Re: Who is in the wrong???
Posted 2/13/2007 2:10:09 PM by Bxgell2
Posted by ThusSpokeLaLolita
Posted by Bxgell2
Posted by ThusSpokeLaLolita
Posted by Bxgell2
Family A is at fault - if you know that your dog has aggressive tendencies around other dogs, or just one other dog, you are the responsible one for making sure that your dog is never in a situation where he will act out on those aggressions. Family B shouldn't have to tip toe around Family A, and only bring their dog out when dog A isn't outside - that isn't fair to other dog owners. If you know your dog has a problem, you should have him leashed at all times, no ifs ands or buts, because you NEVER know what will happen, even in just a second.
Edited to say - family B has some part in this, by allowing their dog to roam around unleashed.
understood. BUT... dog A was in HIS yard.
family B brought their dog into family A's yard.
i dont find that tip toeing around.
actually, its quite the opposite, family A tip toes around family B's dog, since he is constantly off leash.
Doesn't matter. The fact is Dog B isn't aggressive - he's not the one who bit a child, it was Dog A. No matter what the circumstance, the owners of Dog A are responsible if he bites someone, even more so if the owners are AWARE that Dog A has aggressive tendencies. Because they are aware, they have an even higher responsibility to keep a very close eye on the dog.
dog B IS actually aggressive. lets call this person a young adult rather than child though.
and dog A isnt "agressive" but can be provoked. to me there is a difference.
like i said , yes dog A is at fault, but im just tryig to say this is excatly why you should NOT bring your dog onto other ppl's yards. somehting that could have been totally prevented right? but it wasnt and therefore one family is at fault when it could have been totally prevented by family b
I get what you're saying, and I agree, it isn't responsible for ANY dog owner to allow their dog to roam free, and that's why most localities put liability on the owner whose dog is not on a leash and bites another person or animal. With that said, however, with regard to this particular case, although I think Family B was irresponsible, the fault *mostly* lies with Family A. Doesn't matter that B dog can be aggressive - what matters is what happened exactly, and here, it was Dog A, not Dog B who took the bite.
|