Talk to me about Ferberizing... *LONG*

Posted By Message

maybeamommy
Blessed beyond belief

Member since 10/07

17048 total posts

Name:

Talk to me about Ferberizing... *LONG*

Does it work?

How did you do it?

As most of you know... we are cosleeping. Would it be better to transition Loey to the crib NOW before we move, so that when we DO move and he's in his own room it will be less of a change? (meaning, same crib.. different place?) We definitely want him in his own crib in his own room when we are back in NY.

Also, what about the pacifier? Do I give it to him? Give him a lovey instead?

What about night feedings? He eats during the night also, but not sure if it's just a comfort thing or actual hunger.

How do you deal with crying during the night??

Did it break your heart to do this? Or was the end product worth it?

I know it's silly, but I'm scared Loey will think that Mommy isn't there for him and that his cries don't mean anything when that's his only way of communicating with me at times. I'm scared he'll think Mommy abandoned him Chat Icon

Also, how long did this take? I am off from today until Monday (end of school year until start of summer school) - do you think it could be done by the time I have to go back to work?

Posted 6/23/10 12:13 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Rycois
Blessed with 2blue/2pink

Member since 12/05

13341 total posts

Name:
J

Re: Talk to me about Ferberizing... *LONG*

Hayley, no one knows your baby like you do but I'm going to guess - he's NOT hungry. He is nursing out of comfort and honestly, it's an easy habit to break if you can hang in there for a solid few nights.

I would get him in his crib, give him both a lovey and a paci (leave a few in there too so he can find them when he wakes). Use a sound machine.

Try letting him cry for a little bit. I know some don't recommend going in at all, but I couldn't stay out for a long time. I would try to say go for 20-minutes. Listen to his cry. Is it a steady scream? Does he tapper off? Is it more of a whine than a scream? I found when I let Colin going it was on and off, to the point I thought he went back down, but then it started up again. It wasn't easy to listen to, but I knew he wasn't starving if it wasn't constant.

After the allotted amt of time, if you feel the need to go it, I would sneak in - give him back the lovey, paci and stand somewhere nearby (but out of sight) and shush him.

Good luck! I know, easier said than done. But so many people dread this and then once they stick with it they wonder why they didn't do it sooner. I really only put my foot down with this the night Colin turned 7-months. He started going from 8:30-5:30AM and then I'd go in and feed him. Then I stopped that session and he started going later. Last night he slept 8:15-7:50AM. THAT'S SLEEP! Chat Icon

With Ryan I did it earlier (he was 6 months when he started doing 8:30-7:30AM). He got it quicker and it only took like 2 nights of letting him go for like 20-minutes tops.

Chat Icon

Posted 6/23/10 12:27 PM
 

maybeamommy
Blessed beyond belief

Member since 10/07

17048 total posts

Name:

Re: Talk to me about Ferberizing... *LONG*

The crib is in our room.... does that make a difference??

Posted 6/23/10 12:31 PM
 

Rycois
Blessed with 2blue/2pink

Member since 12/05

13341 total posts

Name:
J

Re: Talk to me about Ferberizing... *LONG*

He he positioned so he can see you? What about a chinese screen or curtain? It may be a lot harder on you both to do this if you're in his direct view, KWIM?

Posted 6/23/10 12:32 PM
 

maybeamommy
Blessed beyond belief

Member since 10/07

17048 total posts

Name:

Re: Talk to me about Ferberizing... *LONG*

Thanks!

I think maybe ONE time he could be hungry, but not the other times - KWIM?

Do you have a good sound machine you recommend? We had one but it was CRAPPPP!

I definitely can't let him cry without going in! I've been doing a TEENSY bit of CIO with naps. I get him super drowsy in my arms, then put him into the swing. He cries/fusses a little but ends up falling asleep within usually 2 minutes... 10 at most.

