| Posted By |
Message |
mtdr1106
junior supafly
 Member since 3/06 2268 total posts
Name: tricia
|
tubes in ears
i dont want a big controversial post about this topic. i will start off by saying im tube netural. i believe in modern medicine and how it can help. i also believe the body knows what it needs to do and sometimes it should be allowed to run its course. im feeling very conflicted about my situation and would like any feed back from btdt moms who chose tubes for their children & from moms that chose not to when it was recommended and the respective outcomes.
my ds is 10 months old. he has had an "ear infection" since he is 4 months old and has been on numerous rounds of antibiotics. i put ear infections in quotes because only 2x's out of these months of infections did he behave like he had an infection. my son sleeps 9-11 hrs a night, eats well, is playful & happy. not at all outwardly miserable.
i began seeing an ent a few weeks ago. he told me my son has fluid in the ears but it is not infected fluid. he recommended just waiting it out. he also gave my ds a hearing test (which is difficult for an infant) but said he would consider the results average. since then ive had to make a trip to the ped for pink eye and she told me she still sees infection. my ped understood my frustration and sent me to the ent again this morning. he is now seeing infection and recommended putting tubes into my sons ears.
i guess what is making me hesitant about saying yes to surgery is the fact that he seems like such a happy baby. there isnt one person that would look at this kid and think a thing is wrong with him! is it possible my son is THAT tough to be handling a constant ear infection like a champ? or is the poor baby so used to being uncomfy that he thinks its normal to feel that? or am i being a proud mama who just cant imagine her baby not being perfect?
any experiences that you can share would be helpful. i dont want my son to suffer but i also do not want to perform any unnecessary procedures. the doctor said if i do not do this surgery the child will not go deaf but may have speech issues because he isnt hearing at capacity. i also will be faced with this child suffering from more colds & more rounds of antibiotics.
any experiences shared will be appreciated. tia
|
Posted 7/26/11 1:14 PM
|
| |
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
|
Linda1003
love my 2 boys
 Member since 8/08 10923 total posts
Name: Linda
|
Re: tubes in ears
John got tubes in May.. best decision I made.
My bottom line was:
1. I would feel way too guilty if he had speech issues due to the constant fluid in his ears 2. Hearing loss i couldn't live with that 3. Constant pain from infections 4. off Balance all the time (you may think it's normal b/c of his age) 5. Constant meds!!!! John got resistant to TWO antibiotics..Dangerous if he gets sick and NEEDS THEM!!! Hated that he was on meds ALL THE TIME!!!
You may think he is acting fine and well balanced etc.. BUT...if he's had this since 4 months.. to some extent..yeah he's probably used to it but also you may not realize what he COULD be doing if he didn't have the tubes...kwim...words..walking...less crying (even though you said he was happy..john was like that.. I thought he was a happy kid UNTIL he got the tubes!!!! 1000 times better)..
JMHO...
ETA: the surgery is NOTHING!!! within 15 mins they are back in your arms!! by the time you get home.. he is back to himself again!!! Also ped told me kids like this have constant popping in his ears b/c of the fluid.. I couldn't imagine..
Message edited 2011-07-26 13:26:04.817000. |
Posted 7/26/11 1:21 PM
|
| |
|
Ian&EmmesMommy23
My family is complete!
 Member since 11/08 12970 total posts
Name: Diana
|
Re: tubes in ears
whenever DS has an ear infection, he coughs...that's it. he doesn't have a fever, doesnt act irritable. but when he coughs (like i can hear it in his chest) its an ear infection. luckily for us AB have worked.
in my personal experience, i had so many ear infections has a child that it caused me to go deaf in one ear. i didnt get tubes until later on and thats when my infections stopped. the infections caused my incus bone to erode away. luckily in 2003 i had reconstructive surgery and now have my hearing back.
so i would NOT delay tubes. it can't hurt them. i would however go to a 2nd opinion. if you want one, i took DS to Dr. Mendlesohn in Garden City. he did a hearing test on DS around the same age as your DS and was able to give accurate results.
Dr. Zelman (who did my surgery) also does pediatrics, but doesn't take my insurance anymore. They are both part of the same practice.
|
Posted 7/26/11 1:23 PM
|
| |
|
JDandMe
LIF Adult
 Member since 9/10 996 total posts
Name:
|
Re: tubes in ears
DS has tubes in his ears but the situation appears to be different from yours. DS was miserable when he has an ear infection. He was so uncomfortable, he didn't even want to lay down, he wanted his upper body elevated. The fevers, the discomfort, and the frequent infections and medications are the reasons why I choose to consent to tubes.
