What would you do? Buying a cape question...

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

Sandy55
My family ROCKS!!!

Member since 2/08

1219 total posts

Name:
Sandy

What would you do? Buying a cape question...

My hubby and I found a house in a great neighborhood at a price we can afford..BUT:
it is a 3 bedroom 1 bath cape.
There are 2 bedrooms downstairs, and the 3rd is upstairs.
We would eventually want to add a bathroom upstairs and dormer the cape, but not sure if it is worth it (around $50k??).
This house would be a house we would live in for 5 to 10 years. I know we would have to eventually sell it, and a cape with one bathroom doesn't have a great resale value.
Has anyone experienced this "what if?"
TIA!
Chat Icon

Posted 9/1/08 8:24 PM
 
Prudential Douglas Elliman Real Estate
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
  |   Long Island Weddings

Teri
my girls!

Member since 2/06

1491 total posts

Name:
Teri

Re: What would you do? Buying a cape question...

I'm not really clear on your question? But we have a 4 bdrm, 1 bath cape - but the upstairs is already rear-dormered and there is a large room for the future 2nd bath - many capes we looked at didn't have this so it would have been even more work. We're thinking of adding the 2nd bath next year and were quoted it would be around $8k for a decent bathroom, but we don't have to worry about actually dormering or anything since that's done already.

But I agree, a 2 bathroom house is much more appealing when it comes down to selling it.

Posted 9/1/08 8:40 PM
 

ready2ttc
LIF Toddler

Member since 8/08

383 total posts

Name:

Re: What would you do? Buying a cape question...

I personally wouldn't do it knowing you have to put that much into it. Chat Icon 1 bathroom houses don't have good resale (and neither do capes in general), so I wouldn't throw that much into it. In general, many buyers do not want homes with split bedrooms on different floors, so I wouldn't assume that it will increase the value by that much.

Message edited 2008-09-01 21:10:14.890000.

Posted 9/1/08 8:58 PM
 

Palebride
I am an amazing bakist

Member since 5/05

13673 total posts

Name:
Lori

Re: What would you do? Buying a cape question...

We bought a cape with the back dormered. We have 4 bedrooms - 2 up and 2 down, and 2 bathrooms, 1 up and 1 down.
If you do dormer upstairs, there is room for a bathroom, which might change your plan a little and will help with resale.

Posted 9/1/08 9:01 PM
 

JandJ1224

Member since 6/06

5911 total posts

Name:
Jannette

Re: What would you do? Buying a cape question...

You might be better off finding a cape that is already dormered as it is probably cheaper than buying and then dormering yourself.

Posted 9/1/08 9:43 PM
 

Teri
my girls!

Member since 2/06

1491 total posts

Name:
Teri

Re: What would you do? Buying a cape question...

Posted by ready2ttc

1 bathroom houses don't have good resale (and neither do capes in general), so I wouldn't throw that much into it.



I do not agree with this at all! Not everyone likes capes, but you can't rule them out entirely regarding their resale value. (I'm speaking of the actual house type and not how many bathrooms you have).

Posted 9/1/08 10:13 PM
 

VickiC
Rocking the party

Member since 5/05

4937 total posts

Name:
Vicki

Re: What would you do? Buying a cape question...

Posted by Teri

Posted by ready2ttc

1 bathroom houses don't have good resale (and neither do capes in general), so I wouldn't throw that much into it.



I do not agree with this at all! Not everyone likes capes, but you can't rule them out entirely regarding their resale value. (I'm speaking of the actual house type and not how many bathrooms you have).



Totally agree with this statement. We have a one bath, 4 BR cape as well. Obviously only having one bathroom didn't effect the resale value for the previous owners. The potential that a Cape give you far surpasses some other home styles.

Plus, there are many homes that we saw that only had one bath, splits and ranches included. You need to do what is best for YOU and if you think it is worthwhile to invest that money into a house that you might resell in 10 years.

Posted 9/2/08 8:16 AM
 

Sandy55
My family ROCKS!!!

Member since 2/08

1219 total posts

Name:
Sandy

Re: What would you do? Buying a cape question...

Thanks everyone!
I guess what I'm really asking if it is worth it knowing that we would have to put at least $50K into it.

