Re: interesting point brought up by a poster...
Posted 10/10/2008 9:44:12 AM by headoverheels


Posted by mka06


Posted by BunnyWife

I think it's the same. It's ridiculous that people are so afraid of the term marriage when it comes to gay relationships.



i know you weren't directing this at me specifically... but just wanted to reply. i am not afraid of using the term "marriage" for gay relationships. personally, i would not have a problem referring to two people joined in a civil union as married.

on the flip side, marriage is also a religious institution/ritual. i don't think it reasonable regardless of my personal opinion to ask a religion to change their rituals/sacraments.




i am confused - who is asking ANY of the religions to change their rituals or sacraments?

this issue is purely secular. this is the issue of most state governments (since i don't think this has been addressed by the Supreme Court yet, PLEASE correct me if i am wrong) refusing to refer to the "civil union" of two same-sex people as marriage.

IMO, it is EXACTLY the same as "separate but equal" - they are offering the same privileges to same-sex couples but are refusing to allow them to call themselves married.

it's like saying here - you can join the civil union country club, it's exactly the same as the marriage country club, but you just can't come in here because you are gay.

if the bible says that marriage can only occur between a man and a woman, fine - far be it from me to try and argue against the word of god Chat Icon but since when are state laws based on the bible? what happened to the separation of church and state?
Print Post      Close Window