Spanking

Forum Opinion Poll
I do it 23 18.40%
No way 51 40.80%
I rarely do it 44 35.20%
Other- what do you think? 7 5.60%
 

Vote in this poll

View poll

Spanking- poll and discussion

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2 3

waterspout4
My loves

Member since 5/06

19150 total posts

Name:
Kelly

Spanking- poll and discussion

I just was talking with a family member and spanking came up. I was quite shocked how the conversation went. My questions are:

How do you feel about spanking? Do you do quick, light 'spanks'? Is there a difference between light spanks and spanks? What about public spanking? Is there such a thing as 'rare' spanking? Just want to know what you all have to say.

Posted 6/6/09 4:37 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

karacg
Babygirl is 4!

Member since 5/05

17076 total posts

Name:
Kara®

Re: Spanking- poll and discussion

I've never done it, and don't plan to.

But I've also learned to never say never.

Posted 6/6/09 6:46 AM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Spanking- poll and discussion

I never imagined every spanking kids when I had them.

Yes I have spanked them. I'm sure some will say there are better ways to discipline a child, maybe there are but when they were 2-3, it was what worked for us. It was a rare occasion and after all else failed (timeouts, warnings, etc) and usually for something like hitting the baby & running in the parking lot.

Now that they're older, they understand consquences & we can ground them.

Posted 6/6/09 7:13 AM
 

jaysee00
LIF Adult

Member since 3/06

1647 total posts

Name:

Re: Spanking- poll and discussion

Posted by karacg

I've never done it, and don't plan to.

But I've also learned to never say never.



This is exactly how I feel. My DD is only 4 mo. so I think never say never. However, it's not something that I plan on or am completely OK with...for myself.

Posted 6/6/09 7:55 AM
 

mikeswife06
Drama Momma

Member since 9/06

9947 total posts

Name:
Anne

Re: Spanking- poll and discussion

I do not plan on using spanking as a form of discipline however, I feel there are times with an "immature" toddler, that you are left with few options at getting your point across.

Hopefully I won't ever have to, but if I feel it's necessary I will let DH. I don't think I could do it myself. Chat Icon

Posted 6/6/09 7:56 AM
 

alexlynn7
Big brother to be!

Member since 9/06

6314 total posts

Name:

Re: Spanking- poll and discussion

Posted by karacg

I've never done it, and don't plan to.

But I've also learned to never say never.



couldn't have said it better.

Posted 6/6/09 7:59 AM
 

JChia
Mom of 2 Princesses

Member since 9/07

2540 total posts

Name:
Jen

Re: Spanking- poll and discussion

I was spanked as a child and i"m not sure it was all that effective - I remember spedifically being spanked for not cleaning my room - well my room remained a mess my entire childhood and I still have issues picking up after myself -just ask DH Chat Icon

I have no plans to spank DD,but I do have to read up on discipline since we are entering the terrible twos!

I will say that I will absolutely NEVER spank a child in public. I feel very strongly about this.

Posted 6/6/09 8:02 AM
 

lipglossjunky73
My Everything!

Member since 11/05

35670 total posts

Name:
<3

Re: Spanking- poll and discussion

I was put over the knee and spanked for everything when I was little - and I was still bad Chat Icon

I will not spank. I have given "angry mommy" taps on the hand or hiney, but there was no oomph in it - it was all in my face that delivered the message - and the taps were for situations where he could get himself very hurt (running out into the parking lot, for example)

Posted 6/6/09 8:05 AM
 

KateDevine
*

Member since 6/06

24950 total posts

Name:

Re: Spanking- poll and discussion

We've done a "smack on the tush" twice

It's only been done when he has been totally out of control and not realizing that he was hurting someone (ok me) and he now knows that isn't something he is supposed to do.

I will say (b/c I was the one who did it and that shocked the crap out of me b/c my DH is usually the disaplinarian) that I don't even know if he felt anything b/c I did it gently and he has a diaper on, but the action definately got the point across.

Posted 6/6/09 8:05 AM
 

Hofstra26
Love to Bake!

Member since 7/06

27915 total posts

Name:

Re: Spanking- poll and discussion

As everyone else said, I don't "plan" on it but realistically I am sure there will be times where a smack on the tush or hands is going to happen.

Posted 6/6/09 8:09 AM
 

dm24angel
Happiness

Member since 5/05

34581 total posts

Name:
Donna

Re: Spanking- poll and discussion

I have smacked his hand away a few times, and it was for things like going for the curling iron, touching an electric socket type of thing and if I had grabbed it I probably would have hurt him worse. I do NOT BELIEVE in causing any kidn of pain. It was more to get a reaction, stop the action QUICK. I think I smacked his butt through the pants like 2x's. First I felt silly doing it...and he didnt even feel it with that diaper on and I can remember saying to myself, what good would this serve? He doesnt understand what I'm doing.

