Re: interesting point brought up by a poster...
Posted 10/10/2008 10:36:43 AM by mka06


Posted by Ophelia


Posted by mka06


on the flip side, marriage is also a religious institution/ritual. i don't think it reasonable regardless of my personal opinion to ask a religion to change their rituals/sacraments.




this is the cruxt of it I think.

every one of us that is married had a "civil union" first when we applied for our marriage licenses.

we then chose (or didn't) to have that civil union reinforced by our religious one.

a two step process.

there are religions that don't "believe" in the union of a man with a man or a woman with a woman.

with our separation of church and state, we cannot expect or impress upon religious groups to alter their tenants or beliefs.

as long as the civil unions for gay couples are the same as those for straight that we all received, I think we should stop beating this dead horse about semantics.



this is exactly how i would have answered the ?s asked of my position. well stated, so i won't reiterate.

i had an intersting convo with a gay friend of mine a few months back about exactly this. he doesn't care at all about the word marriage being applied to civil unions. he cares that he can officially/legally join in a union with his bf when the time comes. And, he cares that that union will provide them the same rights as a heterosexual married couple. he even went so far to say that it was his opinion that some of the activist organizations on this were losing the forests for the trees....focusing so much on the terminology that more energy was being put on that then getting/protecting the actual rights.

i do feel the need to reiterate i have said from the beginning that I think that gay couples should be entitled to all the same rights as heterosexual married couples and that I have no problem referring to a gay couple that has had a civil union as "married." i feel like some of the posts in response to mine took a tone that implied that just bc i don't think this falls in the "separate but equal" category, that i am against the concept in general. i'm not. that and the semantics issue are two different things.
Print Post      Close Window