The movie "something borrowed"

Posted By Message

Teach723
Have faith. Believe. Dream.

Member since 8/10

2356 total posts

Name:

The movie "something borrowed"

Ok so the other night I saw this movie with my mom. We were both very disturbed by the fact that this guy was cheating on his fiancé with her best friend. Then the writers tried to make it ok by making his fiancé seem like a bad person.
So now today on fb my SIL writes how much she loved the movie. I'm going back and forth with all these people on her page who think this movie was so cute, romantic, and was destiny. I can't possibly be the only one who thinks the premise behind this movie was so horrible. Where are peoples morals and values? This guy should've broken up with his fiancé if he felt this way, not cheat on her. I just always think of the other side and the person who's being cheated on.
Am I the only person who feels this way about the movie?

Posted 9/2/11 6:50 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

DiamondGirl
You are my I love you

Member since 7/09

18802 total posts

Name:
DiamondMama

I felt this way about the book, actually I did not read it for a long time bc when I read the summary I was SO put off. I think Emily Griffin is a great writer but I almost always dislike her main characters Chat Icon

I saw the movie and thought it was good but again ita with you. What they did is SO wrong. It does not make it better that the friend was self centered or a flake or cheated on the FH also. That is your BFF!! The two are wrong!!

Message edited 2011-09-02 18:55:19.150000.

Posted 9/2/11 6:54 PM
 

peanutbutter2
Carpe diem!

Member since 11/10

5287 total posts

Name:

Re: The movie "something borrowed"

I get what you're saying, and I've heard other people say the same thing. However, I personally liked this movie because I think it did show viewers real situations that can and do happen. I think the writers absolutely tried to make everything seem better by portraying the fiance as a witch, but at the same time, the audience is free to make their own judgments.

I definitely wasn't watching this movie to find a moral compass, but I don't think all movies need to have one (American Pie, American Pie II, American Wedding, any movie where people are constantly killing each other, etc.!)

Posted 9/2/11 6:56 PM
 

ChilisWife
God Bless America

Member since 5/05

3572 total posts

Name:
A.K.

Re: The movie "something borrowed"

Posted by JAAMS

I get what you're saying, and I've heard other people say the same thing. However, I personally liked this movie because I think it did show viewers real situations that can and do happen. I think the writers absolutely tried to make everything seem better by portraying the fiance as a witch, but at the same time, the audience is free to make their own judgments.

I definitely wasn't watching this movie to find a moral compass, but I don't think all movies need to have one (American Pie, American Pie II, American Wedding, any movie where people are constantly killing each other, etc.!)



Exactly, it's a movie, not an instructional video. If everyone behaved perfectly it would be boring. You need that conflict to make it entertaining! I'd rather see a story about cheating than a story about people killing each other and blowing each other up.

Posted 9/2/11 7:43 PM
 

Michi
My Love

Member since 5/05

31600 total posts

Name:
M

Re: The movie "something borrowed"

I felt the same way when I read the book. Then I read the 2nd part--which has yet to become a movie and it gives so much more detail, background, story, that u truly understood the story better---i think the movie was one layer and the book (both parts) had many many dimensions.. You really understand a lot more of how things happened, and why they turned out the way they did. Just my opinion on it

Posted 9/2/11 8:06 PM
 

adn16
LIF Adult

Member since 5/10

917 total posts

Name:
A

Re: The movie "something borrowed"

I read the book but haven't seen the movie. As a person who was in a very similar situation, it's hard to judge a situation until you're in it. I was with someone for over 2 years and cheated on him with his best friend, who is now my husband. 4 years later, we became friends with my ex again and we actually hang out quite often with him and his girlfriend. DH and I knew that what we did was wrong, no matter how bad my ex treated me and how good of friends they were. My DH is the best person I know... We have morals and values. We made a mistake years ago that led to the best thing in both our lives.

