Homeschooling ...
| Forum Opinion Poll | ||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
Thoughts on Homeschooling
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: 1 [2] 3 | |
|
Re: Thoughts on Homeschooling A few years ago I met DH's cousin and a couple of his children. His wife is homeschooling all 6 children, and the kids were more more advanced than many I meet. As for social skills, the children are active in church and church activities, scouting, sports and homeschool groups so they have plenty of opportunity to gain social skills. The 13 year old daughter was able to debate religion and politics with DH better than most adults he runs into. I would personally give it a lot of serious consideration as a viable option, considering the social agenda that many schools are pushing these days, as well as the lack of morals you see among so many of today's kids. |
|
Posted 8/18/07 11:01 AM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: Thoughts on Homeschooling I voted maybe. |
|
Posted 8/18/07 11:55 AM
|
|
|
Re: Thoughts on Homeschooling Like many said, each child and situation is different. For some it works, for others it doesnt.YOu really can't generalize it, just give opinions. |
|
Posted 8/18/07 1:47 PM
|
|
|
Re: Thoughts on Homeschooling Posted by mimih As a teacher, I honestly would never homeschool my child. I think that it is incredibly important for them to socialize with peers, respect other figures of authority (besides their parents) and follow rules within a group. I truly believe children who are home schooled are missing out on learning how to deal with the world in preparation for a future job. JMHO I agree...me being a teacher and all, I dont feel I would be able to teach them EVERYTHING that is taught in school. Message edited 2007-08-18 14:33:15.327000. |
|
Posted 8/18/07 2:32 PM
|
|
|
Re: Thoughts on Homeschooling Posted by mimih As a teacher, I honestly would never homeschool my child. I think that it is incredibly important for them to socialize with peers, respect other figures of authority (besides their parents) and follow rules within a group. I truly believe children who are home schooled are missing out on learning how to deal with the world in preparation for a future job. JMHO I'm a teacher and I was actually going to say the same thing. Everything she wrote I agree with. |
|
Posted 8/18/07 2:36 PM
|
|
|
Re: Thoughts on Homeschooling OK, I hadn't read what you wrote about the specific situation... First off, as a special ed teacher I'm pretty disgusted with the way the district handled things. Be aware of your rights though - if they claim to not have an appropriate placement, you can sue to force them to either pay for an appropriate one or help with costs. So just make sure you (is it you or a friend?) look into everything. Also, though I fully believe in the benefits of attending a school, every situation is different and it sounds like in this case homeschooling is working best. Just one final thing... It might be that it's not the homeschooling but the supportive environment (since the district did not seem to be supplying that) and that if you DO find a special school or program that you feel is appropriate, it might be worth trying it again in hopes of that teacher being much more professional and understanding. |
|
Posted 8/18/07 2:42 PM
|
|
|
Re: Thoughts on Homeschooling Posted by SPECIALNEEDSMOMMY I want to present a specific situation to all of you and see if your opinions change: A 6.5 year old with a very severe seizure disorder, ataxia, apraxia, functionally deaf and developmentally delayed. He understands and follows directions very well. He can make some word approximations, but no clear verbalizations. He is charting about 2-3 year old skills with a few scattered higher skills. A delightful little boy with a lot on his plate. He was in a special needs school since age 3 ... full day program including 6 weeks of summer. Full therapy ... PT, OT, Speech. After three years of formal schooling, the child could barely walk independently. No speech development all all. Motor skills were very poor. The child knows no colors, letters, numbers, etc. He cannot answer a simple question after reading a book. The child has no means of communication other than grunting and pointing. After three years of schooling at the same location and the same teacher, the school assigns the child a new teacher. During the first six weeks of school, the child loses 7 lbs because the teacher refuses ... yes, refuses ... to work with the child's feeding issues. The school decides (about working with this child for three prior years and dealing with the feeding issues) that things are "too difficult to manage any further". The parent is called in and told the child needs a "more medically fragile program." The parent fights and the superintendent refuses to assign another teacher or work with the family. The choice ... the child remains and continues to lose weight and will wind up with a g-tube ... or the child is withdrawn from school? The parent withdraws the child and searches for a new school ... nothing available or suitable for the child. Homeschooling becomes the only option. A year of homeschooling under the child's belt and guess what??? He recites (after being prompted) every alphabet letter. He counts to five (prompted.) He knows 4 of his colors. He's signing about twenty signs. He points to objects and attempts to vocalize the words for what he points to. He is walking ... and not falling. He climbs stairs. He has regained 8 lbs and is trying new foods. He goes to the library and takes field trips with a homeschooling group. He is social, friendly and happy. The bottom line ... he has made strides with the parent as a teacher that school couldn't accomplish in three years. After reading this, what do you think? Does this make you feel any differently about homeschooling? Be honest. I am appalled by that story. I don't know if it is you or a friend, but whoever it is needs to contact an attorney. If it is not you, I would give school a try for your child. Not everyone has the same bad experience. There are pros and cons to regular schooling and home schooling. As a former teacher and now a parent, I can see both sides. I wish you luck in whatever your decision is. |
|
Posted 8/18/07 3:34 PM
|
|
|
Re: Thoughts on Homeschooling I think homeschooling can be a good thing. Often times it is done mostly because of religious beliefs & not because of academics(as with the family we bought our house from). There are a few woman in my neighborhood that homeschool & honestly I don't think their kids are going to be prepared for college-or anything else in life, because I don't think they are structured enough. |
|
Posted 8/18/07 4:05 PM
|
|
|
Re: Thoughts on Homeschooling Thanks ladies for your input. I appreciate the thoughts on both sides. |
|
Posted 8/18/07 4:48 PM
|
|
|
Re: Thoughts on Homeschooling I would never do it! |
|
Posted 8/18/07 4:51 PM
|
|
|
Re: Thoughts on Homeschooling I haven't read the whole thread, but have you looked into a BOCES type school? or was your son already at a school for children with special needs? |
|
Posted 8/18/07 4:55 PM
|
|
|
Re: Thoughts on Homeschooling Posted by Diane Posted by mimih As a teacher, I honestly would never homeschool my child. I think that it is incredibly important for them to socialize with peers, respect other figures of authority (besides their parents) and follow rules within a group. I truly believe children who are home schooled are missing out on learning how to deal with the world in preparation for a future job. JMHO I agree...me being a teacher and all, I dont feel I would be able to teach them EVERYTHING that is taught in school. for special needs kids, they sometimes don't need to learn everything. If they have limited abilities and really need to learn the basics that will help them lead functional and productive lives, some school programs are just not appropriate because there is too much crammed in the day that is required to be taught to them, so it becomes a long day of behaviors and very little learning.... |
|
Posted 8/18/07 5:07 PM
|
|
|
Re: Thoughts on Homeschooling Posted by SPECIALNEEDSMOMMY I made a very hard decision last October to withdraw my son from school and I second guess myself all the time. I take enormous criticizm and judgement from family and friends ... but ... I know in my heart I made the right decision. It is always easy to judge someone when you are outside looking in. I'm an Administrative Assistant by trade. I am not a teacher. I work hard teaching Gregory. I joined two homeschooling groups. I attend many events. We go to the library, museums, etc, etc, etc. My son and my daughter are very social, friendly, polite, hardworking and well-behaved. I submit an IHIP every year detailing my curriculum, books, tools, tests, etc. I am bound to 20 page quarterly progress reports and time logs. I don't get summers or vacation weeks due to regression ... I teach 365 days a year without a break. I attend all meetings and file everything on time. Our school district and NYS keep a close eye on us. It's hard, but I do it. For us, this was the right road. This was a long post but a descriptive and truthful one. For doing what was best for you and your son, he's very lucky to have a mom that loves him so much.
|
|
Posted 8/18/07 5:27 PM
|
|
|
Re: Thoughts on Homeschooling Posted by meghanmetz For doing what was best for you and your son, he's very lucky to have a mom that loves him so much. I agree!!!
