Re: Thanks everyone
Posted 4/1/2013 4:31:15 PM by nrthshgrl


Posted by itsbabytime

Here's the thing (and I think this is why threads on this topic go south quickly)-- unless your DH's income is completely superfluous and you can carry all the bills yourself on your salary, then you need to ask yourself the same questions regarding death and divorce. Most of my WOHM friends would be in pretty rough financial straits if they had to raise the family on their income alone.

Why single out the SAHMs then? Why assume that they have no financial plans in place? Why assume that they just made this impulsive "feel good" decision to stay home without considering the big picture? Did we somehow lose our financial savvy when we made our decision to stay home? There's something to be said for living the life you want TODAY and not missing out on the experiences you desire because you're so busy hedging against death or divorce. Lots of husbands stay alive. Lots of couples stay married.

.



ITA with this 100%. And, I was one of the people that responded to that thread. I felt the question posted was condescending and one-sided and, honestly, whether someone is a SAHM or not is completely irrelevant to this issue as the above poster pointed out very nicesly. HOnestly, my two-income family friends and family members would be in a WORSE position than most of my SAHM friends should this worst case scenario happen. I think to assume that SAHM families haven't planned for that situation is ridiculous. I also felt that thread you are referring to was defensive on the other spectrum as well - using this worst case scenario as a way to justify why staying at home to raise your kids is not the best option.



In the post, I wrote that I had four (male) friends in one year come down with cancer & all of their wives were in a panic trying to figure out how they were going to support their family during treatment, how they could come up with COBRA payments while the DHs stopped work for treatments, how they were going to financially support them now that 2 of the husbands died. Only 2 of the DHs had a job that allowed him short & long term disability & full insurance benefits.

and yet you thought that was condescending? Or that I assumed that all of the SAHMs on this messageboard had no plan? That I was saying staying home with the children wasn't the best option? Seriously? How would I know what the best option was for your family? My friends & their wives decided to have the mom stay home because in 3 of those situations the wife didn't make enough to cover daycare expenses.

I assume most of the people on this messageboard would be in a rough situation financially if one of the earners died. I think it's prudent that everyone have a contingency plan in place. But for families where there is one income, it is even more vital.


Posted by computergirl
Lots of husbands stay alive. Lots of couples stay married.
.



Actually that's not true. Every husband will eventually die. So will every wife. If you're not the one that dies, you are the one that is supporting your family - whether you were a SAHM or a Working mom.
Print Post      Close Window