Can you hold a child too much?

Forum Opinion Poll
Yes, let her cry it out if you know that she is only crying to be held. 4 4.82%
Yes, start to hold her less each time she is awake 13 15.66%
No, she is an infant and she needs her mother 61 73.49%
Either way she will grow out of it, don't change anything 5 6.02%
 

Vote in this poll

View poll

Can you hold your child too much?

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 [2] 3

CrankyPants
I'm cranky

Member since 7/06

18178 total posts

Name:
Mama Cranky

Re: Can you hold your child too much?

Posted by Hofstra26

Posted by CrankyPants

Posted by MarisaK

Posted by CrankyPants

Posted by MarisaK

Posted by MrsProfessor

Posted by MarisaK

I think the attitude of holding them vs. NOT holding them is more of a comforting/nurturing thing rather than a scientific thing - Some people feel that it's cruel to leave them 'alone' since they've been so close to you (inside you) for so long .......




I read in at least one parenting book (that was written by a pediatrician) that habits aren't formed for the first six months.



I'm not saying you're wrong - I've read the same thing a few times - I just don't buy it. I don't care what the author's credentials are - IMO it's not something that's cut and dry -
Like X antibiotic cures Y - KWIM?
How do you prove that theory ??
My son had 'habits' WELL before he turned 6 months old -



I get what you are saying-that's interesting. I guess then I would say even if you can spoil a newborn, I think it's okay because they need it in the early stages.



Chat Icon Which is why I think it's completely a matter of parenting style and comfort level .......*I* didn't feel that my son NEEDED to be with me constantly or need to be held constantly. A lot of people disagreed with me -

I always held him, talked to him, comforted him when he WAS fussing or upset - but I made a vey conscious effort to 'leave him alone' for periods of time when he was content to just chill and look around .......and I forced other people do it as well. (Needless to say, I got a lot of Chat Icon but that is what *I* felt was important for him)



I agree-it's all about your comfort level.

I also don't think there is anything wrong with letting sleeping babies lie-i.e. if he's content to just hang out then let him be.

I found myself wanting to pick up DD even when she was content just because I needed it-she was fine doing her own thing. I made an effort to let her be so she could get comfortable in her own skin-as long as she wasn't crying/fussing.



I think there is a difference if they are content or upset and fussing so I do agree with you on that point. My DD was able to chill by herself and play but to fall asleep and when she was fussy all she ever wanted was to be held and I think that's normal. I didn't hold her just to hold her, I left her alone if she was content and now at 13 months she's independent and plays on her own and has been for months. But again, I did hold her a lot and it's what she needed at that time in her life. Chat Icon




I agree completely-I think we are all caught up and on the same page nowChat Icon

Posted 10/28/09 2:56 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

MarisaK
HELLO Manolo !!

Member since 5/06

14562 total posts

Name:
Marisa

Re: Can you hold your child too much?

Posted by CrankyPants


I agree, but if you read some of her subsequent posts I think we are misunderstanding the poster.

She's not saying to let a fussing baby CIO nor is she saying that we shouldn't have lots of cuddle time with our DC.

She is saying when they are not fussing, we should make an effort to put the baby down and let them just be so that we don't develop a need to be held all the time.

Very different IMO and not off the mark.



Thanks - Maybe I wasn't expressing myself correctly -

Posted 10/28/09 2:56 PM
 

lipglossjunky73
My Everything!

Member since 11/05

35670 total posts

Name:
<3

Re: Can you hold your child too much?

I held my son for the entire maternity leave, and every night when I picked him up after daycare. He still loves sitting on my lap and cuddling with me at 2.5 years old. It doesn't spoil them - and if you have to put them down for a while and they cry when you shower or do errands, so what? Pick them up when you are done. It is the best way to spoil a child, I have learned!!! Chat Icon

Posted 10/28/09 2:59 PM
 

CrankyPants
I'm cranky

Member since 7/06

18178 total posts

Name:
Mama Cranky

Re: Can you hold your child too much?

Posted by MarisaK

Posted by CrankyPants


I agree, but if you read some of her subsequent posts I think we are misunderstanding the poster.

She's not saying to let a fussing baby CIO nor is she saying that we shouldn't have lots of cuddle time with our DC.

