Spinoff to the abortion thread...

Posted By Message

OrganicMama
So in love with my little man!

Member since 6/08

5172 total posts

Name:
Mama

Spinoff to the abortion thread...

This is kind of infertility related, but I think it should be on this board because it's a spinoff to the abortion thread.

For all of the pro-lifers, or anyone really that believes life begins at conception, what is your take on leftover embryos from IVF? I've gone back and forth on this, since we had to do IVF and will again for another child. Some women have none leftover, some have a dozen or more. What do you do you then? Your options are to "discard" them, donate them to science or an embryo donation center to give another family a chance for a baby. WWYD if you were in this situation with a dozen embies leftover?

Message edited 2011-10-07 20:54:00.313000.

Posted 10/7/11 8:39 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

MrsDeVito
Gio's gonna be a big brother!

Member since 7/09

4671 total posts

Name:
Christina

Re: Spinoff to the abortion thread...

We did one IVF (was unsuccessful and none to freeze) but we discussed what we would do if we had more left over than we needed. We decided that we would donate them to science. We weren't comfortable destroying them or having our biological child being raised by another family, especially when we wouldn't know who it was raising the child. For us donating to science meant the possibility of our embryo being a part of a cure for a disease or other breakthrough in medicine.

Posted 10/7/11 8:47 PM
 

CookieMomster
Golden

Member since 5/09

6414 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Spinoff to the abortion thread...

Great question...I want to say I would donate them for science but I am not sure where my religion stands on this, or for some one to have a chance.

Posted 10/7/11 11:08 PM
 

mamabear
LIF Adult

Member since 3/08

4539 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff to the abortion thread...

I haven't had IVF, but I have thought about this. I honestly don't know. I would like to say I would donate them to another couple, but I know in my heart I could not to that. I mean, it would be a sibling to my children. My child. And DH's. together. I couldn't do it. I would wonder forever and look at everyone that age wondering if by chance that was my child.

I would have to make a choice, though, right? I think I would just have to suck it up and decide on the spot whether to discard or donate to science. I think I would ultimately donate to science so that some good comes out of it, but I can say I rest easy on that choice.

Posted 10/7/11 11:53 PM
 

shiv
Twinsanity!!

Member since 5/07

4747 total posts

Name:
Shiv

Re: Spinoff to the abortion thread...

I am pro-life and had to do IVF to have a baby. I struggled a lot with IVF because each embryo represents a life to me and therefore deserves every chance at a life. I made the embryologist freeze any viable embryos- even those that don't meet the 'quality standard' for freezing. In addition, I signed my embryos over to my sister in case me and DH died. She would donate them to another couple. Discarding or donating embryos to science is destroying a life.
If we had more than we could use I would donate to another couple. I researched it and its a wonderful thing to do for another couple. However, I would do everything I could to use the embryos myself before donating them. Luckily we've used them all so we won't have to make that choice.

Posted 10/8/11 11:31 AM
 

ElizaRags35
My 2 Girls

Member since 2/09

20494 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Spinoff to the abortion thread...

I actually have a question as well for pro-lifers who are because of religion...

Did any of you do IVF? I'm curious because in Pre Cana, we learned that abortion is wrong and so is IVF because it's not natural. So wouldn't it be hypocritical to be pro-life because of religion but also do IVF or other fertility treatments?

Just curious!!

Chat Icon

Posted 10/8/11 12:16 PM
 

maybebaby
LIF Adult

Member since 11/05

6870 total posts

Name:
Maureen

Re: Spinoff to the abortion thread...

Posted by ElizaRags35

I actually have a question as well for pro-lifers who are because of religion...

Did any of you do IVF? I'm curious because in Pre Cana, we learned that abortion is wrong and so is IVF because it's not natural. So wouldn't it be hypocritical to be pro-life because of religion but also do IVF or other fertility treatments?

Just curious!!

Chat Icon



Well I am pretty pro-life... but i have nothing against IVF. I think its a wonderful thing and I don't really care what my religion says about it.

My feelings on abortion are based solely on my own feelings, not b/c of my religion. I disagree with a lot of the catholic churches views actually.

