Spanking
| Forum Opinion Poll | ||||||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
Spanking- poll and discussion
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: [1] 2 3 | |
|
Spanking- poll and discussion I just was talking with a family member and spanking came up. I was quite shocked how the conversation went. My questions are: |
|
Posted 6/6/09 4:37 AM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: Spanking- poll and discussion I've never done it, and don't plan to. |
|
Posted 6/6/09 6:46 AM
|
|
|
Re: Spanking- poll and discussion I never imagined every spanking kids when I had them. |
|
Posted 6/6/09 7:13 AM
|
|
|
Re: Spanking- poll and discussion Posted by karacg I've never done it, and don't plan to. But I've also learned to never say never. This is exactly how I feel. My DD is only 4 mo. so I think never say never. However, it's not something that I plan on or am completely OK with...for myself. |
|
Posted 6/6/09 7:55 AM
|
|
|
Re: Spanking- poll and discussion I do not plan on using spanking as a form of discipline however, I feel there are times with an "immature" toddler, that you are left with few options at getting your point across. |
|
Posted 6/6/09 7:56 AM
|
|
|
Re: Spanking- poll and discussion Posted by karacg I've never done it, and don't plan to. But I've also learned to never say never. couldn't have said it better. |
|
Posted 6/6/09 7:59 AM
|
|
|
Re: Spanking- poll and discussion I was spanked as a child and i"m not sure it was all that effective - I remember spedifically being spanked for not cleaning my room - well my room remained a mess my entire childhood and I still have issues picking up after myself -just ask DH |
|
Posted 6/6/09 8:02 AM
|
|
|
Re: Spanking- poll and discussion I was put over the knee and spanked for everything when I was little - and I was still bad |
|
Posted 6/6/09 8:05 AM
|
|
|
Re: Spanking- poll and discussion We've done a "smack on the tush" twice |
|
Posted 6/6/09 8:05 AM
|
|
|
Re: Spanking- poll and discussion As everyone else said, I don't "plan" on it but realistically I am sure there will be times where a smack on the tush or hands is going to happen. |
|
Posted 6/6/09 8:09 AM
|
|
|
Re: Spanking- poll and discussion I have smacked his hand away a few times, and it was for things like going for the curling iron, touching an electric socket type of thing and if I had grabbed it I probably would have hurt him worse. I do NOT BELIEVE in causing any kidn of pain. It was more to get a reaction, stop the action QUICK. I think I smacked his butt through the pants like 2x's. First I felt silly doing it...and he didnt even feel it with that diaper on and I can remember saying to myself, what good would this serve? He doesnt understand what I'm doing. |
|
Posted 6/6/09 8:12 AM
|
|
|
Re: Spanking- poll and discussion Depends how you define "spanking." If my DC are doing something that I find "dangerous" to them I will definitely grab their hand and smack it to give them a good scare and know I mean business. Thankfully that is rare! |
|
Posted 6/6/09 8:16 AM
|
|
|
Re: Spanking- poll and discussion OK I don't "plan" on doing it but I won't say never because you never know! |
|
Posted 6/6/09 8:17 AM
|
|
|
Re: Spanking- poll and discussion I've never done it and never will - I can only speak from my own experience and my own child, but at least for my child, I think there are other, more effective, less physical ways to discipline her. |
|
Posted 6/6/09 8:22 AM
|
|
|
Re: Spanking- poll and discussion These are very interesting questions. I have to say, like some other moms, I can't see myself spanking my child at this moment... but one never knows. I KNOW I will never spank my child the way a good friend was spanked. I have such vivid memories of her mom, when upset with her or one of her 3 siblings, taking her over her knee, pulling down her pants and smacking away. It made me so scared and confused as a child... heck it still confuses me. |
|
Posted 6/6/09 8:24 AM
|
|
|
Re: Spanking- poll and discussion Posted by Bxgell2 I've never done it and never will - I can only speak from my own experience and my own child, but at least for my child, I think there are other, more effective, less physical ways to discipline her. I just think it gives the wrong, conflicting message to a child to tell them that they can't hit, but then to turn around as the parent and spank them on the tuchus. I agree. I was spanked (and hit) a lot when I was younger...the only thing it did for me was make me resent my mother. |
|
Posted 6/6/09 8:25 AM
|
|
|
Re: Spanking- poll and discussion Posted by Bxgell2 I just think it gives the wrong, conflicting message to a child to tell them that they can't hit, but then to turn around as the parent and spank them on the tuchus. this is what I'm thinking, too. |
|
Posted 6/6/09 8:25 AM
|
|
|
Re: Spanking- poll and discussion I have yet to be that angry at DD. I never want to and don't plan to. But I am also one of those "never say never" people. |
