Thanks everyone
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: 1 2 [3] | |
|
Re: Thanks everyone Posted by computergirl Posted by nrthshgrl I once asked on the Parenting board, what plans do the SAHMs have in terms of supporting themselves? Will they go back to work when the kids are in school? Do you have contingency plans of support if something where to happen to your DH (death/divorce)? Here's the thing (and I think this is why threads on this topic go south quickly)-- unless your DH's income is completely superfluous and you can carry all the bills yourself on your salary, then you need to ask yourself the same questions regarding death and divorce. Most of my WOHM friends would be in pretty rough financial straits if they had to raise the family on their income alone. Why single out the SAHMs then? Why assume that they have no financial plans in place? Why assume that they just made this impulsive "feel good" decision to stay home without considering the big picture? Did we somehow lose our financial savvy when we made our decision to stay home? There's something to be said for living the life you want TODAY and not missing out on the experiences you desire because you're so busy hedging against death or divorce. Lots of husbands stay alive. Lots of couples stay married. Unfortunately there's this caricature of the vapid, spoiled SAHM, trotting off to Starbucks in her Lululemons, while her poor husband has to deal with the bills she ran up at the mall. I feel like a lot of the defensive responses on topics like this stem from a need to fight this stereotype. I still dont get the original question was vapid, nor "attacking". The OP's question was not that at all. It was JUST a curios question that was asking for honest answers. Maybe she is looking into being a SAHM and wants to know how others handle it? I just think that the OP's question WAS innocent and should be taken at face value, nothing more. |
|
Posted 4/1/13 3:12 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: Thanks everyone Posted by Paramount I still dont get the original question was vapid, nor "attacking". The OP's question was not that at all. It was JUST a curios question that was asking for honest answers. Maybe she is looking into being a SAHM and wants to know how others handle it? I just think that the OP's question WAS innocent and should be taken at face value, nothing more. The OP's original question was 100% innocent. She just wondered how they afforded all that stuff on one income. Notice I defended her intentions earlier in the thread when someone jumped down her throat. My post was in reference to a lot of the responses. Some people got unnecessarily defensive. Some people segued into a discussion of what the poor, helpless SAHMs would do if their husbands died or left them. I don't understand why this post, like many others, became sort of a referendum on SAHMs, and that's what I'm responding to. |
|
Posted 4/1/13 3:17 PM
|
|
|
Re: Thanks everyone Posted by computergirl Posted by nrthshgrl I once asked on the Parenting board, what plans do the SAHMs have in terms of supporting themselves? Will they go back to work when the kids are in school? Do you have contingency plans of support if something where to happen to your DH (death/divorce)? Here's the thing (and I think this is why threads on this topic go south quickly)-- unless your DH's income is completely superfluous and you can carry all the bills yourself on your salary, then you need to ask yourself the same questions regarding death and divorce. Most of my WOHM friends would be in pretty rough financial straits if they had to raise the family on their income alone. Why single out the SAHMs then? Why assume that they have no financial plans in place? Why assume that they just made this impulsive "feel good" decision to stay home without considering the big picture? Did we somehow lose our financial savvy when we made our decision to stay home? There's something to be said for living the life you want TODAY and not missing out on the experiences you desire because you're so busy hedging against death or divorce. Lots of husbands stay alive. Lots of couples stay married. . ITA with this 100%. And, I was one of the people that responded to that thread. I felt the question posted was condescending and one-sided and, honestly, whether someone is a SAHM or not is completely irrelevant to this issue as the above poster pointed out very nicesly. HOnestly, my two-income family friends and family members would be in a WORSE position than most of my SAHM friends should this worst case scenario happen. I think to assume that SAHM families haven't planned for that situation is ridiculous. I also felt that thread you are referring to was defensive on the other spectrum as well - using this worst case scenario as a way to justify why staying at home to raise your kids is not the best option. |
|
Posted 4/1/13 3:24 PM
|
|
|