Posted 6/23/10 12:34 PM
 

Rycois
Blessed with 2blue/2pink

Member since 12/05

13341 total posts

Name:
J

Re: Talk to me about Ferberizing... *LONG*

I have this one. Cheap and works great (and runs all night so it doesn't stop after 30-minutes like others):

Sound spa

I keep it on the rain setting.
Ryan was confused one morning when we went in to get Colin. He was like, "why do I hear rain in Colin's room Mommy?" Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 6/23/10 12:36 PM
 

Linda1003
love my 2 boys

Member since 8/08

10923 total posts

Name:
Linda

Re: Talk to me about Ferberizing... *LONG*

doesn't make a difference he has to get used to the crib so wheather in your room or not..def start before you move!!Chat Icon (can't wait )

I can't handle John crying but he sometimes only wakes up once a night at 7 months.. if Loey is waking multiple times at night.. I would feed him once during the night and let him CIO..Chat Icon the rest of the time!! JMO of course!!! My boy is hungry at night so it may take loey's stomach some time before he is ready to quit eating totally in the middle of the night.. JMO of course!!Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 6/23/10 12:37 PM
 

maybeamommy
Blessed beyond belief

Member since 10/07

17048 total posts

Name:

Re: Talk to me about Ferberizing... *LONG*

Posted by SweetCaroline

He he positioned so he can see you? What about a chinese screen or curtain? It may be a lot harder on you both to do this if you're in his direct view, KWIM?



don't mind his kooky face... this is the only pic i could find right now to show the setup..

External Image

Posted 6/23/10 12:39 PM
 

MrsDrMatt
Live and RUN like a Ninja!

Member since 5/06

3104 total posts

Name:
MrsDrMatt

Re: Talk to me about Ferberizing... *LONG*

Don't make too may changes at once. First I would get hime out of your bed. The pacifier and feeding thing can come second.

I did ferber for all 3 kids. But, I started at 2 minute intervals. It was easier for me to handle mentally

Posted 6/23/10 12:40 PM
 

mommyIam

Member since 7/09

9209 total posts

Name:
Shana

Re: Talk to me about Ferberizing... *LONG*

I'm sending you an FM, I took a very soft-core approach, no crying method. If your baby is ready for more serious you can adapt it.

I have to be honest, it stopped working this morning, but poor guy is teething really bad.
Chat Icon

edited to say I LIED ... I just updated an old post of mine where I was asking similar things, don't you love when people don't read questions and flame you anyway

http://www.lifamilies.com/chat/topic.aspx?&P=1&ID=546563

Message edited 2010-06-23 12:54:54.060000.

Posted 6/23/10 12:42 PM
 

Carolyn
.....

Member since 5/07

5351 total posts

Name:
Twin mommy

Re: Talk to me about Ferberizing... *LONG*

We Ferberized both boys. Each took two nights.

I went in after 3 minutes, put my hand on him, shusshed but no eye contact. Then waited 5 minutes and went back in, then every ten minutes. This was for middle of the night waking - we didn't have a problem with them going down. They were still waking 1-2 times a night to feed, but I knew they didn't need to eat.

We did Christian first, the first night he cried for an hour and 20 minutes, then slept till morning. Next night, 30 minutes. After that, STTN 7pm-5am. He is now going till 6:30am usually.

Nicholas was next, first night 40 minutes, next night I did the 3 minutes and 5 minutes and that was it. STTN now 7pm-5am.

I felt they were too little for true CIO, so Ferber was more comfortable for me. The first night was awful, but after that I knew I could do it. The way I got through it was knowing that once we started, if I gave in then all that crying would be for nothing, KWIM? Like I just let him cry for no reason. So that made sticking with it easier.

ITA with PP, transition to the crib first. But - IMO, Ferber won't work if he's in the crib and can see you right there in your bed.

ETS - this was the BEST thing I did as a parent. For my marriage, my sanity, and for the boys. Life is COMPLETELY different now that they sleep.

They don't use pacis - one never took it and the other self-weaned. They do have loveys.

Message edited 2010-06-23 12:53:58.823000.

Posted 6/23/10 12:50 PM
 

Diana1215
Living on a prayer!!!

Member since 10/05

29450 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: Talk to me about Ferberizing... *LONG*

I think you need to tackle one thing at a time.

First put him in his crib. If you don't want to wait till you move then there is no time like the present.

Second, I would still give him the pacifier.

Do you have a mobile for his crib? Both boys LOVE the Tiny Love Sympony in Motion mobile. You can't go wrong with any Tiny Love mobile.

Get a sound machine. They sell a cheap good one at BRU for 19.00

I don't believe he is eating bc he is hungry in the middle of the night. It is habit.

