Who oh why...
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: 1 [2] | |
|
Re: Who oh why... Posted by Gatsbygirl Although in the 1860s Mary Todd Lincoln was harshly criticized for her spening too much money on clothes so maybe it's not such a new phenomena. they actually called her homely and dowdy.... nope, it's definitely a 19th century mentality
|
|
Posted 1/21/09 4:09 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: Who oh why... Posted by MrsERod Posted by lipglossjunky73 Posted by MrsERod Posted by lipglossjunky73 I never in a million years ever expected to have a hot first lady - who cares? ....... How far have women come that others still, at the end of the day, judge them for their looks? kinda contradictory, no? Nope sure it is, IMO on one hand you're complaining about women judging other women for their looks -- yet you refer to never expecting to have a "hot" first lady. isn't referring to someone as "hot", aka "good looking", judging one on their looks??? That's the whole point!!!
|
|
Posted 1/21/09 4:10 PM
|
|
|
Re: Who oh why... Posted by wannabemom The lack of male fashion criticism is not becuase they all wear suits... Wow - and here I am thinking that it IS because of the suits. How far off the fashion radar can a suit go, honestly? If a public male figure wore an ugly or ill-fitting suit - we'd (by 'we' - I mean the collective we) make a comment. Regarding looks - did we not make fun of GWB's ears? Cause I swear we did. Steve Forbes anyone? Didn't Obama make fun of his own ears? Being too big for Mt Rushmore? Will Smith could play him because he has the ears? It does work both ways. FTR - I think Michelle Obama is very attractive. |
|
Posted 1/21/09 4:11 PM
|
|
|
Ophelia
Member since 5/06 23378 total posts Name: |
Re: Who oh why... one of my favorite Shakespeare poems talks about women of his day and false comparison. |
Posted 1/21/09 4:11 PM
|
|
|
Re: Who oh why... Posted by Jenn627 Posted by wannabemom The lack of male fashion criticism is not becuase they all wear suits... Wow - and here I am thinking that it IS because of the suits. How far off the fashion radar can a suit go, honestly? If a public male figure wore an ugly or ill-fitting suit - we'd (by 'we' - I mean the collective we) make a comment. Regarding looks - did we not make fun of GWB's ears? Cause I swear we did. Steve Forbes anyone? Didn't Obama make fun of his own ears? Being too big for Mt Rushmore? Will Smith could play him because he has the ears? It does work both ways. FTR - I think Michelle Obama is very attractive. Not that it matters, I do think Michelle Obama is a nice looking woman, and Obama happens to be a BEEEEAutiful man!!!!
|
|
Posted 1/21/09 4:12 PM
|
|
|
Re: Who oh why... Posted by Ophelia Posted by wannabemom my sentiments exactly.... I love how people were commenting on her height, her 'horse teeth', and how she 'walked like a man'.... and how ugly she is.... It's fine (and a fun/harmless thread) to discuss an outfit or 2... but it stunned me that it went on for over 100 posts... And men basically get-off with barely a footnote, becuase they're valued for their brains. don't even try to convince me that they're treated the same... women have to try to look like a model, be fashionable, AND be productive and bright... men merely need to bathe, be reasonably unwrinkled, productive and bright. The lack of male fashion criticism is not becuase they all wear suits... it's becuase it's generally acknowledged that fashion is petty and busy important men need not be bothered by it. the striking thing was not the fashion disses...par for the course...but that it went to the core of who she is. . I think the B'tch remarks were based on all the info that has been available on the internet about way before the innaguration. At least that's what I am assuming--I never actually saw the B'tch remarks myself. |
|
Posted 1/21/09 4:12 PM
|
|
|
Re: Who oh why... Posted by bird382 I think it's one thing to critique/comment on the First Lady's STYLE and a completely different thing to rip apart her LOOKS. The first is fun. The second is disgusting. Exactly. There is nothing wrong with discussing the clothing. The Smithsonian actually has exhibit about first ladies' atire throughout the years. Message edited 2009-01-21 16:24:09.660000. |
|
Posted 1/21/09 4:15 PM
|
|
|
Re: Who oh why... People ripped Hillary apart and Chelsea when they were in office. People ripped Palin and Cindy McCain's outfit choices apart. Michelle Obama is no exception. |
|
Posted 1/21/09 4:24 PM
|
|
|
