"civil union" - SAME as "separate but equal" or TOTALLY DIFFERENT?

Forum Opinion Poll
SAME 40 57.97%
DIFFERENT 25 36.23%
OTHER 4 5.80%
 

Vote in this poll

View poll

interesting point brought up by a poster...

Posted By Message

headoverheels
s'il vous plaît

Member since 6/07

42079 total posts

Name:
LB

interesting point brought up by a poster...

(see Songwriter76's post here )

if you are NOT in favor of gay marriage, and instead favor what seems to be the more widely accepted term "civil union," do you AGREE or DISAGREE that this is the same thing as "separate but equal" for African-Americans?

Posted 10/9/08 9:14 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

bluegreen08
LIF Adolescent

Member since 10/07

574 total posts

Name:
a

Re: interesting point brought up by a poster...

I think it's separate but equal, but it's better than nothing. If we go that route I hope it is a stepping stone on the way to equality.

it boggles my mind how we could deny people equal rights. marriage is a religious institution, but as long as its tied to legal rights then that's potentially problematic. they should be separate for everyone, or nobody

Posted 10/9/08 9:31 PM
 

mka06
LIF Adult

Member since 8/06

1079 total posts

Name:
Melis

Re: interesting point brought up by a poster...

i see it as different. i think that there should absolutely be equal rights in all ways -- benefits, taxes, right to make decisions for health care, etc.... Now, if someone told me that people who had "civil unions" were going to get benefits, but diff ones, then I'd say separate but equal. But, if they can get eligibility to the exact same government and private sector benefits, I don't think it falls in that category.

to me, the rights are what is most important... not the term used to label it.

Posted 10/10/08 8:52 AM
 

BunnyWife
Insert Witty Comment Here

Member since 5/07

8274 total posts

Name:
BunnyWife

Re: interesting point brought up by a poster...

I think it's the same. It's ridiculous that people are so afraid of the term marriage when it comes to gay relationships.

Posted 10/10/08 9:07 AM
 

Beth
The Key to your new home....

Member since 2/06

24849 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: interesting point brought up by a poster...

Posted by BunnyWife

I think it's the same. It's ridiculous that people are so afraid of the term marriage when it comes to gay relationships.




Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

seriously- enough already

we have bigger issues in the country and the world

so many people in this country voted for Bush out of fear of gay people getting married- that is hardly an issue for the government in my honest opinion

live and let live

Posted 10/10/08 9:16 AM
 

mka06
LIF Adult

Member since 8/06

1079 total posts

Name:
Melis

Re: interesting point brought up by a poster...

Posted by BunnyWife

I think it's the same. It's ridiculous that people are so afraid of the term marriage when it comes to gay relationships.



i know you weren't directing this at me specifically... but just wanted to reply. i am not afraid of using the term "marriage" for gay relationships. personally, i would not have a problem referring to two people joined in a civil union as married.

on the flip side, marriage is also a religious institution/ritual. i don't think it reasonable regardless of my personal opinion to ask a religion to change their rituals/sacraments.

Posted 10/10/08 9:18 AM
 

JennZ
MY LIFE!!

Member since 8/05

25463 total posts

Name:

Re: interesting point brought up by a poster...

Posted by BunnyWife

I think it's the same. It's ridiculous that people are so afraid of the term marriage when it comes to gay relationships.





ITA! Such a shame we can't see past the term GAY marriage.

Posted 10/10/08 9:24 AM
 

vmac
Mommy VMac

Member since 8/07

1860 total posts

Name:
Vanessa

Re: interesting point brought up by a poster...

Posted by BunnyWife

I think it's the same. It's ridiculous that people are so afraid of the term marriage when it comes to gay relationships.




ITA!!! Every time I hear anyone say that they believe that gay and lesbian couples should have the same rights, but marriage is between a man and a woman, I always think back to Seperate but Equal. And in that case it was decided that if it was seperate it could not be equal.

I think it should be the same. Marriage is marriage. In a country where we have seperation of Church and State, I don't see why if they would be getting married by the state, outside of a religous setting why it can't be called marriage.

JMO.

Posted 10/10/08 9:42 AM
 

Luv2bAmom
LIF Adult

Member since 2/08

1255 total posts

Name:
J

Re: interesting point brought up by a poster...

