**UPDATE** Desperate for advice: POOP TRAINING

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

Mere09
So Dam* Lucky

Member since 10/08

6368 total posts

Name:

**UPDATE** Desperate for advice: POOP TRAINING

DS is 3.5.

He has been pee trained and out of diapers since February. He STILL will not poop on the potty.

Through the summer, to save our sanity, we put him back in diapers at night and during naps, knowing that if we did that, he would use that time to poop in his diaper...which he always did. He will hold it all day and wait until he has a diaper on to poop.

Every couple of months we would take the diapers away all together, hoping THIS would be the time that it would CLICK and he would finally poop on the potty...but no. Failure every time. He will hold it in for days, and then finally he would hide and poop his pants the moment you take your eyes off of him.

We've tried everything. Sticker charts, rewards, taking away his favorite things when he has accidents, reading to him while he's on the potty. He's only ever had two successful poops on the potty, and both times are from when we left him on the potty for an extended period of time (30 minutes or so), and that's just not realistic plus it seems kinda cruel to leave him sitting there for that long.

For whatever reason, he is completely terrified of pooping on the potty. He's certainly ready physically because he can time it perfectly for his diapers, but is obviously not ready mentally. I'm just not sure where to go from here.

And I do realise that going back and forth between wearing diapers/not wearing diapers is not helping. But we just get so fed up and finally say..."He's not ready! Put him back in diapers." We really want it to stick this time.

I know a lot of parents have experienced issues with poop training...so I'm wondering what finally worked for these people??

Please help! We're desperate!

Message edited 2014-02-04 16:51:57.000000.

Posted 12/17/13 3:18 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

oneday
<3

Member since 5/05

4319 total posts

Name:
Pam

Re: Desperate for advice: POOP TRAINING

Hoping someone has ideas for you because I am trying to figure out what to do as well.

DS was 4 in Sept. He was pee trained for over a year. He doesn't - and I don't think has ever - pooped in his pants. But, he won't poop on the potty. When he has to poop, he says he wants to "Hide" and that means he wants a pull-up and he goes off and poops and we change him.

We have tried numerous times to tell him we have no more or he HAS to go on the potty. He holds it in until he is totally constipated and crying. And then - sorry, TMI - we end up with skid marks but still, he won't go.

We have tried threatening, bribing (we told him he would have ice cream for dinner and chocolate candy for desert - watch all the Star Wars Movies - ANYTHING he wants) - and he still says "No thank you" and just goes to hide. We are at our wits end!!

The ped told us to try and lay off him, and we did, but it's just so frustrating!!

Posted 12/17/13 3:56 PM
 

NervousNell
Just another chapter in life..

Member since 11/09

54921 total posts

Name:
..being a mommy and being a wife!

Re: Desperate for advice: POOP TRAINING

ANother same boat here.
DD is just about 3.5 and REFUSES to poop on the potty.
She says it hurts. Yet it doesn't hurt to do it in her pants.
Chat Icon
We have tried EVERYTHING.
EVERYTHING.
nothing works
I have no idea what to do.
Glad I am not alone but MAN this is awful!

Posted 12/17/13 4:39 PM
 

Kelly9904
Mommy to 2 amazing little boys

Member since 5/05

9306 total posts

Name:
Kelly

Re: Desperate for advice: POOP TRAINING

This was us! DS1 pee pee trained in literally 1 day! BUt it took maybe a year or more to poop. During the early days of this stage, he became severly constipated and needed miralax to help. Once we got over that, the ped told me explain to him tha the can use a diper, pull up or the potty, but that poop in his pants was not okay. He only had 1 accident. For over a year he would wear underwear all day and then ask for a pull up to poop. The ped said as far as she was concerned he was "trained" he was just choosing WHERE to do it, but that he was in full control and wasnt having accidents so he was "trained".
It was rough. seriously threatening did nothing, rewards did nothing (if he called me on all the rewards I offered it woudl probably have cost us nearly 10K!!!). For whatever reason he just couldnt/wouldnt do it.

all i can say is one day it clicked and he said, he would try. once he saw it didnt hurt he was okay. Someone suggested having him wear his diaper while sitting on the potty, someone else suggested a magic wand that makes pooping easy, etc. I tried it all. I jsut kept asking, kept telling him how big kids use hte potty, how daddy used the potty, etc.

Sorry I dont think there is any magic cure, but one day it does just happen! (I think DS was 4 or nearly 4 when he finally pooped on the potty. and once he did I got rid of all pull ups so he understood no going back!)

