What would you do....

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

MrsSx2
Finally a MOM!

Member since 11/10

2222 total posts

Name:
Valerie

What would you do....

My SIL bought her granddaughter a doll and some clothing from Target for her birthday last month. My SIL threw her a small party of her own. Well, the following week, the mother of the little girl threw her own party. It turns out, to get extra $$ for the party, she returned all the gifts my SIL bought for her. Her granddaughter is soooo upset (especially over the doll). My SIL actually found out because she asked the child where the doll was and she told her "Mommy brought it back to Target and got other stuff for my party instead". I was pi$$ed over this, and so is SIL.

So, MY SIL doesn't know if she should mention it to her daughter in law...or just leave it alone. What would you guys do?

Message edited 2011-10-25 23:54:19.383000.

Posted 10/25/11 10:28 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

jilliibabii
Mrs. O'Connor

Member since 6/10

12821 total posts

Name:
Jillian

Re: What what you do....

I would be LIVID. I don't think I'd say anything though. I'd just make it a point to make sure that every gift that kid gets is out of the box, tags off, no gift receipts, ready to play with.

Posted 10/25/11 10:30 AM
 

Linda1003
love my 2 boys

Member since 8/08

10923 total posts

Name:
Linda

Re: What what you do....

Posted by jilliibabii

I would be LIVID. I don't think I'd say anything though. I'd just make it a point to make sure that every gift that kid gets is out of the box, tags off, no gift receipts, ready to play with.



this!! and Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 10/25/11 10:31 AM
 

neener1211
:-)

Member since 4/07

22952 total posts

Name:
J

Re: What what you do....

Posted by jilliibabii

I would be LIVID. I don't think I'd say anything though. I'd just make it a point to make sure that every gift that kid gets is out of the box, tags off, no gift receipts, ready to play with.



I would do this, but I would say something. I wouldn't be able to keep my mouth shut.

Posted 10/25/11 10:31 AM
 

mrsh2010
To travel is to live.

Member since 7/09

1679 total posts

Name:
Celia

Re: What what you do....

OMG!! That was horrible! I would most definitely mention it to her! The nerve of some people! and that poor little girl! Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 10/25/11 10:33 AM
 

MrsDamonSalv7319
Somewhere in Westeros

Member since 10/10

4495 total posts

Name:

Re: What what you do....

I feel bad for the little girl, but why did your SIL throw her granddaughter a party if the mom was going to? Maybe the mom wanted to be the one to throw the party and was mad the grandma beat her to it??

Either way I feel bad for the little girl who was given a gift and had it taken away. If I was your SIL I'd prob go buy it for her again.

Posted 10/25/11 10:36 AM
 

LSP2005
Bunny kisses are so cute!

Member since 5/05

19461 total posts

Name:
L

Re: What what you do....

Posted by Linda1003

Posted by jilliibabii

I would be LIVID. I don't think I'd say anything though. I'd just make it a point to make sure that every gift that kid gets is out of the box, tags off, no gift receipts, ready to play with.



this!! and Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon



ITA. I would no longer give the gift receipt and write the kids name on the tag inside the doll. I would be livid. And yes, I would get a new doll for the granddaughter.

Posted 10/25/11 10:54 AM
 

PrettyPeonies
GAW my baby boy <3

Member since 8/10

3874 total posts

Name:
Pino

Re: What what you do....

How very "Mommy Dearest" of this woman. How a persona could do that to her own child is beyond me. I agree w/ PP that moving forward all gifts should be in the state on no return. I dont know if she should say anything per say... its done and over with. If she feels she must say something, I would advise her to approach her DIL in a non confrontational way.

Posted 10/25/11 10:57 AM
 

imyself

Member since 10/06

2938 total posts

Name:
me

Re: What what you do....