She is saying when they are not fussing, we should make an effort to put the baby down and let them just be so that we don't develop a need to be held all the time.

Very different IMO and not off the mark.



Thanks - Maybe I wasn't expressing myself correctly -



No-I think you are fine. I think everyone (myself, at least) just jumps to CIO and imagines letting a screaming 4 weeks old fuss until she passes out and doesn't even think about the other times that a baby can be content in their swing/bouncer/on a blanket, etc without being held.

Posted 10/28/09 3:00 PM
 

nov04libride
big brother <3

Member since 5/05

14672 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Can you hold your child too much?

Posted by CrankyPants

Posted by MarisaK

Posted by CrankyPants


I agree, but if you read some of her subsequent posts I think we are misunderstanding the poster.

She's not saying to let a fussing baby CIO nor is she saying that we shouldn't have lots of cuddle time with our DC.

She is saying when they are not fussing, we should make an effort to put the baby down and let them just be so that we don't develop a need to be held all the time.

Very different IMO and not off the mark.



Thanks - Maybe I wasn't expressing myself correctly -



No-I think you are fine. I think everyone (myself, at least) just jumps to CIO and imagines letting a screaming 4 weeks old fuss until she passes out and doesn't even think about the other times that a baby can be content in their swing/bouncer/on a blanket, etc without being held.


one of the poll options was to let the newborn cry, so that's why i addressed cio in newborns

Posted 10/28/09 3:06 PM
 

dpli
Daylight savings :)

Member since 5/05

13973 total posts

Name:
D

Re: Can you hold your child too much?

I think you can't hold them too much when they are awake. However, I think holding her all the time while she is sleeping can start a habit that will be really hard to break later on.

I also may not know what I am talking about. My DS was so heavy I couldn't hold him all the time. Chat Icon

Isn't everything a little different with preemies, though? In the beginning, if the baby is 8 weeks old, but was 5 weeks premature, shouldn't you treat her like a 3 week old that went full term? If that's the case, then I would probably be holding her all the time too. Chat Icon Chat Icon

Message edited 2009-10-28 15:19:55.810000.

Posted 10/28/09 3:19 PM
 

Xelindrya
Mommy's little YouTube Star!

Member since 8/05

14470 total posts

Name:
Veronica

Re: Can you hold your child too much?

I remember those days/weeks

She had to have some part of her touching me to sleep. Made going to the bathroom interesting I'll tell you that!Chat Icon

I agree with most here. There's no such thing has holding her too much or spoiling her. Around 3months I started to 'hold' her less but still always there when and if she needed me.

Its not THEM that learn the habit as much as it is US.

By 6months it was a different story. She was in daycare for 3 months already and didnt have to be held as much. Daycare solved the problem for us you could say.

As soon as she could crawl she chose her daddy over mommy. so that goes to prove they can learn their preferences! I held her non stop for months and she picks him over me every chance she gets. Chat Icon

Still when she's crying, cranky, tired or not feeling well its me she comes to and sleeps on or leans on, wants to be fed by or just wants to be rocked back to sleep. Chat Icon


Seriously ENJOY these days.. they are hard and tiring but oh so precious!

Posted 10/28/09 3:53 PM
 

MrsS2005
Mom of 3

Member since 11/05

13118 total posts

Name:
B

Re: Can you hold your child too much?

Posted by Hofstra26

Posted by MarisaK

I think you can ABSOLUTELY spoil a newborn. The baby is learning every single second of the day - I will never understand the idea that you can't get them accustomed to something before X months old .....-

I think the attitude of holding them vs. NOT holding them is more of a comforting/nurturing thing rather than a scientific thing - Some people feel that it's cruel to leave them 'alone' since they've been so close to you (inside you) for so long .......

Call me a cold hearted b*tch - but at SOME point you're going to have to put that baby down, so would you rather do it after you got them 'used to' being held for 6 months ?? Personally I think it's better to do it while EVERYTHING is new to them -

Ultimately it's up to you and what you are comfortable with.

Everyone is going to have a different opinion and tell you what you 'should' or shouldn't do .......