Posted by mka06

Posted by BunnyWife

I think it's the same. It's ridiculous that people are so afraid of the term marriage when it comes to gay relationships.



i know you weren't directing this at me specifically... but just wanted to reply. i am not afraid of using the term "marriage" for gay relationships. personally, i would not have a problem referring to two people joined in a civil union as married.

on the flip side, marriage is also a religious institution/ritual. i don't think it reasonable regardless of my personal opinion to ask a religion to change their rituals/sacraments.




I'm sorry but I disagree, Marriage is not only a religious institution/ritual its a legal one. Religion does not have to have anythign to do with it, accordign to what you said then I take you that if a man & a woman go to the justice of the peace not a church, they are not married since religion had nothing to do wth it??


I just don't understand WHY people cannot let everyone live thieir own lives, how does two people, be it 2 man, 2 woman affect you in anyway.

It makes me sad to think that the goverment can tell me who I can and cannot love. DH & I are very religious and as a catholic, I am darn sure the God I worship is merciful & loving and don't think its against Gods rule for people to love each other.

Message edited 2008-10-10 09:44:14.277000.

Posted 10/10/08 9:43 AM
 

headoverheels
s'il vous plaît

Member since 6/07

42079 total posts

Name:
LB

Re: interesting point brought up by a poster...

Posted by mka06

Posted by BunnyWife

I think it's the same. It's ridiculous that people are so afraid of the term marriage when it comes to gay relationships.



i know you weren't directing this at me specifically... but just wanted to reply. i am not afraid of using the term "marriage" for gay relationships. personally, i would not have a problem referring to two people joined in a civil union as married.

on the flip side, marriage is also a religious institution/ritual. i don't think it reasonable regardless of my personal opinion to ask a religion to change their rituals/sacraments.




i am confused - who is asking ANY of the religions to change their rituals or sacraments?

this issue is purely secular. this is the issue of most state governments (since i don't think this has been addressed by the Supreme Court yet, PLEASE correct me if i am wrong) refusing to refer to the "civil union" of two same-sex people as marriage.

IMO, it is EXACTLY the same as "separate but equal" - they are offering the same privileges to same-sex couples but are refusing to allow them to call themselves married.

it's like saying here - you can join the civil union country club, it's exactly the same as the marriage country club, but you just can't come in here because you are gay.

if the bible says that marriage can only occur between a man and a woman, fine - far be it from me to try and argue against the word of god Chat Icon but since when are state laws based on the bible? what happened to the separation of church and state?

Posted 10/10/08 9:44 AM
 

Kara
Now Zagat Rated!

Member since 3/07

13217 total posts

Name:
They call me "Tater Salad"

Re: interesting point brought up by a poster...

Posted by mka06


on the flip side, marriage is also a religious institution/ritual. i don't think it reasonable regardless of my personal opinion to ask a religion to change their rituals/sacraments.




So people who get married by lay people (e.g., judge) aren't married? Marriage is NOT just a religious institution; it's a civil and legal one as well. Legalizing gay marriage wouldn't force a church to change its beliefs or sacraments.

Posted 10/10/08 9:44 AM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: interesting point brought up by a poster...

Posted by mka06


on the flip side, marriage is also a religious institution/ritual. i don't think it reasonable regardless of my personal opinion to ask a religion to change their rituals/sacraments.




this is the cruxt of it I think.

every one of us that is married had a "civil union" first when we applied for our marriage licenses.

we then chose (or didn't) to have that civil union reinforced by our religious one.

a two step process.

there are religions that don't "believe" in the union of a man with a man or a woman with a woman.

with our separation of church and state, we cannot expect or impress upon religious groups to alter their tenants or beliefs.

as long as the civil unions for gay couples are the same as those for straight that we all received, I think we should stop beating this dead horse about semantics.

Posted 10/10/08 9:56 AM
 

tourist

Member since 5/05

10425 total posts

Name:

Re: interesting point brought up by a poster...

Technically aren't all legal marriages civil unions?

I think arguing over the name is just splitting hairs, and I know some of my gay friends would absolutely make the concession on the terminology, if it would help the laws get passed. Same sex couples joined in a "civil union" would still call themselves amrried. I know people that do that now, even though it isn't legally recognized by their state.

The problem with "separate but equal" is that once things were separate, they weren't equal. It was one of those things, that sounded like a good compromise at the time, but wasn't.