Posted 9/2/11 8:38 PM
 

Bluechristmas
LIF Adolescent

Member since 12/09

595 total posts

Name:

Re: The movie "something borrowed"

Life is messy and complicated.

The book deals much more with Rachel's inner struggle over her actions. The author, Emily Giffin, has been interviewd saying she writes about women who are generally likable doing things that are not so likable. She went on to explain that there are grey areas in life. I liked the moviem but felt that it was lacking the explanation of how it all happened.

Posted 9/2/11 8:40 PM
 

MrsPJB2007
MBA at your service!

Member since 7/06

12020 total posts

Name:
MJ

Re: The movie "something borrowed"

Posted by Bluechristmas

Life is messy and complicated.

The book deals much more with Rachel's inner struggle over her actions. The author, Emily Giffin, has been interviewd saying she writes about women who are generally likable doing things that are not so likable. She went on to explain that there are grey areas in life. I liked the moviem but felt that it was lacking the explanation of how it all happened.




ITA. The book is sooooo much better than the movie. They took way too much out of the film that gives you more insight into the characters.

Not every romance is boy meets girl and they live happily ever after. Sometimes things get messy and people make hasty decisions when it comes to matters of the heart. That's why I like the book. It's not cut and dry and you really understand Rachel's turmoil through it all and really they don't make Darcy even remotely as mean and self-involved I'm the film as her character is in the book as well as in Something Blue.

Posted 9/2/11 9:15 PM
 

JennB
My princess <3

Member since 5/09

2473 total posts

Name:
Jenn

Re: The movie "something borrowed"

I read the book, haven't seen the movie. I was a bit put off about the premise but as someone else mentioned it was more about Rachel's inner struggles and how she thought she wasn't good enough.

Posted 9/2/11 9:38 PM
 

Teachergal
We made a snowman!

Member since 1/08

3239 total posts

Name:

Re: The movie "something borrowed"

Some spoilers below!

I haaaaaated the book. Haven't seen the movie because of it. I actually skipped the chapters where she goes to visit her friend because I just wanted the book to be over. I 100% agree with you. I think that the author used the fact that the girl had low self-esteem and was the "Plain Jane" compared to her witchy friend in order to justify her actions. The fiancee absolutely should have just broken up with her BFF. If Rachel was posting on this board that she was cheating on her BFF with her fiancee no one would be cheering her on. We would be telling her to be strong, stand up to him and tell him to leave the BFF if he truly wanted to be with her. I think it was such a COP OUT to have the BFF also have cheated on the fiancee. As if that made what Rachel and he did ok. And what did Rachel really learn in the end? That she was worthy enough to be a girl that a guy could sneak around with all the way up until right before his wedding? How did that help raise her self-worth at all? I just didn't see what she learned or how she grew through the whole thing. I really did not like this book!

Posted 9/2/11 10:03 PM
 

MrsDamonSalv7319
Somewhere in Westeros

Member since 10/10

4495 total posts

Name:

Re: The movie "something borrowed"

Posted by adn16

I read the book but haven't seen the movie. As a person who was in a very similar situation, it's hard to judge a situation until you're in it. I was with someone for over 2 years and cheated on him with his best friend, who is now my husband. 4 years later, we became friends with my ex again and we actually hang out quite often with him and his girlfriend. DH and I knew that what we did was wrong, no matter how bad my ex treated me and how good of friends they were. My DH is the best person I know... We have morals and values. We made a mistake years ago that led to the best thing in both our lives.


Chat Icon
At least he figured it out BEFORE he got married in the movie...IMHO it makes it waaaay worse if they were married and he still cheated! Plus, they show the struggle of how he wants to make it work with the fiancé but can't stop living the best friend who he loved 1st anyway!

Posted 9/3/11 12:29 AM
 

rojerono
Happiest.

Member since 8/06

13803 total posts

Name:
Jeannie

Re: The movie "something borrowed"

I watched the movie and did not read the book.

