Would you lie about this question to give blood, if you knew you were disease free?

Forum Opinion Poll
Yes, there's such a great need for blood and it's an outdated question 16 12.70%
Yes, but only if I were giving directly to a friend or family member (not at a drive) 6 4.76%
I'm completely on the fence about it. 5 3.97%
No, rules are rules even if I disagree with them 88 69.84%
I would never donate blood regardless 8 6.35%
Obligatory other 3 2.38%
 

Vote in this poll

View poll

Poll about giving blood - possibly controversial

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2 3

AnonyMouse
LIF Zygote

Member since 12/09

6 total posts

Name:

Poll about giving blood - possibly controversial

I know there have been threads in the past about donating blood and some of the questions asked -- most particularly if you have had sexual contact with a man who has sex with a man since 1977. Or if you're a man, if you have had sex with a man since 1977.

I used to give blood all of the time, until I found out that I am in the above group. Since finding that out, I have NOT given blood because I would have to lie to donate. I wish I could give blood, though. I think it's a really great thing to do for someone else.

I know for a fact that the man is HIV negative and disease free. His one-time sexual contact with another man was many years ago (well over a decade ago). He has been tested several times over the past few years and was even tested as recently as last year. I have been tested every year as part of my physical for the past decade, even though I'm happily married with children for the past 7 yrs. I have no STDs, have never had an STD and am HIV negative.

Curious, would you lie about this question to give blood in this situation?

FTR, I have always been pretty taken aback by the fact that they still ask this question today. HIV and STDs really aren't just something affecting the gay population. Plenty of straight people who have never had a same sex relationship contract STDs and HIV. but I have never broken the rules and lied to donate blood since I became a member of this category.

Would you lie about this particular question in order to donate blood, if you knew you were disease free? Whether you are in my situation or in the situation where you are a gay man who is certain he is disease free?

Thanks. I made it a poll so people can be anonymous if they want.

**ETA -- I don't want people to be confused. I'm not asking if I should lie to give blood. I'm not planning to do that or change anything as a result of this poll.

Message edited 2010-02-12 12:54:18.943000.

Posted 2/12/10 12:45 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

CathyB

Member since 5/05

19403 total posts

Name:

Re: Poll about giving blood - possibly controversial

I can't donate blood in the US for another reason - I lived in the UK in the early 80's and since there was a mad cow outbreak there then I might be carrying it. Everything I've read says that it would have manifested itself by now, so it frustrates me that I can't donate since I really would like to. But I won't lie about it, I assume the people making these decisions are going on more knowledge/research than I have access to via google.

Posted 2/12/10 12:51 PM
 

Jenn627
Laaaaaaaambert!

Member since 5/08

9818 total posts

Name:
Jenn

Re: Poll about giving blood - possibly controversial

According to the NY Blood Center - you can still donate.

eta: Link

Message edited 2010-02-12 12:53:04.140000.

Posted 2/12/10 12:51 PM
 

Jenn627
Laaaaaaaambert!

Member since 5/08

9818 total posts

Name:
Jenn

Re: Poll about giving blood - possibly controversial

I wouldn't donate blood anyway. I was on Accutane a while ago (about 3 yrs ago) and I'm still hestitant to give blood b/c of it.

Posted 2/12/10 12:53 PM
 

CathyB

Member since 5/05

19403 total posts

Name:

Re: Poll about giving blood - possibly controversial

Posted by Jenn627

According to the NY Blood Center - you can still donate.

eta: Link




They just rejected me 2 weeks ago.

Posted 2/12/10 12:55 PM
 

Sash
Peace

Member since 6/08

10314 total posts

Name:
fka LIW Smara

Re: Poll about giving blood - possibly controversial

I wouldnt do it, they have those rules. Its unfortunate but I couldnt see myself lying. Im too nervous, I feel I would jeapordize somethng by lying.

Posted 2/12/10 12:57 PM
 

AnonyMouse
LIF Zygote

Member since 12/09

6 total posts

Name:

Re: Poll about giving blood - possibly controversial

Posted by Jenn627

According to the NY Blood Center - you can still donate.

eta: Link




Thank you. I'm confused by this. It says 12 months after last incident, but what is the incident? The man having sex with a man, or the woman having sex with that man?

Posted 2/12/10 12:57 PM
 

greenfreak
.