Posted 12/17/13 4:58 PM
 

KarenK122
The Journey is the Destination

Member since 5/05

4431 total posts

Name:
Karen

Re: Desperate for advice: POOP TRAINING

Posted by oneday

Hoping someone has ideas for you because I am trying to figure out what to do as well.

DS was 4 in Sept. He was pee trained for over a year. He doesn't - and I don't think has ever - pooped in his pants. But, he won't poop on the potty. When he has to poop, he says he wants to "Hide" and that means he wants a pull-up and he goes off and poops and we change him.

We have tried numerous times to tell him we have no more or he HAS to go on the potty. He holds it in until he is totally constipated and crying. And then - sorry, TMI - we end up with skid marks but still, he won't go.

We have tried threatening, bribing (we told him he would have ice cream for dinner and chocolate candy for desert - watch all the Star Wars Movies - ANYTHING he wants) - and he still says "No thank you" and just goes to hide. We are at our wits end!!

The ped told us to try and lay off him, and we did, but it's just so frustrating!!



My DD did the same thing. Was pee trained for a year before she went poop on the potty. She asked for her pull up...went...wiped herself and threw it away and put her underwear back on lol. One day she just decided to do it and that was that. What I think eventually helped her was putting in a step stool in the bathroom for her to rest her feet on. Not to sound to TMI but when she was in the pull up she would be pushing on the ground when she went. On the potty there was nothing to help her push so the step stool helped that.

Good luck!

Posted 12/17/13 5:57 PM
 

DRMom
Two in Blue

Member since 5/05

20223 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Desperate for advice: POOP TRAINING

Same with my son. He ended up going on the potty one day once we said, thats it no more pull ups. He had a few episodes of constipation and not wanting to go, but mostly its been good. I think around 4 and 3 months or so.

Posted 12/17/13 6:16 PM
 

Mere09
So Dam* Lucky

Member since 10/08

6368 total posts

Name:

Re: Desperate for advice: POOP TRAINING

After researching this basically the entire day today, we've come up with a new plan. And it's something that one of the previous posters touched on.

I had DH buy a pack of diapers before he came home from work. When DS woke up from nap, we made a deal. I told him that when he felt like he had to poop, he would have to tell either me or Daddy, and we would put a diaper on for him to poop in BUT he had to poop in his diaper IN the bathroom. He had such a happy look on his face when I told him this. A look of relief. Poor guy. This whole process has got to be just as hard on him as it is on us.

Anyway, we figure we'll have him poop in the diaper in the bathroom for a couple weeks, hopefully transition him to pooping in his diaper while sitting on the potty, and then HOPEFULLY that will lead to him just pooping on the potty. :::FINGERS CROSSED:::

Phase 1 is already working out. About an hour later he told us he had to poop. We put a diaper on him and walked him to the bathroom. Pooped in the diaper! LITTLE VICTORIES PEOPLE!!!! Chat Icon

Posted 12/17/13 6:19 PM
 

Millie3
LIF Adult

Member since 7/13

1280 total posts

Name:

Re: Desperate for advice: POOP TRAINING

My ds is 3.5 as well, same issue. Refuses and hold it in for days. I just give him a diaper now. I can't take these mini man poops anymore Chat Icon we have taken away and given his diapers back. My PED says he is not ready yet. Clearly I have no advice Chat Icon

Posted 12/17/13 7:29 PM
 

whoababy1
Love my little girls <3

Member since 8/10

1418 total posts

Name:

Desperate for advice: POOP TRAINING

This is a very refreshing thread for me too! I am in the SAME boat!
DD is 2.5 and pee trained in 1 day.
WOULD NOT POOP!!! We battled weeks of constipation. Had to do enemas. Giver her Miralax every day or so.

All very emotionally traumatizing for both her and I.

Told her she could ask for a diaper to poop. That worked for a bit, but every time she asked we would encourage her to use the potty. She would get upset. Eventually she stopped asking for a diaper and went back to holding it.

She still wears a diaper at night and so she has started holding it until bedtime. As soon as she is in bed she poops. So it's not impacting her going to bed.

This is a nightmare!! I can't wait for it to "click".

Good luck and keep us updated!!

Posted 12/17/13 9:30 PM
 

nycgirl
Angels!

Member since 3/09

7721 total posts

Name:

Re: Desperate for advice: POOP TRAINING

It just stops one day.
DS was like this.
We were washing underwear for 4 months.
Positive encouragement worked, but it took a while.
We were sure not to make a fuss about poop... Just say it should go in the potty.

Posted 12/17/13 10:05 PM
 

Peainapod
Peanuts are here!

