WWYD: Do YOU think this is FAIR?

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

pig22seal
LOVE MY 2 BOYS!

Member since 5/07

1877 total posts

Name:
Carissa

WWYD: Do YOU think this is FAIR?

My friend just called me in regards to her DS who is in the second grade - she wanted to vent and was looking for my opinion. A little bit about her DS: he has an IEP and is diagnosed with Executive disorder. He has trouble following directions and listening at home and in school. He is also involved a social group at school.

Yesterday he came home from school and told his parents that he was sent to the principles office and has detention during recess and DOESN'T understand why. My friend received no phone call from the school in regards to this...so she called the school today to find out what happened yesterday.

Apparently, her DS was in Art class. He was talking to a classmate while the teacher was talking. He was told by the aide to stop talking more than once. Eventually he was sent to the principles. When he was asked why he was sent down there, he didn't know. Then he had to write a paragraph on why he lied and said he didn't know; when he did Chat Icon . He also stressed to his parents that the aide (which happens to be a male) doesn't like him.

In the end he was given 1 day of detention during recess. Do you think this was a good decision on behalf of the principle, knowing the special needs this child has? Do you think the social worker or pychologist should have been present? Do you think the principle or teacher should have called the parents?

I don't have a child in school yet; however, I did give her some of my thoughts. Just wanted to know WYWD. TIA Chat Icon

Message edited 2010-01-07 13:23:17.980000.

Posted 1/7/10 1:22 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

KateDevine
*

Member since 6/06

24950 total posts

Name:

Re: WWYD: Do YOU think this is FAIR?

I don't have a school aged child, but I do not think it is unfair.

Just because he has special needs doesn't mean that he doesn't have to follow the rules.

As for the parents being called, I don't know that the protocol is in that school, it is only one day of detention, IMO, is not a totally outrageous punishment Chat Icon

ETA-What does is IEP say about who has to be present at meetings?

Message edited 2010-01-07 13:28:26.660000.

Posted 1/7/10 1:26 PM
 

brownie
Baby #1 is here!

Member since 11/08

13903 total posts

Name:

Re: WWYD: Do YOU think this is FAIR?

Posted by KateDevine

I don't have a school aged child, but I do not think it is unfair.

Just because he has special needs doesn't mean that he doesn't have to follow the rules.

As for the parents being called, I don't know that the protocol is in that school, it is only one day of detention, IMO, is not a totally outrageous punishment Chat Icon



Same...

Also, its really hard to judge unless you see the child on a day to day basis...JMO

Posted 1/7/10 1:27 PM
 

pickles16
Real Estate Professional

Member since 11/07

17227 total posts

Name:
Jen

Re: WWYD: Do YOU think this is FAIR?

It's a tough call...I do agree with the above poster that he shouldn't be treated that much differently than other kids, BUT if HONESTLY didn't know why he was sent down to the principles office, then it should have been explained to him and maybe given a warning and not detention...JMO

Posted 1/7/10 1:30 PM
 

pinkandblue
Our family is complete, maybe

Member since 9/05

32436 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: WWYD: Do YOU think this is FAIR?

Posted by KateDevine

I don't have a school aged child, but I do not think it is unfair.

Just because he has special needs doesn't mean that he doesn't have to follow the rules.

As for the parents being called, I don't know that the protocol is in that school, it is only one day of detention, IMO, is not a totally outrageous punishment Chat Icon

ETA-What does is IEP say about who has to be present at meetings?



I agree, but I DO think that the parent should have been called...no matter what...he is only in 2nd grade, not high school

Posted 1/7/10 1:31 PM
 

Leeners
:)

Member since 5/05

4898 total posts

Name:
Eileen

Re: WWYD: Do YOU think this is FAIR?

I don't have a school aged child either but I think that if this is the punishment any child would have received for the same actions then it is reasonable.

I don't believe in treating children differently - JMO.

Posted 1/7/10 1:31 PM
 

babyonthebrain
Brotherly Love!

Member since 1/08

6209 total posts

Name:
Rafaela

Re: WWYD: Do YOU think this is FAIR?