My mil does the same as you sil. She has cake and presents for everyone's birthday. I always thought it was sweet of her. She doesn't do it to step on toes just to do something special for the birthday. If the dil was that hard up for money she should have asked for help not returned the poor girls birthday gifts. I would buy her a new one but give it out of the package. My il's usually take the toys out of the boxes for us and then wrap them. It makes life so much easier for us since we don't have to fight with all those darn fasteners while the kid is jumping up and down waiting for the toy :)

Posted 10/25/11 11:01 AM
 

timefortwo
LIF Infant

Member since 10/11

321 total posts

Name:

Re: What what you do....

while it sucks, what can you do? once you give the gift, it is their's to do with as they please. Chat Icon

Posted 10/25/11 11:08 AM
 

Naner325
waiting on nugget!

Member since 6/10

4432 total posts

Name:
N

Re: What what you do....

I would be pi$$ed and I would do as others have suggested and give gifts that can not be returned in the future. I would also be sure to give the little girl a new doll, out of the packaging, in front of the mother to make a point but I would most likely not say something

Posted 10/25/11 11:20 AM
 

Sweetheart409
LIF Adult

Member since 11/10

2219 total posts

Name:

Re: What what you do....

i would be so pizzed! i'm not the type of person NOT to say something, i would have to talk to my daughter in law if i found this out. i would say it in a nice way but let her know that she shouldn't have done that especially since the granddaughter liked the doll. if the granddaughter didn't like the doll i could accept returning it a little more.

Posted 10/25/11 11:52 AM
 

BellaRock
I am all the Me I will ever Be

Member since 5/06

9746 total posts

Name:
She who shall remain nameless

Re: What what you do....

I would be so beyond livid that I would have to say something. I don't think my brain would be able to stop my mouth in this case. Chat Icon Chat Icon

In the future all toys would be opened up and totally nonreturnable.

Posted 10/25/11 12:09 PM
 

mamabear
LIF Adult

Member since 3/08

4539 total posts

Name:

Re: What what you do....

if there is nothing more to the story, that seems really cruel. I feel really bad for the little girl. I don't know if I would say something, though. What good would come of saying something? And maybe there is another side to the story... What I would do is go out and buy that little girl another one of the same dolls, take it out of the box and give it to her.

ETA--just trying to give the mother the benefit of the doubt here--but maybe the little girl wasn't crazy about the presents, so the mother exchanged without saying something, and the little girl doesn't want to say anything about not liking the presents? Either way--I would get the girl a new doll--that can't hurt.

Message edited 2011-10-25 12:34:14.060000.

Posted 10/25/11 12:30 PM
 

annoyedTTCer
LIF Adult

Member since 4/09

3272 total posts

Name:

Re: What what you do....

I'd totally say something

The gifts I give kids are for them to enjoy, not to help parents pay their bills or fund their own activities


I'd be buying that kid personalized gifts going forward just to be a beoytch to the mother


Message edited 2011-10-25 12:39:20.147000.

Posted 10/25/11 12:38 PM
 

BargainMama
LIF Adult

Member since 5/09

15660 total posts

Name:

Re: What what you do....

Maybe the mother didn't want her to have the doll or some reason? I know in the past my child has received some dolls from a store that I would prefer her not have (the particular brand she got was known to not hold up well), so we returned them. We did get something else for her though. I think there is probably more to the story. I personally wouldn't buy her a new doll, I would let it go.

Posted 10/25/11 12:52 PM
 

DrMeg
Back home!

Member since 5/08

1858 total posts

Name:
Meg

Re: What what you do....

Posted by Naner325

I would be pi$$ed and I would do as others have suggested and give gifts that can not be returned in the future. I would also be sure to give the little girl a new doll, out of the packaging, in front of the mother to make a point but I would most likely not say something



This. I think by giving a new gift, the point would be very clearly made to the DIL.

Posted 10/25/11 12:55 PM
 

Pray4Baby2010
<3 Cutest Giants Fan

Member since 10/09

5796 total posts

Name:
MB

Re: What what you do....

I dont know what actually happened or their relationship but I can tell you that I love my mil but she constantly buys age in-appropriate gifts for my son

I keep them because I would never want to hurt her feelings- but my son's only 11 months- its possible at some point, I'll be forced to return them if we run out of space.

just another perspective

Posted 10/25/11 1:49 PM
 

MrsBurtch525
Year for change!