But it is a GREAT neighborhood, and a GREAT school district, GREAT price.
I am so torn.

Posted 9/2/08 9:41 AM
 

ave1024
I Took The Wrong Road

Member since 12/07

6153 total posts

Name:
That Led To The Wrong Tendencies

Re: What would you do? Buying a cape question...

Posted by Sandy55

Thanks everyone!
I guess what I'm really asking if it is worth it knowing that we would have to put at least $50K into it.

But it is a GREAT neighborhood, and a GREAT school district, GREAT price.
I am so torn.




A full dormer will cost more than 50k. More like 70k and up.

If you like the house and can get it at a great price, I would look into it. But just keep in mind getting a house that is already dormered will most likely not cost 70k more.

Posted 9/2/08 9:45 AM
 

Sandy55
My family ROCKS!!!

Member since 2/08

1219 total posts

Name:
Sandy

Re: What would you do? Buying a cape question...

Posted by ave1024

Posted by Sandy55

Thanks everyone!
I guess what I'm really asking if it is worth it knowing that we would have to put at least $50K into it.

But it is a GREAT neighborhood, and a GREAT school district, GREAT price.
I am so torn.




A full dormer will cost more than 50k. More like 70k and up.

If you like the house and can get it at a great price, I would look into it. But just keep in mind getting a house that is already dormered will most likely not cost 70k more.




Yeah...that's a lot.
Then we should probably reconsider the dormer; Maybe plan on just adding a bathroom upstairs.

Posted 9/2/08 9:53 AM
 

ave1024
I Took The Wrong Road

Member since 12/07

6153 total posts

Name:
That Led To The Wrong Tendencies

Re: What would you do? Buying a cape question...

Posted by Sandy55

Yeah...that's a lot.
Then we should probably reconsider the dormer; Maybe plan on just adding a bathroom upstairs.




Yeah that will obviously be cheaper. I know soup to nuts cape dormers typically run about 70k and up.

Granted they give you a TON more living space. A lot of times they can squeeze three bedrooms up there, all with closets, and a bathroom (sometimes with a second master suite bathroom).

Posted 9/2/08 9:55 AM
 

MetsGirl07
LIF O2 Vendor

Member since 12/07

16202 total posts

Name:
<FONT COLOR="#9933CC">Deanna</FONT>

Re: What would you do? Buying a cape question...

Posted by VickiC

Posted by Teri

Posted by ready2ttc

1 bathroom houses don't have good resale (and neither do capes in general), so I wouldn't throw that much into it.



I do not agree with this at all! Not everyone likes capes, but you can't rule them out entirely regarding their resale value. (I'm speaking of the actual house type and not how many bathrooms you have).



Totally agree with this statement. We have a one bath, 4 BR cape as well. Obviously only having one bathroom didn't effect the resale value for the previous owners. The potential that a Cape give you far surpasses some other home styles.

Plus, there are many homes that we saw that only had one bath, splits and ranches included. You need to do what is best for YOU and if you think it is worthwhile to invest that money into a house that you might resell in 10 years.



i agree with both these statements!

Posted 9/2/08 10:09 AM
 

Sandy55
My family ROCKS!!!

Member since 2/08

1219 total posts

Name:
Sandy

Re: What would you do? Buying a cape question...

Posted by ave1024

Posted by Sandy55

Yeah...that's a lot.
Then we should probably reconsider the dormer; Maybe plan on just adding a bathroom upstairs.




Yeah that will obviously be cheaper. I know soup to nuts cape dormers typically run about 70k and up.

Granted they give you a TON more living space. A lot of times they can squeeze three bedrooms up there, all with closets, and a bathroom (sometimes with a second master suite bathroom).



Any ideas how much it would cost to add one bathroom and one bedroom without dormering?

Posted 9/2/08 10:11 AM
 

Aries14
Can't plan life...

Member since 8/08

2860 total posts

Name:

Re: What would you do? Buying a cape question...

Posted by Sandy55

Thanks everyone!
I guess what I'm really asking if it is worth it knowing that we would have to put at least $50K into it.

But it is a GREAT neighborhood, and a GREAT school district, GREAT price.
I am so torn.