I read a GREAT book recently called "Taking Back Childhood". It is mostly about raising children in this media filled world but it has a great section on discipline and how to get children to understand and be accountable for their actions and feel sorry for things vs. " punishing" them for the actions they may not understand....we are using the techniques and they are working WONDERS....so Thats the route we will go.

So I wont be spanking no.

Posted 6/6/09 8:12 AM
 

Charly
LOVE!

Member since 5/05

12578 total posts

Name:

Re: Spanking- poll and discussion

Depends how you define "spanking." If my DC are doing something that I find "dangerous" to them I will definitely grab their hand and smack it to give them a good scare and know I mean business. Thankfully that is rare!

I've never spanked their bottom (yet). I haven't had a need to and I don't know if I will. It doesn't feel natural to me, but who knows.

Posted 6/6/09 8:16 AM
 

babyonthebrain
Brotherly Love!

Member since 1/08

6209 total posts

Name:
Rafaela

Re: Spanking- poll and discussion

OK I don't "plan" on doing it but I won't say never because you never know!

Posted 6/6/09 8:17 AM
 

Bxgell2
Perfection

Member since 5/05

16438 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: Spanking- poll and discussion

I've never done it and never will - I can only speak from my own experience and my own child, but at least for my child, I think there are other, more effective, less physical ways to discipline her.

I just think it gives the wrong, conflicting message to a child to tell them that they can't hit, but then to turn around as the parent and spank them on the tuchus.

Posted 6/6/09 8:22 AM
 

july0105
My three little miracles

Member since 4/06

2628 total posts

Name:
Alison

Re: Spanking- poll and discussion

These are very interesting questions. I have to say, like some other moms, I can't see myself spanking my child at this moment... but one never knows. I KNOW I will never spank my child the way a good friend was spanked. I have such vivid memories of her mom, when upset with her or one of her 3 siblings, taking her over her knee, pulling down her pants and smacking away. It made me so scared and confused as a child... heck it still confuses me.

So I guess, what I mean is that I am now realizing that there may be different types of spanking. Gently slapping a child's hand away from a hot stove seems really different to me than what my friend experienced. I am not sure, though, if there really is any difference.

I'm confused with myself! I'll be curious to see what other moms feel about this issue.

Great questions!

Posted 6/6/09 8:24 AM
 

EmmaNick
*

Member since 12/06

16001 total posts

Name:
*

Re: Spanking- poll and discussion

Posted by Bxgell2

I've never done it and never will - I can only speak from my own experience and my own child, but at least for my child, I think there are other, more effective, less physical ways to discipline her.

I just think it gives the wrong, conflicting message to a child to tell them that they can't hit, but then to turn around as the parent and spank them on the tuchus.




I agree.

I was spanked (and hit) a lot when I was younger...the only thing it did for me was make me resent my mother.

Posted 6/6/09 8:25 AM
 

july0105
My three little miracles

Member since 4/06

2628 total posts

Name:
Alison

Re: Spanking- poll and discussion

Posted by Bxgell2

I just think it gives the wrong, conflicting message to a child to tell them that they can't hit, but then to turn around as the parent and spank them on the tuchus.



this is what I'm thinking, too.

Posted 6/6/09 8:25 AM
 

MrsProfessor
hi

Member since 5/05

14279 total posts

Name:

Re: Spanking- poll and discussion

I have yet to be that angry at DD. I never want to and don't plan to. But I am also one of those "never say never" people.

Posted 6/6/09 8:27 AM
 

Stacey1403
Where it all began....

Member since 5/05

24065 total posts

Name:

Re: Spanking- poll and discussion

Posted by EmmaNick

Posted by Bxgell2

I've never done it and never will - I can only speak from my own experience and my own child, but at least for my child, I think there are other, more effective, less physical ways to discipline her.

I just think it gives the wrong, conflicting message to a child to tell them that they can't hit, but then to turn around as the parent and spank them on the tuchus.




I agree.

I was spanked (and hit) a lot when I was younger...the only thing it did for me was make me resent my mother.



ITA
Except it was my Dad. I got spanked on the back of my legs/butt with a metal spoon (the big serving kind).

IMHO all spanking (hitting) proves is that it is okay to hit if your are bigger and stronger.

I am talking about full on spanking not a light tap on the tush or hand.

Posted 6/6/09 8:34 AM
 

casey31
Mommy of 3!