Re: Thanks everyone Posted by nrthshgrl Posted by Paramount Posted by Chatham-Chick Legitimate question (I read the OP yesterday, but didn't get an opportunity to reply until now.) I wonder ALL THE TIME what the heck people do to live certain lifestyles. Same hear. Legit question and could not answer till now. My husband and I make a good living. No kids. We own our home. We do not live above our means. Combined we do well. But. I always wonder what OTHER people do to afford all those vacations, and "stuff". I see friends posting on FB all the time about Hawaii, and Fiji and xyz. We do well but still could not afford a vacation like that. We were thinking about going to Disney, and MAYBE staying at the Contemporary. To stay there for a week would be $5,000. I looked at him and said that I dont know how people make enough money to go to Disney and spend $5k for one week. What do they do for a living? So OP, most people actually understood what you were REALLY asking, so dont worry. I agree. I know plenty of people where the wife is a SAHM & they have a ton of designer clothes,handbags, beautiful house, etc. Scenarios vary from: -The husband makes more money. -They spend their money on different things than we do. -Some are in debt more than what we are comfortable with having. But by far the biggest factor I've seen is from those that bought their house years before we were married. That is probaby the biggest game changer. Those people have significantly more house for a fraction of what we're paying for a mortgage & therefore have more disposable income. As far as what husbands say about it, I heard one husband volunteer he wished his wife would get a job to bring in some money. Their kids are in school & he said it's been tough between them because when he asked about her getting a job, she said she's too busy driving the kids to after school activities & school. She also has been out of the workforce for their entire marriage (10+ years). She'd be hard pressed to find a job without any experience & the flexible hours she needs for the kids. Another husband complained about the amount of shopping his wife did too but since he's the guy that puts a lot of stock in having a hot wife with nice clothes, I think he can go suck it as those things cost money While I don't like to see strain on my friends' marriages, as long as my husband & I are on the same page, it's not my business.I am not a SAHM by choice. But this exactly correct about the housing situation. DH purchased our home before we were even engaged. This helps us 100%. It is a big factor in our lives. Message edited 2013-04-01 15:46:35.463000. |
|
Posted 4/1/13 3:46 PM
|
|
|
Re: Thanks everyone right now my DH works from home, but if that changes I will HAVE to be a SAHM because my salary is barely more than the cost of full time day care. |
|
Posted 4/1/13 3:57 PM
|
|
|
Re: Thanks everyone Posted by itsbabytime Posted by computergirl Posted by nrthshgrl I once asked on the Parenting board, what plans do the SAHMs have in terms of supporting themselves? Will they go back to work when the kids are in school? Do you have contingency plans of support if something where to happen to your DH (death/divorce)? Here's the thing (and I think this is why threads on this topic go south quickly)-- unless your DH's income is completely superfluous and you can carry all the bills yourself on your salary, then you need to ask yourself the same questions regarding death and divorce. Most of my WOHM friends would be in pretty rough financial straits if they had to raise the family on their income alone. Why single out the SAHMs then? Why assume that they have no financial plans in place? Why assume that they just made this impulsive "feel good" decision to stay home without considering the big picture? Did we somehow lose our financial savvy when we made our decision to stay home? There's something to be said for living the life you want TODAY and not missing out on the experiences you desire because you're so busy hedging against death or divorce. Lots of husbands stay alive. Lots of couples stay married. . ITA with this 100%. I felt the question posted was condescending and one-sided and, honestly, whether someone is a SAHM or not is completely irrelevant to this issue as the above poster pointed out very nicesly. I remember that thread. I believed then, and still do now, that it's a legitimate and honest question. I also think that simply asking what the plan is is not the same as assuming there isn't one. I have been both SAHM and working mom and I disagree that it's totally irrelevant mainly because of the job market today. The job market today is extremely tight. Without relevant, recent experience, many fields will be difficult to get back into. While I admit this is anecdotal, I know of many, many SAHMs who would love to get a job but cannot because they lack current skills, connections, and experience. Anyone who thinks that if their DHs left them - either through death or divorce - they could just go get a job needs to realize it is not that easy. I am not saying anyone on this thread said that, but I know people who have. Alimony is limited these days and child support is only a fraction of a husband's salary. Also, even if the wife gets the house in a settlement, remember that houses don't produce income - they consume it (unless of course you are renting it out.) So unless you (general you) are independently wealthy (and more power to you if you are) I think it's wise to have a plan in place to make sure you have a steady flow of income in the event of something like that happening. I think sometimes SAHMs get unnecessarily defensive about these posts. No one said anything about vapid spenders or whatever a PP said. Not a soul. I don't know where this comes from as I was a SAHM and I never felt the need to defend my position. When people post questions like Barbara's old post we all have to take a deep breath and remember - before we get defensive - that everyone has reasons for posting questions and they probably have to do with something they've witnessed in their own lives and nothing to do with what anyone says on here. |
