Teaching "NO"

Posted By Message

JennZ
MY LIFE!!

Member since 8/05

25463 total posts

Name:

Teaching "NO"

When will grasp NO. I must say NO 1000 a day. NO don't climb on the TV, NO stay away from the computer. NO.NO.NO. He is just about 9 mos, and NO means we smile and laugh. Am I nuts to think he is mocking me by laughing. I swear he knows. He will crawl over to the TV, turn around and wait for me to say NO and then try to climb the damn thing.

Upside, my arms may look like MAdonna's with all the lifting and removing from NO things.

Posted 10/15/09 12:14 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

MrsFlatbread
Skinny jeans are in my future

Member since 6/06

10258 total posts

Name:
Baby Momma

Re: Teaching "NO"

Frankie does the same thing...I tell him "no" he stops what it is he is doing, looks at me with this devilish grin and smile...then proceeds to do what he wanted to do in the first place. I think he is starting to get the concept a little bit...but he is surely testing me!!

Posted 10/15/09 12:27 PM
 

JennZ
MY LIFE!!

Member since 8/05

25463 total posts

Name:

Re: Teaching "NO"

Chat Icon I swear, he is trying to break me. Little does he know Mama is one STUBBORN chick. I will win yet!Chat Icon

Posted 10/15/09 12:29 PM
 

Hofstra26
Love to Bake!

Member since 7/06

27915 total posts

Name:

Re: Teaching "NO"

I was just reading about this and they said you should NOT be using the word "NO" to discipline at this age because it's a game to them and it has no meaning. The ONLY time you should use "NO" is if they are in danger of hurting themselves because it will cause an immediate reaction to stop. Example - Going to touch a hot stove or a light socket.

At this age and until they have some concept of right and wrong and a "time out" would mean something to them the best thing is to redirect them when you see them doing something "wrong" or distract them with something else. You can also SHOW them the right way to behave so they learn. For example - show them how to nicely pet the dog instead of grabbing his tail.

The more you say "NO" the more they enjoy it because it's a game. The word itself means nothing to them and they aren't really doing what they are doing to be "bad". They don't understand right and wrong, all they know is that they learned how to do something (like throwing their sippy cup) so they do it.

Posted 10/15/09 12:33 PM
 

SweetTooth
I'm a tired mommy!

Member since 12/05

20105 total posts

Name:
Lauren

Re: Teaching "NO"

I think the word needs to be used sparingly. Instead when they are doing something wrong, I remove them from the situation.
This is in no way an expert opinion, lol. This is what I am doing with my 9.5 month olds. I don't think they can understand "no" at the age.
I can tell you they definitely know when I am upset with them because they turn and give me a look when I use that tone of voice.

Posted 10/15/09 12:33 PM
 

Hofstra26
Love to Bake!

Member since 7/06

27915 total posts

Name:

Re: Teaching "NO"

Posted by MrsFlatbread

Frankie does the same thing...I tell him "no" he stops what it is he is doing, looks at me with this devilish grin and smile...then proceeds to do what he wanted to do in the first place. I think he is starting to get the concept a little bit...but he is surely testing me!!



I don't think he gets the concept, I think he just enjoys your reaction which is why he looks at you and smiles and then continues on. He figures if he goes back and does it again you will again react and acknowledge him. They are too young to understand if what they are doing is right and wrong. They don't grasp that concept until they are older.........right now it's all cause and effect. They do something "wrong", you say no, and yay!!........they just got more attention from you. Chat Icon

Posted 10/15/09 12:35 PM
 

Pooka
Oh Happy Day!!

Member since 11/06

5689 total posts

Name:

Re: Teaching "NO"

We try to use the word "NO" when he tries to touch something dangerous (light socket, if something is going to fall over, etc). Instead, we say "don't do that" or "don't touch that" and we remove him from the situation. I don't know is that is what you are "supposed" to do, but it's what we do.

Posted 10/15/09 12:37 PM
 

FreeButterfly
hum...

Member since 5/05

6263 total posts

Name:

Re: Teaching "NO"

Maybe its time to start time-outs --- modified.

We started w/ DS when he was about 11-12 months.

We gave him 1-2 warnings depending on what it was and how many times he got in trouble for it and then he went into time out.
We picked him up and told him "NO, NOW YOU GET TIME OUT" We sat him in the corner for about 20-40 seconds. Then we told him what he did wrong and gave him a hug.

I'm sure he didn't fully understand but it started the process.


Or, make more use of your pack-n-playChat Icon

Posted 10/15/09 12:43 PM
 

SweetTooth
I'm a tired mommy!

Member since 12/05

20105 total posts

Name:
Lauren

Re: Teaching "NO"

Posted by nora101004

Maybe its time to start time-outs --- modified.

We started w/ DS when he was about 11-12 months.

We gave him 1-2 warnings depending on what it was and how many times he got in trouble for it and then he went into time out.
We picked him up and told him "NO, NOW YOU GET TIME OUT" We sat him in the corner for about 20-40 seconds. Then we told him what he did wrong and gave him a hug.

I'm sure he didn't fully understand but it started the process.


Or, make more use of your pack-n-playChat Icon



I don't think a 9 month old can understand a time out at all. I can't imagine putting my babies in a corner... and at that age what are they really doing wrong to deserve a time out?
Shouldn't time outs be reserved for bad behavior - like hitting? Not for exploring and learning - which is what the OP's DC is doing.

