your baby can read

Posted By Message

Stephybaby
Love my two girls!!

Member since 11/07

1966 total posts

Name:
Stephy

your baby can read

anyone have them? are they a crock of sh!t or what?


i cant see a 15 month old reading when they cant even form sentences!

Posted 1/12/10 7:16 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

itsbabytime
LIF Adult

Member since 11/05

9644 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: your baby can read

I can see it happening b/c what they are doing is really straight memorization of the letter pattern. When DS was around 16 months he could spell and recognize his name wherever he saw it - was he "reading it" - no, but, he has an excellent memory and could remember the letter sequence and the look of the name. B/c of this I thought about it but, everything I read and the teachers in my family said its not the greatest way to learn to read - its better for them to learn the old fashion way - the letters and their sounds and sound it out. So, I never got it. HTH!

Posted 1/12/10 7:41 PM
 

Michmouse
LIF Adult

Member since 11/07

1260 total posts

Name:

Re: your baby can read

It works. My nineteen month has been doing the program for four months and can verbally read 14 words consistently. He also responds to a dozen others. (For example, sticking out his tongue when he sees the word tongue, pointing to the correct word when prompted when three words are presented.)

It is AMAZING! I am a Special Ed/Reading teacher and the infomercial interested me. I have done the program with my DS as directed and the outcome results are incredible! We brought the cards to a family party over the weekend and everyone was shocked. What nineteen month old reads? I also believe the language based program and activities enabled DS to speak much sooner than most other children his age. He has over 200 words now. This program is laying an excellent foundation on which to build.

LOVE IT!

ETA: In response to the above post, learning to read involves many, many sight words than can not be sounded out. www.starfall.com is great site to use for learning letter sounds in conjunction with the MBCR program. Manipulatives of letters are also highly recommended. Anyone who would like more info. please feel free to ask.

Chat Icon

Message edited 2010-01-12 20:11:33.370000.

Posted 1/12/10 8:08 PM
 

nov04libride
big brother <3

Member since 5/05

14672 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: your baby can read

Posted by itsbabytime
B/c of this I thought about it but, everything I read and the teachers in my family said its not the greatest way to learn to read - its better for them to learn the old fashioned way - the letters and their sounds and sound it out. So, I never got it. HTH!



I agree with this. As an educator, word recognition does not really help babies to read any sooner than other babies. I think any English teacher would tell you it's not the best way to teach babies.

In the end, reading is about sounding out letters and learning how to form words from sound patterns, etc.--the DVDs just teach sight recognition.

Message edited 2010-01-12 20:11:17.223000.

Posted 1/12/10 8:10 PM
 

Goldi0218
My miracles!

Member since 12/05

23902 total posts

Name:
Leslie

Re: your baby can read

Im a special ed teacher too and I hate the idea of it. I would be more concerned over comprehension than decoding skills. I don't think this gives a child an edge in any way.

Posted 1/12/10 8:11 PM
 

Missy
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

1038 total posts

Name:
missy

Re: your baby can read

I am a reading teacher and actually there is a Dolch sight word list with over 100 words on it that can't be sounded out. Not every word can be decoded, therefore; memorization is required..that being said, I borrowed the 1st DVD and my son showed no interest in itChat Icon

Posted 1/12/10 8:24 PM
 

Jacksmommy
My love muffin!

Member since 1/07

5819 total posts

Name:
Liz

Re: your baby can read

I am against this for the pure reason that when do we let our kids be kids. in KINDERGARTEN the expectations are SOOOOO great. Why do we feel the need to have BABIES read????? It is nice to see, but why can't babies learn to read through play and incidental learning. This program drives me nuts.
As a side note it also drives me nuts to see people saying how their kid knows the alphabet or colors by 1 1/2 yet the kid can't follow a one step direction or can't play with toys appropriately.

I think we push our kids too much. JMO!

Posted 1/12/10 9:48 PM
 

Michmouse
LIF Adult

Member since 11/07

1260 total posts

Name:

Re: your baby can read

Posted by Jacksmommy

I am against this for the pure reason that when do we let our kids be kids. in KINDERGARTEN the expectations are SOOOOO great. Why do we feel the need to have BABIES read????? It is nice to see, but why can't babies learn to read through play and incidental learning. This program drives me nuts.
As a side note it also drives me nuts to see people saying how their kid knows the alphabet or colors by 1 1/2 yet the kid can't follow a one step direction or can't play with toys appropriately.