|
Posted 4/1/13 4:08 PM
|
|
|
Re: Thanks everyone Posted by computergirl Posted by Paramount I still dont get the original question was vapid, nor "attacking". The OP's question was not that at all. It was JUST a curios question that was asking for honest answers. Maybe she is looking into being a SAHM and wants to know how others handle it? I just think that the OP's question WAS innocent and should be taken at face value, nothing more. The OP's original question was 100% innocent. She just wondered how they afforded all that stuff on one income. Notice I defended her intentions earlier in the thread when someone jumped down her throat. My post was in reference to a lot of the responses. Some people got unnecessarily defensive. Some people segued into a discussion of what the poor, helpless SAHMs would do if their husbands died or left them. I don't understand why this post, like many others, became sort of a referendum on SAHMs, and that's what I'm responding to. Fair enough! |
|
Posted 4/1/13 4:28 PM
|
|
|
Re: Thanks everyone Posted by itsbabytime Here's the thing (and I think this is why threads on this topic go south quickly)-- unless your DH's income is completely superfluous and you can carry all the bills yourself on your salary, then you need to ask yourself the same questions regarding death and divorce. Most of my WOHM friends would be in pretty rough financial straits if they had to raise the family on their income alone. Why single out the SAHMs then? Why assume that they have no financial plans in place? Why assume that they just made this impulsive "feel good" decision to stay home without considering the big picture? Did we somehow lose our financial savvy when we made our decision to stay home? There's something to be said for living the life you want TODAY and not missing out on the experiences you desire because you're so busy hedging against death or divorce. Lots of husbands stay alive. Lots of couples stay married. . ITA with this 100%. And, I was one of the people that responded to that thread. I felt the question posted was condescending and one-sided and, honestly, whether someone is a SAHM or not is completely irrelevant to this issue as the above poster pointed out very nicesly. HOnestly, my two-income family friends and family members would be in a WORSE position than most of my SAHM friends should this worst case scenario happen. I think to assume that SAHM families haven't planned for that situation is ridiculous. I also felt that thread you are referring to was defensive on the other spectrum as well - using this worst case scenario as a way to justify why staying at home to raise your kids is not the best option. In the post, I wrote that I had four (male) friends in one year come down with cancer & all of their wives were in a panic trying to figure out how they were going to support their family during treatment, how they could come up with COBRA payments while the DHs stopped work for treatments, how they were going to financially support them now that 2 of the husbands died. Only 2 of the DHs had a job that allowed him short & long term disability & full insurance benefits. and yet you thought that was condescending? Or that I assumed that all of the SAHMs on this messageboard had no plan? That I was saying staying home with the children wasn't the best option? Seriously? How would I know what the best option was for your family? My friends & their wives decided to have the mom stay home because in 3 of those situations the wife didn't make enough to cover daycare expenses. I assume most of the people on this messageboard would be in a rough situation financially if one of the earners died. I think it's prudent that everyone have a contingency plan in place. But for families where there is one income, it is even more vital. Posted by computergirl Lots of husbands stay alive. Lots of couples stay married. . Actually that's not true. Every husband will eventually die. So will every wife. If you're not the one that dies, you are the one that is supporting your family - whether you were a SAHM or a Working mom. Message edited 2013-04-01 16:34:09.567000. |
|
Posted 4/1/13 4:31 PM
|
|
|
Re: Thanks everyone Posted by itsbabytime Posted by computergirl Posted by nrthshgrl I once asked on the Parenting board, what plans do the SAHMs have in terms of supporting themselves? Will they go back to work when the kids are in school? Do you have contingency plans of support if something where to happen to your DH (death/divorce)? Here's the thing (and I think this is why threads on this topic go south quickly)-- unless your DH's income is completely superfluous and you can carry all the bills yourself on your salary, then you need to ask yourself the same questions regarding death and divorce. Most of my WOHM friends would be in pretty rough financial straits if they had to raise the family on their income alone. Why single out the SAHMs then? Why assume that they have no financial plans in place? Why assume that they just made this impulsive "feel good" decision to stay home without considering the big picture? Did we somehow lose our financial savvy when we made our decision to