Who is in the wrong???

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 [2] 3

Shelly
She's 7!!!

Member since 8/05

14624 total posts

Name:

Re: Who is in the wrong???

I say both are at fault. Any dog owner is responsible for actions of their dog- especially when they are not on a leash.

Family A should have either (1) put their dog on a leash when they saw dog B coming or (2) told Kid B not to come by with the dog without a leash. Since the an adult was there (Father A), he should have done something to prevent it.

Kid B is also responsible, but kid B is also a kid. So you can't hold a kid too responsible. If Adult B was there, it may have been different.

Message edited 2007-02-13 14:03:54.343000.

Posted 2/13/07 2:03 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Who is in the wrong???

Posted by ThusSpokeLaLolita

obviously dog A is at fault....
but i dont think it is acceptable for people to bring their dogs off leash onto other people's properties..... ESPECIALLY if their dog is out.



Right but Dog A didn't bite Dog B, he bit Kid B. Perhaps Family B shoud leash Kid B?Chat Icon

Message edited 2007-02-13 14:04:17.793000.

Posted 2/13/07 2:03 PM
 

Jesaroo
is not the girl you knew

Member since 5/05

14266 total posts

Name:
Jes

Re: Who is in the wrong???

Posted by Bxgell2

Posted by ThusSpokeLaLolita

Posted by Bxgell2

Family A is at fault - if you know that your dog has aggressive tendencies around other dogs, or just one other dog, you are the responsible one for making sure that your dog is never in a situation where he will act out on those aggressions. Family B shouldn't have to tip toe around Family A, and only bring their dog out when dog A isn't outside - that isn't fair to other dog owners. If you know your dog has a problem, you should have him leashed at all times, no ifs ands or buts, because you NEVER know what will happen, even in just a second.

Edited to say - family B has some part in this, by allowing their dog to roam around unleashed.



understood. BUT... dog A was in HIS yard.

family B brought their dog into family A's yard.

i dont find that tip toeing around.

actually, its quite the opposite, family A tip toes around family B's dog, since he is constantly off leash.



Doesn't matter. The fact is Dog B isn't aggressive - he's not the one who bit a child, it was Dog A. No matter what the circumstance, the owners of Dog A are responsible if he bites someone, even more so if the owners are AWARE that Dog A has aggressive tendencies. Because they are aware, they have an even higher responsibility to keep a very close eye on the dog.


dog B IS actually aggressive.
lets call this person a young adult rather than child though.

and dog A isnt "agressive" but can be provoked. to me there is a difference.

like i said , yes dog A is at fault, but im just tryig to say this is excatly why you should NOT bring your dog onto other ppl's yards. somehting that could have been totally prevented right? but it wasnt and therefore one family is at fault when it could have been totally prevented by family b

Posted 2/13/07 2:04 PM
 

QuoteTheRaven424
22 Months?!!!!

Member since 5/05

13659 total posts

Name:
And If That Isn't A True Blue Miracle

Re: Who is in the wrong???

i say family C is at fault

Posted 2/13/07 2:05 PM
 

Jesaroo
is not the girl you knew

Member since 5/05

14266 total posts

Name:
Jes

Re: Who is in the wrong???

Posted by nrthshgrl

Dog A is in the wrong - so it's his family. Regardless of the situation if a dog bites, it is the owner's fault even if it is in their yard.

If they had the dog fenced in or chained & Kid B approached then I would think differently.



what if i said that family A HAS a fence?

Posted 2/13/07 2:06 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Who is in the wrong???

Posted by ThusSpokeLaLolita

dog B IS actually aggressive.
lets call this person a young adult rather than child though.

and dog A isnt "agressive" but can be provoked. to me there is a difference.

like i said , yes dog A is at fault, but im just tryig to say this is excatly why you should NOT bring your dog onto other ppl's yards. somehting that could have been totally prevented right? but it wasnt and therefore one family is at fault when it could have been totally prevented by family b



It wouldn't matter. If someone is in my yard & my dog bites them - for whatever reason, I take responsibility - unless of course they were trespassing.

Posted 2/13/07 2:07 PM
 

MrsMerlot
Unconditional Love

Member since 4/06

6005 total posts

Name:
Chrissy

Re: Who is in the wrong???

Posted by CaptainCharisma424

i say family C is at fault



C themselves out of it.

Posted 2/13/07 2:08 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Who is in the wrong???

Posted by ThusSpokeLaLolita

Posted by nrthshgrl

Dog A is in the wrong - so it's his family. Regardless of the situation if a dog bites, it is the owner's fault even if it is in their yard.

