Which would you pick?

Forum Opinion Poll
Option 1 - NY 25 28.41%
Option 2 - SC 35 39.77%
Option 3 - FL 26 29.55%
Option 4? Other? Explain Please! 2 2.27%
 

Vote in this poll

View poll

Which situation would you pick

Posted By Message

MrsSchwags
Soccer Baseball Lax Mom

Member since 10/05

11240 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Which situation would you pick

I know I mentioned lots of times moving, coming back, etc...however for some reason DH and I can't figure out what we want. DD will be entering KG in Sept and we really would like to make our minds up so we can move before she starts school.

OPTION 1
Stay in NY
We have a house that is in loan modificiation but the mortgage is and will be very expensive especially if I don't have a job - the house needs a ton of work
DH has a good job
I am an unemployed teacher bouncing from subbing to leave replacments - nothing guaranteed
Family is here


OPTION 2
Relocated back to SC
We have a house there in my inlaws name with a low mortgage
DH can get a job - just may take some time as the accounting market is slow
I can get a job
No family

OPTION 3
Move back to Florida (we lived in Palm beach county 5 years ago)
DH can get a good job there (plenty of job postings in a decent salary range)
I can get a job there
We would have to rent
No immediate family, extended family in Naples


I hate the insecurity I have with the job market here. I personally hate the cold. I regret moving back from SC since that was all based on my MIL decision.

I'm not close with most of my family. The only one I really talk to is my mom/dad and brother. They are here on LI.

I appreciate any opinions as we are so confused!

Posted 12/11/10 8:11 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

PrincessP
Big sister!!!!!!!!!!

Member since 12/05

17450 total posts

Name:

Re: Which situation would you pick

1 or 2 seems best to me.
1 bc even if you dont have a salary here, DH does. If you move to SC or FL dhs income drops only for you to work and make up that difference AND you have family here that will watch dc whenever.
2 bc you already have a house there so its not like you are re-establishing and you've BTDT so u know what to expect.
3 stinks bc its kinda like starting 1 and 2 over and it accumulates more bills adding to 1 and 2.

Posted 12/11/10 8:28 AM
 

MrsSchwags
Soccer Baseball Lax Mom

Member since 10/05

11240 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Which situation would you pick

Posted by PrincessP

1 or 2 seems best to me.
1 bc even if you dont have a salary here, DH does. If you move to SC or FL dhs income drops only for you to work and make up that difference AND you have family here that will watch dc whenever.
2 bc you already have a house there so its not like you are re-establishing and you've BTDT so u know what to expect.
3 stinks bc its kinda like starting 1 and 2 over and it accumulates more bills adding to 1 and 2.



Thanks Paulette! Actually DH's income may not drop in FL. We have been watching the market and he can most likely find a job within $10,00 of what he is making here.

In SC, he was making $30,000 less than he is making here.

In FL and SC I would make around the same.

The advantage with FL is that if he doesnt like his job there are plenty of other markets and bigger cities for him to find a job. In SC, he wasn't crazy about his job and started looking for a new one and they were hard to come by. Most accounting jobs down there are advertising $40,000 which is less than half of what he makes here. We can't live there on him making $40,000 not with student loans and bills.

Posted 12/11/10 8:54 AM
 

JennP
LIF Adult

Member since 10/06

3986 total posts

Name:
Jenn

Re: Which situation would you pick

I would say 2 or 3.

Now I will explain the bias with which I answered your question.Chat Icon

I am in the same boat as you, career wise - I'm an unemployed teacher looking for a job. I know, however, that I could never leave NY. Logistically, for a million reasons: DH has a daughter who lives here 4/7 nights a week, my widowed mom depends on me for certain things, DH and I each own a house here, etc. etc. My own baby is 8 months old so schools aren't an issue yet.

That's the "ability" part, but if I'm honest with myself, I could never do it. I just think NY is home to me, and where I belong.

Back to you: My point is that if I was *able* to and *wanted* to move, I probably would. I'd have the job I love and a bigger house. So, in a small way, I envy your mobility.

If you hadn't already lived in both places I wouldn't say what I'm saying with such confidence because I know a few people who left and hated it. But if you've lived in either place and would still go back, maybe you should go for it.

I'm not picking between 2 and 3 because there are so many other factors that come into play. Schools? Which did you like better? Etc. I wouldn't let renting in Florida stop you because it won't be forever.

GL!

Message edited 2010-12-11 09:30:31.213000.

Posted 12/11/10 9:29 AM
 

MrsSchwags
Soccer Baseball Lax Mom

Member since 10/05

11240 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Which situation would you pick

Posted by JennP

I would say 2 or 3.

Now I will explain the bias with which I answered your question.Chat Icon

I am in the same boat as you, career wise - I'm an unemployed teacher looking for a job. I know, however, that I could never leave NY. Logistically, for a million reasons: DH has a daughter who lives here 4/7 nights a week, my widowed mom depends on me for certain things, DH and I each own a house here, etc. etc. My own baby is 8 months old so schools aren't an issue yet.