Member since 9/06

11483 total posts

Name:
greenfreak

Re: Poll about giving blood - possibly controversial

Posted by AnonyMouse

Posted by Jenn627

According to the NY Blood Center - you can still donate.

eta: Link




Thank you. I'm confused by this. It says 12 months after last incident, but what is the incident? The man having sex with a man, or the woman having sex with that man?



I would think it's the woman having sex with the man, since it is the more recent act.

I know what you're saying about being surprised that they still ask the question, but they also ask other qualifying questions about drug use, tattoos, etc. - other ways to contract HIV, right?

Posted 2/12/10 1:12 PM
 

AnonyMouse
LIF Zygote

Member since 12/09

6 total posts

Name:

Re: Poll about giving blood - possibly controversial

Posted by greenfreak

Posted by AnonyMouse

Posted by Jenn627

According to the NY Blood Center - you can still donate.

eta: Link




Thank you. I'm confused by this. It says 12 months after last incident, but what is the incident? The man having sex with a man, or the woman having sex with that man?



I would think it's the woman having sex with the man, since it is the more recent act.

I know what you're saying about being surprised that they still ask the question, but they also ask other qualifying questions about drug use, tattoos, etc. - other ways to contract HIV, right?



Then I can't donate unless the rule changes since I am married to the man.

I know its not the only question about HIV but heterosexual sex is also a way to contract HIV. It's not just a gay mens disease. I don't plan to break the rule but I do wonder if statistics still back up the question as a screening question.

Posted 2/12/10 1:19 PM
 

Kara
Now Zagat Rated!

Member since 3/07

13217 total posts

Name:
They call me "Tater Salad"

Re: Poll about giving blood - possibly controversial

This is not one of those rules I agree with, but I probably wouldn't break it just to donate blood. MAYBE to give to an immediate family member with full disclosure to the doctor, if the doctor would even allow it.

Do they need volunteers for blood drives? Maybe that could be a way for you to contribute since you're unable to donate.

I can't donate for a different reason, and I understand feeling frustrated that you can't donate. If you have the time, maybe see if there's another way to contribute to the cause.

I know safety and health have to be #1 when it comes to donating blood and giving transfusions to other people... I just wish there were some way to do it without having to exclude an entire class of certain people who may or may not be healthy. Like you, I wonder if there are statistics to back it up. I have no idea. I do hope (and assume) there's a reason for the question and it's not just an outdated one... but I don't know. It's always made me a bit uneasy, especially now since we know it can also be transferred to heterosexual people who have never had any same-sex sexual contact.


Message edited 2010-02-12 13:27:14.553000.

Posted 2/12/10 1:26 PM
 

pinkandblue
Our family is complete, maybe

Member since 9/05

32436 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: Poll about giving blood - possibly controversial

I know that the blood is tested for HIV, no matter HOW you answer the questions so I cannot see the harm in donating Chat Icon

Posted 2/12/10 1:33 PM
 

Otherme
Square head cutie pants

Member since 3/06

6899 total posts

Name:

Re: Poll about giving blood - possibly controversial

Posted by pinkandblue

I know that the blood is tested for HIV, no matter HOW you answer the questions so I cannot see the harm in donating Chat Icon



I disagree.. while the rules may seem outdated to some of us, there may be other reasons behind it. To just say 'oh well they'll test for HIV anyway' is irresponsible IMO.

FTR - i too cannot donate since they changed the rules that anyone who lived in the UK during the early 80's may have mad cow disease. Until they enacted that rule in early 2000's i had donated countless number of times. Since then i haven't been able to donate at all and i'm pretty sure i'm clear of Mad Cow disease Chat Icon
however.. it's their rules and if they think the risk of not getting enough blood outweighs the potential for getting diseased blood, that's their perogative

Posted 2/12/10 1:59 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Poll about giving blood - possibly controversial

I would answer the questions honestly. It's not up to me to rationalize that they should or should not take my blood. They ask questions for a good reason & I'd trust that if there was a possiblity that they could use my blood & not jeopardize anyone, they'd do it.

Posted 2/12/10 2:09 PM
 

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Poll about giving blood - possibly controversial

I used to be able to donate blood. The rules changed in the late 90's/early 2000's. Because of ONE case of mad cow disease in France and I lived there when it happened. They started to include other Countries other than the UK.

So I am no longer elligible.

I was a unversal donor and was asked regularly to give blood.