Posted 10/15/09 12:49 PM
 

JennZ
MY LIFE!!

Member since 8/05

25463 total posts

Name:

Re: Teaching "NO"

I am using NO when and really only when he is/could hurt himself. He has no fear. He is stong, he will pull himspef up on the TV stand, and I will say NO and put him somewhere else in the living room. I say NO dont touch Mamas computer, cause he can get hurt. At this point it is a game to him. I have even (gasp) smacked his hand, when he crawls to the wires under DH desk. Because yes he can get hurt. I try to redirect him. He just smiles and goes anyway. Im going to try the time outs, I may have to staple him down the the floor Chat Icon , but I will give it a shot.

Posted 10/15/09 12:51 PM
 

Hofstra26
Love to Bake!

Member since 7/06

27915 total posts

Name:

Re: Teaching "NO"

Posted by SweetTooth

Posted by nora101004

Maybe its time to start time-outs --- modified.

We started w/ DS when he was about 11-12 months.

We gave him 1-2 warnings depending on what it was and how many times he got in trouble for it and then he went into time out.
We picked him up and told him "NO, NOW YOU GET TIME OUT" We sat him in the corner for about 20-40 seconds. Then we told him what he did wrong and gave him a hug.

I'm sure he didn't fully understand but it started the process.


Or, make more use of your pack-n-playChat Icon



I don't think a 9 month old can understand a time out at all. I can't imagine putting my babies in a corner... and at that age what are they really doing wrong to deserve a time out?
Shouldn't time outs be reserved for bad behavior - like hitting? Not for exploring and learning - which is what the OP's DC is doing.



ITA. I think time-outs should be reserved for when a child does something INTENTIONALLY bad (hitting, talking back, etc.) AND has an understanding of why they were put in the time out. My DD is 13 months old and she would have NO clue what was going on if I stuck her in a time out. She doesn't know right from wrong, she's not trying to be bad.........she's being 1. What does it mean to stick her in a time out? It's not the right "discipline" for a child this age.

Posted 10/15/09 1:04 PM
 

FreeButterfly
hum...

Member since 5/05

6263 total posts

Name:

Re: Teaching "NO"

There is a difference between 9 and 11/12 months - I know my DS knew that he was in trouble when we said time out and picked him up.

At least with my son, I think just redirecting him to a toy might have sent the wrong signal like it was a reward to play with the toy instead of punishment* for not listening.

ETA: We felt that if we started early with correcting the little things, it would be easier to correct the bigger things like hitting.

I'm not saying its right or its wrong, just that it is working for us.

Message edited 2009-10-15 13:07:51.337000.

Posted 10/15/09 1:05 PM
 

babyonthebrain
Brotherly Love!

Member since 1/08

6209 total posts

Name:
Rafaela

Re: Teaching "NO"

In the books I read, they say one of the words babies understand first is no.
Adriano def. knows what that means! The little stinker loves to take his hart off his head when we go outside, but when I say no, he stops dead in his tracks!!!! lol

Posted 10/15/09 1:09 PM
 

josie919
Here we go!

Member since 2/08

1108 total posts

Name:
Josie

Re: Teaching "NO"

Gianna went from laughing and smiling to Chat Icon around 10.5 months. Now she knows NO means NO! We try not to use it too much bc then it seems like kids ignore it.

I say 'Gianna, that isn't yours' and ' We don't touch that' more than NO, but sometimes she still looks at me like 'NO? must mean YES' lolChat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 10/15/09 2:51 PM
 

Alex110879
craziness

Member since 8/06

3762 total posts

Name:
Alexandria

Re: Teaching "NO"

to be honest, ds is 13 months old and he still laughs at it.. it is his way of getting attention... we started doing "modified" punishment... which i knows sounds hard... but basically the big issue we have is him climbing onto the tv cabinet.... we move him twice saying no (he laughs) and the third time, the tv goes off.... same with dropping the cup... after two drops it gets taken away... whether he grasps it i dont know...

Posted 10/15/09 2:59 PM
 

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: Teaching "NO"

OMG same here. I am trying to figure out if she knows what I mean and is ignoring me or still doesn't get the concept.

Posted 10/15/09 3:39 PM
 

DomesticDeeva
Tiebreaker on deck!!!

Member since 11/08

2088 total posts

Name:
Dee

Re: Teaching "NO"

If he's in danger or doing something he's not supposed to, I don't say no. I just say his name very firmly in THAT TONE...you know, the mother tone that used to scare the crap out of you when your mom did it to you Chat Icon

He stops dead in his tracks, looks at me with wide eyes, and stops. He's only 8.5 m/o. but it seems to be working.

Posted 10/15/09 3:40 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
After all my complaining about teaching posts... i thought i'd post a good one. VirginiaDeb 5/1/06 6 Families Helping Families ™
help! tomorrow I have an elem. teaching interview... pschica 2/23/06 7 Families Helping Families ™
How many moms/dads are teaching their baby a 2nd language? mommy2Alex 12/2/05 25 Parenting
lost power today for the whole afternoon- while I was in school teaching! ggt08 10/25/05 7 Families Helping Families ™
I cannot believe this...I got offered a teaching job! CaseyGirl 7/22/05 25 Families Helping Families ™
I finally got a teaching interview! I need advice. CaseyGirl 7/12/05 17 Families Helping Families ™