|
|
Posted 8/18/07 5:42 PM
|
|
|
Re: Thoughts on Homeschooling kudos to you for doing whatever it takes to help your son live the best life he can. Homeschooling 365 days a year must be exhausting, have you ever considered enrolling him in a camp that specializes in special needs for a few weeks in the summer to let him enjoy being around other kids that have stuff in common with him as far as challenges go? I think it would be great for you to get a couple of days off in the summer & for him to be around kids. |
|
Posted 8/18/07 7:11 PM
|
|
|
Re: Thoughts on Homeschooling Posted by NewYawkah Posted by meghanmetz For doing what was best for you and your son, he's very lucky to have a mom that loves him so much. I agree!!! I am a friend of SPECIALNEEDSMOMMY for years and can tell you firsthand the frustration she has been through in finding the proper setting for her son. He is such a sweet, wonderful little boy and it is a shame that there is just nowhere left for her to turn to. She is exhausted and emotionally and physically drained in caring for Gregory and his very active 4 year old sister. She has taken on a huge responsibility in homeschooling him, and believe me, she is the first to acknowledge the sadness she feels in him missing out on the much needed socialization that he craves and needs. But when the educational system cannot (or shall I say will not) accomodate his tremendous needs, nor is willing to even attempt to do so, there is really no other option for her. She and her family have sacrificed so much in order for her to take care of and educate him full time - she could have easily thrown in the towel and kept him where he was at or put him someplace else and simply hoped for the best. Instead she has taken on this tremendous job with love and dignity. Barbara, I admire you and your strength. Those who think you are doing your child a disservice by homeschooling him shouldn't speak or form and opinion until they have walked in your shoes. And to those who have supported her decision, thank you. for you!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Message edited 2007-08-18 22:11:24.620000. |
|
Posted 8/18/07 7:46 PM
|
|
|
Re: Thoughts on Homeschooling Posted by SPECIALNEEDSMOMMY I want to present a specific situation to all of you and see if your opinions change: A 6.5 year old with a very severe seizure disorder, ataxia, apraxia, functionally deaf and developmentally delayed. He understands and follows directions very well. He can make some word approximations, but no clear verbalizations. He is charting about 2-3 year old skills with a few scattered higher skills. A delightful little boy with a lot on his plate. He was in a special needs school since age 3 ... full day program including 6 weeks of summer. Full therapy ... PT, OT, Speech. After three years of formal schooling, the child could barely walk independently. No speech development all all. Motor skills were very poor. The child knows no colors, letters, numbers, etc. He cannot answer a simple question after reading a book. The child has no means of communication other than grunting and pointing. After three years of schooling at the same location and the same teacher, the school assigns the child a new teacher. During the first six weeks of school, the child loses 7 lbs because the teacher refuses ... yes, refuses ... to work with the child's feeding issues. The school decides (about working with this child for three prior years and dealing with the feeding issues) that things are "too difficult to manage any further". The parent is called in and told the child needs a "more medically fragile program." The parent fights and the superintendent refuses to assign another teacher or work with the family. The choice ... the child remains and continues to lose weight and will wind up with a g-tube ... or the child is withdrawn from school? The parent withdraws the child and searches for a new school ... nothing available or suitable for the child. Homeschooling becomes the only option. A year of homeschooling under the child's belt and guess what??? He recites (after being prompted) every alphabet letter. He counts to five (prompted.) He knows 4 of his colors. He's signing about twenty signs. He points to objects and attempts to vocalize the words for what he points to. He is walking ... and not falling. He climbs stairs. He has regained 8 lbs and is trying new foods. He goes to the library and takes field trips with a homeschooling group. He is social, friendly and happy. The bottom line ... he has made strides with the parent as a teacher that school couldn't accomplish in three years. After reading this, what do you think? Does this make you feel any differently about homeschooling? Be honest. Unfortunately, I'm not suprised in the least bit. I work for the XXXXXXXXX. 70% of our cases deal with children with disabilities who are not receiving a proper education. I can't even begin to tell you the stories that have come across my desk, that simply INFURIATE me. I have to add the caveat that the majority of schools and teachers are phenomenal, dedicated, passionate and deserve an applause. But, unfortunately, there is a minority, and that's why I have the job that I have. For you, and anyone else grappling with these kind of issues, you are not alone, and there are people and agencies there to help you. If you feel that your child isn't getting an appropriate education, or his/her rights are being violated, you can file a complaint with your state board of education, or the federal department of education, in the office for civil rights. I can assure you they take every single complaint seriously and evaluate each on its own facts. For those students who have serious developmental issues, and are not, for whatever reason, receiving the care and attention they deserve, then yes, homeschooling is by far the most appropriate means. Most of the people filing complaints with our office are at that point, where they have removed the child from the school.