I don't think parents should be called for every little thing. The situation as you described it doesn't seem severe enough for a parent to get a phone call. Since the child has an IEP I believe the IEP should have some intruction on discipline protocol. Exmaple: Child gets 3 verbal warnings before consequence instead of 2 for regular ed children...etc... KWIM?

I can see why the child thinks his aide doesn't like him. The aide is constantly with him. I bet the aide is often the disciplinarian. The child might think he doesn't like him because he's always telling him to do something he doesn't want to do EX:stop talking, keep hands to yourself etc...
1 day seems fair ro me.

Posted 1/7/10 1:36 PM
 

pig22seal
LOVE MY 2 BOYS!

Member since 5/07

1877 total posts

Name:
Carissa

Re: WWYD: Do YOU think this is FAIR?

WOW....very interesting opinions. I guess because I know the child, my feelings are a lot different! He is so very sensitive, passive, and innocent. Knowing all of his traits, makes it very easy for me to think the punishment was harsh. He already was taken out of Art to be sent to the principles; which is intimidating on its own. If I were the aide, I would have removed him from the class, explained to him about the talking policy, and ASKED him if he understood. I guess the aide didn't know of his needs; if he had, he may have done things a little different.

Posted 1/7/10 1:36 PM
 

eddiesmommy
best buds!

Member since 5/09

11524 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: WWYD: Do YOU think this is FAIR?

Posted by KateDevine

I don't have a school aged child, but I do not think it is unfair.

Just because he has special needs doesn't mean that he doesn't have to follow the rules.

As for the parents being called, I don't know that the protocol is in that school, it is only one day of detention, IMO, is not a totally outrageous punishment Chat Icon

ETA-What does is IEP say about who has to be present at meetings?



ITA.

Posted 1/7/10 1:40 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: WWYD: Do YOU think this is FAIR?

Without knowing what Executive disorder is - as long as they followed the protocol of his plan, I think it's fair. For some reason I imagine Executive disorder along the lines of executives which talk alot & rarely pay attention..

My 6 year old was sent to the principal for refusing to wear her jacket. I thought that was fair too.

Posted 1/7/10 1:43 PM
 

KateDevine
*

Member since 6/06

24950 total posts

Name:

Re: WWYD: Do YOU think this is FAIR?

Posted by pig22seal

WOW....very interesting opinions. I guess because I know the child, my feelings are a lot different! He is so very sensitive, passive, and innocent. Knowing all of his traits, makes it very easy for me to think the punishment was harsh. He already was taken out of Art to be sent to the principles; which is intimidating on its own. If I were the aide, I would have removed him from the class, explained to him about the talking policy, and ASKED him if he understood. I guess the aide didn't know of his needs; if he had, he may have done things a little different.



When did this class start? Has he been in this Art class since September or did it just start?

If he has been in this class since the beginning of the school year, then he should be aware of the talking policy...

But even if the class just started, I don't think that it was an unreasonable punishment. One day of detention during recess (IMO) isn't a big deal

Posted 1/7/10 1:46 PM
 

JerseyMamaOf3
Boo!

Member since 6/05

15144 total posts

Name:

Re: WWYD: Do YOU think this is FAIR?

I also do not have school age children but I do think the school was fair in their decision.
I don't agree that all kids with special needs have to have special treatment, and considering he doesn't listen or pay attention, I think this was a good punishment.
He needs to know that when the aide or the teachers tell him to stop talking there is a consequence for his actions if he doesn't listen.
As far as not contacting the parent. I really don't think that is a big deal either. If someone was injured and he received detention for that, then yes that warrents a call, but not for not listening.
My kids are in nursery school and last year their was a boy in DS's class who was very active and couldn't sit still. He was always in time out and was always sent to the directors office for not listening, hitting. The parent was told about it when the child was picked up. So if a nursery school wouldn't call I would expect an elementary school to.

Posted 1/7/10 2:00 PM
 

nbc188
Best friends!

Member since 12/06

23090 total posts

Name:
C

Re: WWYD: Do YOU think this is FAIR?

So he knew what he was doing was wrong?

IMO, all schools have set standards for how to deal with EVERY student, "typical" students and students with special needs. They've got to have them set in stone to cover their own azzes, KWIM? I'm curious if they followed procedure in this situation.