Re: Who oh why... Posted by Jenn627 Posted by wannabemom The lack of male fashion criticism is not becuase they all wear suits... Wow - and here I am thinking that it IS because of the suits. How far off the fashion radar can a suit go, honestly? If a public male figure wore an ugly or ill-fitting suit - we'd (by 'we' - I mean the collective we) make a comment. Regarding looks - did we not make fun of GWB's ears? Cause I swear we did. Steve Forbes anyone? Didn't Obama make fun of his own ears? Being too big for Mt Rushmore? Will Smith could play him because he has the ears? It does work both ways. FTR - I think Michelle Obama is very attractive. when was the last time you remember someone ciriticizing a politician's pants suit? I can honestly only recall one politician being criticized for a pants suit... hillary clinton. and the comments on a guys ears are just fleeting comments... it would never generate over a 100 posts... (Michelle walks like a man and has horse teeth... no one commented on barack's ears). that's really my point. It's a fascination and almost an obligation to chime in with a personal opinion on a woman's clothing... even when the outfit is quite appropriate for the event. a man really has to roll out of bed and put on river pants, basically go out of his way to look odd, in order to warrant a comment. Message edited 2009-01-21 16:27:11.613000. |
|
Posted 1/21/09 4:25 PM
|
|
|
Re: Who oh why... Men just dress better than women, that's all..... |
|
Posted 1/21/09 4:29 PM
|
|
|
Re: Who oh why... Posted by GoldenRod Men just dress better than women, that's all.....
|
|
Posted 1/21/09 4:30 PM
|
|
|
Re: Who oh why... Posted by GoldenRod Men just dress better than women, that's all..... well, my DH dresses better than me he's decked out in banana republic clothes... and since he's thin, everything looks good on him. I'm.... errr... fluffy my ann taylor stuff looks a little off on me
|
|
Posted 1/21/09 4:33 PM
|
|
|
Re: Who oh why... Posted by wannabemom when was the last time you remember someone ciriticizing a politician's pants suit? I can honestly only recall one politician being criticized for a pants suit... hillary clinton. and the comments on a guys ears are just fleeting comments... it would never generate over a 100 posts... (Michelle walks like a man and has horse teeth... no one commented on barack's ears). that's really my point. It's a fascination and almost an obligation to chime in with a personal opinion on a woman's clothing... even when the outfit is quite appropriate for the event. a man really has to roll out of bed and put on river pants, basically go out of his way to look odd, in order to warrant a comment. True, true. I was grasping at straws to make it seem like it works both ways. |
|
Posted 1/21/09 4:43 PM
|
|
|
Re: Who oh why... I didn't start that thread to judge her as a person. I was just commenting on her clothing- I'm sure she's an intelligent, powerful, kind person. Message edited 2009-01-21 16:47:36.573000. |
|
Posted 1/21/09 4:43 PM
|
|
|
Re: Who oh why... Posted by kahlua716 I didn't start that thread to judge her as a person. I was just commenting on her clothing- I'm sure she's an intelligent, powerful, kind person. The fact that I didn't like her outfit doesn't mean I think any less of her as a person. What's wrong with critiquing fashion? I don't get why people take it so personally... ETA: Men don't get discussed as much because 1. Most (not all) men don't care as much about fashion as women 2. They pretty much always wear the same things- suit or tux and tie. If President Obama had walked out wearing a Magenta leisure suit- I betcha plenty of people would've commented. PS- I happened to like Joe Biden's tie See on the one man hand you're right, the fashion critiques were not inappropriate at ALL, imho... but some of the comments about her character were outrageous (not by you Kahlua, but others). On the other man hand, there is DEFINITELY a higher tolerance for both poor wardrobe choices and less than STUNNING looks for our male celebrities and politicians (gasp!) ... except for Prince Charles, the man makes me and age has done nothing to soften his assault on my eyes. Even the average Joe/Joe Six Pack/Joe the plumber has far more self confidence than would seem appropriate sometimes - I always laugh when I hear a middle aged guy with a beer/food baby talking about how awesome Brooke Burke looks "for someone with 4 kids".
|
|
Posted 1/21/09 5:00 PM
|
|
|
Re: Who oh why... OK here is my take on this: |
|
Posted 1/21/09 5:06 PM
|
|
|
QuoteTheRaven424
Member since 5/05 13659 total posts Name: |
Re: Who oh why... Posted by GoldenRod Men just dress better than women, that's all..... yeah i mean, we get off easy - most suits are dark - and black, drak gray, navy blue - kinda just goes with everything
|
Posted 1/21/09 5:11 PM
|
|
|
Re: Who oh why... Ummm what is so worng with having Horse Teeth? |
|
Posted 1/21/09 5:13 PM
|
|
| Pages: 1 [2] | |











my ann taylor stuff looks a little off on me

... except for Prince Charles, the man makes me
and age has done nothing to soften his assault on my eyes.


<----Beautiful!