Non-partisan explaination of Israel
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
|
Non-partisan explaination of Israel I don't understand what's going on recently with Israel. I've tried reading articles on trusted news sites, but I just don't understand. Can someone that's not anti-Obama explain it? |
|
Posted 12/28/16 8:51 AM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: Non-partisan explaination of Israel The UN Security Counsel puts forth a lot of resolutions on Israel about human rights violations against Palestinians, particularly regarding settlements encroaching on what used to be Palestinian territory. The United States reliably vetoes these resolutions, and has consistently in the last 40 years, since the US and Israel have historically had a close relationship. The Obama administration's decision to abstain in this vote allowed this most recent resolution to pass, and Israeli Prime Minister Netanyahu has been very vocal about his anger towards Obama for this. He's also been talking strongly about cutting ties to the (mostly small) nations that co-sponsered the resolution, like New Zealand (he said they've "declared war" on Israel) and Senegal. |
|
Posted 12/28/16 9:23 AM
|
|
|
Re: Non-partisan explaination of Israel Posted by spartagoose The UN Security Counsel puts forth a lot of resolutions on Israel about human rights violations against Palestinians, particularly regarding settlements encroaching on what used to be Palestinian territory. The United States reliably vetoes these resolutions, and has consistently in the last 40 years, since the US and Israel have historically had a close relationship. The Obama administration's decision to abstain in this vote allowed this most recent resolution to pass, and Israeli Prime Minister Netanyahu has been very vocal about his anger towards Obama for this. He's also been talking strongly about cutting ties to the (mostly small) nations that co-sponsered the resolution, like New Zealand (he said they've "declared war" on Israel) and Senegal. So, Israel is pissed because we don't want them building on Palestinian land? Is that the short version? |
|
Posted 12/28/16 9:51 AM
|
|
|
Re: Non-partisan explaination of Israel I think Obama may not feel the need to appease pro-Israel constituents (Dem and Repub alike) here in the US now that he's exiting and he wanted to send a message to Israel that this really is a human rights issue they should be addressing. The resolution passed 14-0. I absolutely understand the pro-Israel stance -- they are a nation with hostile neighbors...even hostile seems like an understatement, but it seems like Palestinians are marginalized in the country. Message edited 2016-12-28 11:27:14.107000. |
|
Posted 12/28/16 11:24 AM
|
|
|
Non-partisan explaination of Israel I still don't get it :/ |
|
Posted 12/28/16 11:36 AM
|
|
|
Re: Non-partisan explaination of Israel It is not Palestinian land. Arabs attacked Israel in 1967. Many Arab nations. Israel won and kept the land. Israel has tried to give the land back MANY times and to withdraw. Israelis want to live in peace but they need to keep control for security. The Palestinians have launched thousands of terrorist attacks. Message edited 2016-12-28 11:41:01.407000. |
|
Posted 12/28/16 11:38 AM
|
|
|
Re: Non-partisan explaination of Israel Posted by ohbaby08 Posted by spartagoose The UN Security Counsel puts forth a lot of resolutions on Israel about human rights violations against Palestinians, particularly regarding settlements encroaching on what used to be Palestinian territory. The United States reliably vetoes these resolutions, and has consistently in the last 40 years, since the US and Israel have historically had a close relationship. The Obama administration's decision to abstain in this vote allowed this most recent resolution to pass, and Israeli Prime Minister Netanyahu has been very vocal about his anger towards Obama for this. He's also been talking strongly about cutting ties to the (mostly small) nations that co-sponsered the resolution, like New Zealand (he said they've "declared war" on Israel) and Senegal. So, Israel is pissed because we don't want them building on Palestinian land? Is that the short version? Yes, but therin lies the rub. I am no expert and will give my understanding which may not be the "correct" understanding. Israel came to "officially exist in 1948. The "land" was under British rule and was literally given to the Jews to officialy form the state of Israel. The Jews took the land. And yes, this meant displacing the Palestinians. (As a side note, my understanding of history has always been that the Palestinians picked the "wrong" side in WW2. Because of that the British said F-you and rewarded the Jews with their own country). There have been a few wars over the years. One of those wars ended where Israel won and took possetion of the Occupied Territory. That's why when you look at maps the "land" never says Israel. its says "Occupied Territory". Israel considers it theirs. The rest of the Arab world does not. So for YEARS Israel has been making Jewish settlements in the Occupied Territory. That is pissing off the Arab world because they see that Israel