If they had the dog fenced in or chained & Kid B approached then I would think differently.



what if i said that family A HAS a fence?



Only if the kid/young adult broke into the yard. I meant an enclosed caged area for the dog, not just a fence.

If the person wanders into my yard while I'm there to talk or play, I'm responsible.

Posted 2/13/07 2:09 PM
 

Jesaroo
is not the girl you knew

Member since 5/05

14266 total posts

Name:
Jes

Re: Who is in the wrong???

let me say, im not defending dog A. im tryingt o play devils advocate

Posted 2/13/07 2:09 PM
 

QuoteTheRaven424
22 Months?!!!!

Member since 5/05

13659 total posts

Name:
And If That Isn't A True Blue Miracle

Re: Who is in the wrong???

Posted by ChrissynRicky

Posted by CaptainCharisma424

i say family C is at fault



C themselves out of it.



exactly

Posted 2/13/07 2:10 PM
 

Bxgell2
Perfection

Member since 5/05

16438 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: Who is in the wrong???

Posted by ThusSpokeLaLolita

Posted by Bxgell2

Posted by ThusSpokeLaLolita

Posted by Bxgell2

Family A is at fault - if you know that your dog has aggressive tendencies around other dogs, or just one other dog, you are the responsible one for making sure that your dog is never in a situation where he will act out on those aggressions. Family B shouldn't have to tip toe around Family A, and only bring their dog out when dog A isn't outside - that isn't fair to other dog owners. If you know your dog has a problem, you should have him leashed at all times, no ifs ands or buts, because you NEVER know what will happen, even in just a second.

Edited to say - family B has some part in this, by allowing their dog to roam around unleashed.



understood. BUT... dog A was in HIS yard.

family B brought their dog into family A's yard.

i dont find that tip toeing around.

actually, its quite the opposite, family A tip toes around family B's dog, since he is constantly off leash.



Doesn't matter. The fact is Dog B isn't aggressive - he's not the one who bit a child, it was Dog A. No matter what the circumstance, the owners of Dog A are responsible if he bites someone, even more so if the owners are AWARE that Dog A has aggressive tendencies. Because they are aware, they have an even higher responsibility to keep a very close eye on the dog.


dog B IS actually aggressive.
lets call this person a young adult rather than child though.

and dog A isnt "agressive" but can be provoked. to me there is a difference.

like i said , yes dog A is at fault, but im just tryig to say this is excatly why you should NOT bring your dog onto other ppl's yards. somehting that could have been totally prevented right? but it wasnt and therefore one family is at fault when it could have been totally prevented by family b



I get what you're saying, and I agree, it isn't responsible for ANY dog owner to allow their dog to roam free, and that's why most localities put liability on the owner whose dog is not on a leash and bites another person or animal. With that said, however, with regard to this particular case, although I think Family B was irresponsible, the fault *mostly* lies with Family A. Doesn't matter that B dog can be aggressive - what matters is what happened exactly, and here, it was Dog A, not Dog B who took the bite.

Posted 2/13/07 2:10 PM
 

CookiePuss
Cake from Outer Space!

Member since 5/05

14021 total posts

Name:

Re: Who is in the wrong???

Dog b has nothing to do with Dog a biting kid b. Any dog that has a tendency to nip/bite at people shouldn't ever be in a position where that dog can bite...regardless of the surroundings.

Posted 2/13/07 2:10 PM
 

MsMBV
:P

Member since 5/05

28602 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Who is in the wrong???

Posted by Shelly

I say both are at fault. Any dog owner is responsible for actions of their dog- especially when they are not on a leash.

Family A should have either (1) put their dog on a leash when they saw dog B coming or (2) told Kid B not to come by with the dog without a leash. Since the an adult was there (Father A), he should have done something to prevent it.

Kid B is also responsible, but kid B is also a kid. So you can't hold a kid too responsible. If Adult B was there, it may have been different.

I agree. If it were a situation where a dog was off-leash in its own fenced yeard, then I might blame B more than A. However, legally (from what I remeber) A could still be at fault if there is no sign present stating that there is a dog on the property.

Posted 2/13/07 2:16 PM
 

Jesaroo
is not the girl you knew

Member since 5/05

14266 total posts

Name:
Jes

Re: Who is in the wrong???

Posted by shamrock124

Dog b has nothing to do with Dog a biting kid b. Any dog that has a tendency to nip/bite at people shouldn't ever be in a position where that dog can bite...regardless of the surroundings.



dog B has EVERYTHING to do with why dog A did what he did.
dog a doesnt mind people, but other dogs he is weary of. especially one in his yard he feels the need to protect his fmaily.

not defending his actions, but dog B had everything to do with dog A's reaction.