This stuff would be more important to me then the number of bathrooms (as your potenial future buyer,lol). We recently purchased an expanded cape that luckly has 4 bedrooms and 2 full baths - but I love the charm of capes and like I said, the neighborhood, school district and price would be more of what I would look at. Is there a reason that you plan on selling again in 5 years? Just wondering bc when we started looking I was so into the "resale" value and looked at a house that way instead of just looking for a home that suits us and fits our needs. As soon as someone pointed that out to me I changed the way I looked at houses and it really made a difference of my feelings for it. Even if you have to sell a few years down the line, there will most likely be another couple who the house will fit just fine, especially if it is in a good area/district. Good Luck!!

Posted 9/2/08 10:27 AM
 

Sandy55
My family ROCKS!!!

Member since 2/08

1219 total posts

Name:
Sandy

Re: What would you do? Buying a cape question...

Posted by Lake0703

Posted by Sandy55

Thanks everyone!
I guess what I'm really asking if it is worth it knowing that we would have to put at least $50K into it.

But it is a GREAT neighborhood, and a GREAT school district, GREAT price.
I am so torn.




This stuff would be more important to me then the number of bathrooms (as your potenial future buyer,lol). We recently purchased an expanded cape that luckly has 4 bedrooms and 2 full baths - but I love the charm of capes and like I said, the neighborhood, school district and price would be more of what I would look at. Is there a reason that you plan on selling again in 5 years? Just wondering bc when we started looking I was so into the "resale" value and looked at a house that way instead of just looking for a home that suits us and fits our needs. As soon as someone pointed that out to me I changed the way I looked at houses and it really made a difference of my feelings for it. Even if you have to sell a few years down the line, there will most likely be another couple who the house will fit just fine, especially if it is in a good area/district. Good Luck!!



thank you for pointing that out to me....I haven't even thought of thinking that way. Honestly, now that I think of it, the house is just fine for us for now. :o)
I'm not even sure we would be moving in 5-10 years; but it may be a possibility.

Posted 9/2/08 10:30 AM
 

ave1024
I Took The Wrong Road

Member since 12/07

6153 total posts

Name:
That Led To The Wrong Tendencies

Re: What would you do? Buying a cape question...

Posted by Sandy55

Posted by ave1024

Posted by Sandy55

Yeah...that's a lot.
Then we should probably reconsider the dormer; Maybe plan on just adding a bathroom upstairs.




Yeah that will obviously be cheaper. I know soup to nuts cape dormers typically run about 70k and up.

Granted they give you a TON more living space. A lot of times they can squeeze three bedrooms up there, all with closets, and a bathroom (sometimes with a second master suite bathroom).



Any ideas how much it would cost to add one bathroom and one bedroom without dormering?




There really isn't any way to know this for sure. There could be a number of obstacles involved with adding a bathroom if you aren't doing a full domer.

You would probably have to just go out and get some quotes.

Posted 9/2/08 11:40 AM
 

ARIELSMOM
Love my Babes

Member since 8/05

5889 total posts

Name:
MEREDITH

Re: What would you do? Buying a cape question...

when i was house hunting, having the second bath wasnt a deal breaker for us. We knew we could add one down the road, and if we sold the house with only 1 bath, someone could do the same.
its a downfall, but not a dealbreaker- for us atleast.
(we have a 3bdrm 1ba cape- not dormered)

Posted 9/2/08 11:47 AM
 

Sandy55
My family ROCKS!!!

Member since 2/08

1219 total posts

Name:
Sandy

Re: What would you do? Buying a cape question...

Posted by ARIELSMOM

when i was house hunting, having the second bath wasnt a deal breaker for us. We knew we could add one down the road, and if we sold the house with only 1 bath, someone could do the same.
its a downfall, but not a dealbreaker- for us atleast.
(we have a 3bdrm 1ba cape- not dormered)


Hi.
Where are the bedrooms?
Upstairs/downstairs?

Posted 9/2/08 11:49 AM
 

bklynitaliana
LIF Infant

Member since 7/07

331 total posts

Name:
Angela

Re: What would you do? Buying a cape question...

