Spanking

Forum Opinion Poll
I do it 23 18.40%
No way 51 40.80%
I rarely do it 44 35.20%
Other- what do you think? 7 5.60%
 

Vote in this poll

View poll

Spanking- poll and discussion

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 [2] 3

NinaLemon
It's a boy!!!

Member since 10/07

6453 total posts

Name:
Jeannine

Re: Spanking- poll and discussion

Posted by karacg

I've never done it, and don't plan to.

But I've also learned to never say never.



I agree.

Posted 6/6/09 9:13 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Jazzyt
My Girl!!!

Member since 8/07

2977 total posts

Name:
Giselle

Re: Spanking- poll and discussion

I will say that I will absolutely NEVER spank a child in public. I feel very strongly about this.



I feel this way too, I'd prefer to leave where we are

Message edited 2009-06-06 09:15:35.840000.

Posted 6/6/09 9:15 AM
 

Diana1215
Living on a prayer!!!

Member since 10/05

29450 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: Spanking- poll and discussion

I have done it twice, and both times he was seriously endangering himself.

The first we were walking up the stairs and half way up he decided to throw himself back into me - we both fell back a few steps - and then he continued to do that the entire way up. He was in that crouching position that wouldn't let me pick him up either. It was a really scary couple of minutes. When we got to the top of the stairs I spanked him.

The second was a few weeks ago at the park. He decided to run out of the gated area full speed ahead to the parking lot - as soon as I got hold of him I spanked his little tush. He needed to know that I meant business because god forbid a car was coming at that very moment. Chat Icon

Posted 6/6/09 9:20 AM
 

Dani922
Here's to new beginnings

Member since 10/07

7260 total posts

Name:
Danielle

Re: Spanking- poll and discussion

I have never done it & I don't plan on starting.

Posted 6/6/09 10:27 AM
 

nferrandi
too excited for words

Member since 10/05

18538 total posts

Name:
Nicole

Re: Spanking- poll and discussion

Luca hasn't really been spanked yet, but I'm sure he will be at some point. I was spanked so infrequently, that on the rare occasion I was, I took it very seriously and did not repeat the action. I think you just can't overuse the spanking, but there's a time and place for just about everything.

Posted 6/6/09 10:50 AM
 

Erica
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

11767 total posts

Name:

Re: Spanking- poll and discussion

never have and don't plan on it.

I agree with the philosophy that it says if you are bigger it's OK to hit.

Posted 6/6/09 11:03 AM
 

julz33
i run for bacon

Member since 5/05

20584 total posts

Name:
julz

Re: Spanking- poll and discussion

Posted by karacg

I've never done it, and don't plan to.

But I've also learned to never say never.



Agreed.
I have hit Landon's hand before when he reached for the stove when it was on... and he is only 1! So you never know what will happen in the future.

Posted 6/6/09 11:04 AM
 

JRD2008
CT. here we come!!

Member since 5/08

2944 total posts

Name:
Kathleen

Re: Spanking- poll and discussion

Maybe a light tap on the hand or bottom, but I can't see myself doing anything more forceful than that. It would also depend on the situation. My kids are still very young, but who knows what I will do when they start reaching for dangerous things or running away from me in parking lots, etc. It may happen in the moment, but I would never plan on it.

Posted 6/6/09 11:06 AM
 

CouponKT
Our family is complete

Member since 6/06

16494 total posts

Name:
K

Re: Spanking- poll and discussion

Yes, I spank. My parents did it effectively, DH's parents did it effectively and so do we.

I do not beat my child
I do not do it with intent to hurt
I do not do it on bare skin
I do not take out my anger with a spank

I make eye contact and let her know what she did wrong. She gets a spank and it pointed in a different direction than where the problem took place.

There, I said it Chat Icon

Posted 6/6/09 11:43 AM
 

computergirl
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

3118 total posts

Name:

Re: Spanking- poll and discussion

Posted by lipglossjunky73

I have given "angry mommy" taps on the hand or hiney, but there was no oomph in it - it was all in my face that delivered the message - and the taps were for situations where he could get himself very hurt (running out into the parking lot, for example)



I've always done this too, when it's a serious safety issue and not an appropriate time to try to "reason" or use some other method to get the point across.

Posted 6/6/09 12:24 PM
 

nbc188
Best friends!

Member since 12/06

23090 total posts

Name:
C

Re: Spanking- poll and discussion

I hope to never have to do it, it's something I (emphasis on I Chat Icon ) personally want to not do if possible...same with really screaming at DD. Made it this far so far, I know there are MANY tough years ahead though.