There are probably several things about calling myself pro-life that are hypocritical, but when it comes down to it we are all hypocrites in so many ways if we really delve into our belief systems.

I guess technically my beliefs wouldn't be considered "pro-life", I am not sure what the exact term would be though.

I confuse myself!!Chat Icon

Posted 10/8/11 12:45 PM
 

Alli06
Baby #3 coming this June

Member since 8/05

6721 total posts

Name:
A

Re: Spinoff to the abortion thread...

Posted by ElizaRags35

I actually have a question as well for pro-lifers who are because of religion...

Did any of you do IVF? I'm curious because in Pre Cana, we learned that abortion is wrong and so is IVF because it's not natural. So wouldn't it be hypocritical to be pro-life because of religion but also do IVF or other fertility treatments?

Just curious!!

Chat Icon



I know a couple who have not been successful with having a baby. There only option really is IVF, but they refuse to do it because of religion.

Message edited 2011-10-08 14:34:58.973000.

Posted 10/8/11 2:32 PM
 

Alli06
Baby #3 coming this June

Member since 8/05

6721 total posts

Name:
A

Re: Spinoff to the abortion thread...

Sorry

Message edited 2011-10-08 14:35:20.360000.

Posted 10/8/11 2:33 PM
 

Alli06
Baby #3 coming this June

Member since 8/05

6721 total posts

Name:
A

Re: Spinoff to the abortion thread...

posted twice by accident

Message edited 2011-10-08 14:35:49.583000.

Posted 10/8/11 2:34 PM
 

AngnShaun
Sisters

Member since 1/10

21015 total posts

Name:
Ang

Re: Spinoff to the abortion thread...

If i wasnt planning to use them, i would probably give them to a lab so that other people can if they needed to... as long as they were ok for others to use!

ETA: my religion has nothing to do with it!

Message edited 2011-10-08 14:44:31.313000.

Posted 10/8/11 2:42 PM
 

ElizaRags35
My 2 Girls

Member since 2/09

20494 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Spinoff to the abortion thread...

Posted by maybebaby

Posted by ElizaRags35

I actually have a question as well for pro-lifers who are because of religion...

Did any of you do IVF? I'm curious because in Pre Cana, we learned that abortion is wrong and so is IVF because it's not natural. So wouldn't it be hypocritical to be pro-life because of religion but also do IVF or other fertility treatments?

Just curious!!

Chat Icon



Well I am pretty pro-life... but i have nothing against IVF. I think its a wonderful thing and I don't really care what my religion says about it.

My feelings on abortion are based solely on my own feelings, not b/c of my religion. I disagree with a lot of the catholic churches views actually.

There are probably several things about calling myself pro-life that are hypocritical, but when it comes down to it we are all hypocrites in so many ways if we really delve into our belief systems.

I guess technically my beliefs wouldn't be considered "pro-life", I am not sure what the exact term would be though.

I confuse myself!!Chat Icon



Thanks for answering! This is why I hate the term "pro-life". I'm all for life, but I'm 100% pro-choice. Just because I wouldn't have one myself, doesn't mean I don't believe that anyone else should not have the choice to do it. And I'm glad that I do have a choice. I just wouldn't choose abortion for myself unless it was for a health risk.

This is why I don't like organized religion! Too many hypocrisies! Chat Icon I was VERY uncomfortable to hear this information in Pre Cana especially because one day we might need IVF Chat Icon .

This is all JMO of course! Chat Icon

ETA: Sorry to the OP for hijacking! Chat Icon

Message edited 2011-10-08 14:44:54.697000.

Posted 10/8/11 2:44 PM
 

sfp0701
Liam's Mommy!

Member since 1/07

9764 total posts

Name:
Tricia

Re: Spinoff to the abortion thread...

If we got to that point, we were going to try and donate them to another family. This is what I felt most comfortable with.

Posted 10/8/11 2:44 PM
 

DRMom
Two in Blue

Member since 5/05

20223 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Spinoff to the abortion thread...

