Which would you get?

Forum Opinion Poll
Red cable knit smaller PB stockings - only 16" long 20 42.55%
Red white snowflake stockings (18" long and half the price of PB ones) 24 51.06%
Other - PLEASE make a suggestion 3 6.38%
 

Vote in this poll

View poll

Stockings help - opinions please!

Posted By Message

LoveyQ
Stalkers, get a life.

Member since 11/07

12820 total posts

Name:

Stockings help - opinions please!

So I want to get a new set of stockings now that we have DS (our current ones are just plain ones with no names or anything and don't match). I want knitted stockings that we won't want to replace in a couple of years.

I LOOOOVE these new cable knit ones from Pottery Barn, BUUUUT they don't make the medium size in the red (WTeF?!?!?! Chat Icon ). From what I can find, it seems that standard size stockings are about 20 inches long, which is what the medium at PB are.

We could get the SMALLER ones of this (pic on the far right), but they are only 16" long and 7" wide. The medium are 20.5" x 9". I don't like the look of the really long ones so that's not an option. And I definitely want the red ones, not the ivory.

External Image


OR

My second option is these from Personal Creations - the one on the far right
External Image

External Image

These are 18" long, don't say the width.

Would you get the small red cable knit PB ones? Or the red/white snowflake Personal Creations ones? Or keep looking (suggestions?).

If it matters, the PB ones are DOUBLE the price of the Personal Creations ones.

Thanksgiving is exactly 2 weeks from today and I wanted to put up all our decorations that weekend.

Posted 11/11/10 1:18 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

JoJo2010
Happy Family

Member since 8/09

6266 total posts

Name:
JO

Re: Stockings help - opinions please!

Your better than me! I was at the $1 store yesterday and bought our stockings the ones you always see red and fuzzy white top and I am going to write our names on them with glue and glitter!



Anyway! I like the first ones better, but for the price and the sizing I would choose the 2nd one!

Posted 11/11/10 1:21 PM
 

maybesoon
LIF Adult

Member since 9/09

5981 total posts

Name:

Re: Stockings help - opinions please!

I ordered the ones with the characters (snow man, santa, etc) from personal creations, they were like 15 bucks plus a littel extra for personalization. I love them, the quality is really good and they are so cute. I would go with the less expensive ones, plus I feel like the small pottery barn one is too small

Posted 11/11/10 1:21 PM
 

CrankyPants
I'm cranky

Member since 7/06

18178 total posts

Name:
Mama Cranky

Re: Stockings help - opinions please!

I like the Personal Creations ones you have there, very cute and festive.

Posted 11/11/10 1:31 PM
 

lucyloo
nope

Member since 1/06

9758 total posts

Name:

Re: Stockings help - opinions please!

Love # 2!

Posted 11/11/10 1:48 PM
 

azoodie

Member since 8/05

8377 total posts

Name:
Team SEXY BACK

Re: Stockings help - opinions please!

#2 Chat Icon

Posted 11/11/10 1:50 PM
 

Mags1227
Just a mommy ...

Member since 10/10

2665 total posts

Name:
M

Re: Stockings help - opinions please!

i like the pb ones better. I think the smaller size is fine.

Posted 11/11/10 1:53 PM
 

LoveyQ
Stalkers, get a life.

Member since 11/07

12820 total posts

Name:

Re: Stockings help - opinions please!

Haha, poll is even right now. Any other opinions?

Posted 11/11/10 3:33 PM
 

jgl
Love my little boys!!!

Member since 8/07

7060 total posts

Name:
g

Re: Stockings help - opinions please!

I thinj the ones from personal creations look more expensive and are nicer!!! I think i may get them

Posted 11/11/10 3:37 PM
 

mnmsoinlove
Mommy to 2 sweet girls!

Member since 3/09

8585 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Stockings help - opinions please!

I ordered our stocking last year form PB and I love them. I'm a PB nut too so that may be why I favor them.

Posted 11/11/10 3:41 PM
 

DBJ808
LIF Adult

Member since 6/09

1039 total posts

Name:
Dana

Re: Stockings help - opinions please!

I like the first ones better. I went with other because I bought the classic velvet ones from Pottery Barn last year and they look beautiful and I love them. Just as another suggestion... it is the velvet style and you can do any variation or red, green, ivory. Check them out... we did the larger ones. DH and I have red with green cuff and DS has green with red cuff. We also got the personalized matching tree skirt!

Posted 11/11/10 3:57 PM
 

CathyB

Member since 5/05

19403 total posts

Name:

Re: Stockings help - opinions please!

Lands End has a red cable knit stocking

JCPenney red & white snowflake ones

Posted 11/11/10 4:02 PM
 

eddiesmommy
best buds!

Member since 5/09

11524 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Stockings help - opinions please!

We have those knit ones from personal creations and i LOVE LOVE LOVE them. The quality is great, the monogrammed is neat and well done and they are HUGE! Weve had them for several years with no issues. If you google it, I believe there is a 20% off at PC coupon out there too.