ETA: All people (children and adults) learn to know there are reprocussions to poor decisions/behavior...I am around a lot of people with developmental disabilities at work, and some are profoundly handicapped...but they still have consequences for misbehaving.

Message edited 2010-01-07 14:02:48.227000.

Posted 1/7/10 2:01 PM
 

Bxgell2
Perfection

Member since 5/05

16438 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: WWYD: Do YOU think this is FAIR?

This is much of what my office handles (office for civil rights with the US department of education) - we get a lot of complaints about discipline with regard to students with disabilities.

I'll tell you this - we look at two items when determining whether the District mishandled the incident: (1) whether it followed the student's plan, and (2) whether it treated the student differently than similarly situated non-disabled students.

So, from our perspective - if there's nothing in his plan that discusses discipline to be meted out in a different manner due to his disability, and as long as they followed protocol with regard to the discpline, so that it is the same for both disabled and non-disabled students, then no, it wouldn't be deemed unfair.

Posted 1/7/10 2:03 PM
 

SweetTooth
I'm a tired mommy!

Member since 12/05

20105 total posts

Name:
Lauren

Re: WWYD: Do YOU think this is FAIR?

Posted by babyonthebrain

I don't think parents should be called for every little thing. The situation as you described it doesn't seem severe enough for a parent to get a phone call. Since the child has an IEP I believe the IEP should have some intruction on discipline protocol. Exmaple: Child gets 3 verbal warnings before consequence instead of 2 for regular ed children...etc... KWIM?

I can see why the child thinks his aide doesn't like him. The aide is constantly with him. I bet the aide is often the disciplinarian. The child might think he doesn't like him because he's always telling him to do something he doesn't want to do EX:stop talking, keep hands to yourself etc...
1 day seems fair ro me.



ITA with this.
Talking during class doesn't warrant a parent call, and one day of detention from recess seems like an appropriate punishment.

Posted 1/7/10 2:03 PM
 

CkGm
They get so big, so fast :(

Member since 5/05

13848 total posts

Name:
Christine

Re: WWYD: Do YOU think this is FAIR?

I will not comment on fair or not since I was not there and do not know the student. I have learned a long time ago that what seems unfair is really logical if you are in the situation at the time.

That being said, it sounds like your friend really needs to call an IEP to discuss how her son will be disciplined in the future and the role of the aide in helping with her child's executive function. He would probably benefit from having a behavior support plan that clearly outlines consequences for this behavior that are logical and fair for his disability.

Hope that helps! Chat Icon

Posted 1/7/10 2:04 PM
 

Xelindrya
Mommy's little YouTube Star!

Member since 8/05

14470 total posts

Name:
Veronica

Re: WWYD: Do YOU think this is FAIR?

Posted by Leeners

I don't have a school aged child either but I think that if this is the punishment any child would have received for the same actions then it is reasonable.

I don't believe in treating children differently - JMO.



I agree

Tho I do believe they should have called the parents.

Oh and I think the sex of the aide makes no diff Chat Icon

Posted 1/7/10 2:33 PM
 

MarisaK
HELLO Manolo !!

Member since 5/06

14562 total posts

Name:
Marisa

Re: WWYD: Do YOU think this is FAIR?

Absolutely fair - I think they treated him the same they would any other child in the class who was not following instructions -

They didn't scream and yell and humiliate the child - They told him to stop talking, and when he didn't, sent him to the principal's office - The whole POINT of the principal's office IS intimidation - You're SUPPOSED to be 'afraid' of getting into trouble - I don't think 1 day's detention from recess is so terrible ..........


I DO think the part about calling the kid a 'liar' is inappropriate though .........Did they actually say that to him?

Posted 1/7/10 2:42 PM
 

KateDevine
*

Member since 6/06

24950 total posts

Name:

Re: WWYD: Do YOU think this is FAIR?

Posted by MarisaK




I DO think the part about calling the kid a 'liar' is inappropriate though .........Did they actually say that to him?



I didn't see this, didn't they ask him why he lied?

Maybe I'm misreading?

Posted 1/7/10 2:46 PM
 

dpli
Daylight savings :)

Member since 5/05

13973 total posts

Name:
D

Re: WWYD: Do YOU think this is FAIR?