Member since 1/09

13591 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: Desperate for advice: POOP TRAINING

my son was the EXACT same way. He was pee trained by 3..but was deathly afraid to poop. only in a pullup.

I would talk about poop every freaking day. I would make him take his pullup and dump in in the toilet and flush and say good bye. he was still scared.

by 3.5 i took him to the ped and she told me that its really not uncommon for kids to be pee trained for a year and still not poop. She suggested I keep him bare butt in the house b/c he was old enough not to pee everywhere and that eventually they learn when they got to poop, well they have to go somewhere. and im like..well my kid would have no problem pooping on the floor. So I didnt go that route.

This sept he started a preK program where he needed to be fully trained. So all of august I really had to buckle down with getting him to sit on the little duck potty. He would cry for a pullup..broke my heart. but one day I said thats it..no more pullups.

I swear..this might sound bad..but by day 2 of holding out for a pullup we were outside playing and I saw him start to squat and grunt like he had to go. and I scooped him right up, forced his little hiney down on the duck potty. I even put it in his playroom with the tv on, gave him my kindle..i sat with him. Held his hand, rubbed his back. Kid was crying and saying he was scared. He didnt know WTF was going to happen..yet I kept reassuring him it was ok. It was like I was giving birth again..I was sweating, he was sweating. I kept saying "you can do it..you can do it.."

Finally he did it. I was clapping like a nut. he cried and then he realized he had did it and that he was still alive and hadnt fallen into the bowl. For about a week after that I had to constantly ask and he was still holding back a little bit.
but by the time his birthday came in OCT, he was fully going on his own.


So rest assured YOU WILL GET THERE. boys are tough with this. But you may need to be tougher and just force the issue. Start talking to him about how one day soon there will be no more pullups. that once you use what is left, and countdown every day..that there are no more at the store and you have to poop like a big boy. Is there a big prize he wants..that also helped. He wanted to go to the disney store to get a doll from the bin. So that was his big reward. and he made sure to tell everyone in the disney store WHY he was getting it..lol.


I say if you have to stick the potty in the living room or play room first then do that. We then transitioned him to going in the bathroom within a matter of days. Now he's like a man..before he goes in he asks me for my kindle or a book..LMAO...

Message edited 2013-12-18 10:16:26.540000.

Posted 12/18/13 10:12 AM
 

Kissy331
My two miracles!

Member since 5/06

17826 total posts

Name:
Kristen

Re: Desperate for advice: POOP TRAINING

When I trained my oldest, he pee trained very easily but poop was a whole different story. Took 6 months & me watching his clues & dragging him to the potty. We had a lot of accidents in his pants & didn't phase him. We use to stress everytime he had accident they it was unacceptable & they he needed to go on potty. One day it clicked.

Posted 12/18/13 1:56 PM
 

JAPH23
LIF Adolescent

Member since 10/13

769 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: Desperate for advice: POOP TRAINING

My son was like this for a little while as well.. He would pee non stop in the potty but he would hold poop in for so long and give himself stomach aches. Sometimes he would have an accident and sometimes I would see that he was about to go so I would run and put him on the potty. Eventually it just stopped and he decided one day he would poop in the potty and has been fine ever since. It probably helped that every time he did go poop in the potty I made a huge deal about how proud I was and how awesome it was etc and the kid just eats that up Chat Icon

He had a well visit around the time he was holding it in and having frequent stomach aches. This was a new doctor since we just recently moved. I mentioned it to her and she wanted me to start giving him miralax and prune juice daily so he wouldn't have a choice but to go. She said he would learn from that and it worked on her kid and other parents she suggested it to. Personally I refused to give my kid miralax for no reason (he wasn't backed up) and also refused to pretty much make him crap his pants, I just figured he would learn and do it when he was ready and I was right because it was only a few weeks later that he was fine. Found him a new dr. since then.

Message edited 2013-12-18 14:58:14.757000.

Posted 12/18/13 2:56 PM
 

ali120206
2 Boys

Member since 7/06

17796 total posts

Name:

Re: Desperate for advice: POOP TRAINING

Posted by Kissy331

When I trained my oldest, he pee trained very easily but poop was a whole different story. Took 6 months & me watching his clues & dragging him to the potty. We had a lot of accidents in his pants & didn't phase him. We use to stress everytime he had accident they it was unacceptable & they he needed to go on potty. One day it clicked.



Same here - and we also gave him little rewards once he did poop on the potty.

He had a few periods of regression here and there, usually when he's angry at us for something, but, it's been almost 6 months since the last one. He's even made a big step and will poop when he's out of the house (previously he would only poop at home).

