Swimming lessons and separation issues

Posted By Message

allIwant
Love my crazy life!

Member since 1/10

9170 total posts

Name:

Swimming lessons and separation issues

I took my twins for their first swimming lesson today.
I expected them to cry a little as they do not go to daycare or school.
But it broke my heart to watch them cry and yell for me for the entire session. I know this is good for them not only because we have a pool but also to help with the separation anxiety but its hard to watch especially when your spending a good amount of $$

If your kid cried how many sessions did it last?

Eta: they are not afraid of the water. We have a pool and they will jump in and go under no problem. They actually have no fear which is the issue

Message edited 2013-05-28 14:25:55.670000.

Posted 5/28/13 1:38 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Jenn1621
<3

Member since 5/05

1728 total posts

Name:

Swimming lessons and separation issues

I haven't brought my dd yet, but my niece was around 2 when she started. She cried for about 3 or 4 sessions but each lesson she cried less and less. She went for a year and cried when they stopped taking her bc she loved it so much.

Posted 5/28/13 1:56 PM
 

mnmsoinlove
Mommy to 2 sweet girls!

Member since 3/09

8585 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Swimming lessons and separation issues

My dd was horrible. She cried hysterical. After 4 sessions we pulled her. She cried the entire time. As soon as i pulled in the parking lot she would started begging me to take her home. Dh and I felt like she wasn't getting anything out of it. We felt like it was causing her to fear the water. I couldn't take watching her cry anymore. We started mommy and me swimming at YMCA and she was fine. Now that she is really use to the pool, instructors and she is older we want to retry her on a class.

Posted 5/28/13 2:20 PM
 

allIwant
Love my crazy life!

Member since 1/10

9170 total posts

Name:

Re: Swimming lessons and separation issues

Posted by Jenn1621

I haven't brought my dd yet, but my niece was around 2 when she started. She cried for about 3 or 4 sessions but each lesson she cried less and less. She went for a year and cried when they stopped taking her bc she loved it so much.

I hope this is the case for us too!

Posted 5/28/13 10:40 PM
 

lynnd126
LIF Adult

Member since 3/11

2630 total posts

Name:

Swimming lessons and separation issues

I'm sorry but I think the crying and separation stuff at swimming is ridiculous. I pulled my 22 month old son after a few sessions. It just didn't make sense to me. Separating him from his mom and putting him into this giant pool to just freak out- not for me. He did great just a few months later in a 2 year old nursery program and he loves playing in the pool. In another year or two he'll learn to swim.

Posted 5/28/13 10:57 PM
 

allIwant
Love my crazy life!

Member since 1/10

9170 total posts

Name:

Re: Swimming lessons and separation issues

Posted by lynnd126

I'm sorry but I think the crying and separation stuff at swimming is ridiculous. I pulled my 22 month old son after a few sessions. It just didn't make sense to me. Separating him from his mom and putting him into this giant pool to just freak out- not for me. He did great just a few months later in a 2 year old nursery program and he loves playing in the pool. In another year or two he'll learn to swim.

do you have a pool?

Posted 5/28/13 11:23 PM
 

Kelly9904
Mommy to 2 amazing little boys

Member since 5/05

9306 total posts

Name:
Kelly

Swimming lessons and separation issues

D's has taken three lessons. One was a trial a few months ago. He did OK at that point cried hard for five mins then on and off the whole class. A few weeks ago he started his normal session. Screamed bloody murder 50% of the time and cried the other 50%. Then we skipped a week BC he was sick then last week we went and he only cried for two mins. He wasn't smiling and laughing but he wasn't crying either. He just turned 2 last month

Give it at least 3-4 classes. It they are still so upset then put the lessons on hold for a little bit.

Posted 5/29/13 8:27 AM
 

Traysee
LIF Adolescent

Member since 12/10

652 total posts

Name:

Swimming lessons and separation issues

What about having an instructor come to the house instead?

Posted 5/29/13 8:35 AM
 

MrsDamonSalv7319
Somewhere in Westeros

Member since 10/10

4495 total posts

Name:

Re: Swimming lessons and separation issues

Posted by lynnd126

I'm sorry but I think the crying and separation stuff at swimming is ridiculous. I pulled my 22 month old son after a few sessions. It just didn't make sense to me. Separating him from his mom and putting him into this giant pool to just freak out- not for me. He did great just a few months later in a 2 year old nursery program and he loves playing in the pool. In another year or two he'll learn to swim.



