Why do you think the command was to kill and not capture?

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 [2] 3

jilliibabii
Mrs. O'Connor

Member since 6/10

12821 total posts

Name:
Jillian

Re: Why do you think the command was to kill and not capture?

Posted by JenniferEver

Posted by jilliibabii

Posted by JenniferEver

Posted by jilliibabii

We don't know that the command was to kill. From that article and others I've read, it didn't seem to be. I wouldn't expect Osama to come quietly.



I read that the command was to kill, though I can't cite the article at the moment since I read so many of them.

ETA: Article



Hmm that surprises me. Not that I think they would've been able to capture him anyway. And even if they did- so what? He never would've spilled the beans about anyone else!




I think trying to capture him would have been a lot more dangerous to our troops and to civillians, really anyone involved. Also, I don't think he would ever give up information. I don't think someone who who has planned the deaths of thousands of people is afraid of death, imprisonment, or torture.



Definitely. I agree 100%. We would've gained nothing by capturing him.

Posted 5/2/11 2:57 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Why do you think the command was to kill and not capture?

I'm fine with the command to kill the leader of a terrorist organization.

I'm not sure how I'd feel about the US (acting alone) giving the command to kill a head of another country though. To me that is the distinction.

Posted by LiveForMoments

In reality, we will never know the 100% truth of what was ordered and what happened. Any news we hear is what the government wants us to hear, and I'm ok with that.



I disagree. I believe governments should be as transparent as possible as long as it's not risking security. It's one of the reasons I think Wikileaks has some value.

Posted 5/2/11 3:29 PM
 

bobby769
LIF Infant

Member since 7/10

253 total posts

Name:

Re: Why do you think the command was to kill and not capture?

I think they knew that he would not allow himself to be taken alive and a wanted alive command would have put our soldiers at risk.

Posted 5/2/11 3:32 PM
 

Leeners
:)

Member since 5/05

4898 total posts

Name:
Eileen

Re: Why do you think the command was to kill and not capture?

By every account I've read and heard, the order was to kill if necessary. John Brennan himself said today we would have taken him alive if that was a possibility, but it was not.

Huffington Post / AOL is not the most credible source IMO.

Posted 5/2/11 3:32 PM
 

bobby769
LIF Infant

Member since 7/10

253 total posts

Name:

Re: Why do you think the command was to kill and not capture?

Posted by JenniferEver

According to some they actually did not follow the precepts of Islam because a sea burial is only allowed in limited contexts,



How is this not considered a 'limited context'?

Posted 5/2/11 3:35 PM
 

JenniferEver
The Disney Lady

Member since 5/05

18163 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Why do you think the command was to kill and not capture?

Posted by Leeners

By every account I've read and heard, the order was to kill if necessary. John Brennan himself said today we would have taken him alive if that was a possibility, but it was not.

Huffington Post / AOL is not the most credible source IMO.



It came from Reuters.

Posted 5/2/11 3:36 PM
 

JenniferEver
The Disney Lady

Member since 5/05

18163 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Why do you think the command was to kill and not capture?

Posted by bobby769

Posted by JenniferEver

According to some they actually did not follow the precepts of Islam because a sea burial is only allowed in limited contexts,



How is this not considered a 'limited context'?



It's not one of the limited contexts (e.g death at sea) that is allowed.

Posted 5/2/11 3:36 PM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: Why do you think the command was to kill and not capture?

Posted by Leeners

By every account I've read and heard, the order was to kill if necessary. John Brennan himself said today we would have taken him alive if that was a possibility, but it was not.

Huffington Post / AOL is not the most credible source IMO.



I agree with this.

SOP is to go for the head sheat if they don't surrender.

he's not the leader of a country. he is a criminal. plain and simple. he does not get the same level of treatment as say Hussein would have gotten.

personally, on a very selfish level, I am thanking my stars today that this will not go to trial. It would have touched my life dramatically and in a very real way. I am selfishly, very happy I don't have to worry about that.

Posted 5/2/11 3:37 PM
 

Michi
My Love

Member since 5/05

31600 total posts

Name:
M

Re: Why do you think the command was to kill and not capture?

By "burial at sea" I hope that means they fed his a$$ to the fishes. He deserves nothing PROPER and glad he wasnt just captured to waste money taking care of him and feeding him as a prisoner.

Message edited 2011-05-02 15:39:25.400000.

Posted 5/2/11 3:39 PM
 

AngnShaun
Sisters

Member since 1/10

21015 total posts

Name:
Ang

Re: Why do you think the command was to kill and not capture?