After the tubes were in- what a difference!! He was back to the happy playful kid he is. I also noticed a difference in his hearing. He could definitely hear better. He heard the phone from a room away, heard the vacuum cleaner which he never seemed to notice before. He starting responding when people were talking around him.
For DS it was a great decision. Feel free to FM me w/ any questions.
|
Posted 7/26/11 1:24 PM
|
| |
|
JChia
Mom of 2 Princesses
 Member since 9/07 2540 total posts
Name: Jen
|
Re: tubes in ears
DD got them when she was just over 2. She had multiple ear infections over the winters and constatntly had fluid in her ears, but she only had fever/complained 1 time over about 10 -12 different infections. Didn't seem to bother her otherwise.
She was constantly on antibiotics. We only saw an ENT when she turned 2 - because the prior year she had only had 5 infections and that was the cut off for being sent to the ENT.
The ENT (Dr. Goldstein) did the hearing test and asked us about her language development. We admitted she was a bit behind, but weren't worried about it at the time - until he pointed out that according to the hearing test she was basically hearing with cotton in her ears. We decided to go through with the surgery. All went well and her daycare teachers and us noticed a significant improvement in her language within a month, so I feel like we made the right decision.
One thing to ask your ENT is how long the tubes last - some only last a year - the ones we use last 18 months - 2 years. I don't remember the pros and cons of each, but it is something to look into.
|
Posted 7/26/11 1:39 PM
|
| |
|
mtdr1106
junior supafly
 Member since 3/06 2268 total posts
Name: tricia
|
Re: tubes in ears
thank you all for sharing your stories.
im def getting more comfortable with the idea after hearing your experiences.
its really appreciated!
|
Posted 7/26/11 1:44 PM
|
| |
|
Peainapod
Peanuts are here!
 Member since 1/09 13591 total posts
Name: Diana
|
Re: tubes in ears
DS last year had infections every month from May to Sept; I noticed it was always when his teething flared up and cutting new teeth; which is possible as teething can interrupt the whole Ears/Nose/Throat system causing fluid and the body to act like there is a foreign substance in the body.
NO infections all winter; April, May, June of this year so far had infections; the last one warranting a trip to the ER one nite b/c we didnt know *** was going on..and it was an ear infection and an upper respiratory infection. He was also cutting 4 teeth through these months. AGain, related..maybe?
all the other ear infections, I would never have known as DS was his usual self, taking bottles, eating playing, no fever; and hardly tugged on his ear. But he would not let you go near his ear at all. His last ear infection was the only time he was running high fevers, trouble breathing, lethargic and in a lot of pain.
I think 10mo might be too early to put tubes in just yet, but thats just my opinion. Have you tried seeing a Pediatric chiropractor? Or a chiro that treats kids; I started bringing DS to mine and he noticed that he couldnt even touch behind DS left ear/neck area and with a few adjustments has gotten a lot better.
The chiro explained that birth trauma (even just a normal delivery is traumatic for babies) can cause cervical or lumbar spinal issues and knock something out of whack and you wouldnt know it. Babies cervical spines are not developed yet to handle the weight of their head and can compress the cervical spine, which houses the nerves for sinuses and ears. This made sense to me as DS was vacuum assisted birth and has a big head. Might be something for you to consider looking into.
ETA: our dr. did say if he gets one more this year, she will send us to an ENT; so far he is speaking just fine and understands me so I believe his hearing to be fine. But I will not rule out putting tubes in if it comes to it as I really would like to avoid DS being on meds all the time for infections. Its a very common problem and a very common surgery.
Message edited 2011-07-26 14:01:46.583000. |
Posted 7/26/11 1:57 PM
|
| |
|
CrankyPants
I'm cranky
 Member since 7/06 18178 total posts
Name: Mama Cranky
|
Re: tubes in ears
I never knew there was any controversy with tubes.
DS got them when he was 9 months-constant ear infections (I think 9 in 6 months?). DS also has questionable hearing in one ear so we did not want to risk any damage. Plus, I don't want my kid to be on constant antibiotics if there is another choice.