Tyler cried for TWO nights and has been sleeping 12 hours ever since. He knows I still love him. He knows you are not abandoning him. You are doing something that is best for the both of you in the long run! Chat Icon

I love Carolyns approach for you. I think it will work. I also agree that it will not work if his crib is in your room. Will he have his own room in NY?

I also looked at it as once I started I couldn't turn back. I would say "He just cried for 20 minutes, I can't go in there now because then it was all for nothing" -- that was how I got through it. I knew there was an end in sight.

Also, do you have a video monitor? I truly could never let either of my boys cry without one! I watch them the entire time. It sounds SO much worse than it really is. It is easier to see them and know that they are ok and not hurt.

Message edited 2010-06-23 13:06:55.493000.

Posted 6/23/10 1:04 PM
 

maybeamommy
Blessed beyond belief

Member since 10/07

17048 total posts

Name:

Re: Talk to me about Ferberizing... *LONG*

Posted by Diana1215

I think you need to tackle one thing at a time.

First put him in his crib. If you don't want to wait till you move then there is no time like the present.

Second, I would still give him the pacifier.

Do you have a mobile for his crib? Both boys LOVE the Tiny Love Sympony in Motion mobile. You can't go wrong with any Tiny Love mobile.

Get a sound machine. They sell a cheap good one at BRU for 19.00

I don't believe he is eating bc he is hungry in the middle of the night. It is habit.

Tyler cried for TWO nights and has been sleeping 12 hours ever since. He knows I still love him. He knows you are not abandoning him. You are doing something that is best for the both of you in the long run! Chat Icon

I love Carolyns approach for you. I think it will work. I also agree that it will not work if his crib is in your room. Will he have his own room in NY?

I also looked at it as once I started I couldn't turn back. I would say "He just cried for 20 minutes, I can't go in there now because then it was all for nothing" -- that was how I got through it. I knew there was an end in sight.

Also, do you have a video monitor? I truly could never let either of my boys cry without one! I watch them the entire time. It sounds SO much worse than it really is. It is easier to see them and know that they are ok and not hurt.




Yes, he'll have his own room in NY....

Can I ask why it won't work with us in the room??

We do have a Tiny Love mobile...

And no video monitor Chat Icon

Posted 6/23/10 1:16 PM
 

Linda1003
love my 2 boys

Member since 8/08

10923 total posts

Name:
Linda

Re: Talk to me about Ferberizing... *LONG*

If he can see you and you can see him with that little face crying!!!! OMG would never work for me.. but also for him ....if you're there he may be more inclined to keep crying.

Posted 6/23/10 1:24 PM
 

Diana1215
Living on a prayer!!!

Member since 10/05

29450 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: Talk to me about Ferberizing... *LONG*

Posted by maybeamommy

Posted by Diana1215

I think you need to tackle one thing at a time.

First put him in his crib. If you don't want to wait till you move then there is no time like the present.

Second, I would still give him the pacifier.

Do you have a mobile for his crib? Both boys LOVE the Tiny Love Sympony in Motion mobile. You can't go wrong with any Tiny Love mobile.

Get a sound machine. They sell a cheap good one at BRU for 19.00

I don't believe he is eating bc he is hungry in the middle of the night. It is habit.

Tyler cried for TWO nights and has been sleeping 12 hours ever since. He knows I still love him. He knows you are not abandoning him. You are doing something that is best for the both of you in the long run! Chat Icon

I love Carolyns approach for you. I think it will work. I also agree that it will not work if his crib is in your room. Will he have his own room in NY?

I also looked at it as once I started I couldn't turn back. I would say "He just cried for 20 minutes, I can't go in there now because then it was all for nothing" -- that was how I got through it. I knew there was an end in sight.

Also, do you have a video monitor? I truly could never let either of my boys cry without one! I watch them the entire time. It sounds SO much worse than it really is. It is easier to see them and know that they are ok and not hurt.




Yes, he'll have his own room in NY....

Can I ask why it won't work with us in the room??

We do have a Tiny Love mobile...

And no video monitor Chat Icon



We have slept in the same room with Jack on vacations, every time he cries and sees us laying there it is sooo much worse, and honestly, I am never strong enough to be right next to him and hear him cry.