should not be there, period. So the MORE Israel builds, the more pissed the Arab world gets. But Israel sees it as their land so they can do what they want. SO the UN is trying to make a resolution saying "stop building in the occupied territory". Israel says "Its my land and I can do what I want". Lastly. There has always been talk about a 2 state solution. Palestinians getting their own land, their own country, their own "state" next to Israel. I personally believe that in theory it certainly could work. However the Palestinians have a mission statement (if you will) saying that they only want the total destruction and annihilation of Israel. Until they change that there will not be peace. Lastly. There has been horrific things that go on with both sides. The Palestinians fire rockets into Israel from Gaza to try and kill as many Israelis as they can. They do that as retaliation. The Jews then go in and destroy the Palestinians for firing rockets as retaliation. My very personal opinion is that if the rockets stopped then Israel would stop . I see Israel responding to the rockets, not the other way around. I will also note that the Israeli army (Israel) has been oppressive to the Palestinians. And that is putting it nicely. SO the Palestinians are angry. REALLY angry. However Israel sees they must be oppressive while the Palestinian mission is "the total destruction of Israel". So they defend themselves with all of their military might. Without that defense the country is no more. But it is widely regarded that if there COULD be a 2 state solution there might be peace. But the 2 state solution wont happen while Israel keeps putting settlements in the occupied territory and the Palestinian mission is for the destruction of Israel. I say again that a lot of this is my understanding and don't want to say that the above is the absolute facts. I have noted where my personal thoughts occur and where I think history speaks for itself. Message edited 2016-12-28 11:49:02.593000. |
|
Posted 12/28/16 11:45 AM
|
|
|
Re: Non-partisan explaination of Israel Posted by casey31 In palestinian schools they literally teach that Jews are they devil and should be killed. This is absolutely untrue. There have been MANY studies on Palestinian and Israeli textbooks and BOTH sides were found to have imbalance, bias, and inaccuracy, but do not incite violence. They simply show history from two different points of view. |
|
Posted 12/28/16 12:04 PM
|
|
|
Re: Non-partisan explaination of Israel The UN partitioned the land in 1948- half to Arabs and half to Jews. The Jews said thank you very much. The Arabs attacked. Israel won. The Arabs attacked in 1956, 1967, 1973. Israel kept winning. Why should Israel give back any land they won? What other country would be expected to do that? The Palestinians were under Jordanian rule- in refugee camps and lived in squalor prior to 1967. Israel took the land in 1967- to keep security borders after they were attacked. Only now the world criticizes? |
|
Posted 12/28/16 12:05 PM
|
|
|
Re: Non-partisan explaination of Israel Posted by ohbaby08 Posted by casey31 In palestinian schools they literally teach that Jews are they devil and should be killed. This is absolutely untrue. There have been MANY studies on Palestinian and Israeli textbooks and BOTH sides were found to have imbalance, bias, and inaccuracy, but do not incite violence. They simply show history from two different points of view. This is absolutely true. Palestinians are teaching their children to kill Jews and be martyrs. You cannot compare anything that Israel does to that kind of mindset. I saw the Palestinians dancing in the street on 9/11 on TV. Where is the outrage in that? Hamas rules their people - and they have ties to Isis - its sad that they can't get out from Hamas. Message edited 2016-12-28 12:19:52.740000. |
|
Posted 12/28/16 12:06 PM
|
|
|
Non-partisan explaination of Israel If you want to take sides, consider. One side makes their woman cover their bodies, doesn't allow them to drive without a man watching them in the car, kills people who are homosexual, and had a hand in the world trade center bombings. No rights, no monies spent on the people in the country and money spent on their hypocritical life style with those white hats on the mens head like they are all sheiks with white stallions. |
|
Posted 12/28/16 12:13 PM
|
|
|
Re: Non-partisan explaination of Israel The short answer is there is no non-partisan explanation of the situation in Israel. And I say this in all seriousness, as a Jew and a Zionist who is pro-Obama. The situation there is mired in history and context, and there is no short answer or explanation to ANYTHING that happens. If you're interested and do not want your thoughts colored by others' opinions, your best bet would be to look into the history through past news reportings and books/texts from both sides. I'm happy to recommend some for you, however you may also want to get some from people who consider themselves more pro-Palestinian, as my bias leans heavily to Israel. |
|
Posted 12/28/16 2:32 PM
|
|
|
