SWITCHING DOCTORS.....

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

MrsKS
Thank You St. Gerard.....

Member since 12/09

8306 total posts

Name:
Kerri

SWITCHING DOCTORS.....

Anyone ever do this??

I'm contemplating switching.
I was going to see Sadaty.. out of 3 appts so far I can't seem to get an appt with her. The dr I did get, mis-measured me (twice in one shot) and though he was nice.. he seemed IDK wimpy and awkward. And truthfully I hoped he wouldn't be the delivery doctor, even though I didn't necessarily NOT like him. The practice was super though.

I was a Dr B. patient and I miss him so much. He recommended Dr Goldstein.... who I normally would have flown to just because he was recommended by Dr B... BUT he is affiliated with LIJ. We wanted NSUH.

Now I'm really contemplating making a swap.. or AT LEAST trying out both offices to see which I like better.

I have an appt in 2 weeks with the old office.... I figure I'd keep that... BUT then should I just make an appt with Goldstein NOW or wait until after the appt in 2 weeks??

Also, would I need to tell the old office that I am switching doctors? I feel kind of bad about that... they were super nice. I liked all the girls.
I'm just wanting a different doctor I think... and since I can't ever seem to get Sadaty to try her out... perhaps I should go with Dr B's recommended guy???

WWYD???
Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Message edited 2010-12-14 21:16:48.363000.

Posted 12/14/10 9:11 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

dajc23
My Loves :)

Member since 1/09

4980 total posts

Name:
Dana

Re: SWITCHING DOCTORS.....

If you don't mind me asking which Dr you were seeing that mis measured you. you can FM me if you want.
I go to that practice and absolutely love love love them.

How come you cant see Sadaty?? They always just ask me which one I want to see so I say Rifkin or Sadaty and I've only gotten them

Posted 12/14/10 9:42 PM
 

MrsJakob
Naterade is Thirstade!

Member since 6/10

3002 total posts

Name:
Danielle

Re: SWITCHING DOCTORS.....

I've already stated my case to you! Chat Icon

Posted 12/14/10 9:57 PM
 

mnmsoinlove
Mommy to 2 sweet girls!

Member since 3/09

8585 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: SWITCHING DOCTORS.....

Crashing I switched drs at 16 weeks, best thing I did all pregnancy. Yes, you need to tell both offices because they need to send your charts over. I told the office I was leaving the truth, I explained I wanted a smaller practice where I wasn't seeing a new dr at each appt, I think they understood

Message edited 2010-12-14 22:09:50.227000.

Posted 12/14/10 10:03 PM
 

RothschildNY
LIF Infant

Member since 7/10

104 total posts

Name:
G

Re: SWITCHING DOCTORS.....

I am NOT preg, but I had an issue witha doctor before this.

Do what is right for you. NEVER feel bad for the doctor you are leaving. YOU have to feel comfortable and happy with a doctor that has your life and your LO's in his (her) hands.

My opinion is if you feel you want to switch there is a reason, and I would switch.

Good luck.

Posted 12/14/10 10:14 PM
 

PennyCat
Just call me mommy :)

Member since 7/08

19084 total posts

Name:
Jib

Re: SWITCHING DOCTORS.....

Posted by RothschildNY

I am NOT preg, but I had an issue witha doctor before this.

Do what is right for you. NEVER feel bad for the doctor you are leaving. YOU have to feel comfortable and happy with a doctor that has your life and your LO's in his (her) hands.

My opinion is if you feel you want to switch there is a reason, and I would switch.

Good luck.



I agree with this. Also, you're still early on in your pregnancy. I imagine it's much easier to switch NOW than it will bet later on!

I'm not so sure I will be going back to the person I used while pregnant ...... I had a feeling from the start, too.

Posted 12/14/10 10:17 PM
 

MrsKS
Thank You St. Gerard.....

Member since 12/09

8306 total posts

Name:
Kerri

Re: SWITCHING DOCTORS.....

Posted by PennyCat

Posted by RothschildNY

I am NOT preg, but I had an issue witha doctor before this.