That's the "ability" part, but if I'm honest with myself, I could never do it. I just think NY is home to me, and where I belong.

Back to you: My point is that if I was *able* to and *wanted* to move, I probably would. I'd have the job I love and a bigger house. So, in a small way, I envy your mobility.

If you hadn't already lived in both places I wouldn't say what I'm saying with such confidence because I know a few people who left and hated it. But if you've lived in either place and would still go back, maybe you should go for it.

I'm not picking between 2 and 3 because there are so many other factors that come into play. Schools? Which did you like better? Etc. I wouldn't let renting in Florida stop you because it won't be forever.

GL!



Thanks! I have wanted to leave NY for years. I just feel like if we dont do it this summer, we aren't ever going to do it...so enough of the moving back and forth we need to make a decision.

We really loved both FL and SC. They both have their perks. SC is more country with very few things to do for a day trip, where Florida is more city and there is more things near by to do.

My DH wanted to move to FL when we moved to SC but settled because his parents were able to buy both of us a house down there.

I want to move but I don't want to do the physical move again...

I really just want a job. I want to get settled somewhere and make friends and establish ourselves. All we do is bounce.

Posted 12/11/10 9:37 AM
 

DGoldfarb0776
LIF Adolescent

Member since 4/08

767 total posts

Name:
Danielle

Re: Which situation would you pick

Posted by PrincessP

1 or 2 seems best to me.
1 bc even if you dont have a salary here, DH does. If you move to SC or FL dhs income drops only for you to work and make up that difference AND you have family here that will watch dc whenever.
2 bc you already have a house there so its not like you are re-establishing and you've BTDT so u know what to expect.
3 stinks bc its kinda like starting 1 and 2 over and it accumulates more bills adding to 1 and 2.



I have to agree with the 1 or 2 choices for the same reasons.

Posted 12/11/10 4:15 PM
 

LittleBlueBug
Happy Mommy

Member since 9/06

4074 total posts

Name:

Re: Which situation would you pick

I would say move back to SC. It seems like the best option in the long run. Why stress yourself into an early grave trying to make it here?

Posted 12/11/10 4:19 PM
 

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Which situation would you pick

1 or 3.

I was BORED TO DEATH when I lived in NC. So I either have to live near a big City or be close to the water.

How do you like to live? Do you like the convenience of LI and having family around?

Do you like the FL weather?

If you lived in SC, why did you leave and why do you want to go back if you left?

Message edited 2010-12-11 20:34:22.073000.

Posted 12/11/10 7:24 PM
 

KevinNKristin8-15-08
Welcome to the world Chase

Member since 9/08

6162 total posts

Name:
Kristin

Re: Which situation would you pick

For me personally I wanted to stay near my family. That was the most important thing to me. I think it's a very personal decision though; many others may not feel this way!

Posted 12/11/10 8:23 PM
 

SHOPAHOLIC
LIF Adult

Member since 1/07

1712 total posts

Name:

Re: Which situation would you pick

Option #2 - SC is a quicker drive back to NY (family) for Holidays, weddings, if you just miss seeing them, etc.

Posted 12/11/10 8:56 PM
 

Mrs213
????????

Member since 2/09

18986 total posts

Name:

Re: Which situation would you pick

If it were me I would try to stay in NY and downsize. But I love it here, it doesn't sound like you are happy.

I agree with SC since you already have a place to stay and your in lawas are there...

Posted 12/11/10 9:03 PM
 

MrsSchwags
Soccer Baseball Lax Mom

Member since 10/05

11240 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Which situation would you pick

A few things to answer:

I love the warm weather...I hate the cold and snow. I was happy when we lived in either state.

We left SC because my MIL said she was miserable and wanted to move back. At first we thought that was best to be near family, but since we have been back we have been regretting it.

I like being near the water and all 3 locations are within 20 minutes.

Message edited 2010-12-12 09:16:14.433000.

Posted 12/12/10 9:15 AM
 

Erica
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

11767 total posts

Name:

Re: Which situation would you pick

How do you know that you will have a job in SC?


I know when I moved to CA, a question I was asked in interviews was if I planned to move back to NY. When I did move back, there were questions if I was planning on moving back to CA.


It might be that moving back and forth and back and forth is tearing up your resume.

Posted 12/12/10 11:50 AM
 

MrsSchwags
Soccer Baseball Lax Mom

Member since 10/05

11240 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Which situation would you pick

Posted by Erica

How do you know that you will have a job in SC?


I know when I moved to CA, a question I was asked in interviews was if I planned to move back to NY. When I did move back, there were questions if I was planning on moving back to CA.


It might be that moving back and forth and back and forth is tearing up your resume.



I know because I have already spoken to HR. They are in need of math teachers - especially with experience. I didn't leave on bad terms.