Posted 2/13/07 2:17 PM
 

dpli
Daylight savings :)

Member since 5/05

13973 total posts

Name:
D

Re: Who is in the wrong???

As neighbors, I would say both families bear some responsibility, but legally, I would say the biting dog's owners are more responsible.

Posted 2/13/07 2:19 PM
 

CookiePuss
Cake from Outer Space!

Member since 5/05

14021 total posts

Name:

Re: Who is in the wrong???

x

Message edited 2007-02-13 14:35:52.840000.

Posted 2/13/07 2:28 PM
 

MrsNaunie
Kai helps my father dump out.

Member since 9/06

1181 total posts

Name:
Lauren

Re: Who is in the wrong???

Why would someone, KNOWING that dog A would attack their little dog B, bring their dog B into a fenced in yard with Dog A?
That is cruel! What if their little puppy Dog B was hurt?!?!?!?!

Why would anyone, knowing that their dog A had any aggressive tendancies toward anything- allow their dog A be off a lease? Or not react before Teen B opened a fence and came into their yard?

Message edited 2007-02-13 14:39:45.477000.

Posted 2/13/07 2:39 PM
 

Sassyz75
Turning a new page

Member since 5/05

9731 total posts

Name:
Dina

Re: Who is in the wrong???

Posted by CaptainCharisma424

gonna have to read this a few times...

two trains leave st. louis at exactly the same time, one going at 75 mph and one going at 50 mph. At what point will they meet in cleveland? Solve for X

Chat Icon



Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 2/13/07 2:43 PM
 

Jesaroo
is not the girl you knew

Member since 5/05

14266 total posts

Name:
Jes

Re: Who is in the wrong???

Posted by MrsNaunie

Why would someone, KNOWING that dog A would attack their little dog B, bring their dog B into a fenced in yard with Dog A?
That is cruel! What if their little puppy Dog B was hurt?!?!?!?!

Why would anyone, knowing that their dog A had any aggressive tendancies toward anything- allow their dog A be off a lease? Or not react before Teen B opened a fence and came into their yard?




i agree and disagree here.
-i agree teen B was dumb for briinging in dog B knowing dog A doesnt like toher dogs
-i disagree that dog a "attacked" (i dont consider pulling on someones pants an attack)
-just pointing out dog b isnt a 'little puppy'. but youre right, knowing dog a and dog b do not get along why tkae the chance??
-i agree dog a family shouldnt take any chances, but he was going from the door, to the car, so i can see how ppl would fine that to be ok
-dad a couldnt react in time, she was just already IN the yard. he turned around aand she was there.




i find this an interesting debate, because it is so common i am sure.

Posted 2/13/07 2:47 PM
 

MrsNaunie
Kai helps my father dump out.

Member since 9/06

1181 total posts

Name:
Lauren

Re: Who is in the wrong???

So the entireyard is enclosed?
Dog A was without a lease, in a completely fenced in yard?
And Dig B came in, through a fence?
That's rediculous. Teen B, tresspassing?! With an unleashed dog? Into the yard of another dog that she KNOWS doesn't like her dog?
Wrong.
I call all dogs, even 12 year olds- puppies.Chat Icon I pronounce it poopies.

Posted 2/13/07 3:00 PM
 

baghag
:P

Member since 5/05

10278 total posts

Name:

Re: Who is in the wrong???

Posted by MrsNaunie
I call all dogs, even 12 year olds- puppies.Chat Icon I pronounce it poopies.



I do that too. Chat Icon

Posted 2/13/07 3:02 PM
 

MrsNaunie
Kai helps my father dump out.

Member since 9/06

1181 total posts

Name:
Lauren

Re: Who is in the wrong???

Posted by baghag

Posted by MrsNaunie
I call all dogs, even 12 year olds- puppies.Chat Icon I pronounce it poopies.



I do that too. Chat Icon



Chat Icon
do you prounce it poopies?!?!?!?Chat Icon

Posted 2/13/07 3:08 PM
 

MrsERod
Praying for Everyone.

Member since 5/05

26170 total posts

Name:
MrsERod™®

Re: Who is in the wrong???

Posted by racheeeee

Posted by CaptainCharisma424

gonna have to read this a few times...

two trains leave st. louis at exactly the same time, one going at 75 mph and one going at 50 mph. At what point will they meet in cleveland? Solve for X

Chat Icon



C. The chemical composite for water is H20.

My eyeballs went crazy trying to read that. A=B+C/D...blimmin 'eck!!!

Sorry, did you say it was the Dogs Birthday??? Well, by law that makes the whole story invalid!!!




i'm sorry, but this just made me LOL!!! Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

imo - both dog owners are wrong. they should have been on the leash - especially since kids were present.