stay home? There's something to be said for living the life you want TODAY and not missing out on the experiences you desire because you're so busy hedging against death or divorce. Lots of husbands stay alive. Lots of couples stay married. . ITA with this 100%. And, I was one of the people that responded to that thread. I felt the question posted was condescending and one-sided and, honestly, whether someone is a SAHM or not is completely irrelevant to this issue as the above poster pointed out very nicesly. HOnestly, my two-income family friends and family members would be in a WORSE position than most of my SAHM friends should this worst case scenario happen. I think to assume that SAHM families haven't planned for that situation is ridiculous. I also felt that thread you are referring to was defensive on the other spectrum as well - using this worst case scenario as a way to justify why staying at home to raise your kids is not the best option. Can you elaborate on how your two income friends would be in a worse position than your sahm friends? I am not asking to be snotty, I genuinely want to understand how that is true in your circle. All my close friends work full time, so I really have no close experience with sahm finances. |
|
Posted 4/1/13 4:45 PM
|
|
|
Re: Thanks everyone Posted by MegZee Posted by itsbabytime Posted by computergirl Posted by nrthshgrl I once asked on the Parenting board, what plans do the SAHMs have in terms of supporting themselves? Will they go back to work when the kids are in school? Do you have contingency plans of support if something where to happen to your DH (death/divorce)? Here's the thing (and I think this is why threads on this topic go south quickly)-- unless your DH's income is completely superfluous and you can carry all the bills yourself on your salary, then you need to ask yourself the same questions regarding death and divorce. Most of my WOHM friends would be in pretty rough financial straits if they had to raise the family on their income alone. Why single out the SAHMs then? Why assume that they have no financial plans in place? Why assume that they just made this impulsive "feel good" decision to stay home without considering the big picture? Did we somehow lose our financial savvy when we made our decision to stay home? There's something to be said for living the life you want TODAY and not missing out on the experiences you desire because you're so busy hedging against death or divorce. Lots of husbands stay alive. Lots of couples stay married. . ITA with this 100%. And, I was one of the people that responded to that thread. I felt the question posted was condescending and one-sided and, honestly, whether someone is a SAHM or not is completely irrelevant to this issue as the above poster pointed out very nicesly. HOnestly, my two-income family friends and family members would be in a WORSE position than most of my SAHM friends should this worst case scenario happen. I think to assume that SAHM families haven't planned for that situation is ridiculous. I also felt that thread you are referring to was defensive on the other spectrum as well - using this worst case scenario as a way to justify why staying at home to raise your kids is not the best option. Can you elaborate on how your two income friends would be in a worse position than your sahm friends? I am not asking to be snotty, I genuinely want to understand how that is true in your circle. All my close friends work full time, so I really have no close experience with sahm finances. I am curious too. I work full time ( from home) and thankfully, I could carry our family completely and comfortably on my income of god forbid, something were to happen. We also have life insurance but that takes a while to pay out and estates take a while to be settled. I think it is a valid question. I have had several friends who have gotten divorced and have had to take out bank loans to pay for daycare because the jobs they were able to get do not offer much money despite degrees from prestigious schools because they spent o much time out of the workforce. I am not disparaging anyone's decision at all and I am sure many have planned for those situations but I am sure some haven't and I think it is important to think about especially considering the divorce rate is 50% As to the regional question, I really don't know how people do it. Clearly, they are much smarter than me. We are considered the top percentage of earners and I can't buy the stuff I see a lot of people buy so I am really at a loss and am doing something wrong. Message edited 2013-04-01 16:59:12.387000. |
|
Posted 4/1/13 4:58 PM
|
|
|