WE did not have any and we struggled a lot with this before we knew that. I was relieved when my IVF was successful and I did not have to make that decision

Posted 10/8/11 8:47 PM
 

Bearcat
Love my little girls!!! <3

Member since 6/10

10818 total posts

Name:
E

Re: Spinoff to the abortion thread...

in my personal experience, people who are truly pro-life (in the purest sense, no exceptions) will not even do IVF in the first place.

Posted 10/8/11 9:39 PM
 

donegal419
St. Gerard, pray for us.

Member since 7/07

7650 total posts

Name:
K

Re: Spinoff to the abortion thread...

Posted by ElizaRags35

I actually have a question as well for pro-lifers who are because of religion...

Did any of you do IVF? I'm curious because in Pre Cana, we learned that abortion is wrong and so is IVF because it's not natural. So wouldn't it be hypocritical to be pro-life because of religion but also do IVF or other fertility treatments?

Just curious!!

Chat Icon



the reason IVF is frowned upon is not because it's not natural, but because of the left-over embryos that are considered a life because life begins at conception. these embryos usually end up getting destroyed. there are many other fertility treatments that are supported by the Church as another means in which to get pregnant.

Posted 10/8/11 10:17 PM
 

Sparrow
LIF Adult

Member since 11/10

6826 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff to the abortion thread...

I am pro life and believe life begins at conception. That is what my religion believes but I would believe that regardless becuase it's the only thing that makes sense to me.

This is why I am so very thankful that we didn't have to go the IVF route. I don't know what I would do with any extra embryos. The thought of them not being used is really unsettling to me. I think I would have to not have any extras. My personal beliefs go against donating them to science and I couldn't discard them. I guess if it really came down to it I'd donate them to another couple?

My religion doesn't even believe in IVF so there is no "right" answer by that book. I still think that if I had no other option I would go the IVF route but it would not be easy for me.

Posted 10/8/11 10:39 PM
 

MrsLL2010
LIF Infant

Member since 2/09

318 total posts

Name:
Lori

Re: Spinoff to the abortion thread...

Posted by donegal419

Posted by ElizaRags35

I actually have a question as well for pro-lifers who are because of religion...

Did any of you do IVF? I'm curious because in Pre Cana, we learned that abortion is wrong and so is IVF because it's not natural. So wouldn't it be hypocritical to be pro-life because of religion but also do IVF or other fertility treatments?

Just curious!!

Chat Icon



the reason IVF is frowned upon is not because it's not natural, but because of the left-over embryos that are considered a life because life begins at conception. these embryos usually end up getting destroyed. there are many other fertility treatments that are supported by the Church as another means in which to get pregnant.



In addition - what my priest told me was that it is not allowed because conception is between a man and woman and God and IVF is coming between that bond.

Message edited 2011-10-09 00:45:43.843000.

Posted 10/9/11 12:37 AM
 

hope316
LIF Adult

Member since 8/07

1085 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff to the abortion thread...

I am pro-life and I have done IVF and I have elected to donate my embryos ( don't have any one ice now) As a Christian I believe life is to be cherished form conception, Especially going thru infertility I have worked so hard to create these embryos I would never destroy them. I'm not Catholic who believe IVF is wrong.

Posted 10/9/11 7:38 AM
 

kahlua716
3 Girls for Me!

Member since 8/07

12475 total posts

Name:
Keri

Re: Spinoff to the abortion thread...

I have not had IVF- but my sister is struggling with this decision.

The only option I would be comfortable with would be to donate to science. I feel that there is a possibility of good coming from that research.

I couldn't donate to another couple and know that my biological child is out there somewhere Chat Icon I feel the same way about adoption as an option for unwanted pregnancy. I give other people who do it a TON of credit- but I know I would never feel comfortable knowing my offspring was out there being raised by someone else. Or that someday there may be a knock at my door. . .

I consider myself to be catholic- but I don't agree with many of the catholic beliefs (I am pro-choice, pro-gay marriage, pro-IVF, etc.)

JMHO

Posted 10/9/11 10:38 AM
 

JennyPenny
?