To each their own though!

Posted 6/6/09 12:27 PM
 

DanaRenee
Fitness Junkie!

Member since 6/06

6470 total posts

Name:
Dana

Re: Spanking- poll and discussion

I don't plan on spanking, I just don't want DS to think hitting is ok in any way ...

I was "put in the corner" when I was a child and that was 10x worse than any spanking I ever got so I'll probably torture my child that way Chat Icon

Posted 6/6/09 12:33 PM
 

Janice
Sweet Jessie Quinn

Member since 5/05

27567 total posts

Name:
Janice

Re: Spanking- poll and discussion

I do also believe in putting him in the corner or sending him to his room. This gets the message across. then he's out of my sight...I cool down, he calms down.

I spanked once outside his diaper...we were at a house, this big dog was locked in bedroom...he went to open the door and I froze. I spanked him, shocked that I did.

Then one night, before a bath, I tell him to go pee. He says no...I turn for a second and he says uhh oh mom...and there he is holding himself like a hose peeing all over the bathroom. I saw red and gave him a smack...bare bottom since he was already naked. I HATED myself in that moment and the rest of the night. I don't think I would ever do it again...he kept telling me it was okay and he feels better...but I should have just put him in his room.

DH was pro spanking till he met Josh. He would never ever lay a hand on him, never raised his voice ever...just preaches to him. Total role reversal from what we thought we were going to be.

I don't judge spankers at all. I judge people without out of control kids who don't do anything about it.

Posted 6/6/09 1:31 PM
 

CouponKT
Our family is complete

Member since 6/06

16494 total posts

Name:
K

Re: Spanking- poll and discussion

Posted by Janice
I judge people without out of control kids who don't do anything about it.



Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 6/6/09 1:58 PM
 

GenLCSW
Baby # 3 is here!!!

Member since 7/05

21138 total posts

Name:
Genna

Re: Spanking- poll and discussion

Posted by karacg

I've never done it, and don't plan to.

But I've also learned to never say never.



ITA and well said!

Posted 6/6/09 3:38 PM
 

2PreciousBlessings
The Perfect Pair

Member since 5/06

19861 total posts

Name:
Best Wife & Mommy

Re: Spanking- poll and discussion

Posted by CouponMom

Yes, I spank. My parents did it effectively, DH's parents did it effectively and so do we.

I do not beat my child
I do not do it with intent to hurt
I do not do it on bare skin
I do not take out my anger with a spank

I make eye contact and let her know what she did wrong. She gets a spank and it pointed in a different direction than where the problem took place.

There, I said it Chat Icon



This is us in every way.

Posted 6/6/09 3:52 PM
 

Metsmomma
Happy Winter!

Member since 1/09

5351 total posts

Name:
Renee

Re: Spanking- poll and discussion

ok...this is a sensitive subject....but i have an example for you. my "friend" never believed in spanking. she believed in "talking" to her children. well needless to say...her oldest has been arrested 3 times before he was 18 and her middle has been in trouble with the cops too. children have to have a little fear of consequence in them. otherwise they will do whatever they want and be out of control. everyone is free to have their own opinion but this is just mine. don't get me wrong....i don't agree with hitting your children like they did back in the day with belts and such. that to me is just abuse!!!!!

Posted 6/6/09 5:56 PM
 

pmpkn087
Life is good...

Member since 9/05

18504 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: Spanking- poll and discussion

I always said I never would.

I do.

I guess the plus side is that I don't do it nearly as much as my mom didChat Icon

Posted 6/6/09 6:40 PM
 

BaroqueMama
Chase is one!

Member since 5/05

27530 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Spanking- poll and discussion

I'm not quite sure what spanking actually teaches a child other than to fear you, so we don't spank her, nor do we plan to ever. I know I can never say never, but I really don't think spanking her would ever teach her anything. I like to lead by example and if hitting is ok for me, then that would mean it's ok for her.

Posted 6/6/09 6:44 PM
 

CkGm
They get so big, so fast :(

Member since 5/05

13848 total posts

Name:
Christine

Re: Spanking- poll and discussion

Posted by nrthshgrl

I never imagined every spanking kids when I had them.

Yes I have spanked them. I'm sure some will say there are better ways to discipline a child, maybe there are but when they were 2-3, it was what worked for us. It was a rare occasion and after all else failed (timeouts, warnings, etc) and usually for something like hitting the baby & running in the parking lot.

Now that they're older, they understand consquences & we can ground them.



