St Catherines vs. Stony Brook

Posted By Message

MelissaZB
LIF Infant

Member since 6/09

193 total posts

Name:
Melissa

St Catherines vs. Stony Brook

Hey girls! I was originally planning on delivering at St. Catherines... just because my Dr's office is right next door... but now I'm thinking they may be affiliated with Stony Brook too... since they have another office there as well. I havent done much research yet but was wondering what your experiences were with the two. I live probably dead center between the them. TIA!

Posted 6/19/10 8:01 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

julz33
i run for bacon

Member since 5/05

20584 total posts

Name:
julz

Re: St Catherines vs. Stony Brook

I prefer Stony Brook for many reasons, mainly because of the NICU, and private rooms & bathrooms.

Posted 6/19/10 8:06 AM
 

Shorty
.

Member since 5/05

30390 total posts

Name:
really

Re: St Catherines vs. Stony Brook

i landed in St Cath's labor and delivery twice for early labor - after my experiences there, I decided to deliver at stony brook.

My water broke in my dr's office ON THE ST CATH'S PROPERTY - they wanted to throw me in a wheelchair and cart me to the hospital, but I signed myself out and drove to Stony Brook. BEST DECISION EVER.

I had an incredible experience @ SB, the private room was soooo great (they're all private). I loved my nurses, the NICU, my delivery was great, and I didn't hate the food either. I was sick my entire pregnancy - I puked every single day. I couldn't wait to have a burger without being nauseous after I delivered! Apparently I told the nurses this, and they had "room service" bring me a cheeseburger in my L&D room before I was even moved to post-partum. Chat Icon Chat Icon

At the time I delivered, St Cath's was so busy, they actually had patients tripled in the maternity rooms. I could never ever ever share a bathroom with 2 strangers post-partum. You MAY get lucky and have a room to yourself, but it's not certain.

My Dr was pretty pis$sed at me, but you know what? Its my life, my child, I'm going to do what I want. I've since switched Drs.

Posted 6/19/10 8:10 AM
 

drewsgirl
My loves

Member since 5/05

3221 total posts

Name:
Amanda

Re: St Catherines vs. Stony Brook

i only have experience with stonybrook, but loved it my first time there and looking forward to having dc #2 there as well..everyone and everything was great

Posted 6/19/10 8:17 AM
 

Dragonfly75
I love Hypnobabies

Member since 3/06

2333 total posts

Name:

Re: St Catherines vs. Stony Brook

I've delivered twice at Stony Brook. Here's what I love about it: all the post-partum rooms are private and brand new and you get to order off of a menu for food; they did all my baby checks (including hearing) in my room so my baby never had to go to the nursery (I could have sent him if I wanted, though); they did not push interventions on me during labor (I was a midwife patient, so I don't know how OB patients are treated; and if your baby needs help, they have the top NICU in Suffolk. I really love Stony Brook.

To be fair, you're going to hear good and bad about every hospital, but I recently had a friend's sister-in-law bring her baby home from St. Catherine's with a staph infection in the diaper area -- it was probably just one nurse who didn't wash her hands properly and could probably happen at another hospital, too, but yuck! I also had a friend who delivered there and the nurse put some drug (she still doesn't know what it was) to "take the edge off." The nurse told my friend about it after she had already put it in her IV and my friend did not react well to it -- it made her feel sick and dizzy and she was upset that the nurse did not ask her if she wanted drugs, but just put it in her IV without asking. So, although I'm sure plenty of people have wonderful experiences there I just happen to know 2 who did not.

Posted 6/19/10 8:19 AM
 

MelissaZB
LIF Infant

Member since 6/09

193 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: St Catherines vs. Stony Brook

Posted by Shorty

i landed in St Cath's labor and delivery twice for early labor - after my experiences there, I decided to deliver at stony brook.

My water broke in my dr's office ON THE ST CATH'S PROPERTY - they wanted to throw me in a wheelchair and cart me to the hospital, but I signed myself out and drove to Stony Brook. BEST DECISION EVER.

I had an incredible experience @ SB, the private room was soooo great (they're all private). I loved my nurses, the NICU, my delivery was great, and I didn't hate the food either. I was sick my entire pregnancy - I puked every single day. I couldn't wait to have a burger without being nauseous after I delivered! Apparently I told the nurses this, and they had "room service" bring me a cheeseburger in my L&D room before I was even moved to post-partum. Chat Icon Chat Icon

At the time I delivered, St Cath's was so busy, they actually had patients tripled in the maternity rooms. I could never ever ever share a bathroom with 2 strangers post-partum. You MAY get lucky and have a room to yourself, but it's not certain.

My Dr was pretty pis$sed at me, but you know what? Its my life, my child, I'm going to do what I want. I've since switched Drs.



Which Dr was this?

Thanks for your input ladies! :)

Posted 6/19/10 8:30 AM
 

SweetTooth
I'm a tired mommy!