I don't think we can really say if that would be the case with this, untill it happens. For example, if jobs were allowed to make the choice to offer family insurance to people in marriages, but not people in civil unions, then yes, that would separate & not equal.

Message edited 2008-10-10 10:04:05.720000.

Posted 10/10/08 10:02 AM
 

mka06
LIF Adult

Member since 8/06

1079 total posts

Name:
Melis

Re: interesting point brought up by a poster...

Posted by Ophelia

Posted by mka06


on the flip side, marriage is also a religious institution/ritual. i don't think it reasonable regardless of my personal opinion to ask a religion to change their rituals/sacraments.




this is the cruxt of it I think.

every one of us that is married had a "civil union" first when we applied for our marriage licenses.

we then chose (or didn't) to have that civil union reinforced by our religious one.

a two step process.

there are religions that don't "believe" in the union of a man with a man or a woman with a woman.

with our separation of church and state, we cannot expect or impress upon religious groups to alter their tenants or beliefs.

as long as the civil unions for gay couples are the same as those for straight that we all received, I think we should stop beating this dead horse about semantics.



this is exactly how i would have answered the ?s asked of my position. well stated, so i won't reiterate.

i had an intersting convo with a gay friend of mine a few months back about exactly this. he doesn't care at all about the word marriage being applied to civil unions. he cares that he can officially/legally join in a union with his bf when the time comes. And, he cares that that union will provide them the same rights as a heterosexual married couple. he even went so far to say that it was his opinion that some of the activist organizations on this were losing the forests for the trees....focusing so much on the terminology that more energy was being put on that then getting/protecting the actual rights.

i do feel the need to reiterate i have said from the beginning that I think that gay couples should be entitled to all the same rights as heterosexual married couples and that I have no problem referring to a gay couple that has had a civil union as "married." i feel like some of the posts in response to mine took a tone that implied that just bc i don't think this falls in the "separate but equal" category, that i am against the concept in general. i'm not. that and the semantics issue are two different things.

Posted 10/10/08 10:36 AM
 

Shelly
She's 7!!!

Member since 8/05

14624 total posts

Name:

Re: interesting point brought up by a poster...

Posted by BunnyWife

I think it's the same. It's ridiculous that people are so afraid of the term marriage when it comes to gay relationships.



I agree! And with the 50% divorce rate in this country, its HETEROSEXUALS who have destroyed the sanctity of "marriage".

Although quite a few of my gay friends don't care what you call it, as long as the rights are the same.

Posted 10/10/08 10:41 AM
 

MrsFlatbread
Skinny jeans are in my future

Member since 6/06

10258 total posts

Name:
Baby Momma

Re: interesting point brought up by a poster...

Posted by bluegreen08

I think it's separate but equal, but it's better than nothing. If we go that route I hope it is a stepping stone on the way to equality.

it boggles my mind how we could deny people equal rights. marriage is a religious institution, but as long as its tied to legal rights then that's potentially problematic. they should be separate for everyone, or nobody



exactly...

Posted 10/10/08 11:41 AM
 

Songwriter76
LIF Adult

Member since 4/08

902 total posts

Name:
David

Re: interesting point brought up by a poster...

Wiki defines marriage as a legal OR religious institution.

I don't know why religious people think they own the word "marriage."

Like so many people pointed out, if you're joined together in a city hall, are you not married?

If you are athiest or agnostic, are you not married?

If you are like me and do not believe in organized religion, am I not married?

I could never imagine having to call my WIFE my PARTNER just because religious people think they own a certain word.


Posted 10/10/08 12:38 PM
 

BunnyWife
Insert Witty Comment Here

Member since 5/07

8274 total posts

Name:
BunnyWife

Re: interesting point brought up by a poster...

Posted by Songwriter76


If you are athiest or agnostic, are you not married?





Exactly. My husband is an atheist. There was no mention of God in our wedding ceremony. I wish politicians would stop using god and religion to justify law and rulings when we are supposed to be a secular country.

Posted 10/10/08 1:09 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
My brother brought up an interesting point last night about the Mets and Yankees... preciouslove 9/26/06 4 Sports
Interesting point made at the conference I went to karacg 5/8/06 7 Infertility
Has anyone brought their dog to Smith's Point Beach? chikita315 8/9/07 6 Pets