I think we push our kids too much. JMO!



As a teacher and the parent of a senior in high school and a baby I completely agree with your comment that expectations are extremely high for kids in today's society. My daughter has a 96 average over four years of high school (multiple AP courses as well) and she is not in the top 10% of her Half Hollow Hills graduating class. Can you imagine? It is so competitive and extremely high expectations are placed on our children and they need to hear from their parents that a balanced life is really what brings success. Kids are so overwhelmed that sports, drama, church and other learning based activities often need to take a back seat to classroom academics. Don 't even get me started on the hours of homework given in elementary school in the HHH school district.

That said, The MBCR program is not about raising the bar for my DS. He LOVES learning and doing the activities and asks to do them. This is not forced or an unpleasant experience....It is play! As I posted earlier I beleive this program is largely responsible for his extensive vocabulary as well. I feel this program is laying an excellent foundation on which to build. When a child enters kindergarten and they are well prepared they feel successful. This is of critical importance as it sets the stage for positive school expereinces. A child who feels successful is successful...KWIM?

Anyway, to each their own. I LOVE this program and highly recommend it to everyone.

Message edited 2010-01-13 09:11:26.010000.

Posted 1/13/10 9:06 AM
 

WNA01
my 2 boys

Member since 10/08

4240 total posts

Name:

Re: your baby can read

Posted by Jacksmommy

I am against this for the pure reason that when do we let our kids be kids. in KINDERGARTEN the expectations are SOOOOO great. Why do we feel the need to have BABIES read????? It is nice to see, but why can't babies learn to read through play and incidental learning. This program drives me nuts.
As a side note it also drives me nuts to see people saying how their kid knows the alphabet or colors by 1 1/2 yet the kid can't follow a one step direction or can't play with toys appropriately.

I think we push our kids too much. JMO!



Chat Icon Chat Icon well said! couldnt have said it better myself!

Posted 1/13/10 9:33 AM
 

ReiRei13
Life is Good!!

Member since 1/08

6460 total posts

Name:

Re: your baby can read

ITA with michmouse on everything! I also have the program and love it!!Chat Icon

Posted 1/13/10 9:40 AM
 

pickles16
Real Estate Professional

Member since 11/07

17227 total posts

Name:
Jen

Re: your baby can read

Posted by Michmouse

Posted by Jacksmommy

I am against this for the pure reason that when do we let our kids be kids. in KINDERGARTEN the expectations are SOOOOO great. Why do we feel the need to have BABIES read????? It is nice to see, but why can't babies learn to read through play and incidental learning. This program drives me nuts.
As a side note it also drives me nuts to see people saying how their kid knows the alphabet or colors by 1 1/2 yet the kid can't follow a one step direction or can't play with toys appropriately.

I think we push our kids too much. JMO!



As a teacher and the parent of a senior in high school and a baby I completely agree with your comment that expectations are extremely high for kids in today's society. My daughter has a 96 average over four years of high school (multiple AP courses as well) and she is not in the top 10% of her Half Hollow Hills graduating class. Can you imagine? It is so competitive and extremely high expectations are placed on our children and they need to hear from their parents that a balanced life is really what brings success. Kids are so overwhelmed that sports, drama, church and other learning based activities often need to take a back seat to classroom academics. Don 't even get me started on the hours of homework given in elementary school in the HHH school district.

That said, The MBCR program is not about raising the bar for my DS. He LOVES learning and doing the activities and asks to do them. This is not forced or an unpleasant experience....It is play! As I posted earlier I beleive this program is largely responsible for his extensive vocabulary as well. I feel this program is laying an excellent foundation on which to build. When a child enters kindergarten and they are well prepared they feel successful. This is of critical importance as it sets the stage for positive school expereinces. A child who feels successful is successful...KWIM?

Anyway, to each their own. I LOVE this program and highly recommend it to everyone.



ITA with all your points!!! I was toying with the idea of looking into this...my parents are off the boat from EuropeChat Icon and were and still shocked at how late kids do things in the US. Is it a cultural thing absolutely, do I think it's a bit much from them and what they expect kids to do there absolutely, at the same time I do see their points, and to your poiint, that I do think it gives children confidence which in turn leads to them wanting to know more, and learn, etc...