I am NOT going to break the rules. I was trying to help out. If they don't want it anymore..Oh well!!!!!!

But I am quite surprised when they all claim we have a blood shortage. The rules are getting so strict that no wonder we don't have enough blood supplies.

Lots of people have lived 6 months or month in Europe. If only to go to school for for work.

Posted 2/12/10 2:10 PM
 

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: Poll about giving blood - possibly controversial

Posted by pinkandblue

I know that the blood is tested for HIV, no matter HOW you answer the questions so I cannot see the harm in donating Chat Icon



Well the reality is there truly is a window period that HIV may not show in the blood.

Plus, the other reality is, other diseases can surface in the future, that are linked with another disease. So my point is they cannot test for diseases they are not aware of. So this is a second reason to not give blood if you may be in the category, there truly is a window period of about 2 weeks.

For ex...years ago, they tested for Hep A and Hep B. They did not know Hep C existed so they did not test. If anyone was at risk for Hep B, they may not have had it but could have had Hep C. That's how many people contracted Hep C, through transfusions. So if you have ONE disease are at risk for, you never know if another one will surface down the road that you could have and could have exposed someone to.

Am I making sense?

Message edited 2010-02-12 14:58:15.143000.

Posted 2/12/10 2:56 PM
 

pinkandblue
Our family is complete, maybe

Member since 9/05

32436 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: Poll about giving blood - possibly controversial

Posted by Goobster

Posted by pinkandblue

I know that the blood is tested for HIV, no matter HOW you answer the questions so I cannot see the harm in donating Chat Icon



Well the reality is there truly is a window period that HIV may not show in the blood.

Plus, the other reality is, other diseases can surface in the future, that are linked with another disease. So my point is they cannot test for diseases they are not aware of. So this is a second reason to not give blood if you may be in the category, there truly is a window period of about 2 weeks.



true - good points, I stand corrected Chat Icon

Posted 2/12/10 2:57 PM
 

pinkandblue
Our family is complete, maybe

Member since 9/05

32436 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: Poll about giving blood - possibly controversial

Posted by Otherme

Posted by pinkandblue

I know that the blood is tested for HIV, no matter HOW you answer the questions so I cannot see the harm in donating Chat Icon



I disagree.. while the rules may seem outdated to some of us, there may be other reasons behind it. To just say 'oh well they'll test for HIV anyway' is irresponsible IMO.

FTR - i too cannot donate since they changed the rules that anyone who lived in the UK during the early 80's may have mad cow disease. Until they enacted that rule in early 2000's i had donated countless number of times. Since then i haven't been able to donate at all and i'm pretty sure i'm clear of Mad Cow disease Chat Icon
however.. it's their rules and if they think the risk of not getting enough blood outweighs the potential for getting diseased blood, that's their perogative




valid point, I agree.....can I take back my post and change my mind Chat Icon - I donate all the time and answer the questions truthfully

Posted 2/12/10 2:58 PM
 

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: Poll about giving blood - possibly controversial

Posted by pinkandblue

Posted by Goobster

Posted by pinkandblue

I know that the blood is tested for HIV, no matter HOW you answer the questions so I cannot see the harm in donating Chat Icon



Well the reality is there truly is a window period that HIV may not show in the blood.

Plus, the other reality is, other diseases can surface in the future, that are linked with another disease. So my point is they cannot test for diseases they are not aware of. So this is a second reason to not give blood if you may be in the category, there truly is a window period of about 2 weeks.



true - good points, I stand corrected Chat Icon



See above, I added more info, a concrete example.

Posted 2/12/10 2:58 PM
 

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: Poll about giving blood - possibly controversial

Posted by AnonyMouse

TR, I have always been pretty taken aback by the fact that they still ask this question today. HIV and STDs really aren't just something affecting the gay population. Plenty of straight people who have never had a same sex relationship contract STDs and HIV. but I have never broken the rules and lied to donate blood since I became a member of this category.


I can see where you might think this. But the reality is it is a VERY valid question to be asked. The type of sexual intercourse that homosexual males typically have is deemed more risky than vaginal sex, due to the possibility to break blood vessels, etc. Def more of a risky behavior re disease transmission so they do need to ask this question.

Do they ask if you have had non vaginal sex or no? I never gave blood so I dont know.

Message edited 2010-02-12 15:08:34.660000.