You CANNOT in any way spoil a newborn. They NEED to be held A LOT. That's how they develop trust and security and bonds. To put a baby down because you don't feel like holding them is cruel and selfish IMO..........they don't have the tools to self soothe on their own and they need you to hold them and snuggle them and make them feel secure. I had to hold my DD A LOT in the those early months, more so when she wanted to fall asleep, but it's what she needed. NO bad habits were formed and she wasn't spoiled by my holding her a lot. Within a few months she learned to put herself to sleep and she was fine on her own but as a new baby in this world........she needed a lot of cuddling time like most new babies do. EVERY book, website, and doctor will tell you the same.


IT. DS wanted to be held 24/7 as a newborn. He became much more independent around 3 months old.

At the beginning, all I did was hold him. That was what he needed to feel secure. Believe me, it will get better. Chat Icon

Posted 10/28/09 4:15 PM
 

yankinmanc
Happy Days!

Member since 8/05

18208 total posts

Name:

Re: Can you hold your child too much?

No way, babies need to be held!! Hold that kid!

Posted 10/28/09 4:20 PM
 

SweetTooth
I'm a tired mommy!

Member since 12/05

20105 total posts

Name:
Lauren

Re: Can you hold your child too much?

Why don't you try a sling? That way she can still be close to you, but you can have your hands free sometimes. I used one with DS and it was wonderful for both of us.

Posted 10/28/09 4:23 PM
 

myasmommy
LIF Zygote

Member since 10/09

20 total posts

Name:
Sue

Re: Can you hold your child too much?

Thank you all for your input. I should say that I hold her 90% of the time when she is awake. She has colic and has been constipated on and off for the past 2 weeks. So she is not a happy baby :( If she is awake when I put her in her swing or boppy pillow she will cry almost instantly. If she is sleeping and content I do not pick her up but this is rare that she is content. Once I put her down when she is sleeping, she wakes up with in 1/2 hour. I generally pick her up because I don't want her to cry. My concern is that I an forming a habit and she will not grow out of it.
I guess I just want to make sure that I can not creating a bigger problem for the future.

Posted 10/28/09 4:24 PM
 

myasmommy
LIF Zygote

Member since 10/09

20 total posts

Name:
Sue

Re: Can you hold your child too much?

i have her in the sling right nowChat Icon It is a lifesaver!

Posted 10/28/09 4:25 PM
 

myasmommy
LIF Zygote

Member since 10/09

20 total posts

Name:
Sue

Re: Can you hold your child too much?

MrsS2005 Where did your DC sleep? Did they have a hard time at night when you were not holding them? Right now this is my biggest issue...I can not get any sleep b/c she wants to be held at night, once I put her in the bassinet she wakes up.

Posted 10/28/09 4:29 PM
 

BaroqueMama
Chase is one!

Member since 5/05

27530 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Can you hold your child too much?

As someone who feared spoiling my newborn by holding her too much, I can tell you that I went against my stubborn brain that wanted me to put her down and just held her as long as she needed to be. By four months, she grew out of it and by five months she was crawling and exploring. It proved to me that some infants really do need that extra comfort and I couldn't imagine not giving my child the comfort they need. They have no way to meet their needs on their own. They need you to do that. and not for nothing, even if you COULD spoil a baby that age by holding them too much...SO WHAT? You're their mother, it's your job to make them feel safe and comforted. That's my honest opinion, and I don't judge those who choose to let their small infant cry, but to me, my instinct to say I'm not going to do that was wrong. I needed to get over myself and just hold her for four months straight. I only wish I appreciated it as much then as I can now because she really did need me and I wish I enjoyed it more at the time.

Posted 10/28/09 4:36 PM
 

MrsS2005
Mom of 3

Member since 11/05

13118 total posts

Name:
B

Re: Can you hold your child too much?

Posted by myasmommy

MrsS2005 Where did your DC sleep? Did they have a hard time at night when you were not holding them? Right now this is my biggest issue...I can not get any sleep b/c she wants to be held at night, once I put her in the bassinet she wakes up.


DS slept in my arms. He wouldn't sleep anywhere else. As soon as I put him down, he'd wake up and scream. Holding him was the only way we both got sleep. I never thought I'd co-sleep, but it was the only thing that worked for us. It was easier to have him in the bed at the beginning since he woke frequently to BF. We tried to transition DS to the crib several times, but it was a disaster. Once I went back to work, DH started holding DS at night. He usually transferred DS to the swing for a few hours so we could both get some uninterrupted sleep. By 6 months, DS was able to sleep next to us, but still wouldn't sleep in the crib. We finally transitioned him to the crib at 10 months.