Posted 1/13/10 9:44 AM
 

josie919
Here we go!

Member since 2/08

1108 total posts

Name:
Josie

Re: your baby can read

I hope I don't get yelled at lol BUT IN MY OPINION.... I will rely on the good ol' fashioned way of teaching DD to read. I 100% do not disagree with what the teachers have posted, I am not a teacher, so what the hell do I know really, however.... i'm a firm believer in 'they will do it when they are ready'.

Granted, if my daughter was showing signs of a delay, I think I would give it a whirl. But for now, I can't see having her learn to 'READ' when she barely SPEAKS.

To the poster (mich??) who said their DC is reading from the program.... I think your child is advanced and that's super cool. I can't even imagine my 15 month old reading. I can't go back and read your post while typing mine, but I think in another post you mentioned your older DD being in AP classes..... that's great and she should be so proud of herself. The fact that she isn't in the top 10% wows me Chat Icon , but I hope she knows she is one smart cookie Chat Icon

ETA: I think it's all about balance. If my DD could read by 20 months, but wasn't doing the other things that were developmentally appropriate for a 20 month old, then I think it's a bad idea. I'm going to assume (and we all know what that means) however, i'm going to assume that the babies who can read early on, were also early babblers and possibly hit other milestones early on. My DD, not so much Chat Icon

Message edited 2010-01-13 09:48:45.470000.

Posted 1/13/10 9:45 AM
 

Celt
~~~~~~~~~~

Member since 4/08

7758 total posts

Name:
colette

Re: your baby can read

The whole idea of it freaks me out. Chat Icon And someone is getting very rich off of it...

Now, "Your Baby Can Cook" -- THAT would be awesome!!!!!Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 1/13/10 9:48 AM
 

pickles16
Real Estate Professional

Member since 11/07

17227 total posts

Name:
Jen

Re: your baby can read

Posted by colette

The whole idea of it freaks me out. Chat Icon And someone is getting very rich off of it...

Now, "Your Baby Can Cook" -- THAT would be awesome!!!!!Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon



I like " your baby can clean up after themselves better to be honest"...


Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 1/13/10 9:53 AM
 

eddiesmommy
best buds!

Member since 5/09

11524 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: your baby can read

Posted by Jacksmommy

I am against this for the pure reason that when do we let our kids be kids. in KINDERGARTEN the expectations are SOOOOO great. Why do we feel the need to have BABIES read????? It is nice to see, but why can't babies learn to read through play and incidental learning. This program drives me nuts.
As a side note it also drives me nuts to see people saying how their kid knows the alphabet or colors by 1 1/2 yet the kid can't follow a one step direction or can't play with toys appropriately.

I think we push our kids too much. JMO!



I COMPLETELY agree! I think its out of hand and a one year old doesnt need the pressure of being drilled on learning to read. They have enough to learn at that age......its ridiculous in my opinion.

Plus, with the exception of some words that cannot be sounded out, memorizing a word is not reading. Just bc a child can recognize the word doesnt mean when he gets to kindergarten he is going to be any more able than his peers to read a word he has never seen before bc he will not have the fundamentals that are needed for reading.

Posted 1/13/10 9:59 AM
 

pinkandblue
Our family is complete, maybe

Member since 9/05

32436 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: your baby can read

Posted by Jacksmommy

I am against this for the pure reason that when do we let our kids be kids. in KINDERGARTEN the expectations are SOOOOO great. Why do we feel the need to have BABIES read????? It is nice to see, but why can't babies learn to read through play and incidental learning. This program drives me nuts.
As a side note it also drives me nuts to see people saying how their kid knows the alphabet or colors by 1 1/2 yet the kid can't follow a one step direction or can't play with toys appropriately.

I think we push our kids too much. JMO!



I agree 1000000000% ...I think it is silly....

Message edited 2010-01-13 10:29:14.610000.

Posted 1/13/10 10:05 AM
 

ReiRei13
Life is Good!!

Member since 1/08

6460 total posts

Name:

Re: your baby can read

I don't understand why everyone would be so against this program!! I don't see what the big deal is, the DVDs are fun and my DS truly enjoys them! Whats the difference if he watches MBCR or Little Bill???? I read to my son every night anyway, whats the big deal if I read one of the MBCR books with the mix of other books!!?? I personally think its great that he's being exposed to the written language at such an early age! I am by no means forcing anything down his throat, or stopping him from being a typical 11 month old!

Posted 1/13/10 10:18 AM
 

Celt
~~~~~~~~~~