Posted 12/18/13 3:09 PM
 

Deeluvsvinny
DONE

Member since 10/08

4952 total posts

Name:
Whatever

Desperate for advice: POOP TRAINING

DD was like this. She was fine for pee, but would not poop in the potty. We tried everything as well. I would try to really pay attention to her cues and drag her to the potty every 5 mins until she did poop. It was torture for all of us.
One day, she randomly asked me to paint her room purple. I said "if you poop on the potty everyday, I will paint your room purple". it still took about a week (she did it a few times/had a few accidents), but it worked. Her room is now purple and she poops on the potty.
I think every kid is different. this worked for us, it may not work for others. DD wanted to poop on the potty- I think she just couldn't read her body's clues.

Posted 12/18/13 3:51 PM
 

Aries14
Can't plan life...

Member since 8/08

2860 total posts

Name:

Desperate for advice: POOP TRAINING

we took our dd to a GI doctor bc of this. SHe kept saying it hurt. The dr said it is so common for this to happen when potty training. She put her on miralx (?spelling?) and it helps them get regular and more importantly it is a stool softner so it made it not hurt her. Honest to God as soon as it came out easier and she realized it didn't hurt anymore she had no problem going on the potty.

Posted 12/18/13 3:53 PM
 

wakemeup

Member since 10/13

1397 total posts

Name:

Re: Desperate for advice: POOP TRAINING

This is us now with DD. DS (5) would ask to poop in a diaper for 3 months after being pee trained and one day we told him no more diapers, he held it in for 12 hours and then finally went, after that it was fine.

DD (3.5) has been pee trained for 3 months now as well and still asks for a diaper to poop in. Now that school's out we are going to try to find a week where we won't have to leave the house and just make her go on the potty. I plan on giving her only water and juice during that time as well because milk can sometimes constipate her.

Posted 12/18/13 4:31 PM
 

wakemeup

Member since 10/13

1397 total posts

Name:

Re: Desperate for advice: POOP TRAINING

Just read your update, what a great idea! Going to use that for DD Chat Icon

Posted 12/18/13 4:35 PM
 

Mere09
So Dam* Lucky

Member since 10/08

6368 total posts

Name:

Re: Desperate for advice: POOP TRAINING

Thanks for all the advice everyone! It's nice to hear that other people are going through the same hardships as us. Misery loves company, as they say. lol

Posted 12/18/13 7:24 PM
 

my3bugs
Mom of 2 Boys

Member since 5/05

4381 total posts

Name:

Re: Desperate for advice: POOP TRAINING

Posted by Mere09

After researching this basically the entire day today, we've come up with a new plan. And it's something that one of the previous posters touched on.

I had DH buy a pack of diapers before he came home from work. When DS woke up from nap, we made a deal. I told him that when he felt like he had to poop, he would have to tell either me or Daddy, and we would put a diaper on for him to poop in BUT he had to poop in his diaper IN the bathroom. He had such a happy look on his face when I told him this. A look of relief. Poor guy. This whole process has got to be just as hard on him as it is on us.

Anyway, we figure we'll have him poop in the diaper in the bathroom for a couple weeks, hopefully transition him to pooping in his diaper while sitting on the potty, and then HOPEFULLY that will lead to him just pooping on the potty. :::FINGERS CROSSED:::

Phase 1 is already working out. About an hour later he told us he had to poop. We put a diaper on him and walked him to the bathroom. Pooped in the diaper! LITTLE VICTORIES PEOPLE!!!! Chat Icon



I know someone who did this and it worked. The first step was he could use a diaper but it had to be in the bathroom. Then it had to be in the diaper while sitting on the potty and then it transitioned to doing it on the potty. Took awhile and they had to be stern but it worked for them! Good Luck!

Posted 12/19/13 8:18 AM
 

EandF
LIF Adult

Member since 11/11

1674 total posts

Name:

Re: Desperate for advice: POOP TRAINING

Posted by Mere09

After researching this basically the entire day today, we've come up with a new plan. And it's something that one of the previous posters touched on.

I had DH buy a pack of diapers before he came home from work. When DS woke up from nap, we made a deal. I told him that when he felt like he had to poop, he would have to tell either me or Daddy, and we would put a diaper on for him to poop in BUT he had to poop in his diaper IN the bathroom. He had such a happy look on his face when I told him this. A look of relief. Poor guy. This whole process has got to be just as hard on him as it is on us.