Posted by Michi

By "burial at sea" I hope that means they fed his a$$ to the fishes.



we were wondering exactly what that means also...

Posted 5/2/11 3:40 PM
 

SweetTooth
I'm a tired mommy!

Member since 12/05

20105 total posts

Name:
Lauren

Re: Why do you think the command was to kill and not capture?

Posted by AngnShaun

Posted by Michi

By "burial at sea" I hope that means they fed his a$$ to the fishes.



we were wondering exactly what that means also...



I thought they just dropped the body in the middle of the ocean. I'm pretty sure there was no funeral pyre or anything of that context.

Posted 5/2/11 3:51 PM
 

Serendipity
Summer!

Member since 4/07

7631 total posts

Name:
PrayingWishingHopingALOT

Re: Why do you think the command was to kill and not capture?

Posted by CathyB

I'd imagine it was to avoid having his foot soldiers trying to stage a rescue operation, which would put our troops at further risk.

I heard this morning they went with a head shot as they were concerned about suicide vests that might be detonated if they went for a chest shot.

I have no problem with the decision. I think it was a lot more merciful that what his "troops" would have done had they captured one of our leaders.




Thats what I heard as well.

Posted 5/2/11 4:22 PM
 

mrsBLT
missing my baby

Member since 1/10

1359 total posts

Name:
Brittany

Re: Why do you think the command was to kill and not capture?

Posted by MySunshine

Posted by NYPD-Wife

All I've been hearing was that people want to see his body, they don't believe it until they see it. Chat Icon



I heard on 1010 that the government is debating releasing the pictures. They feel that they are too graphic since the shot was to the head.

Random question: they said that DNA confirmed it was Bin Laden BUT um how can we have records to match his DNA? Sorry if it's dumb but I just don't get it.




um, fcuk that!

THIS is a graphic picture

External Image

i probably wouldn't look at them if they were released but i'm all for them releasing them if that's what people need to see

Posted 5/2/11 4:52 PM
 

summertime
LIF Adolescent

Member since 9/10

852 total posts

Name:

Re: Why do you think the command was to kill and not capture?

I think it was smart, it isnt like he was going to tellus anything, we wouldnt be able to torture him and where would we put him??

Posted 5/2/11 4:54 PM
 

Babymakin
LIF Adult

Member since 12/10

920 total posts

Name:
Sarah

Re: Why do you think the command was to kill and not capture?

Posted by neener1211

Posted by Jenhos

I would have preferred him captured. Honsetly he got off easy being killed on site.



He did get off easy being killed on site. But 'if' he were captured, then what? Taxpayer money being used to hold him, and where do we hold him? Worry about terrorists trying to break him out? Paying for a trial? What's his punishment after trial? Death? Seems like we cut to the chase, and I'm okay with that.



SOOOOO what I am thinking. I would prefer him dead and buried. I would hate to spend our money to protect him while we put him up for the death penalty.

Posted 5/2/11 7:25 PM
 

Cheeks24
Living a dream

Member since 1/08

8589 total posts

Name:
Cheeks

Re: Why do you think the command was to kill and not capture?

Armed forces are trained to shoot to kill.

Posted 5/2/11 9:23 PM
 

HeathKernandez
Our Ron is an awesome Ron

Member since 4/07

9091 total posts

Name:
baby fish mouth

Re: Why do you think the command was to kill and not capture?

I honestly think the only way to "capture" him was to kill him... This man would have died before surrendering. He's a monster.

Posted 5/2/11 9:26 PM
 

lipglossjunky73
My Everything!

Member since 11/05

35670 total posts

Name:
<3

Re: Why do you think the command was to kill and not capture?

DH feels it is because - since he used to work with the US government - he would be betraying whatever secrets we gave him years ago....

Posted 5/2/11 10:13 PM
 

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: Why do you think the command was to kill and not capture?

I just heard on the news they wanted to capture him alive.

Posted 5/2/11 10:30 PM
 

LoveBeingMrsT
Love my Boys!

Member since 12/05

4648 total posts

Name:

Re: Why do you think the command was to kill and not capture?

Posted by mrsBLT

Posted by MySunshine

Posted by NYPD-Wife

All I've been hearing was that people want to see his body, they don't believe it until they see it. Chat Icon



I heard on 1010 that the government is debating releasing the pictures. They feel that they are too graphic since the shot was to the head.

Random question: they said that DNA confirmed it was Bin Laden BUT um how can we have records to match his DNA? Sorry if it's dumb but I just don't get it.




um, fcuk that!

THIS is a graphic picture

External Image

i probably wouldn't look at them if they were released but i'm all for them releasing them if that's what people need to see


Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon
There isn't anything worse then those pics imho.