Member since 4/08

7758 total posts

Name:
colette

Re: your baby can read

Hi Marie, I don't think anyone is saying they "harm" the child, I don't feel that at all at all. But I think there are many parents out there, not like you, who would be tempted to replace actual "reading" time with this program, and that could potentially cause a problem later.
There's no real danger of "harming" the child's development by using a video IMHO as long as it doesn't replace the tried and true method of reading/talking to baby Chat Icon

Posted 1/13/10 10:21 AM
 

josie919
Here we go!

Member since 2/08

1108 total posts

Name:
Josie

Re: your baby can read

Posted by MrsP747

I don't understand why everyone would be so against this program!! I don't see what the big deal is, the DVDs are fun and my DS truly enjoys them! Whats the difference if he watches MBCR or Little Bill???? I read to my son every night anyway, whats the big deal if I read one of the MBCR books with the mix of other books!!?? I personally think its great that he's being exposed to the written language at such an early age! I am by no means forcing anything down his throat, or stopping him from being a typical 11 month old!



I speak only for myself, but I think it should be a personal decision based off your own DC's development. If my DD was speaking more, I think I would consider it. I think it's going to get drastically mixed reviews no matter what. If it works and your DS likes it, awesome. I know my DD can't be bothered with any of those Einstein DVD's or TV in general, so that leads me to think it wouldn't work for her. But if it works for your DC, go for it.

Posted 1/13/10 10:23 AM
 

ReiRei13
Life is Good!!

Member since 1/08

6460 total posts

Name:

Re: your baby can read

Posted by colette

Hi Marie, I don't think anyone is saying they "harm" the child, I don't feel that at all at all. But I think there are many parents out there, not like you, who would be tempted to replace actual "reading" time with this program, and that could potentially cause a problem later.
There's no real danger of "harming" the child's development by using a video IMHO as long as it doesn't replace the tried and true method of reading/talking to baby Chat Icon



I hear ya! I think it'd be a shame, if a parent thought that this program would be a replacement for actually reading and speaking to your baby! Chat Icon

Posted 1/13/10 10:27 AM
 

pinkandblue
Our family is complete, maybe

Member since 9/05

32436 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: your baby can read

Posted by colette


There's no real danger of "harming" the child's development by using a video IMHO as long as it doesn't replace the tried and true method of reading/talking to baby Chat Icon



I agree, and I just think that kids at that age should be read to "the old fashioned way"...learn their sounds the old fashioned way, etc

too much, too soon, IMHO but I do not begrudge anyone for using the system if they choose to

Posted 1/13/10 10:28 AM
 

eroxgirl
My Loves

Member since 5/05

15697 total posts

Name:
Rebecca

Re: your baby can read

We bought this program and returned it. My DH was all for it but I really was not.

But my DH comes from a family where they don't put any pressure whatsoever on their kids to read, to study, to do well in school beyond basic passing grades and so he wanted to make sure he's a different parent.

I come from a family where nothing less than a B is acceptable and it's expected that you'll be in the top of your class (my hs career was a major disappointment), and nearly every member of my family learned how to read by the time they were 3 years old. As far as I'm concerned my DD will likely follow in my footsteps because she's already showing the signs. I have no desire to push it more.

I'm not an educator, but I was also uncomfortable with the memorization required rather than the sounding out of the words. I'm glad to see that others agree with me.

Posted 1/13/10 10:47 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
SO FUNNY- Baby names- You have to read this thread mamaA 9/17/07 1 Parenting
i read the entire baby laughs book tonight!! raken40 7/26/07 6 Pregnancy
when can we read to the baby? Bklyngrl 5/6/07 6 Pregnancy
Anyone read the book The Baby Whisperer? Charly 1/10/07 9 Parenting
Want to get ready to read to the baby (belly) Ang-Rich 12/7/06 15 Pregnancy
anyone read the baby whisperer? 04bride 10/7/06 10 Parenting