Posted 2/13/07 3:17 PM
 

HoneyBadger
YourWorstNightmare.

Member since 10/06

15979 total posts

Name:
BahBahBlackJeep

Re: Who is in the wrong???

Posted by ThusSpokeLaLolita

let me give you a scenario.....

family A is outside. the kids are playing soccer and then dad is trying to jump one of their cars to take their dog to the park for the dogs birthday.....

the dad lets the dog out to jump in the truck....

at this time the neighbor's kid (lets call them family B) comes over with THEIR dog.

A dog does not like dog B and family B knows this, yet still allows their dog off leash to poo on family A's lawn and drive family A's dogs crazy.

well, dog A go up and nips the pants (not skin thankfully) of kid B.

the dad of A takes dog A inside and reprimands him and tells kid B to go home and make sure she is ok. Kid B's paretns are not home.
she comes back 5 mins later saying she is fine. she leaves dog B home this time and continues to play soccer with kids A.

later hat day mom A gets home and hears what happened so she immediatly calls mom B.

thankfully like i mentioned kid b is totally fine.
but mom B b*tches out mom A. mom A then gets fed up and gives the phoen to dad A to deal with her.

in the end everyone is happy. but mom B still thinks that her kid B is totally innocent (which of course she is) BUT she will mnot admit that she was wrong for bringing dog B there.

if dog B was not there dog a wouldnt have nipped.

just curious on everyones feelings on this.



Kid B was wrong so is family B for letting their dog poo on family A's lawn.

We had a similar situation with an old neighbor. Their dog would come on our property to do it's business. We tried everything, calling, walking over there to speak to the owners. even put up a fence to keep our dog away from their dog b/c mine was much bigger and used to go nuts when this dog would come in the yard.

Well, the annoying dog dug a hole under the fence and came over to which my dog who was lose in OUR YARD and didn't like this dog did go nuts and started to attack the neighbor's dog. We finally were able to break them up but the neighbor was pizzed and tried to have our dog put down. That didn't happen THANKFULLY but my point of the story is that annoying people don't seem to know any better. Family A's dog did nothing wrong as far as I'm concerned.

Posted 2/13/07 3:18 PM
 

HoneyBadger
YourWorstNightmare.

Member since 10/06

15979 total posts

Name:
BahBahBlackJeep

Re: Who is in the wrong???

Posted by nov04libride

Posted by ThusSpokeLaLolita

Posted by Bxgell2

Family A is at fault - if you know that your dog has aggressive tendencies around other dogs, or just one other dog, you are the responsible one for making sure that your dog is never in a situation where he will act out on those aggressions. Family B shouldn't have to tip toe around Family A, and only bring their dog out when dog A isn't outside - that isn't fair to other dog owners. If you know your dog has a problem, you should have him leashed at all times, no ifs ands or buts, because you NEVER know what will happen, even in just a second.

Edited to say - family B has some part in this, by allowing their dog to roam around unleashed.



understood. BUT... dog A was in HIS yard.

family B brought their dog into family A's yard.

i dont find that tip toeing around.

actually, its quite the opposite, family A tip toes around family B's dog, since he is constantly off leash.



It doesn't matter though--someone could trip and fall walking on my driveway when I am not home and sue me. Rules of home ownership.

From this story it doesn't sound like dog B did anything wrong. Dog A comes across as the aggressive, uncontrolled dog.



Did we read the same story?? Dog B was on Dog A's property. Family B needs to take responsibility for their dog and kid's actions. This TEENAGER made a VERY poor choice by going on family A's property when they KNEW dog A would react poorly.

It's mindsets like this that award millions to people who burn themselves on hot coffee.

Posted 2/13/07 3:26 PM
 
Pages: 1 [2] 3
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
YUMMY WW 2 PT SNACK ALERT!! Repost..cause I posted on the wrong board... Cookiegobbler 1/23/06 10 Diet & Fitness
OK, I need honest opinions. Am I wrong? (VERY long) Scotty-CassidysMom 1/8/06 9 Families Helping Families ™
Am I feeding Kevin Wrong? Veggies? Maximum amount of formula per day? MM2004 12/6/05 1 Parenting
I have a number that is a wrong number but it is restricted how can i call this person back luvsbob4603 11/15/05 7 Families Helping Families ™
i knw i am sensitive b/c i just had a DNc but this is whast so wrong with twh worlkd sometimes... 04bride 11/9/05 11 Pregnancy
i want ask you all something and let me know if you agree or am i wrong luvsbob4603 8/24/05 8 Families Helping Families ™