Posted 2/12/10 3:08 PM
 

Kara
Now Zagat Rated!

Member since 3/07

13217 total posts

Name:
They call me "Tater Salad"

Re: Poll about giving blood - possibly controversial

Posted by Goobster

Posted by pinkandblue

I know that the blood is tested for HIV, no matter HOW you answer the questions so I cannot see the harm in donating Chat Icon



Well the reality is there truly is a window period that HIV may not show in the blood.

Plus, the other reality is, other diseases can surface in the future, that are linked with another disease. So my point is they cannot test for diseases they are not aware of. So this is a second reason to not give blood if you may be in the category, there truly is a window period of about 2 weeks.

For ex...years ago, they tested for Hep A and Hep B. They did not know Hep C existed so they did not test. If anyone was at risk for Hep B, they may not have had it but could have had Hep C. That's how many people contracted Hep C, through transfusions. So if you have ONE disease are at risk for, you never know if another one will surface down the road that you could have and could have exposed someone to.

Am I making sense?



I understand the testing issues, but this also applies to heterosexual people. I still want to know the statistics regarding whether or not a gay man (or a man who has had sex with another man) is that more likely to be HIV positive than a heterosexual person. I'm asking honestly - I just don't know.

Also, in the OP's case, it's been ten YEARS since the homosexual sex and she and the man have been monogomous ever since... However, both are basically banned from giving for life (or for her, until they have been apart more than a year).

I don't doubt that there is a valid reason for the rule / question. I just don't understand it personally. My assumption is that statistically gay men are at higher risk for contracting HIV/AIDS.

What is more puzzling to me, though, is that a woman can donate blood a year after having sex with a man who has had sex with a man... but the man can never donate again after having sex with another man once...

Message edited 2010-02-12 15:14:06.780000.

Posted 2/12/10 3:09 PM
 

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Poll about giving blood - possibly controversial

Posted by Goobster

Posted by pinkandblue

Posted by Goobster

Posted by pinkandblue

I know that the blood is tested for HIV, no matter HOW you answer the questions so I cannot see the harm in donating Chat Icon



Well the reality is there truly is a window period that HIV may not show in the blood.

Plus, the other reality is, other diseases can surface in the future, that are linked with another disease. So my point is they cannot test for diseases they are not aware of. So this is a second reason to not give blood if you may be in the category, there truly is a window period of about 2 weeks.



true - good points, I stand corrected Chat Icon



See above, I added more info, a concrete example.



I contracted malaria when in Africa. That's one of their questions. They are on the lookout for HIV/AIDS but they are looking at the whole picture of other disease.

Honeslty, I don't blame them. Imagine you need blood forthe surgery of a loved one and they contract HEP C because of donated blood.

Posted 2/12/10 3:11 PM
 

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: Poll about giving blood - possibly controversial

Posted by Kara

Posted by Goobster

Posted by pinkandblue

I know that the blood is tested for HIV, no matter HOW you answer the questions so I cannot see the harm in donating Chat Icon



Well the reality is there truly is a window period that HIV may not show in the blood.

Plus, the other reality is, other diseases can surface in the future, that are linked with another disease. So my point is they cannot test for diseases they are not aware of. So this is a second reason to not give blood if you may be in the category, there truly is a window period of about 2 weeks.

For ex...years ago, they tested for Hep A and Hep B. They did not know Hep C existed so they did not test. If anyone was at risk for Hep B, they may not have had it but could have had Hep C. That's how many people contracted Hep C, through transfusions. So if you have ONE disease are at risk for, you never know if another one will surface down the road that you could have and could have exposed someone to.

Am I making sense?



I understand the testing issues, but this also applies to heterosexual people. I still want to know the statistics regarding whether or not a gay man (or a man who has had sex with another man) is more likely to be HIV positive than a heterosexual person. I'm asking honestly - I just don't know.




Absolutely. Anal sex is deemed absolutely more risky, due to the fragile and vascular nature of the colon. In addition, in the homosexual population, it is much more commonplace to have multiple partners. So anal sex is the most risky, then vaginal sex, then oral sex. It's all about blood supply, lack of oxygen and blood to blood contact (or other infected bodily fluid, blood having the highest percentage of virus particles) that are the ingredients needed to pass the virus along to someone else.

So anal sex is a very prominent way to contract HIV. So it is a very valid question to ask if someone is a homosexual male practicing anal sex.