Re: Thanks everyone Posted by MegZee Posted by itsbabytime Posted by computergirl Posted by nrthshgrl I once asked on the Parenting board, what plans do the SAHMs have in terms of supporting themselves? Will they go back to work when the kids are in school? Do you have contingency plans of support if something where to happen to your DH (death/divorce)? Here's the thing (and I think this is why threads on this topic go south quickly)-- unless your DH's income is completely superfluous and you can carry all the bills yourself on your salary, then you need to ask yourself the same questions regarding death and divorce. Most of my WOHM friends would be in pretty rough financial straits if they had to raise the family on their income alone. Why single out the SAHMs then? Why assume that they have no financial plans in place? Why assume that they just made this impulsive "feel good" decision to stay home without considering the big picture? Did we somehow lose our financial savvy when we made our decision to stay home? There's something to be said for living the life you want TODAY and not missing out on the experiences you desire because you're so busy hedging against death or divorce. Lots of husbands stay alive. Lots of couples stay married. . ITA with this 100%. And, I was one of the people that responded to that thread. I felt the question posted was condescending and one-sided and, honestly, whether someone is a SAHM or not is completely irrelevant to this issue as the above poster pointed out very nicesly. HOnestly, my two-income family friends and family members would be in a WORSE position than most of my SAHM friends should this worst case scenario happen. I think to assume that SAHM families haven't planned for that situation is ridiculous. I also felt that thread you are referring to was defensive on the other spectrum as well - using this worst case scenario as a way to justify why staying at home to raise your kids is not the best option. Can you elaborate on how your two income friends would be in a worse position than your sahm friends? I am not asking to be snotty, I genuinely want to understand how that is true in your circle. All my close friends work full time, so I really have no close experience with sahm finances. The families I know where the mom and dad both work it is because they both HAVE to work to pay the bills. Without one income they cannot support their lifestyle (mortgage, child care etc.). If they lost one income they would NOT be able to pay the bills. Additionally, they have very little savings and, small, if any life ins. policies. I don't feel like I need to go into tons of detail here but - The SAHM's have DH's that make a lot of $$. They have BIG life insurance policy's (2-3 million) that will more than cover their yearly expenses for a long time. They have savings, 529 plans for their kids, very large homes (they could sell if they need to) and, have advanced degrees themselves if it was absolutely necessary for them to go back into the work force - they could (lawyers, doctors, cpa's etc.), Honestly, most people don't fit into the first category OR the second - they are somewhere in between...The bottom line is - just because one family has two parents working and the other has only one - doesnt mean that one is better off in that situation. I think it is wrong to assume a SAHM would be in a worse position that a FTWM. I think it varies, family to family and that was my only point. A "warning" in this respect would be better for ALL moms - working or not. JMO. Message edited 2013-04-01 17:14:46.537000. |
|
Posted 4/1/13 5:03 PM
|
|
|
Re: Thanks everyone Posted by nrthshgrl you thought that was condescending? Or that I assumed that all of the SAHMs on this messageboard had no plan? That I was saying staying home with the children wasn't the best option? Seriously? How would I know what the best option was for your family? My friends & their wives decided to have the mom stay home because in 3 of those situations the wife didn't make enough to cover daycare expenses. I assume most of the people on this messageboard would be in a rough situation financially if one of the earners died. I think it's prudent that everyone have a contingency plan in place. But for families where there is one income, it is even more vital. Your post was addressed only to SAHM's that is why I had a problem with it. Because, in reality, a FTWM could have just a big a problem if she doesn't have a contingency plan should something happen to her DH - couldn't that be the case don't you think? At the time, I think the people that responded to your thread took offense because - you, NOT a SAHM was singling out ONLY SAHM's to lecture about the fact that one day they might not have their DH's income. I don't think that is fair honestly because, in reality, as I stated - a FTWM could have just a big a problem. Honestly, most moms that I know work (IRL and from what I see on here) do so because they HAVE to. So, my guess would be - if they lost 1/2 of the household income and potentially the household benefits as well - they would be in just as bad a place! If you truly were trying to be helpful - your post should have been addressed to all moms - not just SAHM's. Message edited 2013-04-01 17:09:55.080000. |
|
Posted 4/1/13 5:05 PM
|
|
|
Re: Thanks everyone Posted by itsbabytime Posted by MegZee Posted by itsbabytime Posted by computergirl Posted by nrthshgrl I once asked on the Parenting board, what plans do the SAHMs have in terms of supporting themselves? Will they go back to work when the kids are in school? Do you have contingency plans of support if something where to happen to your DH (death/divorce)? Here's the thing (and I think this is why threads on this topic go south quickly)-- unless your DH's income is completely superfluous and you can carry all the bills yourself on your salary, then you need to ask yourself the same questions regarding death and divorce. Most of my WOHM friends would be in pretty rough financial straits if they had to raise the family on their income alone. Why single out the SAHMs then? Why assume that they have no financial plans in place? Why assume that they just made