Message edited 2010-11-11 16:04:38.707000.

Posted 11/11/10 4:04 PM
 

LoveyQ
Stalkers, get a life.

Member since 11/07

12820 total posts

Name:

Re: Stockings help - opinions please!




Ooh that snowflake one is cute! I would have to take it somewhere to get the names embroidered though

Image Attachment(s):
Posted 11/11/10 4:14 PM
 

LoveyQ
Stalkers, get a life.

Member since 11/07

12820 total posts

Name:

Re: Stockings help - opinions please!

Posted by eddiesmommy

We have those knit ones from personal creations and i LOVE LOVE LOVE them. The quality is great, the monogrammed is neat and well done and they are HUGE! Weve had them for several years with no issues. If you google it, I believe there is a 20% off at PC coupon out there too.



Ooh, that's great to know, thanks! By any chance do you have pics of them at your home? Do they look just like the pics? I'm hesitant to jump the gun. I found a 25% off coupon earlier this week for them, hopefully it's not expired now - I wanted to order a few other things from them anyway.

Posted 11/11/10 4:15 PM
 

1stimemom
Love my boys

Member since 2/08

8766 total posts

Name:
Mrs Dee

Re: Stockings help - opinions please!

Go with # 2. Just as nice for 1/2 the price... sold!

Posted 11/11/10 4:18 PM
 

Bella311
Me and my Boys

Member since 1/10

1400 total posts

Name:

Re: Stockings help - opinions please!

I like the solid PB ones, imo I don't like the others too busy/country I think I'd get tired of them sorry.

Posted 11/11/10 4:40 PM
 

eddiesmommy
best buds!

Member since 5/09

11524 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Stockings help - opinions please!

Posted by LoveyQ

Posted by eddiesmommy

We have those knit ones from personal creations and i LOVE LOVE LOVE them. The quality is great, the monogrammed is neat and well done and they are HUGE! Weve had them for several years with no issues. If you google it, I believe there is a 20% off at PC coupon out there too.



Ooh, that's great to know, thanks! By any chance do you have pics of them at your home? Do they look just like the pics? I'm hesitant to jump the gun. I found a 25% off coupon earlier this week for them, hopefully it's not expired now - I wanted to order a few other things from them anyway.



I dont, but I promise they look as good as they do in the picture if not better.

Posted 11/11/10 6:34 PM
 

Bops
My 3 wishes

Member since 12/07

13625 total posts

Name:

Re: Stockings help - opinions please!

I actually think the 2nd ones have a little more "character" than the PB ones...

My only hesitation would be if I wasn't sure if my family was complete, and then needing to match them in the future ( I know PB seems to always carry the same stockings, not sure if Personal Creations does Chat Icon )

Posted 11/11/10 6:44 PM
 

OrganicMama
So in love with my little man!

Member since 6/08

5172 total posts

Name:
Mama

Re: Stockings help - opinions please!

I love the PB stockings!

Posted 11/11/10 9:19 PM
 

mommyIam

Member since 7/09

9209 total posts

Name:
Shana

Re: Stockings help - opinions please!

Posted by OrganicMama

I love the PB stockings!



me too, and I'm jewish Chat Icon
I would go with the shorter ones, I think they are really cute actually, just speaking aesthetics

Posted 11/11/10 9:23 PM
 

annienyc
LIF Adult

Member since 10/06

1347 total posts

Name:

Re: Stockings help - opinions please!

We have the PB red/white velvet stockings and i must say they are HUGE - so I see nothing wrong with getting the smaller knit red ones if you prefer the PB ones...

The Personal Creations ones are great as well but I agree with the other posters that PB always has the same stockings so if you ever need to add to your collection it is no problem (we are buying one for dd this year)...

Sorry I am really not too much help Chat Icon

Posted 11/11/10 9:32 PM
 

dawnygirl25
Growing up soo fast..

Member since 1/06

14917 total posts

Name:
Dawn

Re: Stockings help - opinions please!

I like the snow flake ones a lot.

Posted 11/11/10 9:36 PM
 

piggy007
Mommy of 2!!

Member since 11/08

1742 total posts

Name:

Re: Stockings help - opinions please!

I ordered the Velvet stockings w/ white trim from Pottery Barn and got our names engraved. I got this particular one because I read this is their classic style and they always have it. Figured it would be good when we have more children, I wouldn't have to worry about our stockings not matching!

Posted 11/12/10 9:00 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
JUST NEED TO VENT AND OPINIONS iffer042373 6/7/05 2 Parenting
What do you guys think Re: my cycle length...need opinions MrsJ 5/25/05 20 TTC
Pali Cribs.....any opinions???? Dani00518 5/21/05 1 Pregnancy
Opinions (advice needed) PLEASE..job related dm24angel 5/17/05 32 Families Helping Families ™
Repost from pregnancy - Nursery opinions please :) MrsR 5/16/05 2 Home
I think I have my color cheme for kitchen, opinions btrflygrl 5/15/05 1 Home