Re: WWYD: Do YOU think this is FAIR?
Posted 1/7/2010 1:46:20 PM by KateDevine


Posted by pig22seal

WOW....very interesting opinions. I guess because I know the child, my feelings are a lot different! He is so very sensitive, passive, and innocent. Knowing all of his traits, makes it very easy for me to think the punishment was harsh. He already was taken out of Art to be sent to the principles; which is intimidating on its own. If I were the aide, I would have removed him from the class, explained to him about the talking policy, and ASKED him if he understood. I guess the aide didn't know of his needs; if he had, he may have done things a little different.



When did this class start? Has he been in this Art class since September or did it just start?

If he has been in this class since the beginning of the school year, then he should be aware of the talking policy...

But even if the class just started, I don't think that it was an unreasonable punishment. One day of detention during recess (IMO) isn't a big deal
Print Post      Close Window