This was my reason for holding off on swimming all together. I spoke w/someone at the swimming place on the phone about separation anxiety, and didn't really like her non-chalant response that they're used it it and DD will get over it. I wasn't going to spend that much money to watch DD scream and NOT learn to swim.

DD is 23 months and not overly attached to me, but she gets clingy around strangers...she's also stubborn and I know she would not give in to the swim instructors attempts to win her over. We don't have a pool, but I plan to teach her some basics in my parents pool, and give her formal lessons when she's older.

ETA my cousins kids hated swimming...they have a pool and had an instructor come to the house and it worked out well.

Message edited 2013-05-29 10:46:19.277000.

Posted 5/29/13 10:44 AM
 

ItsaJoya19
my cup runneth over

Member since 1/10

2949 total posts

Name:
E

Re: Swimming lessons and separation issues

I started DD in 1:1 lessons at 15 months and suffered through the first 2 classes watching her cry hysterically. It broke my heart watching that and I'd be counting down the minutes for it to end. After the second class, I pulled her and signed us up for the mommy & me class. We didn't renew after that ended.

Posted 5/29/13 11:22 AM
 

dpli
Daylight savings :)

Member since 5/05

13973 total posts

Name:
D

Re: Swimming lessons and separation issues

We've been going to SafeTSwim for about 2.5 years. My DS was older when he started, so he did not have issues. When I sit and watch his lesson, though, I have seen lots of kids cry when they start. I would say most kids acclimate by the 3rd or 4th lesson. Typically, they cry a lot the first lesson and it lessens each week. I will also tell you that the kids who acclimate better are the ones whose parents don't keep going into the pool to talk to them or try to calm them down. If you have a hard time with it, try leaving them the whole time, but go in a little earlier to get them out of the pool.

I think if I were you, I would try to stick it out a little longer, especially since you have a pool.

Posted 5/29/13 12:04 PM
 

CarlieJLD7
I love my daughter!

Member since 7/07

3061 total posts

Name:
Carlie

Re: Swimming lessons and separation issues

We had Carlie in the Mommy and me sessions, we loved the teacher. Signed up with him for individual lessons... she cried for 4-5 weeks straight! I couldn't believe it... but it was just the separation... it wasn't the fear of the pool or anything, just not me being there.

To me, I think its crazy when parents keep going inside to comfort the child, or even pulls them from the program b/c they are crying... in my book Swimming is SOOOO IMPORTANT TO LEARN... If I had to drop all the other activities she had... Dance, Gymnastics, MMA... to just keep her in swimming I would. Swimming is something you don't mess around with, there are way to many drownings out there.

I would stick too it, they will surprise you, Carlie is 3 and swims half the length of the pool by herself now... I would never let her go into a pool by herself... but she is much more confident and capable of handling herself (turning onto her back etc) and knows how to get out if she needed to god forbid anything happened.

Posted 5/29/13 12:54 PM
 

allIwant
Love my crazy life!

Member since 1/10

9170 total posts

Name:

Re: Swimming lessons and separation issues

Posted by CarlieJLD7

We had Carlie in the Mommy and me sessions, we loved the teacher. Signed up with him for individual lessons... she cried for 4-5 weeks straight! I couldn't believe it... but it was just the separation... it wasn't the fear of the pool or anything, just not me being there.

To me, I think its crazy when parents keep going inside to comfort the child, or even pulls them from the program b/c they are crying... in my book Swimming is SOOOO IMPORTANT TO LEARN... If I had to drop all the other activities she had... Dance, Gymnastics, MMA... to just keep her in swimming I would. Swimming is something you don't mess around with, there are way to many drownings out there.

I would stick too it, they will surprise you, Carlie is 3 and swims half the length of the pool by herself now... I would never let her go into a pool by herself... but she is much more confident and capable of handling herself (turning onto her back etc) and knows how to get out if she needed to god forbid anything happened.


Thank you! These are my thoughts exactly!
It sounds like the norm is 3-4 sessions.
I only purchased 6 weeks and I am hoping to know if they like it by the 6 weeks so I know if I should continue, try another instructor or do lessons at home.
I didn't go into the pool at all. I know that would make it 10 x worse. Hoping next week is better.
My DD cried for me the entire time while doing it but when she got out of the pool said....."mommy I had fun in the pool with kelsey" Chat Icon

Posted 5/29/13 1:07 PM
 

mrsboss
my little love

Member since 12/09

5054 total posts

Name:
Me

Swimming lessons and separation issues

We started DD with survival swim at 15 mos. she went mon-fri for 15 min daily lessons for 10 weeks. She cried ALOT, and still cried some days even at the end. I think the crying had to do with the time of day we went (6pm) and she was getting cranky too. But, it was in invaluable and can swim and get to the side of the pool if she ever fell in. It was worth the crying to me.