Do what is right for you. NEVER feel bad for the doctor you are leaving. YOU have to feel comfortable and happy with a doctor that has your life and your LO's in his (her) hands.

My opinion is if you feel you want to switch there is a reason, and I would switch.

Good luck.



I agree with this. Also, you're still early on in your pregnancy. I imagine it's much easier to switch NOW than it will bet later on!

I'm not so sure I will be going back to the person I used while pregnant ...... I had a feeling from the start, too.



I didn't go back to the dr from the first pregnancy either. I didn't care for A LOT of things... from the things his office said to me... to the D&C and aftermath!!!

Posted 12/14/10 10:22 PM
 

MrsKS
Thank You St. Gerard.....

Member since 12/09

8306 total posts

Name:
Kerri

Re: SWITCHING DOCTORS.....

Posted by dajc23

If you don't mind me asking which Dr you were seeing that mis measured you. you can FM me if you want.
I go to that practice and absolutely love love love them.

How come you cant see Sadaty?? They always just ask me which one I want to see so I say Rifkin or Sadaty and I've only gotten them



I just FM'd you all the details!!

it's long!!!

Posted 12/14/10 10:25 PM
 

PennyCat
Just call me mommy :)

Member since 7/08

19084 total posts

Name:
Jib

Re: SWITCHING DOCTORS.....

Posted by MrsKS

Posted by PennyCat

Posted by RothschildNY

I am NOT preg, but I had an issue witha doctor before this.

Do what is right for you. NEVER feel bad for the doctor you are leaving. YOU have to feel comfortable and happy with a doctor that has your life and your LO's in his (her) hands.

My opinion is if you feel you want to switch there is a reason, and I would switch.

Good luck.



I agree with this. Also, you're still early on in your pregnancy. I imagine it's much easier to switch NOW than it will bet later on!

I'm not so sure I will be going back to the person I used while pregnant ...... I had a feeling from the start, too.



I didn't go back to the dr from the first pregnancy either. I didn't care for A LOT of things... from the things his office said to me... to the D&C and aftermath!!!



That's one of the primary reasons I don't want to go back to my previous office- Once I wasn't pregnant anymore it's like I was wiped off the face of the earth and no longer a patient. Personally, I was a little annoyed they never inquired or followed up, especially considered it was a late loss and complications my doctor had seen like three times in his career.

Oh, and when I called to cancel one of my appointments since I would no longer be needing it... I specifically told the person on the phone I was calling to cancel because I was losing the baby and wouldn't be pregnant at the time of the appointment. Her response? "Ok thanks hun take care!" Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 12/14/10 10:25 PM
 

MrsKS
Thank You St. Gerard.....

Member since 12/09

8306 total posts

Name:
Kerri

Re: SWITCHING DOCTORS.....

Posted by PennyCat

Posted by MrsKS

Posted by PennyCat

Posted by RothschildNY

I am NOT preg, but I had an issue witha doctor before this.

Do what is right for you. NEVER feel bad for the doctor you are leaving. YOU have to feel comfortable and happy with a doctor that has your life and your LO's in his (her) hands.

My opinion is if you feel you want to switch there is a reason, and I would switch.

Good luck.



I agree with this. Also, you're still early on in your pregnancy. I imagine it's much easier to switch NOW than it will bet later on!

I'm not so sure I will be going back to the person I used while pregnant ...... I had a feeling from the start, too.



I didn't go back to the dr from the first pregnancy either. I didn't care for A LOT of things... from the things his office said to me... to the D&C and aftermath!!!



That's one of the primary reasons I don't want to go back to my previous office- Once I wasn't pregnant anymore it's like I was wiped off the face of the earth and no longer a patient. Personally, I was a little annoyed they never inquired or followed up, especially considered it was a late loss and complications my doctor had seen like three times in his career.

Oh, and when I called to cancel one of my appointments since I would no longer be needing it... I specifically told the person on the phone I was calling to cancel because I was losing the baby and wouldn't be pregnant at the time of the appointment. Her response? "Ok thanks hun take care!" Chat Icon Chat Icon



She clearly wasn't listening.. and just saying her usual good bye comment. that's insensitive. I'm sorry.