Message edited 2010-02-12 15:16:32.613000.

Posted 2/12/10 3:13 PM
 

SusiBee
. . . . .

Member since 3/09

8268 total posts

Name:
S

Re: Poll about giving blood - possibly controversial

During my mother's illness, she received a number of blood transfusions. I was able to bank some of my blood for her, but not enough.

It is a really scary thought that someone who donated blood may have lied about their health just so that they could continue to donate, thereby jeopardizing the fragile health of someone else.

It is a great thing to donate blood - it helps so many people in need.

Posted 2/12/10 3:16 PM
 

Kara
Now Zagat Rated!

Member since 3/07

13217 total posts

Name:
They call me "Tater Salad"

Re: Poll about giving blood - possibly controversial

Posted by Goobster

Posted by Kara

Posted by Goobster

Posted by pinkandblue

I know that the blood is tested for HIV, no matter HOW you answer the questions so I cannot see the harm in donating Chat Icon



Well the reality is there truly is a window period that HIV may not show in the blood.

Plus, the other reality is, other diseases can surface in the future, that are linked with another disease. So my point is they cannot test for diseases they are not aware of. So this is a second reason to not give blood if you may be in the category, there truly is a window period of about 2 weeks.

For ex...years ago, they tested for Hep A and Hep B. They did not know Hep C existed so they did not test. If anyone was at risk for Hep B, they may not have had it but could have had Hep C. That's how many people contracted Hep C, through transfusions. So if you have ONE disease are at risk for, you never know if another one will surface down the road that you could have and could have exposed someone to.

Am I making sense?



I understand the testing issues, but this also applies to heterosexual people. I still want to know the statistics regarding whether or not a gay man (or a man who has had sex with another man) is more likely to be HIV positive than a heterosexual person. I'm asking honestly - I just don't know.




Absolutely. Anal sex is deemed absolutely more risky, due to the fragile and vascular nature of the colon. In addition, in the homosexual population, it is much more commonplace to have multiple partners. So anal sex is the most risky, then vaginal sex, then oral sex. It's all about blood supply, lack of oxygen and blood to blood contact.

So anal sex is a very prominent way to contract HIV.



I understand that, but as a population, are gay men more likely to have HIV than heterosexual people or lesbians? I understand the behavior is higher risk for contracting it, but does it in fact translate today to a population of people who have higher instances of HIV such that the entire population of people is that much riskier? I wouldn't be surprised if it did, but I haven't see any statistics to back it up. (And, in 2007, statistics WERE given to the ARC (I think) attempting to prove that it was not unsafe to allow gay men to donate blood. Of course, the ARC didn't accept it as enough proof... so I don't know exactly what the statistics show.)

Also, what I edited to add to my post... Why can a woman who has has sex with a man who has had sex with a man donate a year later -- but the man can never donate again, even if he never has sex with another man again?

Message edited 2010-02-12 15:17:48.173000.

Posted 2/12/10 3:16 PM
 

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: Poll about giving blood - possibly controversial

Posted by Kara

I understand that, but as a population, are gay men more likely to have HIV than heterosexual people or lesbians? I understand the behavior is higher risk for contracting it, but does it in fact translate today to a population of people who have higher instances of HIV?

Also, what I edited to add to my post... Why can a woman who has has sex with a man who has had sex with a man donate a year later -- but the man can never donate again, even if he never has sex with another man again?



Yes, gay men or anyone who has sex with multiple partners, or riskier type sexual behaviors remain the most at risk.

I think they just have to make blanket rules to just eliminate the riskiest population, kwim? Odds are if you are a man who is homosexual you will have sex again with another man. If you are a woman who is straight, you may not have sex with a man who had sex with another man, ever again, kwim?

Posted 2/12/10 3:19 PM
 
Pages: [1] 2 3
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Controversial Question/Topic - Banking your newborns cord blood gabbie83 1/6/09 5 Pregnancy
Harry Potter and the Half Blood Prince Moehick 7/9/05 28 StoryBoard
Just an update - more blood and DHs SA MrsJ 7/9/05 6 TTC
Progesterone blood test dm24angel 6/8/05 4 TTC
Blood drive HarleyGirlFLA 6/4/05 0 Families Helping Families ™
Cord Blood Registry emc 6/4/05 5 Pregnancy