Member since 1/09

6017 total posts

Name:
Taryn

Re: What what you do....

Posted by mrsh2010

OMG!! That was horrible! I would most definitely mention it to her! The nerve of some people! and that poor little girl! Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon



Exactly, I would have to say something, I can't imagine how upset that poor little girl was when her mother returned that doll. A doll lasts more than a party would!

Posted 10/25/11 1:54 PM
 

MySunshine
In love with my Baby Boy

Member since 3/11

2783 total posts

Name:

Re: What what you do....

As much as I would like to say I would walk away, I couldn't. I would be beyond pi$$ed!!! This was a gift for the little girl NOT a fundraiser for her party. If you can't afford to throw her a party don't have one, don't return my gifts to pay for what you as a parent should be responsible for. I would def ask the mother about the doll and see what she says.

Posted 10/25/11 2:17 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: What what you do....

I could see being upset, but coming from a household where I've reached max toy capacity, you would need to see what the full story is.

I wouldn't think twice about asking my fictitious daughter in law why she returned my gift to my fictitious granddaughter. It sounds absolutely logical. Until you're the daughter-in-law who has a mother in law that buys the kid whatever her heart desires. The one whose kid is begging for an expensive American Girl Doll and her grandmother gets her a doll from Target instead. Throw in maybe the doll is from China (which doesn't regulate the lead in toys) & I can see why.

There are many ways this story can go.

All of which may result in making the DIL & the MIL's relationship strained.

I had someone who would tell me to get whatever thing their child wanted. When the toys started costing $80-100 and I realized that she was ebaying toys, I got the kids a small gift & savings bond. Then the mom cashed the savings bonds in to buy the kids things (that they probably never knew were from me). What I'm getting at is that it's possible that you can't win this one.

If the goal is to maintain a cordial relationship with her DIL & son's family, walk on egg shells.

Message edited 2011-10-25 14:46:43.687000.

Posted 10/25/11 2:45 PM
 

MrsDamonSalv7319
Somewhere in Westeros

Member since 10/10

4495 total posts

Name:

Re: What what you do....

Posted by Pray4Baby2010

I dont know what actually happened or their relationship but I can tell you that I love my mil but she constantly buys age in-appropriate gifts for my son

I keep them because I would never want to hurt her feelings- but my son's only 11 months- its possible at some point, I'll be forced to return them if we run out of space.

just another perspective



My ILs do this too...toys are given age limits for a reason. I have kept them too bc DD will grow into them, but w/Christmas coming, I could see myself returning some if she got a bunch of inappropriate toys for some stuff she could use now.

But I'm a BIG returner. I ALWAYS put either a lot of thought into a gift, get what I KNOW the person wants/needs, or give a gift card. I would have no problem if someone returned my gift to get something they could use more. It is still from me in my mind.

Posted 10/25/11 2:49 PM
 

dpli
Daylight savings :)

Member since 5/05

13973 total posts

Name:
D

Re: What what you do....

I'd probably leave it alone. Or I might buy another doll and leave it at my house for her to play with when she came over.

Posted 10/25/11 2:52 PM
 

brownie
Baby #1 is here!

Member since 11/08

13903 total posts

Name:

Re: What what you do....

Posted by timefortwo

while it sucks, what can you do? once you give the gift, it is their's to do with as they please. Chat Icon



ITA

Posted 10/25/11 3:10 PM
 

MrsM429
Mama x2 <3

Member since 12/10

4946 total posts

Name:

Re: What what you do....

Posted by BellaRock

I would be so beyond livid that I would have to say something. I don't think my brain would be able to stop my mouth in this case. Chat Icon Chat Icon

In the future all toys would be opened up and totally nonreturnable.




This. I can't believe the nerve of that woman. Especially when that little girl obviously liked and wanted that present. I'd without a doubt say something

Posted 10/25/11 3:16 PM
 
Pages: [1] 2