The old dr's office first didn't want me to come in until 10 weeks.. not even the more normal 8 weeks. I faught for an appt at 9 weeks. they told me it's bc it's likely you could mc! Um... OK so NO dr if I could mc?? wouldn't i NEED a dr then??? Chat Icon Chat Icon Just an odd thing to say.. and put in my mind!!
THEN I get there and they say things like "we will see how things go this appt".... the 2nd appt I had which was the missed mc appt.. they said "if things work out this appt we will give you a blood test after the appt"... Chat Icon IF THINGS WORK OUT!! And they didn't... but still.. WHO says that and WHY?? it's insensitive and not only that but uncomfortable and scares the crap out of you. EVERY time i saw them those were the comments I was getting, even over the phone... like they EXPECTED me to mc; I felt this way before I did mc too... it's not even in retrospect.

They NEVER told me a SINGLE thing about being pregnant...as a first time pregnant person I was looking for information, what to eat what not to eat, what not to do, etc. NOTHING. I had to ask for a due date... which he had to LEAVE the room to get his chart...

Then after the D&C the doctor refused to really listen to the type of cramping I had... brushed it off. It was VERY odd and NOT at all normal. I still don't know what the heck happened to me or why I felt as I did for as long as I did. He NEVER EVER EVER gave me a blood test of any kind. They did genetic testing from the D&C and said they would call and NEVER did call... I called them (this wasn't too terrible... but added to everything else it just gets to the point of... can you do ANYTHING to please me AT ALL??).... The dr had to call me back.. it wasn't even my dr who called back it was a dr I never heard of.
Even when I had trisomy 21 as the reason... they never had me come in for genetic testing.. just told me to look into getting genetic testing done. Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Not let's make an appt for genetic testing, or I will send you a script. I didn't even know WHERE to get it done or that they could do it there.. etc.
Believe it or not, there's still more.. but that's enough ranting... haha!

Posted 12/14/10 10:39 PM
 

MrsKS
Thank You St. Gerard.....

Member since 12/09

8306 total posts

Name:
Kerri

Re: SWITCHING DOCTORS.....

Posted by RothschildNY

I am NOT preg, but I had an issue witha doctor before this.

Do what is right for you. NEVER feel bad for the doctor you are leaving. YOU have to feel comfortable and happy with a doctor that has your life and your LO's in his (her) hands.

My opinion is if you feel you want to switch there is a reason, and I would switch.

Good luck.



Thank you for this.

I just feel bad... like guilty.. or like i'm going to hurt someone's feelings. I know it's strange...

I really need to hear things like this...

Posted 12/14/10 10:46 PM
 

sal79
LIF Adult

Member since 8/06

1464 total posts

Name:

Re: SWITCHING DOCTORS.....

I see Dr Goldstein. Delivered 2 kids with him (well, ds was delivered by a different doc, he didn't make delivery). perfectly happy. you can FM me any questions.
why didnt you want LIJ? i mean, why did you prefer NSUH? DH, who is a doc, actually felt strongly about me delivering in LIJ, he thinks its a better hospital. may be more gritty, mroe dingy, sure.

Posted 12/14/10 11:08 PM
 

MrsKS
Thank You St. Gerard.....

Member since 12/09

8306 total posts

Name:
Kerri

Re: SWITCHING DOCTORS.....

Posted by sal79

I see Dr Goldstein. Delivered 2 kids with him (well, ds was delivered by a different doc, he didn't make delivery). perfectly happy. you can FM me any questions.
why didnt you want LIJ? i mean, why did you prefer NSUH? DH, who is a doc, actually felt strongly about me delivering in LIJ, he thinks its a better hospital. may be more gritty, mroe dingy, sure.



Really it's my DH that wanted NSUH... he has family that worked and works there and bc of the affiliation he just preferred that hospital. but he now says he can deal with either one.

I personally have never stepped foot in either one... but you just gave me a poll idea...