Posted 12/12/10 12:03 PM
 

mrswask
Pookie Love

Member since 5/05

20229 total posts

Name:
Michal

Re: Which situation would you pick

OK - I'm biased because I would love for you to pick #3 so I have a friend nearbyChat Icon Chat Icon

Reaslistically though, in your case, I would go with #2 or #3. It's always seemed, from what you've posted, that as soon as you left SC and came back to NY, you regretted it.

It's hard to pick between 2 and 3 because you have a house in SC and that's a biggie - but I would go with what would make you more happy as a whole. As someone said, you wouldn't rent forever in FL - we only rented for 2 years before we bought. I think that SC sounds more isolating - S FL is more "NY" - if that's what you're looking for - more to do, more northerners, more stores, etc. The fact that you said DH's salary would be almost the same in FL as in NY is huge.
Plus, if I remember correctly, you're a math teacher, right? HUGE demand for math teachers down here - my school can't keep enough!

Posted 12/12/10 12:03 PM
 

DRMom
Two in Blue

Member since 5/05

20223 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Which situation would you pick

Posted by MrsSchwags

A few things to answer:

I love the warm weather...I hate the cold and snow. I was happy when we lived in either state.

We left SC because my MIL said she was miserable and wanted to move back. At first we thought that was best to be near family, but since we have been back we have been regretting it.

I like being near the water and all 3 locations are within 20 minutes.




I also lived in SC(downtown Charleston) I mostly hated it. I was PG at the time which had a lot to do with it...couldn't stand the smells, the drunks, the fact that I wasn't drunkChat Icon etc. I think you had said the house was in Summerville? I feel like SV is SOOO far out and nothing to do there. Is there a possibility you could sell that house an ddo Johns Island, Mt Pleasant or something like that?

Posted 12/12/10 12:16 PM
 

JandJ1224

Member since 6/06

5911 total posts

Name:
Jannette

Re: Which situation would you pick

Seemed like your were happiest in SC. I would see if your DH can find a job he likes there.

If you decide to stay in NY we should get together more often!

Posted 12/12/10 1:25 PM
 

DiamondGirl
You are my I love you

Member since 7/09

18802 total posts

Name:
DiamondMama

Re: Which situation would you pick

Knowing you from the teachers board it seems that the choice in which you would happiest is one of the two that you would be able to have a full time teaching position.

I know from your past posts that you are stuggling with the decision to move but you keep coming back to wanting to so maybe it would be the best thing for you. Chat Icon

Is Dh willing and wanting to move also? If so I think you should Chat Icon

Message edited 2010-12-12 14:55:11.117000.

Posted 12/12/10 2:54 PM
 

MrsSchwags
Soccer Baseball Lax Mom

Member since 10/05

11240 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Which situation would you pick

Thanks again everyone.

He wants to move but he doesn't. He is more of a momma's boy.

The house in SC has been on the market since Feb-March. We barely have anyone come look at it. Even though its a brand new house, people can customize their house for the price of ours...so unless you want to buy in a hurry our house is going to keep sitting.


(It's currently listed at 189 if anyone is interested!)

Summerville is about 25 minutes from Charleston and there isn't much to do. But we liked it. But we liked FL also.

I'm so tired of moving. I was happy both times out of state. It's such a shame that the job market here stinks for teachers.

I have even thought about changing careers just to stay here - but I don't know if I am ready to change careers. I am happy with teaching. I really like it.

I swear I feel as if my head just keeps spinning and spinning. I can never make the right decisions! It's so annoying. Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 12/13/10 6:50 AM
 

browneyedgirl
family is all that matters

Member since 6/06

6513 total posts

Name:
browneyes

Re: Which situation would you pick

NY--stay with family. to me that's more important

Posted 12/13/10 9:09 AM
 

Lina
My angel is finally here

Member since 5/10

2559 total posts

Name:
Lindsay

Re: Which situation would you pick

I said option 2 but have you considered other options. There are plenty of other places in NY that are WAY less expensive than here and you wouldn't make that much less money. I am from Buffalo and you could get an AMAZING house for under 200K there and that is a REALLY NICE HOUSE. If we didn't have to be here for DH's job we wouldn't, it is insanely expensive. If you moved somewhere else in NY you could get a nice house for less $ and not have to worry about finding a job so quickly. Just a thought.

Posted 12/13/10 10:05 AM
 

JDubs
different, not less

Member since 7/09

13160 total posts

Name:

Re: Which situation would you pick

i say SC if you're not going to struggle there and can both get jobs.

Posted 12/13/10 1:19 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Meh! Pick up the phone! Pick up the phone! VirginiaDeb 2/21/07 3 Pets
Help! I can't pick a color....Did you ever pick a paint color, hate it, and repaint immediately? krashnburn 11/17/05 5 Home
spinoof to pick up lines.. where did he use this pick up line? where did you meet? 04bride 10/6/05 0 Families Helping Families ™
Need advice on stressful lawyer situation DKF1016 5/14/05 8 Home
Do you pick TheInfamousOTG 5/12/05 31 Families Helping Families ™
POLL - Help me pick a watch Please Leeners 5/12/05 16 Families Helping Families ™