|
Posted 6/6/09 8:27 AM
|
|
|
Re: Spanking- poll and discussion Posted by EmmaNick Posted by Bxgell2 I've never done it and never will - I can only speak from my own experience and my own child, but at least for my child, I think there are other, more effective, less physical ways to discipline her. I just think it gives the wrong, conflicting message to a child to tell them that they can't hit, but then to turn around as the parent and spank them on the tuchus. I agree. I was spanked (and hit) a lot when I was younger...the only thing it did for me was make me resent my mother. ITA Except it was my Dad. I got spanked on the back of my legs/butt with a metal spoon (the big serving kind). IMHO all spanking (hitting) proves is that it is okay to hit if your are bigger and stronger. I am talking about full on spanking not a light tap on the tush or hand. |
|
Posted 6/6/09 8:34 AM
|
|
|
Re: Spanking- poll and discussion Posted by Bxgell2 I've never done it and never will - I just think it gives the wrong, conflicting message to a child to tell them that they can't hit, but then to turn around as the parent and spank them on the tuchus. I agree with Beth wrote. However, as Kara also said, I have learned that as parent to never say never. ETA: before we had the children, we would give the dogs a smack on the tush if they stole food and we saw them doing it. (Never to hurt them though). I will never do that now, as i will never let my children see that- how could I teach them to never hit if they saw us do it? Message edited 2009-06-06 08:42:56.357000. |
|
Posted 6/6/09 8:41 AM
|
|
|
Re: Spanking- poll and discussion I was spanked as a child for serious offenses. I have an incredibly close relationship with both parents, am successful in my life (emotionally and professionally), and I think I'm a great mom. |
|
Posted 6/6/09 8:44 AM
|
|
|
Re: Spanking- poll and discussion when it counts-and i mean she is doing something dangerous or really bad then i will. like she tried to jump into my parents open pool.... scary. it's not often but she has gotten a swift spank on the behind. Message edited 2009-06-06 08:51:38.873000. |
|
Posted 6/6/09 8:48 AM
|
|
|
Re: Spanking- poll and discussion Posted by Porrruss I was spanked as a child for serious offenses. I have an incredibly close relationship with both parents, am successful in my life (emotionally and professionally), and I think I'm a great mom. Was it because I was spanked? Who knows- I never thought about it. I will say this though- I HAVE spanked my DD. I hated it each time because purposely making her cry rips me apart each time. It's because of the way it makes ME feel is why we tend more towards "time-outs" around here. But for really serious infractions where I need to get her immediate attention and show her I mean business, she gets popped on the tush or on the back of the hand. Serious infractions= annoying the dog while she's eating, running in the street, etc. Regardless of whether I spank or not- my kids will still blame me for effing them up anyway...... see i should have just quoted you that was what i was trying to say. i left out the part where yes, it has ripped me apart to make her cry on the rare occasion. but my like my dad would say- better she cries now than you cry later (when something bad happens).
|
|
Posted 6/6/09 8:50 AM
|
|
|
Re: Spanking- poll and discussion I have spanked mikayla once for running away from me in the parking lot. That is it, I do not use spanking as a form of punishment on a regular basis. |
|
Posted 6/6/09 9:10 AM
|
|
|
Re: Spanking- poll and discussion Posted by Bxgell2 I just think it gives the wrong, conflicting message to a child to tell them that they can't hit, but then to turn around as the parent and spank them on the tuchus. I agree completely with this, I would never spank her for hiting. |
|
Posted 6/6/09 9:11 AM
|
|
| Pages: [1] 2 3 | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| My issues with the DVR world we live in... - After discussion, now includes AI Spoiler! | jerseypanda | 4/2/09 | 29 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Interesting discussion at work today: Do you think it is easier to marry someone of a different faith or a different race? | BigB | 12/8/08 | 11 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| A drama free discussion on Mommy vs. Daddy issues | lipglossjunky73 | 9/18/08 | 11 | Parenting |
| Can we start a nineteen minutes discussion? I have some questions | jxnoscar | 9/2/08 | 6 | StoryBoard |
| Jealousy...figuring it all out...a discussion, a long one. It doesn't make much sense, but try to follow. | yankinmanc | 8/12/07 | 12 | Parenting |
| My current "discussion" with DH: If your in laws were to stay over your house for the weekend... | jxnoscar | 6/25/07 | 90 | Families Helping Families ™ |