Message edited 2007-08-20 08:12:03.150000. |
|
Posted 8/18/07 7:53 PM
|
|
|
Re: Thoughts on Homeschooling My SIL homeschools her two boys. I personally would never do it. They have poor social skills, and its hard to make friends. I can imagine when they grow up and are in the real word, such as a job or even college, how aukward they are going to be. She is also getting very tired with it. They don't want to pay attention and it's a lot of work, which most people, unless you are a teacher, don't know how to handle, and she never has time for herself since the kids are always home. I went to 5 years of school to be a teacher, so I find it hard to believe that someone who has no training can do it as well. Message edited 2007-08-18 22:33:53.497000. |
|
Posted 8/18/07 10:30 PM
|
|
|
Re: Thoughts on Homeschooling SPECIALNEEDSMOMMY, I really feel for you. I cannot imagine what it must feel like to be in your situation and I applaud you for putting your child first and doing what you need to do. Message edited 2007-08-18 22:48:21.530000. |
|
Posted 8/18/07 10:47 PM
|
|
|
Re: Thoughts on Homeschooling Posted by SPECIALNEEDSMOMMY I want to present a specific situation to all of you and see if your opinions change: A 6.5 year old with a very severe seizure disorder, ataxia, apraxia, functionally deaf and developmentally delayed. He understands and follows directions very well. He can make some word approximations, but no clear verbalizations. He is charting about 2-3 year old skills with a few scattered higher skills. A delightful little boy with a lot on his plate. He was in a special needs school since age 3 ... full day program including 6 weeks of summer. Full therapy ... PT, OT, Speech. After three years of formal schooling, the child could barely walk independently. No speech development all all. Motor skills were very poor. The child knows no colors, letters, numbers, etc. He cannot answer a simple question after reading a book. The child has no means of communication other than grunting and pointing. After three years of schooling at the same location and the same teacher, the school assigns the child a new teacher. During the first six weeks of school, the child loses 7 lbs because the teacher refuses ... yes, refuses ... to work with the child's feeding issues. The school decides (about working with this child for three prior years and dealing with the feeding issues) that things are "too difficult to manage any further". The parent is called in and told the child needs a "more medically fragile program." The parent fights and the superintendent refuses to assign another teacher or work with the family. The choice ... the child remains and continues to lose weight and will wind up with a g-tube ... or the child is withdrawn from school? The parent withdraws the child and searches for a new school ... nothing available or suitable for the child. Homeschooling becomes the only option. A year of homeschooling under the child's belt and guess what??? He recites (after being prompted) every alphabet letter. He counts to five (prompted.) He knows 4 of his colors. He's signing about twenty signs. He points to objects and attempts to vocalize the words for what he points to. He is walking ... and not falling. He climbs stairs. He has regained 8 lbs and is trying new foods. He goes to the library and takes field trips with a homeschooling group. He is social, friendly and happy. The bottom line ... he has made strides with the parent as a teacher that school couldn't accomplish in three years. After reading this, what do you think? Does this make you feel any differently about homeschooling? Be honest. Yes I guess you convinced me. There are certain instances where this is best...but I think it shows complete failure in the system and should not have to be that way. The district should provide an education for this child and support to the parents no matter what the circumstances, unfortunately it does not always happen that way. Kudos to the mom in that instance. I would have gotten a lawyer. |
|
Posted 8/19/07 11:38 AM
|
|
|