Member since 1/08

12702 total posts

Name:
Jen

Re: Spinoff to the abortion thread...

I was thinking this very same question the other day.

I have 7 frozen embryos.

I used two and had my daughter. 7 were left. I was intending to use them again but miraculously got pregnant on my own. I still have 7 left.

DH and I signed the paperwork to donate them to another couple when we were presented with the options. Right now I am just paying for them to stay frozen. I *may* need them some day, but I feel like I might be done after this pregnancy. I cannot imagine destroying something that eventually turned into my daughter and would be someone just like her. It's so hard to think of that. I also sort of feel that way about donating them to science. Those are my children- regardless whether or not there are heartbeats yet. Do I really want them to be dissected?? No...I don't.

Donating them to another couple seemed the only huimane option to me, but I also don't want MY children just OUT there somewhere. Without me. They are my babies.

I am having such a hard time with this.Chat Icon

Posted 10/9/11 2:25 PM
 

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Spinoff to the abortion thread...

For those who are unware and don't want to disgard their embryo.

There is such thing as "embryo adoption". For couples who cannot have biological children.

They "adopt an embryo" and have either have the embryo implanted in the adoptive mother or in a surrogate mother.

They don't need to be destroyed.

Posted 10/9/11 2:43 PM
 

Kazuri
LIF Adolescent

Member since 8/11

703 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff to the abortion thread...

Posted by maybebaby

Posted by ElizaRags35

I actually have a question as well for pro-lifers who are because of religion...

Did any of you do IVF? I'm curious because in Pre Cana, we learned that abortion is wrong and so is IVF because it's not natural. So wouldn't it be hypocritical to be pro-life because of religion but also do IVF or other fertility treatments?

Just curious!!

Chat Icon



Well I am pretty pro-life... but i have nothing against IVF. I think its a wonderful thing and I don't really care what my religion says about it.

My feelings on abortion are based solely on my own feelings, not b/c of my religion. I disagree with a lot of the catholic churches views actually.

There are probably several things about calling myself pro-life that are hypocritical, but when it comes down to it we are all hypocrites in so many ways if we really delve into our belief systems.

I guess technically my beliefs wouldn't be considered "pro-life", I am not sure what the exact term would be though.

I confuse myself!!Chat Icon



The term would be anti-choice or anti-abortion.

My SIL is anti-abortion but pro-death penalty. She said she felt like a fraud calling herself "pro-life" because she does not value all human life.

Posted 10/9/11 2:44 PM
 

Jan1975
.

Member since 8/09

3846 total posts

Name:
Sarah

Re: Spinoff to the abortion thread...

I am pro-choice, however, I would defintely dontate them to science. I would not want them destroyed, but I also would not want someone to have my biological child.

Posted 10/9/11 6:50 PM
 

Momma2Be
Mommy of an angel

Member since 10/09

5911 total posts

Name:
Dina

Re: Spinoff to the abortion thread...

I have not gone through IVF so obviously I am answering hypothetically and my response may or may not be what I would actually feel if I were *really* put in the position to have to choose. I don't think I would feel comfortable destroying the embryos or donating them to science. I would donate them to another couple struggling with infertility to give them the opportunity to have a child as well.

Posted 10/9/11 8:03 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Spinoff to the NEW Abortion Poll: To those of you who had unplanned pregnancies and kept your child... HoneyBadger 9/10/08 16 Families Helping Families ™
I was thinking about the recent abortion debates...an anonymous poll... Melbernai 9/8/08 127 Families Helping Families ™
Another abortion spin-off b/c hey...there just aren't enough! MissJones 9/7/08 34 Families Helping Families ™
How much weight does the abortion issue bear in your decision this November? babymakes3 9/6/08 22 Families Helping Families ™
Spinoff to Pro-Life/Pro-Choice: Do you think there is a difference between being Pro-Choice and Pro-Abortion? HoneyBadger 6/10/08 169 Families Helping Families ™
Do you think the prompt asking "abortion" searchers "Did you mean adoption?" was a political statement DebG 3/22/06 9 Families Helping Families ™