Posted 12/14/10 11:17 PM
 

sal79
LIF Adult

Member since 8/06

1464 total posts

Name:

Re: SWITCHING DOCTORS.....

Posted by MrsKS

Posted by sal79

I see Dr Goldstein. Delivered 2 kids with him (well, ds was delivered by a different doc, he didn't make delivery). perfectly happy. you can FM me any questions.
why didnt you want LIJ? i mean, why did you prefer NSUH? DH, who is a doc, actually felt strongly about me delivering in LIJ, he thinks its a better hospital. may be more gritty, mroe dingy, sure.



Really it's my DH that wanted NSUH... he has family that worked and works there and bc of the affiliation he just preferred that hospital. but he now says he can deal with either one.

I personally have never stepped foot in either one... but you just gave me a poll idea...



not to be too personal, but doing what? unless they are goign to be there at delivery, why woudl this matter?

Posted 12/14/10 11:21 PM
 

MrsKS
Thank You St. Gerard.....

Member since 12/09

8306 total posts

Name:
Kerri

Re: SWITCHING DOCTORS.....

Posted by sal79

Posted by MrsKS

Posted by sal79

I see Dr Goldstein. Delivered 2 kids with him (well, ds was delivered by a different doc, he didn't make delivery). perfectly happy. you can FM me any questions.
why didnt you want LIJ? i mean, why did you prefer NSUH? DH, who is a doc, actually felt strongly about me delivering in LIJ, he thinks its a better hospital. may be more gritty, mroe dingy, sure.



Really it's my DH that wanted NSUH... he has family that worked and works there and bc of the affiliation he just preferred that hospital. but he now says he can deal with either one.

I personally have never stepped foot in either one... but you just gave me a poll idea...



not to be too personal, but doing what? unless they are goign to be there at delivery, why woudl this matter?



surgeon, nurse, i also have a labor and delivery nurse friend there.

Also, SIL also had a VERY traumatic delivery and the baby was having seizures and she was about 97% brain dead (cerebral palsy due to a blood clot in the placenta)... because the doctor's all knew his surgeon BIL they did actually do a few favor's and got results to tests sooner, etc. Just from that experience alone, it can really build up your comfort level and trust in the hospital. I know it might sound silly to some, but going through something traumatic like that and having a nice amt of the staff knowing a family member in a hospital does help some.

Posted 12/14/10 11:27 PM
 

sal79
LIF Adult

Member since 8/06

1464 total posts

Name:

Re: SWITCHING DOCTORS.....

Posted by MrsKS

Posted by sal79

Posted by MrsKS

Posted by sal79

I see Dr Goldstein. Delivered 2 kids with him (well, ds was delivered by a different doc, he didn't make delivery). perfectly happy. you can FM me any questions.
why didnt you want LIJ? i mean, why did you prefer NSUH? DH, who is a doc, actually felt strongly about me delivering in LIJ, he thinks its a better hospital. may be more gritty, mroe dingy, sure.



Really it's my DH that wanted NSUH... he has family that worked and works there and bc of the affiliation he just preferred that hospital. but he now says he can deal with either one.

I personally have never stepped foot in either one... but you just gave me a poll idea...



not to be too personal, but doing what? unless they are goign to be there at delivery, why woudl this matter?



surgeon, nurse, i also have a labor and delivery nurse friend there.

Also, SIL also had a VERY traumatic delivery and the baby was having seizures and she was about 97% brain dead (cerebral palsy due to a blood clot in the placenta)... because the doctor's all knew his surgeon BIL they did actually do a few favor's and got results to tests sooner, etc. Just from that experience alone, it can really build up your comfort level and trust in the hospital. I know it might sound silly to some, but going through something traumatic like that and having a nice amt of the staff knowing a family member in a hospital does help some.



nope, not silly at all. i just thought you meant in terms of getting a free private room or something. for me, dh knwos people in btoh hospitals, and he felt strongly. they are both good hospitals. i woudl tell you to make an appointment wiht dr goldstein, see, and go form there

Posted 12/14/10 11:30 PM
 

MrsKS
Thank You St. Gerard.....