Dh and I bought a cape that is not dormered.. however we converted the two downstair bedrooms into a living room and office for DH.. for resale value 4 bedrooms is more appealing than 2 but for us this is what we wanted(I wanted my formal dining room) and have two bedrooms upstairs with a w/ a 1/2 bath which seperates the two. This is also something to consider b/c it stacks right on top of the main bath on the first floor. We went for location school distract. Those were more important than the dormer.

Posted 9/2/08 12:04 PM
 

Sandy55
My family ROCKS!!!

Member since 2/08

1219 total posts

Name:
Sandy

Re: What would you do? Buying a cape question...

Posted by bklynitaliana

Dh and I bought a cape that is not dormered.. however we converted the two downstair bedrooms into a living room and office for DH.. for resale value 4 bedrooms is more appealing than 2 but for us this is what we wanted(I wanted my formal dining room) and have two bedrooms upstairs with a w/ a 1/2 bath which seperates the two. This is also something to consider b/c it stacks right on top of the main bath on the first floor. We went for location school distract. Those were more important than the dormer.



That is what I'm thinking too....
It's a great location and district.

Posted 9/2/08 12:07 PM
 

ave1024
I Took The Wrong Road

Member since 12/07

6153 total posts

Name:
That Led To The Wrong Tendencies

Re: What would you do? Buying a cape question...

If you want to add a dining room to a Cape, you can also try doing a side extension or a rear extension.

That won't cost you as much as a full upstairs dormer. Maybe 30-50k.

Posted 9/2/08 12:14 PM
 

VickiC
Rocking the party

Member since 5/05

4937 total posts

Name:
Vicki

Re: What would you do? Buying a cape question...

For us, when we plan to dormer our cape we'd like to add a master suite and bathroom upstairs so that we'd have 3 BR's upstairs. We'd get rid of our MBR now downstairs and open that wall to become the DR. We'd keep that 4th BR downstairs as an office or Guest room.

Posted 9/2/08 1:57 PM
 

ali120206
2 Boys

Member since 7/06

17796 total posts

Name:

Re: What would you do? Buying a cape question...

Posted by VickiC

For us, when we plan to dormer our cape we'd like to add a master suite and bathroom upstairs so that we'd have 3 BR's upstairs. We'd get rid of our MBR now downstairs and open that wall to become the DR. We'd keep that 4th BR downstairs as an office or Guest room.



We're planning on doing the same thing (although we're currently living in one of the upstairs bedrooms and put the dining room in the traditional MB already (but, didn't open the wall).

ETA - We bought a cape. There were only two options that we could afford - cape or ranch - and we found a great deal on a cape on a nice piece of land, in a great neighborhood with great schools.

Message edited 2008-09-02 14:20:03.493000.

Posted 9/2/08 2:16 PM
 

ILJ619
LIF Adult

Member since 6/06

1985 total posts

Name:
Irene

Re: What would you do? Buying a cape question...

Can I ask if looking for a 2nd bathroom upstairs would be much more? Reason I ask is b/c initially we looked at 4 bed 1 bath but then it seem to cost us less to buy the 2nd bathroom so to speak 25K in asking price vs 50K+ to rear dormer ourselves. We ended up getting a rear dormered cape with the 2nd bath upstairs. HTH.

Posted 9/2/08 5:33 PM
 

twinkletoes807
Mommy's Girls! &hearts;

Member since 11/07

10116 total posts

Name:
Gabi

Re: What would you do? Buying a cape question...

My parents, 2 sisters, 1 brother and I grew up in a cape that was not dormered. Originally, It had 1 bathroom. As the years went on, my parents finished the basement and added a bathroom and a bedroom. Can you finish the basement in the house you are looking at? It worked fine for our family of 6. Chat Icon

Posted 9/3/08 8:19 AM
 
Pages: [1] 2
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Question about buying a home Pumpkin 6/23/06 7 Home
Question buying electronics from stores! MissJones 6/18/06 8 Families Helping Families ™
Buying a home - permit question Ang-Rich 6/12/06 13 Home
Question re: buying an open-ended plane ticket MrsJ 3/27/06 4 Families Helping Families ™
Neurotic Mom Question on buying used baby clothing? Calla 10/13/05 19 Parenting
ANother question about buying MissJones 7/22/05 2 Home