this impulsive "feel good" decision to stay home without considering the big picture? Did we somehow lose our financial savvy when we made our decision to stay home? There's something to be said for living the life you want TODAY and not missing out on the experiences you desire because you're so busy hedging against death or divorce. Lots of husbands stay alive. Lots of couples stay married. . ITA with this 100%. And, I was one of the people that responded to that thread. I felt the question posted was condescending and one-sided and, honestly, whether someone is a SAHM or not is completely irrelevant to this issue as the above poster pointed out very nicesly. HOnestly, my two-income family friends and family members would be in a WORSE position than most of my SAHM friends should this worst case scenario happen. I think to assume that SAHM families haven't planned for that situation is ridiculous. I also felt that thread you are referring to was defensive on the other spectrum as well - using this worst case scenario as a way to justify why staying at home to raise your kids is not the best option. Can you elaborate on how your two income friends would be in a worse position than your sahm friends? I am not asking to be snotty, I genuinely want to understand how that is true in your circle. All my close friends work full time, so I really have no close experience with sahm finances. The families I know where the mom and dad both work it is because they both HAVE to work to pay the bills. Without one income they cannot support their lifestyle (mortgage, child care etc.). If they lost one income they would NOT be able to pay the bills. I don't feel like I need to go into tons of detail here but - The SAHM's have DH's that make a lot of $$. They have BIG life insurance policy's (2-3 million) that will more than cover their yearly expenses for a long time. They have savings, 529 plans for their kids, very large homes (they could sell if they need to) and, have advanced degrees themselves if it was absolutely necessary for them to go back into the work force - they could (lawyers, doctors, cpa's etc.), The bottom line is - just because one family has two parents working and the other has only one - doesnt mean that one is better off in that situation. I think it is wrong to assume a SAHM would be in a worse position that a FTWM. But what about divorce? Which is far more likely considering the statistics. If you ( g eneral you) have an advanced degree and have been out of the work place for a while that degree becomes pretty useless. I also think it is quite a stretch to think that women who work do so because they HAVE too. |
|
Posted 4/1/13 5:14 PM
|
|
|
Re: Thanks everyone Posted by MegZee Can you elaborate on how your two income friends would be in a worse position than your sahm friends? I am not asking to be snotty, I genuinely want to understand how that is true in your circle. All my close friends work full time, so I really have no close experience with sahm finances. I really can't speak for any SAHMs except myself, but DH and I live a fairly simple, below-our-means lifestyle. We have zero debt, we even paid off our home in the last couple years. We've never been the type to take on a huge mortgage or huge car payments. We just don't have expensive spending habits, it's not like we purposely deprive ourselves. If my DH had a long stint of unemployment, for example, we wouldn't freak out at all because we've saved and prepared for just such an event. Now, I have relatives and friends who have huge mortgages, two car payments, and generally expensive lifestyles. They have said that ANY stretch of unemployment would be a crisis for them, because they basically spend every penny. So I guess my point is, there is a lot more to a family's financial picture than whether there are one vs. two incomes. What are their monthly expenses, and can any of them be cut if needed? What level of lifestyle do they live? Some people's "needs" are other people's luxuries. How much debt do they have? Savings and other assets? |
|
Posted 4/1/13 5:14 PM
|
|
|
Re: Thanks everyone Posted by itsbabytime Posted by MegZee Posted by itsbabytime Posted by computergirl Posted by nrthshgrl I once asked on the Parenting board, what plans do the SAHMs have in terms of supporting themselves? Will they go back to work when the kids are in school? Do you have contingency plans of support if something where to happen to your DH (death/divorce)? Here's the thing (and I think this is why threads on this topic go south quickly)-- unless your DH's income is completely superfluous and you can carry all the bills yourself on your salary, then you need to ask yourself the same questions regarding death and divorce. Most of my WOHM friends would be in pretty rough financial straits if they had to raise the family on their income alone. Why single out the SAHMs then? Why assume that they have no financial plans in place? Why assume that they just made this impulsive "feel good" decision to stay home without considering the big picture? Did we somehow lose our financial savvy when we made our decision to stay home? There's something to be said for living the life you want TODAY and not missing out on the experiences you desire because you're so busy hedging against death or divorce. Lots of husbands stay alive. Lots of couples stay married. . ITA with this 100%. And, I was one of the people