Maybe the book conveyed the story better but on screen all that showed were two wishy washy leads who betrayed her best friend and his fiance in a really terrible way. Why? Because they were cowardly and lame. And the whole "Quick! He's not married YET!" theme that was running throughout the movie was LAME. They were engaged - invites out, dress chosen - that's not like he had just slipped a ring on her finger moments earlier. AND this was her best friend since childhood.. not some random girl she didn't know! And I didn't think Darcy was that much worse than either of the other two. When Rachel flew to London to see Ethan I thought there might be some redemption.. but nope.

Now - let's be clear - I don't look for movies to provide my 'moral compass' but I do look to feel something for the lead characters - that is part of the experience and part of what makes it entertaining. And with a romantic comedy I WANT to root for the core couple. I want to get that "Awww.." moment at the end. I didn't get that here at ALL. I felt like every person in the movie was a creep - except for Ethan. Darcy, Dex and Rachel were all self centered and mean.

Long story short.. I feel you OP. But, I also think that the actors were attractive, there was some chemistry between them and I can't bring myself to judge anyone who really thought the movie was charming and made them sigh at the end.


Message edited 2011-09-03 09:28:52.193000.

Posted 9/3/11 9:23 AM
 

maybesoon
LIF Adult

Member since 9/09

5981 total posts

Name:

Re: The movie "something borrowed"

My sister saw this movie and she was a bit upset about it. She said the movie was disturbing in a way

Posted 9/3/11 9:38 AM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: The movie "something borrowed"

Posted by Bluechristmas

Life is messy and complicated.

The book deals much more with Rachel's inner struggle over her actions. The author, Emily Giffin, has been interviewd saying she writes about women who are generally likable doing things that are not so likable. She went on to explain that there are grey areas in life. I liked the moviem but felt that it was lacking the explanation of how it all happened.




Well said. ITA.

Posted 9/3/11 10:51 AM
 

SpringBride08
LIF Toddler

Member since 5/08

435 total posts

Name:
Danielle

Re: The movie "something borrowed"

I only read the book but I do agree that it's gross how he cheats and we're supposed to see it as destiny.

Message edited 2011-09-05 10:40:21.137000.

Posted 9/5/11 10:39 AM
 

PeasandCarrots
&hearts;

Member since 5/07

9579 total posts

Name:
L

Re: The movie "something borrowed"

I did not really like it that much, but found it to be more of a real life thing then a perfect ending movie. Does that make sense? I did find some irony in the ending that while Rachel was struggling so much with this her bf was ALSO cheating and was now pg. People are flawed and I liked that it showed how while she was going through this inner struggle Darcy was ALSO cheating and clearly not struggling as much. In the end the bestfriends cheated on the bestfriends.

Posted 9/5/11 6:09 PM
 

jilliibabii
Mrs. O'Connor

Member since 6/10

12821 total posts

Name:
Jillian

Re: The movie "something borrowed"

I am glad you said this! I felt the same way when I read the book. (Even more so because it was given to me by my SIL right after I got engaged! Chat Icon) But I have to say, I really liked the movie!

Posted 9/6/11 11:14 AM
 

AngnShaun
Sisters

Member since 1/10

21015 total posts

Name:
Ang

Re: The movie "something borrowed"

Posted by medic6809

I did not really like it that much, but found it to be more of a real life thing then a perfect ending movie. Does that make sense? I did find some irony in the ending that while Rachel was struggling so much with this her bf was ALSO cheating and was now pg. People are flawed and I liked that it showed how while she was going through this inner struggle Darcy was ALSO cheating and clearly not struggling as much. In the end the bestfriends cheated on the bestfriends.



I agree... its not pleasant to read or see this stuff on TV but it happens... and it happens a lot... maybe not in the DESTINED to be with each other sort of way... but id rather see that in FICTION books and movies than meaningless cheating!

Posted 9/6/11 11:44 AM
 

NJGirl
LIF Adult

Member since 4/11

3241 total posts

Name:

Re: The movie "something borrowed"

I loved the book and enjoyed the movie too.