Posted 5/29/13 1:10 PM
 

Xelindrya
Mommy's little YouTube Star!

Member since 8/05

14470 total posts

Name:
Veronica

Swimming lessons and separation issues

Is it sad that this is why I am going to let my DAD take her. So he will be the one she 'leans on' so they can build that relationship and also so she can learn to play in that water she loves sooooooo tooooo much?

but she needs to learn. She has no fear of water at all unless it gets in her nose.

Posted 5/29/13 3:19 PM
 

lynnd126
LIF Adult

Member since 3/11

2630 total posts

Name:

Re: Swimming lessons and separation issues

Posted by allIwant

Posted by lynnd126

I'm sorry but I think the crying and separation stuff at swimming is ridiculous. I pulled my 22 month old son after a few sessions. It just didn't make sense to me. Separating him from his mom and putting him into this giant pool to just freak out- not for me. He did great just a few months later in a 2 year old nursery program and he loves playing in the pool. In another year or two he'll learn to swim.

do you have a pool?



If I did have a pool and was extra concerned about teaching my ds to swim bc of it, I STILL wouldn't send them to swimming lessons where they get separated and scream/ cry their eyes out. I would do a class where I'm involved, in the room, or have an instructor come to the house. I don't understand for the life of me why swimming instructions have to be this crazy separation thing.

Message edited 2013-05-29 16:52:43.800000.

Posted 5/29/13 4:51 PM
 

lynnd126
LIF Adult

Member since 3/11

2630 total posts

Name:

Re: Swimming lessons and separation issues

sry dbl

Message edited 2013-05-29 16:53:48.193000.

Posted 5/29/13 4:51 PM
 

CarlieJLD7
I love my daughter!

Member since 7/07

3061 total posts

Name:
Carlie

Re: Swimming lessons and separation issues

Posted by allIwant

Posted by CarlieJLD7

We had Carlie in the Mommy and me sessions, we loved the teacher. Signed up with him for individual lessons... she cried for 4-5 weeks straight! I couldn't believe it... but it was just the separation... it wasn't the fear of the pool or anything, just not me being there.

To me, I think its crazy when parents keep going inside to comfort the child, or even pulls them from the program b/c they are crying... in my book Swimming is SOOOO IMPORTANT TO LEARN... If I had to drop all the other activities she had... Dance, Gymnastics, MMA... to just keep her in swimming I would. Swimming is something you don't mess around with, there are way to many drownings out there.

I would stick too it, they will surprise you, Carlie is 3 and swims half the length of the pool by herself now... I would never let her go into a pool by herself... but she is much more confident and capable of handling herself (turning onto her back etc) and knows how to get out if she needed to god forbid anything happened.


Thank you! These are my thoughts exactly!
It sounds like the norm is 3-4 sessions.
I only purchased 6 weeks and I am hoping to know if they like it by the 6 weeks so I know if I should continue, try another instructor or do lessons at home.
I didn't go into the pool at all. I know that would make it 10 x worse. Hoping next week is better.
My DD cried for me the entire time while doing it but when she got out of the pool said....."mommy I had fun in the pool with kelsey" Chat Icon




YESSS this is what happened exactly! SHE LOVED MOMMY AND ME... and She cried and cried and cried like I said for the 4 or so sessions... You know what, I did have my husband bring her in on the 5th session, maybe you can try that? If he can take off or something, or bring a grandparent? Then have them walk them in... Ya know... it might work? Or sometimes it is just the dynamic with the instructor maybe they feel more comfy with a male or female or opposite.

I would def stick too it! Good Luck! Keep us posted!

Posted 5/29/13 6:04 PM
 

allIwant
Love my crazy life!

Member since 1/10

9170 total posts

Name:

Re: Swimming lessons and separation issues

Posted by lynnd126

Posted by allIwant

Posted by lynnd126

I'm sorry but I think the crying and separation stuff at swimming is ridiculous. I pulled my 22 month old son after a few sessions. It just didn't make sense to me. Separating him from his mom and putting him into this giant pool to just freak out- not for me. He did great just a few months later in a 2 year old nursery program and he loves playing in the pool. In another year or two he'll learn to swim.

do you have a pool?