Anyway, we figure we'll have him poop in the diaper in the bathroom for a couple weeks, hopefully transition him to pooping in his diaper while sitting on the potty, and then HOPEFULLY that will lead to him just pooping on the potty. :::FINGERS CROSSED:::

Phase 1 is already working out. About an hour later he told us he had to poop. We put a diaper on him and walked him to the bathroom. Pooped in the diaper! LITTLE VICTORIES PEOPLE!!!! Chat Icon



I have no advice because my LO is only 4 1/2 mos but you can bet I'll be referring back to this thread when it's time!

I think what you're doing is great and it sounds like it's helping both you and DS. Good luck and keep us posted!! (I can't believe how much time I spend talking about poop since becoming a parent Chat Icon )

Posted 12/19/13 12:43 PM
 

Mere09
So Dam* Lucky

Member since 10/08

6368 total posts

Name:

Re: Desperate for advice: POOP TRAINING

Posted by my3bugs

Posted by Mere09

After researching this basically the entire day today, we've come up with a new plan. And it's something that one of the previous posters touched on.

I had DH buy a pack of diapers before he came home from work. When DS woke up from nap, we made a deal. I told him that when he felt like he had to poop, he would have to tell either me or Daddy, and we would put a diaper on for him to poop in BUT he had to poop in his diaper IN the bathroom. He had such a happy look on his face when I told him this. A look of relief. Poor guy. This whole process has got to be just as hard on him as it is on us.

Anyway, we figure we'll have him poop in the diaper in the bathroom for a couple weeks, hopefully transition him to pooping in his diaper while sitting on the potty, and then HOPEFULLY that will lead to him just pooping on the potty. :::FINGERS CROSSED:::

Phase 1 is already working out. About an hour later he told us he had to poop. We put a diaper on him and walked him to the bathroom. Pooped in the diaper! LITTLE VICTORIES PEOPLE!!!! Chat Icon



I know someone who did this and it worked. The first step was he could use a diaper but it had to be in the bathroom. Then it had to be in the diaper while sitting on the potty and then it transitioned to doing it on the potty. Took awhile and they had to be stern but it worked for them! Good Luck!



Great news!! Thank you!!

And just to update.... Phase 1 of the plan is definitely working. Again today he let us know that he had to go, we diapered him, he went into the bathroom and pooped in the diaper. No accidents to speak of plus he seems to be getting back to going on a regular basis with this new routine. We figure we'll continue with this for about two weeks, and then try and transition him to phase 2: pooping in his diaper while sitting on the potty. Here's to hoping!!!

Posted 12/19/13 7:15 PM
 

Mere09
So Dam* Lucky

Member since 10/08

6368 total posts

Name:

**UPDATE** Desperate for advice: POOP TRAINING

*******UPDATE********

VICTORY IS OURRRRRS!!!!!!

We moved on to phase 2, which was pooping in his diaper WHILE sitting on the potty. There were no issues with this whatsoever. He would tell us when he had to go, we would diaper him, he would sit and do his business. When he was done, we would drop the poop in the toilet and have him flush it down. We stayed with this for about 3 weeks because we really wanted to make sure that he was comfortable before moving on to Phase 3 -- pooping on the potty without a diaper.

Super Bowl Sunday was D-day..... He was a little hesitant and there was some whining and nervousness, but he sat down and did it!! He has gone everyday since with no resistance whatsoever!!! Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

I'm so so so soooooo happy to FINALLY be done with diapers and FINALLY be done with potty training this kid! It's been a year in the making, and I'm so glad it's over!! Very proud of my boy.

I DEFINITELY recommend this corse of action for anyone who's having trouble training their toddler. Hopefully it goes as well for you as it did for us! Chat Icon

Posted 2/4/14 4:50 PM
 

nycgirl
Angels!

Member since 3/09

7721 total posts

Name:

Re: **UPDATE** Desperate for advice: POOP TRAINING

That's great news! Congratulations!

Posted 2/5/14 10:24 AM
 

whoababy1
Love my little girls <3

Member since 8/10

1418 total posts

Name:

**UPDATE** Desperate for advice: POOP TRAINING

Congrats!
I am using this as the light at the end of the tunnel!

Problem is DD is still diapered overnight and she will poop in the AM right when she wakes up so I don't have the time to get her to the bathroom!

I hope we have success!

Posted 2/5/14 2:40 PM
 
Pages: [1] 2
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Desperate for potty training help (w/ poop!) babyquestion 8/25/11 3 Parenting
Potty training advice please! Karebaby 3/28/07 4 Parenting
crate training... need advice aliwnec10 3/11/07 12 Pets
Need puppy training advice Pooka 3/3/07 3 Pets
Need puppy training advice Pooka 3/3/07 12 Pets
Need puppy training advice Pooka 2/19/07 4 Pets