Message edited 2011-05-02 22:52:30.623000.

Posted 5/2/11 10:51 PM
 

Sweetheart409
LIF Adult

Member since 11/10

2219 total posts

Name:

Re: Why do you think the command was to kill and not capture?

Posted by SweetTooth

Posted by AngnShaun

Posted by Michi

By "burial at sea" I hope that means they fed his a$$ to the fishes.



we were wondering exactly what that means also...



I thought they just dropped the body in the middle of the ocean. I'm pretty sure there was no funeral pyre or anything of that context.



they were talking about the bural at sea today on the news. they said the burial followed the muslim tradition. but idk what the muslim tradition is besides that they have to be buried within 24 hours of their death.

Posted 5/2/11 11:23 PM
 

Leeners
:)

Member since 5/05

4898 total posts

Name:
Eileen

Re: Why do you think the command was to kill and not capture?

Posted by Sweetheart409

Posted by SweetTooth

Posted by AngnShaun

Posted by Michi

By "burial at sea" I hope that means they fed his a$$ to the fishes.



we were wondering exactly what that means also...



I thought they just dropped the body in the middle of the ocean. I'm pretty sure there was no funeral pyre or anything of that context.



they were talking about the bural at sea today on the news. they said the burial followed the muslim tradition. but idk what the muslim tradition is besides that they have to be buried within 24 hours of their death.



It is that if burial on land - within 24 hours - is not an option, burial at sea is warranted.

No one wanted this man's body. US tried to get Saudi to take it since he was born a Saudi national; they would have none of it.

The ceremony - yes CEREMONY - took a full hour, commenced at 1:10 and ended at 2:10. They did all of the ritual washing, sheet cover, readings of prayers - which were translated into Arabic.

There was nothing weird or shady about this burial at sea, this was and is standard protocol in such a situation.

(To be sure, I do not know if Yemen and Syria were offered his remains since his father was Yemeni and mother Syrian.)

Message edited 2011-05-03 06:55:07.987000.

Posted 5/3/11 6:54 AM
 

Deedlebugs
Blessed

Member since 12/05

10281 total posts

Name:
Kiki

Re: Why do you think the command was to kill and not capture?

I read he was washed wrapped in a white shroud and place in a weighted bag.

I hope they release the photos even if he was shot through the eye. I think we have the right to see them.

Posted 5/3/11 9:16 AM
 

AngnShaun
Sisters

Member since 1/10

21015 total posts

Name:
Ang

Re: Why do you think the command was to kill and not capture?

Posted by Leeners

Posted by Sweetheart409

Posted by SweetTooth

Posted by AngnShaun

Posted by Michi

By "burial at sea" I hope that means they fed his a$$ to the fishes.



we were wondering exactly what that means also...



I thought they just dropped the body in the middle of the ocean. I'm pretty sure there was no funeral pyre or anything of that context.



they were talking about the bural at sea today on the news. they said the burial followed the muslim tradition. but idk what the muslim tradition is besides that they have to be buried within 24 hours of their death.



It is that if burial on land - within 24 hours - is not an option, burial at sea is warranted.

No one wanted this man's body. US tried to get Saudi to take it since he was born a Saudi national; they would have none of it.

The ceremony - yes CEREMONY - took a full hour, commenced at 1:10 and ended at 2:10. They did all of the ritual washing, sheet cover, readings of prayers - which were translated into Arabic.

There was nothing weird or shady about this burial at sea, this was and is standard protocol in such a situation.

(To be sure, I do not know if Yemen and Syria were offered his remains since his father was Yemeni and mother Syrian.)



But do they just dump the body in and thats it?

Posted 5/3/11 9:23 AM
 

MrsA714
Baby #2 is here!

Member since 8/07

8806 total posts

Name:

Re: Why do you think the command was to kill and not capture?

Posted by AngnShaun

But do they just dump the body in and thats it?



From what I understand, yes.

Posted 5/3/11 9:35 AM
 
Pages: 1 [2] 3
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Is it true that saliva can kill sperm? MommyofG 10/30/05 2 TTC
I am seriously going to lose my mind....or kill my dog btrflygrl 10/3/05 9 Families Helping Families ™
Uh Oh DH is gunna kill me AJsMommy122 9/23/05 46 Families Helping Families ™
for those who watch Kill Reality MamaNDaddyof3 8/5/05 6 Families Helping Families ™
London police kill man day after transit blasts june262004 7/22/05 2 Families Helping Families ™
DH is GONNA KILL ME NOW! dm24angel 5/10/05 26 Families Helping Families ™