Is it possible to get a video monitor? At 3 years later I still use one with Jack. It is the best money you will ever spend IMO!

Posted 6/23/10 1:24 PM
 

maybeamommy
Blessed beyond belief

Member since 10/07

17048 total posts

Name:

Re: Talk to me about Ferberizing... *LONG*

Yeah we could get a video monitor... I just didn't want to get one yet since it seemed silly because he's IN the room with us - KWIM? DH would never go for that!

What time would you try to put him down for bed??

And so being that he's in our room... would you NOT do it then? Wait until NY?

I guess we can move the crib back into the second bedroom when my BIL/nephew move out in July... should we wait until then? But then that is also our guest room for when anyone comes to visit... Chat Icon

Posted 6/23/10 1:27 PM
 

Diana1215
Living on a prayer!!!

Member since 10/05

29450 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: Talk to me about Ferberizing... *LONG*

Posted by maybeamommy

Yeah we could get a video monitor... I just didn't want to get one yet since it seemed silly because he's IN the room with us - KWIM? DH would never go for that!

What time would you try to put him down for bed??

And so being that he's in our room... would you NOT do it then? Wait until NY?

I guess we can move the crib back into the second bedroom when my BIL/nephew move out in July... should we wait until then? But then that is also our guest room for when anyone comes to visit... Chat Icon



I get not needing one when he is next to you, but it will be soooo helpful when he is in his own room.

It's a tough call, when are you moving back to NY?

Does he sleep in his crib at all? If not, then I would start putting him into his crib, even napping in it is a start. Maybe during the night when he is really sleepy put him back down in his crib. Try it a little at a time so that it's not this huge adjustment when you make the move.

I would put him in his own room once they move out. Don't worry about visitors. I would personally wait to Ferberize him when he's in your room. I don't really know how that would work (Unless you and DH slept on the couch for a few nights) Chat Icon

ETA:
What time does he go to bed now? I'll tell you Tyler's schedule.

He wakes around 5:30 gets a bottle. Goes down for a nap an hour later (around 6:30)

Wakes up around 7:30 - has breakfast.

Around 9:30/10 he gets another bottle and a nap. Wakes around 11

Gets lunch around 11:30/12. Bottle around 1 (1:30) then another nap.

Wakes around 3pm. Sometimes he gets a bottle if he's super cranky, otherwise dinner is at 4:30.

Last bottle at 6pm on the nose. Sleeping in his crib by 6:30 for the night. I do know that 6:30 is early for alot of babies, that is just the time his body always told me he was ready for bed (same thing with Jack!)

HTH! Chat Icon

Message edited 2010-06-23 13:35:31.767000.

Posted 6/23/10 1:32 PM
 

headoverheels
s'il vous plaît

Member since 6/07

42079 total posts

Name:
LB

Re: Talk to me about Ferberizing... *LONG*

Posted by SweetCaroline

Hayley, no one knows your baby like you do but I'm going to guess - he's NOT hungry. He is nursing out of comfort and honestly, it's an easy habit to break if you can hang in there for a solid few nights.

I would get him in his crib, give him both a lovey and a paci (leave a few in there too so he can find them when he wakes). Use a sound machine.

Try letting him cry for a little bit. I know some don't recommend going in at all, but I couldn't stay out for a long time. I would try to say go for 20-minutes. Listen to his cry. Is it a steady scream? Does he tapper off? Is it more of a whine than a scream? I found when I let Colin going it was on and off, to the point I thought he went back down, but then it started up again. It wasn't easy to listen to, but I knew he wasn't starving if it wasn't constant.

After the allotted amt of time, if you feel the need to go it, I would sneak in - give him back the lovey, paci and stand somewhere nearby (but out of sight) and shush him.



Hayley this is almost exactly what I was going to write! I did full CIO but I totally understand you not wanting to.

I think the inconsistency of his wake times is what tips me off that he's NOT doing it because he's hungry. He's using you to self-soothe, that's all.

DS was 5 months when I did full CIO, it worked amazingly well, and we never had to do it again. Chat Icon

Posted 6/23/10 1:52 PM
 

Rycois
Blessed with 2blue/2pink

Member since 12/05

13341 total posts

Name:
J

Re: Talk to me about Ferberizing... *LONG*

Hayley, I do think you should to the crib first.