I don't think what the characters did was right but it is a movie not real life. I wouldn't do what Rachael did but I don't mind watching a fictional movie about it.

Posted 9/6/11 11:55 AM
 

Kazuri
LIF Adolescent

Member since 8/11

703 total posts

Name:

Re: The movie "something borrowed"

Posted by NJGirl

I loved the book and enjoyed the movie too.

I don't think what the characters did was right but it is a movie not real life. I wouldn't do what Rachael did but I don't mind watching a fictional movie about it.




ITA! Living vicariously through movies and books.

Posted 9/6/11 1:45 PM
 

mamabear
LIF Adult

Member since 3/08

4539 total posts

Name:

Re: The movie "something borrowed"

I think I'm a fairly decent person to comment on this because of the time of my life when it impacted me.

i read the book when it first came out. it was very very very hard for me to read, and in a strange way, it was therapeutic. I read it about a year after my ex-h left me for another woman, whom he ultimately married. The idea that cheating was ok if you really had feelings for another person was horrible to me. It ripped at my soul and made me so angry. But...it was also helpful to force me to look at another side, understand that there is a grey area, and to get over the feeling of being a victim. I will never say that the cheating was acceptable, but that people are flawed and make mistakes and it's how we deal with them and recover from them that is really important.

I urge you to read the next book--something blue. I didn't read it until earlier this year--7 years after reading something borrowed. I couldn't read it before then because something borrowed did hurt me to read. but when the movie came out, i decided to give it a go, and am glad that i did. would be interested in hearing what you think after reading both books.

Posted 9/6/11 2:06 PM
 

jilliibabii
Mrs. O'Connor

Member since 6/10

12821 total posts

Name:
Jillian

Re: The movie "something borrowed"

Posted by mamabear

I think I'm a fairly decent person to comment on this because of the time of my life when it impacted me.

i read the book when it first came out. it was very very very hard for me to read, and in a strange way, it was therapeutic. I read it about a year after my ex-h left me for another woman, whom he ultimately married. The idea that cheating was ok if you really had feelings for another person was horrible to me. It ripped at my soul and made me so angry. But...it was also helpful to force me to look at another side, understand that there is a grey area, and to get over the feeling of being a victim. I will never say that the cheating was acceptable, but that people are flawed and make mistakes and it's how we deal with them and recover from them that is really important.

I urge you to read the next book--something blue. I didn't read it until earlier this year--7 years after reading something borrowed. I couldn't read it before then because something borrowed did hurt me to read. but when the movie came out, i decided to give it a go, and am glad that i did. would be interested in hearing what you think after reading both books.




That's a really interesting take on it. Thank you for sharing. I have to say, I really loved the book Something Blue, so much more so than Something Borrowed.

Posted 9/6/11 2:10 PM
 

Serendipity
Summer!

Member since 4/07

7631 total posts

Name:
PrayingWishingHopingALOT

Re: The movie "something borrowed"

Posted by jilliibabii

Posted by mamabear

I



That's a really interesting take on it. Thank you for sharing. I have to say, I really loved the book Something Blue, so much more so than Something Borrowed.



I loved Something Borrowed...but I agree...I oved Something Blue 1000x more!

Posted 9/6/11 10:49 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Something Borrowed by Emily Griffin--movie trailer! DiamondGirl 2/19/11 41 Celebrities & Entertainment
Something Borrowed Movie Cast scubashell44 4/10/10 11 StoryBoard
wwyd? If someone you knew well borrowed $800 from you 6-8 years ago Ophelia 2/4/09 40 Families Helping Families ™
Has anyone borrowed a a bag from Bag, Borrow or Steal? randella 7/27/08 0 Fashion & Beauty!
Another Spinoff: What is the highest amt of money you've ever borrowed or loaned? JenniferEver 8/16/05 18 Families Helping Families ™