Member since 5/05

2967 total posts

Name:
Mommy to two boys and a girl

Re: Spanking- poll and discussion

Posted by Bxgell2

I've never done it and never will -
I just think it gives the wrong, conflicting message to a child to tell them that they can't hit, but then to turn around as the parent and spank them on the tuchus.



I agree with Beth wrote.

However, as Kara also said, I have learned that as parent to never say never.

ETA: before we had the children, we would give the dogs a smack on the tush if they stole food and we saw them doing it. (Never to hurt them though). I will never do that now, as i will never let my children see that- how could I teach them to never hit if they saw us do it?

Message edited 2009-06-06 08:42:56.357000.

Posted 6/6/09 8:41 AM
 

Porrruss
Nya nya nya

Member since 5/05

11618 total posts

Name:
Amy

Re: Spanking- poll and discussion

I was spanked as a child for serious offenses. I have an incredibly close relationship with both parents, am successful in my life (emotionally and professionally), and I think I'm a great mom.

Was it because I was spanked? Who knows- I never thought about it.

I will say this though- I HAVE spanked my DD. I hated it each time because purposely making her cry rips me apart each time. It's because of the way it makes ME feel is why we tend more towards "time-outs" around here. But for really serious infractions where I need to get her immediate attention and show her I mean business, she gets popped on the tush or on the back of the hand. Serious infractions= annoying the dog while she's eating, running in the street, etc.

Regardless of whether I spank or not- my kids will still blame me for effing them up anyway......Chat Icon

Posted 6/6/09 8:44 AM
 

ME75

Member since 10/06

4563 total posts

Name:

Re: Spanking- poll and discussion

when it counts-and i mean she is doing something dangerous or really bad then i will. like she tried to jump into my parents open pool.... scary. it's not often but she has gotten a swift spank on the behind.
i did not get spanked or hit too much as a kid but when i did it stopped my behavior and i knew that was it. my personal feeling is that SOMETIMES (and this is for my child not everyone elses) she has to have something more than a time out to get the point. i know my opinion is not popular but it works for us.
edited for spelling.

Message edited 2009-06-06 08:51:38.873000.

Posted 6/6/09 8:48 AM
 

ME75

Member since 10/06

4563 total posts

Name:

Re: Spanking- poll and discussion

Posted by Porrruss

I was spanked as a child for serious offenses. I have an incredibly close relationship with both parents, am successful in my life (emotionally and professionally), and I think I'm a great mom.

Was it because I was spanked? Who knows- I never thought about it.

I will say this though- I HAVE spanked my DD. I hated it each time because purposely making her cry rips me apart each time. It's because of the way it makes ME feel is why we tend more towards "time-outs" around here. But for really serious infractions where I need to get her immediate attention and show her I mean business, she gets popped on the tush or on the back of the hand. Serious infractions= annoying the dog while she's eating, running in the street, etc.

Regardless of whether I spank or not- my kids will still blame me for effing them up anyway......Chat Icon



see i should have just quoted you Chat Icon that was what i was trying to say. i left out the part where yes, it has ripped me apart to make her cry on the rare occasion. but my like my dad would say- better she cries now than you cry later (when something bad happens).

Posted 6/6/09 8:50 AM
 

pinkandblue
Our family is complete, maybe

Member since 9/05

32436 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: Spanking- poll and discussion

I have spanked mikayla once for running away from me in the parking lot. That is it, I do not use spanking as a form of punishment on a regular basis.

Posted 6/6/09 9:10 AM
 

pinkandblue
Our family is complete, maybe

Member since 9/05

32436 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: Spanking- poll and discussion

Posted by Bxgell2



I just think it gives the wrong, conflicting message to a child to tell them that they can't hit, but then to turn around as the parent and spank them on the tuchus.


I agree completely with this, I would never spank her for hiting.

Posted 6/6/09 9:11 AM
 
Pages: [1] 2 3
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
My issues with the DVR world we live in... - After discussion, now includes AI Spoiler! jerseypanda 4/2/09 29 Families Helping Families ™
Interesting discussion at work today: Do you think it is easier to marry someone of a different faith or a different race? BigB 12/8/08 11 Families Helping Families ™
A drama free discussion on Mommy vs. Daddy issues lipglossjunky73 9/18/08 11 Parenting
Can we start a nineteen minutes discussion? I have some questions jxnoscar 9/2/08 6 StoryBoard
Jealousy...figuring it all out...a discussion, a long one. It doesn't make much sense, but try to follow. yankinmanc 8/12/07 12 Parenting
My current "discussion" with DH: If your in laws were to stay over your house for the weekend... jxnoscar 6/25/07 90 Families Helping Families ™