, its just once in a while...my feeling is that if someone is watching your baby for free cut them a little slack as long as they are trying to do a nice thing...



i wasn't judging her on whether i thought she should allow them to bathe her DS... and i wasn't going to say what i would do in her situation. i only commented on what she asked - if she was out of line for being mad that they went against her wishes.

if she HAD asked, i might have said that in this case, since they don't watch him all the time, that i personally would have said sure, go ahead and give him a bath, because i didn't think that this one time would make a difference, and it would be special for her MIL and SIL. but since that's not what she asked Chat Icon that's not what i answered. Chat Icon



oh ok...i just really see no harm in it...honestly i dont think my mom or MIL would even ask me if they could bathe him...But yes, they should respect her wishes but I think that her saying no is really just not nice...Im sorry im not trying to make you feel bad...do you have a good relationship with MIL. If your mom wanted ot bathe him woulod you feel the same or would you let her? It just kinda seems like a power struggle with MIL...Dont get me wrong, maybe shes done you wrong and you just want to return the favor, I dont know the situation...Chat Icon

Print Post      Close Window