WWYD: Do YOU think this is FAIR?
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: [1] 2 | |
|
WWYD: Do YOU think this is FAIR? My friend just called me in regards to her DS who is in the second grade - she wanted to vent and was looking for my opinion. A little bit about her DS: he has an IEP and is diagnosed with Executive disorder. He has trouble following directions and listening at home and in school. He is also involved a social group at school. Message edited 2010-01-07 13:23:17.980000. |
|
Posted 1/7/10 1:22 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: WWYD: Do YOU think this is FAIR? I don't have a school aged child, but I do not think it is unfair. Message edited 2010-01-07 13:28:26.660000. |
|
Posted 1/7/10 1:26 PM
|
|
|
Re: WWYD: Do YOU think this is FAIR? Posted by KateDevine I don't have a school aged child, but I do not think it is unfair. Just because he has special needs doesn't mean that he doesn't have to follow the rules. As for the parents being called, I don't know that the protocol is in that school, it is only one day of detention, IMO, is not a totally outrageous punishment Same... Also, its really hard to judge unless you see the child on a day to day basis...JMO |
|
Posted 1/7/10 1:27 PM
|
|
|
Re: WWYD: Do YOU think this is FAIR? It's a tough call...I do agree with the above poster that he shouldn't be treated that much differently than other kids, BUT if HONESTLY didn't know why he was sent down to the principles office, then it should have been explained to him and maybe given a warning and not detention...JMO |
|
Posted 1/7/10 1:30 PM
|
|
|
Re: WWYD: Do YOU think this is FAIR? Posted by KateDevine I don't have a school aged child, but I do not think it is unfair. Just because he has special needs doesn't mean that he doesn't have to follow the rules. As for the parents being called, I don't know that the protocol is in that school, it is only one day of detention, IMO, is not a totally outrageous punishment ETA-What does is IEP say about who has to be present at meetings? I agree, but I DO think that the parent should have been called...no matter what...he is only in 2nd grade, not high school |
|
Posted 1/7/10 1:31 PM
|
|
|
Re: WWYD: Do YOU think this is FAIR? I don't have a school aged child either but I think that if this is the punishment any child would have received for the same actions then it is reasonable. |
|
Posted 1/7/10 1:31 PM
|
|
|
Re: WWYD: Do YOU think this is FAIR? I don't think parents should be called for every little thing. The situation as you described it doesn't seem severe enough for a parent to get a phone call. Since the child has an IEP I believe the IEP should have some intruction on discipline protocol. Exmaple: Child gets 3 verbal warnings before consequence instead of 2 for regular ed children...etc... KWIM? |
|
Posted 1/7/10 1:36 PM
|
|
|
Re: WWYD: Do YOU think this is FAIR? WOW....very interesting opinions. I guess because I know the child, my feelings are a lot different! He is so very sensitive, passive, and innocent. Knowing all of his traits, makes it very easy for me to think the punishment was harsh. He already was taken out of Art to be sent to the principles; which is intimidating on its own. If I were the aide, I would have removed him from the class, explained to him about the talking policy, and ASKED him if he understood. I guess the aide didn't know of his needs; if he had, he may have done things a little different. |
|
Posted 1/7/10 1:36 PM
|
|
|
Re: WWYD: Do YOU think this is FAIR? Posted by KateDevine I don't have a school aged child, but I do not think it is unfair. Just because he has special needs doesn't mean that he doesn't have to follow the rules. As for the parents being called, I don't know that the protocol is in that school, it is only one day of detention, IMO, is not a totally outrageous punishment ETA-What does is IEP say about who has to be present at meetings? ITA. |
|
Posted 1/7/10 1:40 PM
|
|
|
Re: WWYD: Do YOU think this is FAIR? Without knowing what Executive disorder is - as long as they followed the protocol of his plan, I think it's fair. For some reason I imagine Executive disorder along the lines of executives which talk alot & rarely pay attention.. |
|
Posted 1/7/10 1:43 PM
|
|
|
Re: WWYD: Do YOU think this is FAIR? Posted by pig22seal WOW....very interesting opinions. I guess because I know the child, my feelings are a lot different! He is so very sensitive, passive, and innocent. Knowing all of his traits, makes it very easy for me to think the punishment was harsh. He already was taken out of Art to be sent to the principles; which is intimidating on its own. If I were the aide, I would have removed him from the class, explained to him about the talking policy, and ASKED him if he understood. I guess the aide didn't know of his needs; if he had, he may have done things a little different. When did this class start? Has he been in this Art class since September or did it just start? If he has been in this class since the beginning of the school year, then he should be aware of the talking policy... But even if the class just started, I don't think that it was an unreasonable punishment. One day of detention during recess (IMO) isn't a big deal |
|
Posted 1/7/10 1:46 PM
|
|
|
Re: WWYD: Do YOU think this is FAIR? I also do not have school age children but I do think the school was fair in their decision. |