Member since 12/05

20105 total posts

Name:
Lauren

Re: St Catherines vs. Stony Brook

I had an ok experience at St. Catherine's. Its very crowded there and the unit is pretty run down - meaning it hasn't been renovated in many years.
I didn't really eat any hospital food except for breakfast because my parents and DH brought be lunch and dinner every day.
The nurses were all very nice.
However, if I have another, I want to deliver at SB. The private rooms and bathrooms are very appealing to me.

Posted 6/19/10 1:06 PM
 

shelby34
Love being a twin mommy!

Member since 5/07

2934 total posts

Name:
Michele

Re: St Catherines vs. Stony Brook

Posted by julz33

I prefer Stony Brook for many reasons, mainly because of the NICU, and private rooms & bathrooms.



This was my thought, as well....I am choosing my hospital based on the NICU. But, I am having twins, so that may just be more important to me than a lot of other things.
Private room/bathroom is definitely next on my list of important things!

Posted 6/19/10 1:32 PM
 

kmac
Two under two!

Member since 5/07

3703 total posts

Name:
Kris

Re: St Catherines vs. Stony Brook

I chose my doctor based on wanting to deliver at Stony Brook and my experience with my son was amazing. My L & D nurse was outstanding and the overall experience was great. I don't know much about St. Catherine's except that my DH had surgery there once. It was ok.

Posted 6/19/10 4:19 PM
 

VTTG0609
My loves <3

Member since 8/09

3294 total posts

Name:
V

Re: St Catherines vs. Stony Brook

Posted by julz33

I prefer Stony Brook for many reasons, mainly because of the NICU, and private rooms & bathrooms.



DITO

Posted 6/19/10 8:47 PM
 

mrandmrs12
LIF Adult

Member since 1/07

1687 total posts

Name:

Re: St Catherines vs. Stony Brook

I delivered about 2 years ago at Stony Brook and had a great experience overall. I loved having my own room. At the time I shared a bathroom with one person, but i think now you even get your own bathroom! Not sure how they are at other hospitals, but at SB, DH could stay with my overnight which I liked. My second night there he couldn't stay, so my mom stayed with me and they were fine with it - which i loved. There was one or two nurses I wasn't CRAZY about, but it was nothing horrible at all. Overall I loved it and I can't wait to deliver there again soon.

BTW - the food is great!!!!! and you get lots of it!

Chat Icon

Posted 6/19/10 11:45 PM
 

Faithx2
All good things in 2016!!

Member since 8/05

20181 total posts

Name:

Re: St Catherines vs. Stony Brook

I use Contemporary Womens Care across from St Catherines. They have priveledges at Stonybrook but will mostly do deliveries at St Catherines--you don't get the choice to pick a hospital unfortunately(if I did my choice would be Stonybrook). Overall my experience having my 2 kids at St Catherines was good. The nurses were very good. My biggest negative was the communal shower down the hall. Most of their rooms do not have a shower and you have a roomate(maybe even 2). I brought Lysol with me and made my roommate spray down everything after she used the bathroom and vice versa. For my second child my roommate snored like a lumberjack. I almost suffocated her it was so bad. Chat Icon My negatives have nothing to do with quality of care--I have no complaints in that department.

BTW-The food is room service as well in St Catherines. You order off of a menu and it gets delivered to you Chat Icon

Message edited 2010-06-21 08:53:40.417000.

Posted 6/21/10 5:58 AM
 

twiceasnice
LIF Adult

Member since 2/08

1126 total posts

Name:

Re: St Catherines vs. Stony Brook

Posted by Dragonfly75

I've delivered twice at Stony Brook. Here's what I love about it: all the post-partum rooms are private and brand new and you get to order off of a menu for food; they did all my baby checks (including hearing) in my room so my baby never had to go to the nursery (I could have sent him if I wanted, though); they did not push interventions on me during labor (I was a midwife patient, so I don't know how OB patients are treated; and if your baby needs help, they have the top NICU in Suffolk. I really love Stony Brook.




ITA! After delivering my first there I chose my Dr for my 2nd PG based off of this hospital. I also know someone who delivered at St Catherines and had their DC flown to Stonybrook NICU after birth due to unexpected complications. I didnt want that to happen to me. As for the rooms, they are like a hotel suite. Tall ceilings, HUGE windows, the bathroom is awesome, especially the shower. My DC's roomed with me both times and that was the best part. Chat Icon

BTW- It is room service. You call for every meal and order from a menu. They deliver it to you and I was impressed with the quality. It is the same food they serve in the cafeteria.

Posted 6/21/10 8:35 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Help! Need a good OBGyn near stony brook or smithtown gemusic 10/27/07 17 Families Helping Families ™
Beach At End Of Nichols Road In Stony Brook? EmmaNick 7/15/07 11 Families Helping Families ™
Primary doctor reccomendation? - Stony Brook/Port Jeff/Centereach are? azoodie 3/3/07 5 Families Helping Families ™
Did anyone attend an Open House in S Section Stony Brook today? btrflygrl 9/10/06 1 Home
Anyone been to the Homegoods in Stony Brook lately? SweetestOfPeas 6/11/06 7 Families Helping Families ™
Stony Brook Students... I need help! julz33 2/13/06 7 Families Helping Families ™