Member since 12/09

8306 total posts

Name:
Kerri

Re: SWITCHING DOCTORS.....

Posted by sal79

Posted by MrsKS

Posted by sal79

Posted by MrsKS

Posted by sal79

I see Dr Goldstein. Delivered 2 kids with him (well, ds was delivered by a different doc, he didn't make delivery). perfectly happy. you can FM me any questions.
why didnt you want LIJ? i mean, why did you prefer NSUH? DH, who is a doc, actually felt strongly about me delivering in LIJ, he thinks its a better hospital. may be more gritty, mroe dingy, sure.



Really it's my DH that wanted NSUH... he has family that worked and works there and bc of the affiliation he just preferred that hospital. but he now says he can deal with either one.

I personally have never stepped foot in either one... but you just gave me a poll idea...



not to be too personal, but doing what? unless they are goign to be there at delivery, why woudl this matter?



surgeon, nurse, i also have a labor and delivery nurse friend there.

Also, SIL also had a VERY traumatic delivery and the baby was having seizures and she was about 97% brain dead (cerebral palsy due to a blood clot in the placenta)... because the doctor's all knew his surgeon BIL they did actually do a few favor's and got results to tests sooner, etc. Just from that experience alone, it can really build up your comfort level and trust in the hospital. I know it might sound silly to some, but going through something traumatic like that and having a nice amt of the staff knowing a family member in a hospital does help some.



nope, not silly at all. i just thought you meant in terms of getting a free private room or something. for me, dh knwos people in btoh hospitals, and he felt strongly. they are both good hospitals. i woudl tell you to make an appointment wiht dr goldstein, see, and go form there



Oh no..... to be perfectly honest... that thought didn't even cross my mind in the least bit. it was all about the comfort level of knowing the hospital and some staff. we figured we would either share or pay for a single room. I would feel really uncomfortable asking for any sort of favors or rule bending like that. I can't even bargain in china town! haha!!!

Posted 12/14/10 11:32 PM
 

Marbo
LOVE

Member since 7/08

2374 total posts

Name:

Re: SWITCHING DOCTORS.....

Is Goldstein a single practitioner or a group? Just b/c if it is a group there is no guarantee he will deliver you either.

I went to the group you are going to. Not sure which of the doc's were the one that mismeasured you. You will eventually see all of them b/c they want you to meet all of them b/c any of them can deliver you. In fact I primarily saw Dr. Kaufman...then met with the others towards the end of my pregnancy and it ended up that Rifkin was on call when i went into labor, but had to leave when I was around 7cm and then Sadaty was there for when I actually delivered. For me I liked all of them. If you are really worried about the sono...you won't have any more like the first internal. The rest are done there by a tech and another doctor and the machine is much more advanced.

I wouldn't go just based fully on just one visit there...but if you are really uncomfortable with your experience then you have to decide what is best.

ETA: I actually switched to this office at 8 wks. It was a little easier at that point b/c I didn't have too much done at the previous md. You can call dr. goldsteins and see their availability and what they need from the other office. I also felt bad when I was switching, but they didn't even ask me why I was switching-so I worried for nothing!

Message edited 2010-12-15 09:25:04.340000.

Posted 12/15/10 9:04 AM
 

bride07
Ava Rose you are an angel!!!

Member since 3/09

6115 total posts

Name:

Re: SWITCHING DOCTORS.....



If you are not happy it's def not too late to switch. You want to feel comfortable with the physician you choose.


My close friend sees Dr Sadaty and loved her though. SHe just made sure to schedule majority of appts with her.

Posted 12/15/10 9:14 AM
 

WishingforBaby
LIF Adult

Member since 10/09

1110 total posts

Name:

Re: SWITCHING DOCTORS.....

I switched doctors at 12 weeks and couldn't be happier. I was unhappy with my old office all along, it was annoying to get to, their hours sucked and everyone there was very rude. I switched doctors and it's been amazing the two times I've been there.

Although I was nervous about switching, it was the best decision I made. Go for it!