that responded to that thread. I felt the question posted was condescending and one-sided and, honestly, whether someone is a SAHM or not is completely irrelevant to this issue as the above poster pointed out very nicesly. HOnestly, my two-income family friends and family members would be in a WORSE position than most of my SAHM friends should this worst case scenario happen. I think to assume that SAHM families haven't planned for that situation is ridiculous. I also felt that thread you are referring to was defensive on the other spectrum as well - using this worst case scenario as a way to justify why staying at home to raise your kids is not the best option. Can you elaborate on how your two income friends would be in a worse position than your sahm friends? I am not asking to be snotty, I genuinely want to understand how that is true in your circle. All my close friends work full time, so I really have no close experience with sahm finances. The families I know where the mom and dad both work it is because they both HAVE to work to pay the bills. Without one income they cannot support their lifestyle (mortgage, child care etc.). If they lost one income they would NOT be able to pay the bills. I don't feel like I need to go into tons of detail here but - The SAHM's have DH's that make a lot of $$. They have BIG life insurance policy's (2-3 million) that will more than cover their yearly expenses for a long time. They have savings, 529 plans for their kids, very large homes (they could sell if they need to) and, have advanced degrees themselves if it was absolutely necessary for them to go back into the work force - they could (lawyers, doctors, cpa's etc.), The bottom line is - just because one family has two parents working and the other has only one - doesnt mean that one is better off in that situation. I think it is wrong to assume a SAHM would be in a worse position that a FTWM. Thanks for explaining. I definitely don't think that a sahm is in a worse position than a ftwm in all instances, as you explained. Ftwm should definitely have life insurance on both spouses too. |
|
Posted 4/1/13 5:16 PM
|
|
|
Re: Thanks everyone Posted by MegZee Posted by itsbabytime Posted by MegZee Posted by itsbabytime Posted by computergirl Posted by nrthshgrl I once asked on the Parenting board, what plans do the SAHMs have in terms of supporting themselves? Will they go back to work when the kids are in school? Do you have contingency plans of support if something where to happen to your DH (death/divorce)? Here's the thing (and I think this is why threads on this topic go south quickly)-- unless your DH's income is completely superfluous and you can carry all the bills yourself on your salary, then you need to ask yourself the same questions regarding death and divorce. Most of my WOHM friends would be in pretty rough financial straits if they had to raise the family on their income alone. Why single out the SAHMs then? Why assume that they have no financial plans in place? Why assume that they just made this impulsive "feel good" decision to stay home without considering the big picture? Did we somehow lose our financial savvy when we made our decision to stay home? There's something to be said for living the life you want TODAY and not missing out on the experiences you desire because you're so busy hedging against death or divorce. Lots of husbands stay alive. Lots of couples stay married. . ITA with this 100%. And, I was one of the people that responded to that thread. I felt the question posted was condescending and one-sided and, honestly, whether someone is a SAHM or not is completely irrelevant to this issue as the above poster pointed out very nicesly. HOnestly, my two-income family friends and family members would be in a WORSE position than most of my SAHM friends should this worst case scenario happen. I think to assume that SAHM families haven't planned for that situation is ridiculous. I also felt that thread you are referring to was defensive on the other spectrum as well - using this worst case scenario as a way to justify why staying at home to raise your kids is not the best option. Can you elaborate on how your two income friends would be in a worse position than your sahm friends? I am not asking to be snotty, I genuinely want to understand how that is true in your circle. All my close friends work full time, so I really have no close experience with sahm finances. The families I know where the mom and dad both work it is because they both HAVE to work to pay the bills. Without one income they cannot support their lifestyle (mortgage, child care etc.). If they lost one income they would NOT be able to pay the bills. I don't feel like I need to go into tons of detail here but - The SAHM's have DH's that make a lot of $$. They have BIG life insurance policy's (2-3 million) that will more than cover their yearly expenses for a long time. They have savings, 529 plans for their kids, very large homes (they could sell if they need to) and, have advanced degrees themselves if it was absolutely necessary for them to go back into the work force - they could (lawyers, doctors, cpa's etc.), The bottom line is - just because one family has two parents working and the other has only one - doesnt mean that one is better off in that situation. I think it is wrong to assume a SAHM would be in a worse position that a FTWM. Thanks for explaining. I definitely