Re: Thoughts on Homeschooling Posted by lipglossjunky73 Posted by Diane Posted by mimih As a teacher, I honestly would never homeschool my child. I think that it is incredibly important for them to socialize with peers, respect other figures of authority (besides their parents) and follow rules within a group. I truly believe children who are home schooled are missing out on learning how to deal with the world in preparation for a future job. JMHO I agree...me being a teacher and all, I dont feel I would be able to teach them EVERYTHING that is taught in school. for special needs kids, they sometimes don't need to learn everything. If they have limited abilities and really need to learn the basics that will help them lead functional and productive lives, some school programs are just not appropriate because there is too much crammed in the day that is required to be taught to them, so it becomes a long day of behaviors and very little learning.... I agree, for a special needs kid, It is different. They need to learn things we talk for granted such as everyday life skills. I mean for a general ed. student. SPECIALNEEDSMOM...your son sis very lucky to have you as a mom
|
|
Posted 8/19/07 1:04 PM
|
|
|
Re: Thoughts on Homeschooling Posted by mimih As a teacher, I honestly would never homeschool my child. I think that it is incredibly important for them to socialize with peers, respect other figures of authority (besides their parents) and follow rules within a group. I truly believe children who are home schooled are missing out on learning how to deal with the world in preparation for a future job. JMHO Generally, this is my opinion. However, there are exceptions, since every child is unique. Even for a special needs child, there are excellent programs that are geared towards basic skills but also incorporate socialization. I am a true believer in a child being able to learn appropriate socialization skills. If a child has adequate opportunity for socializing outside of the educational setting, then homeschooling is a fine option, IMO. But if homeschooling is going to really sacrifice socialization opportunities, a school setting where the child can thrive socially as well, is IMHO, the best setting. Message edited 2007-08-19 19:10:30.267000. |
|
Posted 8/19/07 7:09 PM
|
|
|
Re: Thoughts on Homeschooling Posted by SPECIALNEEDSMOMMY I respect your opinion very much, but I'm just curious about a few things if you wouldn't mind answering. Have you ever met or spoken to a parent who homeschooled? If so, what did you think of the child they homeschooled? Also, would you feel differently about homeschooling if the child was special needs? Just really curious about this subject ... Thanks for any input! I work with children with special needs and I know without a doubt that school is the best place for them. Special educaiton services are essential for students to make improvements. Special needs kids need specialized therapies, instructional appropaches, and equipment to make gains. Home is no place for a special needs kid to learn and develop. |
|
Posted 8/19/07 7:47 PM
|
|
|
Re: Thoughts on Homeschooling I am a teacher, i dont believe in homeschooling, especially since since the children i work with have special needs, the social factor is SOOOOO important, i think there is so much that is learned in a schoool setting that just canno be taught at home....JMO |
|
Posted 8/19/07 7:51 PM
|
|
|
Re: Thoughts on Homeschooling Ladies ... For those of you who have offered support and understanding for what I do, I say THANK YOU. For those of you who think I am doing my son a disservice by keeping him home, I respect your opinion but I don't agree with it. |
|
Posted 8/19/07 9:50 PM
|
|
| Pages: 1 [2] 3 | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Looking for thoughts | DebG | 3/23/06 | 42 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Thoughts, Suggestions, Advice and/or comfort welcome 5/12 update | DebG | 3/22/06 | 56 | Pregnancy |
| Sensitive topic, just want some thoughts (adult situation) . . . . | theanonymous1 | 3/18/06 | 17 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| thoughts?? | Karen | 3/14/06 | 3 | TTC |
| Please keep NYLISA in your thoughts and prayers | Holly | 3/13/06 | 104 | Prayers |
| Need thoughts? | LIPrincess | 3/8/06 | 7 | Families Helping Families ™ |


















For doing what was best for you and your son, he's very lucky to have a mom that loves him so much.