So, tubes for DS. He still gets ear infections, but not nearly as many as before. He just has bad ears
Message edited 2011-07-26 14:55:01.923000. |
Posted 7/26/11 2:11 PM
|
| |
|
snowprincess
My happy babies
 Member since 3/06 3428 total posts
Name:
|
Re: tubes in ears
My son got tubes at 15 months for us it has been more positive
he always had fluid in his ears and tested extremely poorly on the hearing test and his ear drum was not responding with any movement
he had a lot of infections but we only knew becuase he got fevers or pink eye (pink eye for him is a sign of ear infection for my son) - he did not pull on them or complain or wine - he slept 12 hours at night and took good naps
since the surgery he has been talking more, following direction, has hearing in the normal range, and started walking so much better (ear problems also affect balance)
however my son still does get infections, most go away after a week of putting drops in his ear - he does not get fevers with the infection, i know he has infection because the fluid drains. Some have still needed antibiotics but there is a more wait and see approach before taking an antibiotic - which is good because i am pencillan and sulfer allergic and hoping he won't develop an allergy from antibotic over use
overall it has been positive exeperience and the benefits outweighed the risks for us but each child is different
|
Posted 7/26/11 2:35 PM
|
| |
|
Xelindrya
Mommy's little YouTube Star!
 Member since 8/05 14470 total posts
Name: Veronica
|
Re: tubes in ears
Tube Mom and tube child myself, here.
AJ had non stop infections since about 4-5m old. She got her tubes at 17m and only because I pushed for it. My doctors tried to scare me out of it. She had been through every antibiotic they could find (around 7) when they finally agreed with me. Her fluid was murky and the area was inflamed. She’d be clear of an infection then less than a month later have another raging double infection.
She RARELY complained. RARELY had fevers RARELY acted out of place.
We literally would walk in for a well visit or shots and they’d look in my happy kiddo’s ears and find them filled with fluid. They’d often ask me if I was sure she hadn’t been fussy or warm. I swear she was neither. I started to feel like I was missing her infections and a bad mommy. Later the pediatrician would tell me its not uncommon for children to go symptom free with ear infections.
Her hearing was affected. They tested this before they did the procedure. Even tho one side was infected at the time.
She was a late talker too. Could or could not have something to do with the fluid.
She got her tubes in and actually got an infection the night before and the day after. That last one she reacted to. Terribly fussy, crying uncontrollably. I thought it was the surgery but it wasn’t. Lesson learned. I had never seen her act like that yet they said that’s how ‘normal’ ear infections went.
On a side note, the pediatrician who was trying to talk me out of it was a strange one. She said that I should avoid it because they’d have to put her under. She was under for all of 10mins. She wanted me to avoid it because it wasn’t that bad. It really was that bad even my ENT said it should have and could have been done earlier.
I am very glad with my choice. She’s had only one ear infection since. Her hearing is back at 100%. I’ve had 3 sets put in my ears. Still have hearing loss due to genetic disorder. So I am a fan of it as I see it with no negatives.
|
Posted 7/26/11 3:58 PM
|
| |
|
lucyloo
nope
Member since 1/06 9758 total posts
Name:
|
Re: tubes in ears
I would suggest getting a second opinion. We used Dr. Gargano, he did the surgery at Good Sam.
For the most part DS was a happy baby with the infections as well. He had the tubes put in at 16 months. I was afraid that he would have delayed speech and the constant antibiotics terrified me. Good luck with your decision
ETA: DS never had fevers and never tugged on his ears. His eyes would look glassy and he put his hands in his mouth.
Message edited 2011-07-26 16:10:13.217000. |
Posted 7/26/11 4:09 PM
|
| |
|
mnmsoinlove
Mommy to 2 sweet girls!
 Member since 3/09 8585 total posts
Name: Melissa
|
Re: tubes in ears
I'm in the exact same position as you are. My dd is 11 months and has had ear infections since 6 months old and now has sterile fluid in both ears. ENT wants to wait another month and if he is still seeing fluid he will do tubes. MY dd is unlike your son and its miserable with her ears constant pulling, and doesn't sleep well. Plus she showed mild hearing loss in the hearing test so I've come to the conclusion that I will let them put the tubes in. I'm very scared because even though its minor its surgery. My thoughts are that I would feel soo guilty if she suffered permanent hearing loss or speech delays because of the fluid so I feel like tubes are the right option for her.
|
Posted 7/26/11 4:36 PM
|
| |
|