Totally agree- DD has gotten one spanking from DH and one from me. DH agreed that he probably could have handled it differently(he totally lost his cool and probably should have just done a time out) but we agreed mine was justified(she ran out into the parking lot after being told to stay put by Mommy and almost got run over by a carChat Icon )

Posted 6/6/09 6:45 PM
 

BaroqueMama
Chase is one!

Member since 5/05

27530 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Spanking- poll and discussion

You know, I have to be really honest, I replied before reading all of the answers and now that I have read everyone's response, I think I can that if Ava ever puts herself in danger, I probably would spank her. There are definitely some instances where a little fear is a good thing.

Posted 6/6/09 7:01 PM
 

patti08
Happy

Member since 5/05

3893 total posts

Name:
Patti

Re: Spanking- poll and discussion

Our policy is a light swat if DD knowingly puts herself in danger, like running into the street. I don't know if I'll even do that when the time comes though.

I don't see how I can teach her not to hit by spanking her. I see timeouts and open communication as more effective but I don't fault anyone who uses the spanking method. I think it can depend on the kid.

I was spanked occasionally, threatened more often and it didn't affect me in the overall scheme of things.

Posted 6/6/09 7:58 PM
 

Porrruss
Nya nya nya

Member since 5/05

11618 total posts

Name:
Amy

Re: Spanking- poll and discussion

I think the MOST important part of using spanking as a means of discipline is for the spank to not come from a place of anger. If it's a knee-jerk reaction and seen as aggressive, then I can see where some might say it "teaches hitting is OK."

If it's done in a calm, rational manner with a follow-up to WHY the spank occurred, along with a hug/kiss then it's merely a form of negative reinforcement, much like a time-out.

The big difference I see is that a spanking is MORE of a deterrant from repeat inappropriate/dangerous behavior than the game of chasing a toddler around to sit in time-out. Plus- taking those seconds to calm myself in the few times I've spanked Mads is HAAAAAAAAAARD.

Posted 6/6/09 8:10 PM
 

Bxgell2
Perfection

Member since 5/05

16438 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: Spanking- poll and discussion

Posted by Metsmomma

ok...this is a sensitive subject....but i have an example for you. my "friend" never believed in spanking. she believed in "talking" to her children. well needless to say...her oldest has been arrested 3 times before he was 18 and her middle has been in trouble with the cops too. children have to have a little fear of consequence in them. otherwise they will do whatever they want and be out of control. everyone is free to have their own opinion but this is just mine. don't get me wrong....i don't agree with hitting your children like they did back in the day with belts and such. that to me is just abuse!!!!!



I don't know if I believe in this theory - I was never hit, spanked, slapped, anything growing up. My parents NEVER laid a hand on me. But neither myself, nor any of my brothers have ever been in trouble with the law, and though we each have our own unique personality flaws, as does anyone, one thing that runs common amongst us is a firm understanding and respect for the law, rules and consequences. We're all fondly known as goody two-shoes, and in fact, two of us ended up going to law school.

Children certainly do need to understand their boundaries and understand there are consequences to their actions, but spanking or other physical methods of discipline are not the only method by which to instill this in a child.

Posted 6/6/09 8:21 PM
 

MrsRbk
<3 <3 <3 <3

Member since 1/06

19197 total posts

Name:
Michelle

Re: Spanking- poll and discussion

Posted by EmmaNick

I was spanked (and hit) a lot when I was younger...the only thing it did for me was make me resent my mother.



Same here. My biggest fear as a parent is to "turn" into my mother. There are times when I realize I'm about to say or do something that my mother would do, and it really freaks me out and upsets me.

Posted 6/6/09 8:32 PM
 
Pages: 1 [2] 3
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
My issues with the DVR world we live in... - After discussion, now includes AI Spoiler! jerseypanda 4/2/09 29 Families Helping Families ™
Interesting discussion at work today: Do you think it is easier to marry someone of a different faith or a different race? BigB 12/8/08 11 Families Helping Families ™
A drama free discussion on Mommy vs. Daddy issues lipglossjunky73 9/18/08 11 Parenting
Can we start a nineteen minutes discussion? I have some questions jxnoscar 9/2/08 6 StoryBoard
Jealousy...figuring it all out...a discussion, a long one. It doesn't make much sense, but try to follow. yankinmanc 8/12/07 12 Parenting
My current "discussion" with DH: If your in laws were to stay over your house for the weekend... jxnoscar 6/25/07 90 Families Helping Families ™