If I did have a pool and was extra concerned about teaching my ds to swim bc of it, I STILL wouldn't send them to swimming lessons where they get separated and scream/ cry their eyes out. I would do a class where I'm involved, in the room, or have an instructor come to the house. I don't understand for the life of me why swimming instructions have to be this crazy separation thing.

i understand what your saying. I am a believer in having my kids be able to separate from me. Since money is tight I cant put them in a lot of programs. I chose swimming because I felt that at least they would be learning something valuable. Of course if they continue to scream after 4 sessions I wouldn't continue, that is partly why I asked the question. To see how it went for others. I am pretty sure dd would cry if I had her take any class she is way too attached to me and IMO it is inhibiting her socially. Hopefully they are better in the next session or 2 and I won't have to pull them.
Eta: sorry for the typos!!

Message edited 2013-05-29 21:15:45.163000.

Posted 5/29/13 9:14 PM
 

allIwant
Love my crazy life!

Member since 1/10

9170 total posts

Name:

Re: Swimming lessons and separation issues

Posted by CarlieJLD7

Posted by allIwant

Posted by CarlieJLD7

We had Carlie in the Mommy and me sessions, we loved the teacher. Signed up with him for individual lessons... she cried for 4-5 weeks straight! I couldn't believe it... but it was just the separation... it wasn't the fear of the pool or anything, just not me being there.

To me, I think its crazy when parents keep going inside to comfort the child, or even pulls them from the program b/c they are crying... in my book Swimming is SOOOO IMPORTANT TO LEARN... If I had to drop all the other activities she had... Dance, Gymnastics, MMA... to just keep her in swimming I would. Swimming is something you don't mess around with, there are way to many drownings out there.

I would stick too it, they will surprise you, Carlie is 3 and swims half the length of the pool by herself now... I would never let her go into a pool by herself... but she is much more confident and capable of handling herself (turning onto her back etc) and knows how to get out if she needed to god forbid anything happened.


Thank you! These are my thoughts exactly!
It sounds like the norm is 3-4 sessions.
I only purchased 6 weeks and I am hoping to know if they like it by the 6 weeks so I know if I should continue, try another instructor or do lessons at home.
I didn't go into the pool at all. I know that would make it 10 x worse. Hoping next week is better.
My DD cried for me the entire time while doing it but when she got out of the pool said....."mommy I had fun in the pool with kelsey" Chat Icon




YESSS this is what happened exactly! SHE LOVED MOMMY AND ME... and She cried and cried and cried like I said for the 4 or so sessions... You know what, I did have my husband bring her in on the 5th session, maybe you can try that? If he can take off or something, or bring a grandparent? Then have them walk them in... Ya know... it might work? Or sometimes it is just the dynamic with the instructor maybe they feel more comfy with a male or female or opposite.

I would def stick too it! Good Luck! Keep us posted!


Thanks!!!

Posted 5/29/13 9:16 PM
 

my3bugs
Mom of 2 Boys

Member since 5/05

4381 total posts

Name:

Re: Swimming lessons and separation issues

I pulled my daughter after maybe 6 sessions (I bought 12 sessions). She is just over 2yrs old and loved the water and pools when we went on vacation. I am getting an in ground pool installed next week.

Her first lesson was perfect - they all thought she'd be swimming in no time. She had no problems being dunked or anything. But then something happened and her separation anxiety kicked in. She'd swim fine for about 15 minutes and then she'd freak out and call for me and when she starts a tantrum there is no calming her. She is in this bad tantrum and separation phase to top it off. Each week after it got worse! One week she wouldn't go in and finally went in for the last 5 minutes - sat on the stairs and poured water on the teachers head for the whole time. So not worth my money or the stress on her or myself.

I have 2 other children both who are good swimmers and learned later. I started one at 4yrs and the other just under 3. I am going to wait this one out. I see no reason to torture the kid. The people at the desk kept saying it is normal and wait it out but I know my kid - this wasn't right. The teacher quietly told me the same too.

Posted 5/30/13 6:34 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
If you did swimming lessons for your DC, what age were they? peabody 1/20/11 21 Parenting
Anybody do swimming lessons through the town or HS programs? kerrycec03 7/14/10 7 Parenting
Need to start swimming lessons for a 3 yr old. Saf-T-Swim or YMCA? adeline27 7/8/10 9 Parenting
Been so busy... forgot to sign up for swimming lessons CaidensMommy 6/11/10 0 Parenting
DS is starting private swimming lessons today & I am so nervous! MrsKellyBride 4/21/10 3 Parenting
Swimming lessons...What age to start and where can I go?? Mdolph6 4/27/09 5 Parenting