If the school followed what is in his IEP, then I think it's fair. As the parent, though, I would want to know, is the detention for the talking or the lying? I think the detention would have been sufficient. If he was unclear on the rules, I think a conversation with a warning in the principal's office would be enough for that. I think writing the essay and the detention is a little over the top for a 2nd grader, but I would think the same if he was a typical child.

Posted 1/7/10 2:50 PM
 

Porrruss
Nya nya nya

Member since 5/05

11618 total posts

Name:
Amy

Re: WWYD: Do YOU think this is FAIR?

I think having a kid with executive functioning disorder write a paragraph about why he lied is a bit much. Is that what the school told her, or her son?

Taking away recess is entirely appropriate. Our school counselor and psychologist don't usually get involved with discipline like that unless it's a serious offense (like bodily harm or threats).

Regardless of his ability to self regulate himself (which is one area affected by EFD), he still needs to be held to the same standards as other "typical" kids. I can guarantee if this is typical for him (unable to follow directions, control behaviors, etc) that even an informal behavior plan is in place (e.g. 2 verbal warnings, then a trip to see the principal).

If this really bothers her, your friend should most definitely contact the school team to find out what kind a plan is in place for helping with his behaviors.

Message edited 2010-01-07 14:56:46.430000.

Posted 1/7/10 2:53 PM
 

Palebride
I am an amazing bakist

Member since 5/05

13673 total posts

Name:
Lori

Re: WWYD: Do YOU think this is FAIR?

As a teacher, I try not to form a judgment unless I was there for the incident. I tend to trust the school's decision in most cases, as I feel the majority of principals really are looking out for the welfare of the children....especially in elementary school.

Posted 1/7/10 2:54 PM
 

Porrruss
Nya nya nya

Member since 5/05

11618 total posts

Name:
Amy

Re: WWYD: Do YOU think this is FAIR?

Message edited 2010-01-07 14:56:18.437000.

Posted 1/7/10 2:56 PM
 

HeathKernandez
Our Ron is an awesome Ron

Member since 4/07

9091 total posts

Name:
baby fish mouth

Re: WWYD: Do YOU think this is FAIR?

It's VERY VERY hard to get the 'story' from a second grader... Apparently my fourth grader does 'nothing' all day in school.

With that said, I don't know if I would be upset that I didn't get a phone call. Depending on the severity of the 'situation,' not everything requires a phone call. I would at LEAST expect a note so that I can talk to my son about the incident.

I have a kid who is CONSTANTLY getting (not so much YELLED at) but 'told to' quiet or pay attention and gets 'in trouble' more often... And there is ALWAYS an 'I don't know why I got in trouble' response from him...

Posted 1/7/10 3:15 PM
 

kerrycec03
Mom of 2 beautiful boys!!

Member since 6/06

13519 total posts

Name:
Kerry

Re: WWYD: Do YOU think this is FAIR?

Posted by brownie

Posted by KateDevine

I don't have a school aged child, but I do not think it is unfair.

Just because he has special needs doesn't mean that he doesn't have to follow the rules.

As for the parents being called, I don't know that the protocol is in that school, it is only one day of detention, IMO, is not a totally outrageous punishment Chat Icon



Same...

Also, its really hard to judge unless you see the child on a day to day basis...JMO




completely agree

Posted 1/7/10 3:24 PM
 
Pages: [1] 2
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
MOST LIKELY NOT-But will anyone be going to China to the Canton or Hong Kong Fair? aliasPook 10/21/06 1 Families Helping Families ™
Anyone going to the Fair in Riverhead on Sunday? Holly 10/3/06 3 Families Helping Families ™
SAT. 9/30 - Children's Festival and Crafts Fair *Crab Meadow Beach 4monkeys 9/29/06 3 Parenting
Craft fair at the Bellmore train station this weekend. Jax430 9/15/06 10 Families Helping Families ™
Fair at Suffolk Comm. College.... Diane 8/21/06 5 Families Helping Families ™
My fair Brady they plan a wedding is coming soon. HarleyGirlFLA 5/27/06 4 Families Helping Families ™