Re: Can you hold your child too much?
Posted 10/28/2009 2:56:02 PM by CrankyPants


Posted by Hofstra26


Posted by CrankyPants


Posted by MarisaK


Posted by CrankyPants


Posted by MarisaK


Posted by MrsProfessor


Posted by MarisaK

I think the attitude of holding them vs. NOT holding them is more of a comforting/nurturing thing rather than a scientific thing - Some people feel that it's cruel to leave them 'alone' since they've been so close to you (inside you) for so long .......




I read in at least one parenting book (that was written by a pediatrician) that habits aren't formed for the first six months.



I'm not saying you're wrong - I've read the same thing a few times - I just don't buy it. I don't care what the author's credentials are - IMO it's not something that's cut and dry -
Like X antibiotic cures Y - KWIM?
How do you prove that theory ??
My son had 'habits' WELL before he turned 6 months old -



I get what you are saying-that's interesting. I guess then I would say even if you can spoil a newborn, I think it's okay because they need it in the early stages.



Chat Icon Which is why I think it's completely a matter of parenting style and comfort level .......*I* didn't feel that my son NEEDED to be with me constantly or need to be held constantly. A lot of people disagreed with me -

I always held him, talked to him, comforted him when he WAS fussing or upset - but I made a vey conscious effort to 'leave him alone' for periods of time when he was content to just chill and look around .......and I forced other people do it as well. (Needless to say, I got a lot of Chat Icon but that is what *I* felt was important for him)



I agree-it's all about your comfort level.

I also don't think there is anything wrong with letting sleeping babies lie-i.e. if he's content to just hang out then let him be.

I found myself wanting to pick up DD even when she was content just because I needed it-she was fine doing her own thing. I made an effort to let her be so she could get comfortable in her own skin-as long as she wasn't crying/fussing.



I think there is a difference if they are content or upset and fussing so I do agree with you on that point. My DD was able to chill by herself and play but to fall asleep and when she was fussy all she ever wanted was to be held and I think that's normal. I didn't hold her just to hold her, I left her alone if she was content and now at 13 months she's independent and plays on her own and has been for months. But again, I did hold her a lot and it's what she needed at that time in her life. Chat Icon




I agree completely-I think we are all caught up and on the same page nowChat Icon
Print Post      Close Window