Re: Thoughts on Homeschooling
Posted 8/18/2007 3:34:44 PM by avamamma


Posted by SPECIALNEEDSMOMMY

I want to present a specific situation to all of you and see if your opinions change:

A 6.5 year old with a very severe seizure disorder, ataxia, apraxia, functionally deaf and developmentally delayed. He understands and follows directions very well. He can make some word approximations, but no clear verbalizations. He is charting about 2-3 year old skills with a few scattered higher skills. A delightful little boy with a lot on his plate. He was in a special needs school since age 3 ... full day program including 6 weeks of summer.
Full therapy ... PT, OT, Speech.

After three years of formal schooling, the child could barely walk independently. No speech development all all. Motor skills were very poor. The child knows no colors, letters, numbers, etc. He cannot answer a simple question after reading a book. The child has no means of communication other than grunting and pointing.

After three years of schooling at the same location and the same teacher, the school assigns the child a new teacher. During the first six weeks of school, the child loses 7 lbs because the teacher refuses ... yes, refuses ... to work with the child's feeding issues. The school decides (about working with this child for three prior years and dealing with the feeding issues) that things are "too difficult to manage any further". The parent is called in and told the child needs a "more medically fragile program." The parent fights and the superintendent refuses to assign another teacher or work with the family.

The choice ... the child remains and continues to lose weight and will wind up with a g-tube ... or the child is withdrawn from school? The parent withdraws the child and searches for a new school ... nothing available or suitable for the child.

Homeschooling becomes the only option. A year of homeschooling under the child's belt and guess what??? He recites (after being prompted) every alphabet letter. He counts to five (prompted.) He knows 4 of his colors. He's signing about twenty signs. He points to objects and attempts to vocalize the words for what he points to. He is walking ... and not falling. He climbs stairs. He has regained 8 lbs and is trying new foods.

He goes to the library and takes field trips with a homeschooling group. He is social, friendly and happy.

The bottom line ... he has made strides with the parent as a teacher that school couldn't accomplish in three years.

After reading this, what do you think? Does this make you feel any differently about homeschooling? Be honest.



I am appalled by that story. I don't know if it is you or a friend, but whoever it is needs to contact an attorney.

If it is not you, I would give school a try for your child. Not everyone has the same bad experience.

There are pros and cons to regular schooling and home schooling. As a former teacher and now a parent, I can see both sides.

I wish you luck in whatever your decision is.


Print Post      Close Window