Posted 10/28/09 4:39 PM
 

MrsList
Sweet cheeks

Member since 4/09

1696 total posts

Name:

Re: Can you hold your child too much?

Have you tried swaddling her?

If you have and that still doesn't work, then how about the vacuum cleaner noise? I heard that this DVD called Happiest Baby on the Block is excellent for ideas on how to sooth your newborn and mimic conditions in the womb so they feel more comfortable. I've also heard that letting a newborn cry isn't a good idea because they cry when their basic needs aren't being met (hungry, wet, scared, etc.). Can you try leaving her in the bassinet but putting your hand on her so at least she feels you near?

Posted 10/28/09 4:40 PM
 

kerrycec03
Mom of 2 beautiful boys!!

Member since 6/06

13519 total posts

Name:
Kerry

Re: Can you hold your child too much?

Posted by jellybean1420

It's tough...they say you can't spoil your newborn but at the same time, I think you can start a habit.




I agree with this 100%

Posted 10/28/09 4:42 PM
 

myasmommy
LIF Zygote

Member since 10/09

20 total posts

Name:
Sue

Re: Can you hold your child too much?

Posted by MrsList

Have you tried swaddling her?

If you have and that still doesn't work, then how about the vacuum cleaner noise? I heard that this DVD called Happiest Baby on the Block is excellent for ideas on how to sooth your newborn and mimic conditions in the womb so they feel more comfortable. I've also heard that letting a newborn cry isn't a good idea because they cry when their basic needs aren't being met (hungry, wet, scared, etc.). Can you try leaving her in the bassinet but putting your hand on her so at least she feels you near?



I have tried just about everything.Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon
She does not like to be swaddled. I have used white noise like the vacuum and static. Both work but once I turn it off she wakes up. I do not let her cry, I pick her up as soon as possible when she is crying but I am afraid that I am going to form a habit that I will not be able to break later on.
After she falls asleep in my arms, I move her to the swing or bassinet. When she wakes up, I talk to her or place my hand on her but nothing consoles her so I pick her up and hold her until she falls asleep again. It is a vicious cycle. She wakes every 1/2 hour when she is not in my arms. I can handle it during the day but at night I sometimes cry with her because I am so tired. I am still on maternity leave so I do not ask my husband to get up in the middle of the night. On the weekends I can sleep since he is home to watch her, but by Thursday I am at my wits end.Chat Icon

Posted 10/28/09 9:01 PM
 

cjik
Welcome 2010!

Member since 2/06

8879 total posts

Name:

Re: Can you hold your child too much?

If you are comfortable with it, I would say try cosleeping, that way she is in your arms, and you can get some sleep too.

I also think I read if your baby is born early, they are however many weeks behind in development, so if she is 8 weeks old, she probably has the behaviors of a 3 week old.

During the day, I would recommend a sling or a carrier--that way she can be close, and you can move around and do other things.

But don't worry about spoiling her.

Posted 10/28/09 9:10 PM
 

myasmommy
LIF Zygote

Member since 10/09

20 total posts

Name:
Sue

Re: Can you hold your child too much?

Posted by cjik

If you are comfortable with it, I would say try cosleeping, that way she is in your arms, and you can get some sleep too.

I also think I read if your baby is born early, they are however many weeks behind in development, so if she is 8 weeks old, she probably has the behaviors of a 3 week old.

During the day, I would recommend a sling or a carrier--that way she can be close, and you can move around and do other things.

But don't worry about spoiling her.



At this point I am willing to try anything to get her to sleep longer. I purchased the nap nanny and that has not worked at all. I do use a sling during the day and it works wonders.

Thanks for the advice Chat Icon I will look into a cosleeper.

Posted 10/28/09 9:35 PM
 

Stacey1403
Where it all began....

Member since 5/05

24065 total posts

Name:

Re: Can you hold your child too much?

