|
Re: Non-partisan explaination of Israel
Posted 12/29/2016 5:39:14 PM by JennP I don't disagree with the pro Israel stance on here but I see it with a bit more nuance. Some thoughts in no particular order: I also recommend The Arabs by David Lamb. It's older, so it's more for the historical context, but it is very non partisan. It's written by a journalist. Reserve it from your library if you're really interested in this issue. The settlements are illegal according to the Fourth Geneva Convention of 1949. Now, before anyone jumps down my throat, it's another question entirely whether or not the territories should be considered "occupied" and not "part of Israel because they won it in a war they didn't start." (This is where my largely pro Israeli stance comes in - they've been acting on the defense from literally day one.) The British didn't buy anything. The Ottoman Empire lost WW1, and since it was crumbling anyway, its takeover and domination by the European powers was inevitable. The Sykes Picot agreement was a secret agreement between Britain and France carving up the Levant (the area around and including Israel) before they even won the war. In it they agree to facilitate and protect free Arab States. Then comes the Balfour Declaration, in which they promise to create a Jewish state; many see that as a violation of Sykes Picot. Either way, there was an awful lot of interference going on. The reason why Israel said "Thank you very much" is because they got over half the land even though they had less than half of the people. (Yes, the Law of Return meant they needed space to resettle European Jews after the hell they had been through, but I can see how the other side can view the division as unjust.) Anyway, the inception of the Jewish state is not without its controversy and speaks to a basic question - how much of a right do the dominant world powers have to carve up the territory of others? I think Israel is in a tough spot because its enemies beef is really with the European powers who carved it up but they take it out on them. On top of that, said powers are constantly punishing them for actions other countries get away with easily. On the other hand, Israel has had some HARD right government leaders who have railed against a two state solution and not made things easier over the years. I don't think mocking the Palestinian lifestyle is the answer here. Just because a nation isn't modernized or their religion is different from yours doesn't mean they don't have a right to statehood. |