For 3-4 days just let him sleep in the crib. When he cries, try the paci and shushing to get him to go back to sleep - don't immediately feed him, but if you need to - feed him, then put him back in.

I think you'll get a clearer idea of how much he is really getting up if you're not co-sleeping. Right now, he might just be wiggling around and smell the milk on ya so he's game for a midnight snack. if he's not right next to you, that might not be the case.
Then, after he's familar with a few nights in the crib, I'd try the modified CIO/ferberizing.

JMO as a mom who co-slept/nursed. Good luck Chat Icon

Posted 6/23/10 3:46 PM
 

katiebug
I'll love you for always

Member since 2/08

4624 total posts

Name:
Katie

Re: Talk to me about Ferberizing... *LONG*

Everyone is giving you great advice. I just wanted to offer some Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon I know how tough this is for you.

Posted 6/23/10 4:15 PM
 

maybeamommy
Blessed beyond belief

Member since 10/07

17048 total posts

Name:

Re: Talk to me about Ferberizing... *LONG*

Posted by SweetCaroline

Hayley, I do think you should to the crib first.

For 3-4 days just let him sleep in the crib. When he cries, try the paci and shushing to get him to go back to sleep - don't immediately feed him, but if you need to - feed him, then put him back in.

I think you'll get a clearer idea of how much he is really getting up if you're not co-sleeping. Right now, he might just be wiggling around and smell the milk on ya so he's game for a midnight snack. if he's not right next to you, that might not be the case.
Then, after he's familar with a few nights in the crib, I'd try the modified CIO/ferberizing.

JMO as a mom who co-slept/nursed. Good luck Chat Icon



Thank you (and EVERYONE!) for all of this advice.

So, how do I start with just letting him sleep in the crib?

Now I can't start today... totally forgot we had an appointment today and he had his shots so I don't want to try tonight...

What's the best way to start this? THANK YOU SO MUCH! Chat Icon

Posted 6/23/10 11:08 PM
 

maybeamommy
Blessed beyond belief

Member since 10/07

17048 total posts

Name:

Re: Talk to me about Ferberizing... *LONG*

Diana - we're moving back at the end of July.

He doesn't sleep at all in the crib now. Anytime I try to put him in, he rolls over onto his belly and then pushes himself to sit up... then pulls up to stand on the crib. He never lays down in there!

Right now, he goes to sleep around 8:30 or 9.

Our day goes something like this:

eat- 5
sleep - 5:30-8:30
eat -8:30
nap 10:30-12
eat 12
nap - 2
eat 3:30
nap - sometimes right after he eats, other times not until 5:30 or 6.. it's wacky after that feeding!
eat again - 7
eat again right before bed 8:30ish

we're just starting solids now... so far just 1x/day and i've been doing it around 4:30

Posted 6/23/10 11:13 PM
 

maybeamommy
Blessed beyond belief

Member since 10/07

17048 total posts

Name:

Re: Talk to me about Ferberizing... *LONG*

bump for morning ladies

Posted 6/24/10 11:16 AM
 

Diana1215
Living on a prayer!!!

Member since 10/05

29450 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: Talk to me about Ferberizing... *LONG*

I'm bumping for you to get more opinions, but I also wanted to say that he will learn how to get down. Tyler is all over the crib. Crawling, cruising, rolling. He does this before he falls asleep. When he is really really exhausted he will just roll right over, but that only happens once a day. He will eventually go to sleep.

There were times that I had to go in there and lay Tyler down. He would cry for two minutes and either fall asleep, or get back up again. If I saw that he wasn't going back down I would go in again until he didn't get up anymore.

Posted 6/24/10 1:01 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
not really CIO .. but Ferberizing Question ... mommyIam 6/16/10 11 Parenting
Ok so I can't do ferberizing ...is this ok??? Purplegirl77 5/12/10 13 Parenting
Ferberizing right now and I can't take her crying.... Purplegirl77 5/10/10 8 Parenting
ANIMALS CAN'T TALK... reggie 7/3/05 0 Families Helping Families ™
Talk to me about North Carolina! MissJones 6/4/05 4 Home
Let's talk dental hygiene Cocoa 5/19/05 10 Families Helping Families ™