don't think that a sahm is in a worse position than a ftwm in all instances, as you explained. Ftwm should definitely have life insurance on both spouses too. I did work full time when my first son was born. I have been a SAHM for four years now. Financially, we are actually in a better position than we were when I was working. We moved from CT, where we owned a home that we bought when the prices of homes were overinflated. Now we live in VA. Our taxes are much lower, as is the price of the house we bought. I actually spend much less than I did while working. We spend a lot less on food (cook a lot, barely any takeout), commuting costs, and I don't buy nearly as many clothes/shoes/bags as I did when worked. The lower cost of living allows us to be more financially comfortable, on less income. It is win win for us, since I get to be home to take care of my boys. We are putting a lot more away towards retirement and the kid's college now, then when I was working. I had my kids later in life, I worked for nearly 14 years in my field before leaving my job. I earned a future pension and have a decent retirement account, that we still contribute too. We also have savings accounts. Every situation is different. I do know many women (working or not) who spends tons of money on things, and it is baffling how the can afford it. But- you never know their situation. They could own their home outright, have family money, tons of debt. The key is to find the best situation that works for your family, and for wife and husband to be on the same page when it comes to spending. |
|
Posted 4/1/13 5:52 PM
|
|
|
Thanks everyone I am a SAHM. I work part time from home. The only debt we have is our mtge, we lease one car and the other is paid in full. I like medium to more expensive priced stores, and usually shop on the sale rack. I have some designer bags that i had before I was a SAHM. We are able to buy things we want when we want because we are really good with money. We have a savings account specifically for house stuff, then we have our do not ever touch savings acount. We also have our own savings accounts which we use for personal things such as clothes, shoes etc... Because we spread our money this way mostly everything is paid in cash or paid off within a couple months. We take a couple small vacations a year, or one big. My daughter is in a mommy & me, and will be starting nursery school in Sept. I think the key is budgeting. We save for things we really want and don't throw money away on unnecessary things. |
|
Posted 4/1/13 9:26 PM
|
|
|
Re: Thanks everyone Posted by nrthshgrl Posted by MorningCuppaCoffee I also think when it comes to the subject of SAHMs and how people spend their $$$ in general, this is a very sensitive topic for most people. I think this is why people respond the way they do on threads like this. Definitely. I once asked on the Parenting board, what plans do the SAHMs have in terms of supporting themselves? Will they go back to work when the kids are in school? Do you have contingency plans of support if something where to happen to your DH (death/divorce)? It was coming on the heels of a good friend's death & his wife was grappling with what she was going to do to support herself & her kids. So while it was done with the best intentions, the reaction was over the top. The thread quickly went south because of the defensiveness. It's a shame because I think everyone should consider how they will support themselves long term but especially one income families. I am in school to become an RN so I have a good backup plan for my future..I do already have a BA in mass comm but have decided I REALLY want to be a nurse... I'll admit that most of my time as a SAHM we've struggled financially...we pay our bills, live frugally and our kids are very happy and loved...but it hasn't always been easy. With that being said, we both were on the same exact page as far as me being a SAHM..there was never a choice..we bought a home with an affordable mortgage. I have married friends where both work and are in worse financial shape than us because their mortgage payments are insane. It's all relative. By nature I am not a worrier. I know anything in life can happen, but I try to take it one day at a time and enjoy the time now. If something god forbid happened to DH right now, we would have our family to help me out while I finished school and could work. Without family/life insurance etc I don't know what the plan would be... |
|
Posted 4/1/13 10:13 PM
|
|
|
Re: Thanks everyone I'm a SAHM. I can totally see how people would question a woman's ability to be able o stay home AND afford designer! So to answer your question based on what I'm surrounded by.....moms who stay home and have the ability to buy whatever are usually in my case the older more established moms in my group. The moms who are in their later forties with young kids. They put their time in at work, saved and their mortgages are much cheaper because they bought before the hype or they paid off their house and most have already received an inheritance. Their husbands have worked for the same company for 20 plus years and raise after raise and promotion they make more then enough, most over 100 k a year. |
|
Posted 4/2/13 9:45 AM
|
|
| Pages: 1 2 [3] | |




While I don't like to see strain on my friends' marriages, as long as my husband & I are on the same page, it's not my business.