The truth of the matter is that some babies just need to be held a lot more than others. My DS wanted me to hold him all the time he slept on me even at night. It was the only way to get to sleep and for me to be able to sleep. My DD was a little bit better but ended up co-sleeping with us. (Yes at one point all four of us were in one bed Chat Icon ) Is for everyone, no way. Did it work for us, it sure did. You have to do what you are comfortable with and what your baby needs from you. It sounds you have a baby that needs to be held a lot. If this is what you are comfortable with then I say keep up the good work. Before you know it she will be reaching lots of milestones and will become more independent from you. This stage of life goes by so very quickly so I say hold your little one every chance you get and enjoy every minute of itChat Icon

Posted 10/28/09 9:49 PM
 

bonitachyc
big sister status may 2012!!

Member since 5/08

3242 total posts

Name:
Lupe

Re: Can you hold your child too much?

not at that age. hold her and just suck it up...pretty soon she won't need you there 100% of the time...think about it...all she knew for 9 months was the comfort of your womb and nothing else. newborns need all the love and affection you can provide. you're already not holding her 24/7 (although it might seem like you are!) so she's missing out on some contact. hold her as much as needed. she'll grow out of it. believe me!

Posted 10/28/09 10:16 PM
 

MrsS2005
Mom of 3

Member since 11/05

13118 total posts

Name:
B

Re: Can you hold your child too much?

Posted by myasmommy

Posted by cjik

If you are comfortable with it, I would say try cosleeping, that way she is in your arms, and you can get some sleep too.

I also think I read if your baby is born early, they are however many weeks behind in development, so if she is 8 weeks old, she probably has the behaviors of a 3 week old.

During the day, I would recommend a sling or a carrier--that way she can be close, and you can move around and do other things.

But don't worry about spoiling her.



At this point I am willing to try anything to get her to sleep longer. I purchased the nap nanny and that has not worked at all. I do use a sling during the day and it works wonders.

Thanks for the advice Chat Icon I will look into a cosleeper.


At the very beginning, DH and I took turns sleeping on the couch with DS in our arms. Eventually, we moved to the bed. I was on the outside and DS was in the middle. I propped my arm on the boppy and he slept in the crook of my arm. I was very aware of him and didn't move my arm at all in my sleep. This worked for us, but may not work for others.

If you really want to get DC into the crib or bassinet, have you tried warming the sheets with a hot water bottle? You can also put a shirt that you've worn in there so DC thinks you're right there.

Posted 10/29/09 10:29 AM
 

Janice
Sweet Jessie Quinn

Member since 5/05

27567 total posts

Name:
Janice

Re: Can you hold your child too much?

some babies just really need to be held.

mine was one. we joke...5000 pics taken in first year, none were in swing, bouncer, carseat, crib. just me holding him.

he was a screamer unless held. at 2 weeks old he would pull out his own hair in the crib while i showered.

8 months holding him. every second, every nap. never slept through the night, never came close.

he is a very secure 2.5 year old. independent, doesn't look for me while we are out. but right now as i type he is watching seasame street laying on me. he is a fan of human touch and contact. nothing makes him happier. its his nature.

there was no putting him down. he was very needy. i see kids at the grocery store in their infant seats content and looking around. never this kid. he screamed unless i held him.

no 2 babies are alike.

Posted 10/29/09 10:36 AM
 

HeathKernandez
Our Ron is an awesome Ron

Member since 4/07

9091 total posts

Name:
baby fish mouth

Re: Can you hold your child too much?

when they're only a few months old I think NO...

BUT, my SIL held my nephew all the time after and he was very very clingy for a while. So I don't know at what age you stop...

my son is nine and I still hold his hand, cuddle him etc etc. Chat Icon

Posted 10/29/09 10:37 AM
 
Pages: 1 [2] 3
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Spinoff to my other post: Did anyone hold their child back? bicosi 1/9/08 4 Parenting
Link to Article from Child Magazine: 10 Best US Fertility Centers CathyB 7/9/05 0 TTC
Would you let your child... KaRiSsA 6/27/05 25 Families Helping Families ™
Cost of child care Woodsy 6/21/05 5 Parenting
Traveling with a small child justme1 5/23/05 3 Travel & Vacations
was your first child (pregnancy) (w/ POLL) neenie 5/19/05 30 Families Helping Families ™