Posted 12/15/10 9:19 AM
 

Barbiegrl
So in love with my little man!

Member since 8/09

2618 total posts

Name:
Barbara

Re: SWITCHING DOCTORS.....

Posted by RothschildNY

I am NOT preg, but I had an issue witha doctor before this.

Do what is right for you. NEVER feel bad for the doctor you are leaving. YOU have to feel comfortable and happy with a doctor that has your life and your LO's in his (her) hands.

My opinion is if you feel you want to switch there is a reason, and I would switch.

Good luck.



ITA!!!! I just switched at 35weeks. You just need to get your medical records and give them to the new Dr.
You want to be 100% confident in your Dr.
GLChat Icon

Posted 12/15/10 9:58 AM
 

SweetTooth
I'm a tired mommy!

Member since 12/05

20105 total posts

Name:
Lauren

Re: SWITCHING DOCTORS.....

I switched at 13 weeks. My new dr. took care of everything - getting my records, etc.
I felt guilty at first too but then realized I was doing what was best for me and my old doctor probably didn't care at all.

Posted 12/15/10 10:41 AM
 

BaseballWidow
*****

Member since 8/08

6657 total posts

Name:

Re: SWITCHING DOCTORS.....

I switched after my initial/8 week appt. Could not be happier! And I was very honest with the practice as to why I left and had my records sent directly yo me and I got them to the new doc. GL!

Posted 12/15/10 11:39 AM
 

pickles16
Real Estate Professional

Member since 11/07

17227 total posts

Name:
Jen

Re: SWITCHING DOCTORS.....

I just switched to this practice...while I loooove my old dr I didn't like his staff...whenever I ask for Sadaty I normally get her, I know with the holidays they've all been in and out and different hours....
What happened??? FM me...but I would recommend my old dr, I just really was annoyed by his staff during my MC!

Posted 12/15/10 11:42 AM
 

MrsKS
Thank You St. Gerard.....

Member since 12/09

8306 total posts

Name:
Kerri

Re: SWITCHING DOCTORS.....

Posted by Marbo

Is Goldstein a single practitioner or a group? Just b/c if it is a group there is no guarantee he will deliver you either.

I went to the group you are going to. Not sure which of the doc's were the one that mismeasured you. You will eventually see all of them b/c they want you to meet all of them b/c any of them can deliver you. In fact I primarily saw Dr. Kaufman...then met with the others towards the end of my pregnancy and it ended up that Rifkin was on call when i went into labor, but had to leave when I was around 7cm and then Sadaty was there for when I actually delivered. For me I liked all of them. If you are really worried about the sono...you won't have any more like the first internal. The rest are done there by a tech and another doctor and the machine is much more advanced.

I wouldn't go just based fully on just one visit there...but if you are really uncomfortable with your experience then you have to decide what is best.

ETA: I actually switched to this office at 8 wks. It was a little easier at that point b/c I didn't have too much done at the previous md. You can call dr. goldsteins and see their availability and what they need from the other office. I also felt bad when I was switching, but they didn't even ask me why I was switching-so I worried for nothing!



Yes he is a single practitioner for delivery. Apparently there are 3 doctor's in his office, but ONLY he does deliveries so he would def be delivering.

I'm not 100% sure what to do. I'm going to see how this next appt goes.

Part of what's learing me towards Goldstein is that he was recommended by Dr B and someone told me they are similar and I miss Dr B. Also, the other issues are what initially pushed me to start contemplating switching.

Maybe the pregnancy hormones are making me insane!!

Posted 12/15/10 4:54 PM
 
Pages: [1] 2
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Need Advice on Switching Doctors and Timing...Kinda Long Tine73 7/28/09 19 Infertility
Switching Doctors.... PeasandCarrots 6/7/09 6 Pregnancy
switching doctors summerBaby10 4/7/09 4 TTC
WWYD? Switching Doctors Question (with Poll) Waste06 2/20/09 13 Pregnancy
Switching doctors.... Dragonfly75 7/27/06 1 Pregnancy
what would you do? Considering switching doctors Shelly 2/21/06 14 Pregnancy