|
Posted 1/7/10 2:00 PM
|
|
|
Re: WWYD: Do YOU think this is FAIR? So he knew what he was doing was wrong? Message edited 2010-01-07 14:02:48.227000. |
|
Posted 1/7/10 2:01 PM
|
|
|
Re: WWYD: Do YOU think this is FAIR? This is much of what my office handles (office for civil rights with the US department of education) - we get a lot of complaints about discipline with regard to students with disabilities. |
|
Posted 1/7/10 2:03 PM
|
|
|
Re: WWYD: Do YOU think this is FAIR? Posted by babyonthebrain I don't think parents should be called for every little thing. The situation as you described it doesn't seem severe enough for a parent to get a phone call. Since the child has an IEP I believe the IEP should have some intruction on discipline protocol. Exmaple: Child gets 3 verbal warnings before consequence instead of 2 for regular ed children...etc... KWIM? I can see why the child thinks his aide doesn't like him. The aide is constantly with him. I bet the aide is often the disciplinarian. The child might think he doesn't like him because he's always telling him to do something he doesn't want to do EX:stop talking, keep hands to yourself etc... 1 day seems fair ro me. ITA with this. Talking during class doesn't warrant a parent call, and one day of detention from recess seems like an appropriate punishment. |
|
Posted 1/7/10 2:03 PM
|
|
|
Re: WWYD: Do YOU think this is FAIR? I will not comment on fair or not since I was not there and do not know the student. I have learned a long time ago that what seems unfair is really logical if you are in the situation at the time. |
|
Posted 1/7/10 2:04 PM
|
|
|
Re: WWYD: Do YOU think this is FAIR? Posted by Leeners I don't have a school aged child either but I think that if this is the punishment any child would have received for the same actions then it is reasonable. I don't believe in treating children differently - JMO. I agree Tho I do believe they should have called the parents. Oh and I think the sex of the aide makes no diff |
|
Posted 1/7/10 2:33 PM
|
|
|
Re: WWYD: Do YOU think this is FAIR? Absolutely fair - I think they treated him the same they would any other child in the class who was not following instructions - |
|
Posted 1/7/10 2:42 PM
|
|
|
Re: WWYD: Do YOU think this is FAIR? Posted by MarisaK I DO think the part about calling the kid a 'liar' is inappropriate though .........Did they actually say that to him? I didn't see this, didn't they ask him why he lied? Maybe I'm misreading? |
|
Posted 1/7/10 2:46 PM
|
|
|
Re: WWYD: Do YOU think this is FAIR? If the school followed what is in his IEP, then I think it's fair. As the parent, though, I would want to know, is the detention for the talking or the lying? I think the detention would have been sufficient. If he was unclear on the rules, I think a conversation with a warning in the principal's office would be enough for that. I think writing the essay and the detention is a little over the top for a 2nd grader, but I would think the same if he was a typical child. |
|
Posted 1/7/10 2:50 PM
|
|
|
Re: WWYD: Do YOU think this is FAIR? I think having a kid with executive functioning disorder write a paragraph about why he lied is a bit much. Is that what the school told her, or her son? Message edited 2010-01-07 14:56:46.430000. |
|
Posted 1/7/10 2:53 PM
|
|
|
Re: WWYD: Do YOU think this is FAIR? As a teacher, I try not to form a judgment unless I was there for the incident. I tend to trust the school's decision in most cases, as I feel the majority of principals really are looking out for the welfare of the children....especially in elementary school. |
|
Posted 1/7/10 2:54 PM
|
|
|
Re: WWYD: Do YOU think this is FAIR? Message edited 2010-01-07 14:56:18.437000. |
|
Posted 1/7/10 2:56 PM
|
|
|
Re: WWYD: Do YOU think this is FAIR? It's VERY VERY hard to get the 'story' from a second grader... Apparently my fourth grader does 'nothing' all day in school. |
|
Posted 1/7/10 3:15 PM
|
|
|
Re: WWYD: Do YOU think this is FAIR? Posted by brownie Posted by KateDevine I don't have a school aged child, but I do not think it is unfair. Just because he has special needs doesn't mean that he doesn't have to follow the rules. As for the parents being called, I don't know that the protocol is in that school, it is only one day of detention, IMO, is not a totally outrageous punishment Same... Also, its really hard to judge unless you see the child on a day to day basis...JMO completely agree |
|
Posted 1/7/10 3:24 PM
|
|
| Pages: [1] 2 | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| MOST LIKELY NOT-But will anyone be going to China to the Canton or Hong Kong Fair? | aliasPook | 10/21/06 | 1 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Anyone going to the Fair in Riverhead on Sunday? | Holly | 10/3/06 | 3 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| SAT. 9/30 - Children's Festival and Crafts Fair *Crab Meadow Beach | 4monkeys | 9/29/06 | 3 | Parenting |
| Craft fair at the Bellmore train station this weekend. | Jax430 | 9/15/06 | 10 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Fair at Suffolk Comm. College.... | Diane | 8/21/06 | 5 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| My fair Brady they plan a wedding is coming soon. | HarleyGirlFLA | 5/27/06 | 4 | Families Helping Families ™ |



. He also stressed to his parents that the aide (which happens to be a male) doesn't like him.


