Non-partisan explaination of Israel I wasn't looking for a quick answer bc I didn't think there would be one. I just knew that Obama voted it down in the past and now a lot of anti-Obama people in my FB feed are using this as a way to say "See? He's awful and I can't wait until Trump's in office." (Which blows my mind bc Trump's only going to do what lines rich people's pockets.) |
|
Posted 12/28/16 2:58 PM
|
|
|
Non-partisan explaination of Israel Just cant wait until January 20, for the new administration! Just a note that anytime Israel has given back anything to the Palestinians there was distruction. No one told the arabs to leave in 1948 they choose the wrong side and ran! Its the land of Israel that the Palestinians want to distroy, no matter what lands are given back or settled it will never be enough until they destroy Israel and all the Western Democratic countries of the world. Hope that will never happen under Trump which is why I voted for him!!! |
|
Posted 12/28/16 3:42 PM
|
|
|
Re: Non-partisan explaination of Israel Posted by casey31 The UN partitioned the land in 1948- half to Arabs and half to Jews. The Jews said thank you very much. The Arabs attacked. Israel won. The Arabs attacked in 1956, 1967, 1973. Israel kept winning. Why should Israel give back any land they won? What other country would be expected to do that? The Palestinians were under Jordanian rule- in refugee camps and lived in squalor prior to 1967. Israel took the land in 1967- to keep security borders after they were attacked. Only now the world criticizes? THIS. People need to do research. How many times has Syria been sanctioned by the UN for the atrocities going on there? So may countries with mass slaughters and/or overrun by terrorists and human rights violations--no UN reaction. Israel? Everyone's favorite target. And you HAVE to ask why. Plus, those rockets are not paper airplanes. I would LOVE to see an organization tell the US that it has to give back land that it won after it was attacked in a war that it didn't start. Or that countries on our borders could shoot ROCKETS across the borders at children, homes, hospitals, etc. and we can't fight back or make it stop. Israel irrigated the desert, built hospitals and museums and schools. They made an uninhabitable place livable. And unlike their enemies, they offered refuge, treatment, water, electricity to everyone, regardless of race, religion, etc. They offer aid around the world, like to Haiti when it needed it, they recognized gay civil rights. But it's not like the UN or its relentless critics have a selective memory or anything--right? ETA: Many people believe that the selective, targeted condemnation of Israel and not others is a sign of systemic anti-semitism. Message edited 2016-12-28 16:01:15.177000. |
|
Posted 12/28/16 3:56 PM
|
|
|
Re: Non-partisan explaination of Israel So the best analogy I can come up with for the US is the French and Indian War. The US fraught and won land. So did Israel in the 1940s and in the 1960s. Imagine after the French and Indian war where the US won, Nearly 50 years later, Americans wanted to build cities on the land they won. They want to build a suburb of St. Lewis. Now the UN says you can't build your home in a new suburb of St. Lewis. You would look at the UN and say WTF. |
|
Posted 12/28/16 3:56 PM
|
|
|
Re: Non-partisan explaination of Israel Posted by MandJZ The short answer is there is no non-partisan explanation of the situation in Israel. And I say this in all seriousness, as a Jew and a Zionist who is pro-Obama. The situation there is mired in history and context, and there is no short answer or explanation to ANYTHING that happens. If you're interested and do not want your thoughts colored by others' opinions, your best bet would be to look into the history through past news reportings and books/texts from both sides. I'm happy to recommend some for you, however you may also want to get some from people who consider themselves more pro-Palestinian, as my bias leans heavily to Israel. This I dont think there are any un-biased opinions maybe through scholarly sources People are very opinionated, get very heated and are very divided on this never-ending issue |
|
Posted 12/28/16 4:57 PM
|
|
|
Non-partisan explaination of Israel There are no unbiased answers. I read an old book that could have been written yesterday called "The Arabs," which seeks to explain the history of the area and what many previous posters say is absolutely true. It is a place of conflict. It was before Israel became Israel and it remains so. Not to generalize, but the people of the region only want to fight over land, but not develop it, modernize it, or make it habitable. Whenever there have been proposed solutions, it's been another war. It is no secret that Jews and Israel are not well liked, but it kind of makes no sense if you think about it. All they want is a place to be..and it's SMALL...there is the REST of the Middle Eastern land and the Northern part of Africa ripe for advancing civilization, Muslim culture, etc. which is HUGE and full of resources (Nile River, etc.) |
|
Posted 12/28/16 9:35 PM
|
|
|
Re: Non-partisan explaination of Israel I don't disagree with the pro Israel stance on here but I see it with a bit more nuance. |
|
Posted 12/29/16 5:39 PM
|
|







